Danielle Rankin V Toll Personnel Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

CITATION:Danielle Rankin v Toll Personnel Pty Limited [2019] NTLC009

PARTIES:Danielle Rankin

V

Toll Personnel Pty Limited

TITLE OF COURT:  LOCAL COURT

JURISDICTION:  WORK HEALTH

FILE NO(s):21611252

DELIVERED ON:  16 December 2019

DELIVERED AT:  DARWIN

HEARING DATE(s):  26, 27, 28, 29, 30 November 2018, 14 February, 7 June, 2 July, 8 August, 21 August, 30 October 2019, 20 November 2019

JUDGMENT OF:  Chief Judge Morris

CATCHWORDS:

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Worker:Michael Doyle

Employer:Duncan McConnel

Solicitors:

Worker:Povey Stirk

Employer:HWL Ebsworth

Judgment category classification:                B

Judgment ID number:  009

Number of paragraphs:  35

IN THE WORK HEALTH COURT
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN
TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 21611252

BETWEEN

Danielle Rankin

Worker

AND

Toll Personnel Pty Ltd

Employer

COSTS

CHIEF JUDGE MORRIS

  1. On 7 June 2019, I determined that the Worker, Danielle Rankin did suffer an injury in the course of her employment on 9 July 2015.  Written reasons were published for that decision and I invited the parties to make further submissions on final orders and costs.

  2. Written submissions were then made by the Worker and the Employer as well as subsequent oral submissions at various mentions of the matter in Court.

  3. I found that the Worker was partially incapacitated as a consequence of the injury, which finding placed the onus on the Employer of proving the value of her most profitable employment while the partial incapacity arising from the work injury persisted.

  4. I found that work injury of 9 July 2015 aggravated the Worker’s underlying degenerative conditions in the affected areas, but this had ceased by 4 February 2016 at the latest. 

  5. I found that the Worker has not satisfied me that she had symptoms or incapacity attributable to the work injury of 9 July 2016 after 4 February 2016 nor attributable to the surgery in February 2016.

  6. The Worker has a closed period claim.

  7. The parties have agreed the details of all payments made to the Worker and the annexure to the written submissions of the Employer, now Exhibit E21, details all payments made by the Employer to the Worker.

  8. Based on my findings the Worker is entitled to payment of the agreed normal weekly earnings from 10 July 2015 to 3 February 2016, being an amount of $54,060.99, less the amount already paid pursuant to section 85 (4) of the Return to Work Act, being $17, 269.27.  Thus, the Worker is entitled to be paid the shortfall of $36, 791.72.

  9. In respect of medical expenses the Worker is entitled to be paid $4,278.41, which is the total incurred minus the expenses that appear to be related to the fusion surgery.

  10. This means that the Worker has been successful on the fundamental issue of having suffered a work-related injury, and she has been successful in establishing partial incapacity from and including 10 July 2015 to and including 3 February 2016.  She has been unsuccessful in establishing any entitlement to any benefits after 4 February 2016.  Accordingly, this is a case of mixed outcomes when it comes to the question of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Danielle Rankin V Toll Personnel Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NTLC 9
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Danielle Rankin, the worker, initiated proceedings against Toll Personnel Pty Ltd, the employer, in the Local Court of the Northern Territory, seeking compensation for a work-related injury she sustained on 9 July 2015. The central dispute was whether the worker had suffered a compensable injury and, if so, the extent of her incapacity and the resultant compensation. The court had to determine whether the employer's conduct in opposing the claim warranted any costs adjustment beyond the usual award where the successful party receives their costs from the unsuccessful party. The worker argued she was substantially successful and should receive her costs, while the employer contended that costs should follow the event or be apportioned based on the issues.

The court examined the nature of the worker's claims, the evidence presented, and the efforts made to settle the dispute. The worker successfully established that she suffered a work-related injury and was partially incapacitated from 10 July 2015 to 3 February 2016, but failed to prove ongoing incapacity or that the injury contributed to her need for spinal fusion surgery. The court found that the worker's claims were not entirely severable and that she had to proceed to trial to establish her entitlement to compensation. While the worker was not entirely successful, her claims were not frivolous or unreasonably pursued. The employer made a late offer of settlement on the morning of the trial, which the worker rejected. The court concluded that the offer was genuine but it was not unreasonable for the worker not to accept it due to the short notice and lack of time to consider it properly.

In light of these findings, the court exercised its discretion to order that the employer pay the worker's costs of the proceedings on a party-to-party basis, to be taxed at 100% of the Supreme Court Scale. The employer was also ordered to pay interest on the arrears of weekly benefits from the date they should have been paid. This decision reflects the court's view that the worker, while only partially successful, had to pursue her claims to trial to establish her entitlement to compensation, and that the unsuccessful claims were not entirely discrete from the successful elements of her case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established