Daniel v State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Daniel v State of Western Australia [2001] FCA 223

EVIDENCE – admissions – communications by applicants for native title and others to expert anthropologist – recorded in field notes – whether documentation of communications admissible as admissions

EVIDENCE – hearsay – communications by applicants for native title and others to expert anthropologist – recorded in field notes – viva voce and documentary evidence of communications- whether admissible as relevant for a purpose other than proof of the fact intended to be asserted by the representation – whether court should limit the use to be made of the evidence or exclude it – relevance of opportunity for cross-examination

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), ss 60, 79, 81(1), 82, 135, 136

Heydon Cross on Evidence 6th ed. Butterworths 2000 at [29080] and at [29165]
Freckleton et al The Law of Expert Evidence Lawbook Company 1999 at pp 658 – 659

Daniel v State of Western Australia [1999] 94 FCR 537, referred to
Daniel v State of Western Australia [2000] FCA 858, applied
HG v R (1999) 160 ALR 554, referred to
Lee v R (1998) 157 ALR 394 at 502, referred to
Sampi v State of Western Australia [2001] FCA 110 at 20 – 21, cited
South Sydney District Rugby League Football Club Ltd v News Ltd (No.4) [2000] FCA 1211, referred to
Lardil & Others v State of Queensland [2000] FCA 1548, distinguished
Rothmore Farms Pty Ltd (in liq) v Balgravier Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 598, distinguished
Quick v Stoland Pty Ltd (1998) 157 ALR 615, referred to
Milirrpum v Nabalco Pty Ltd (1970) 17 FLR 141 at 161, referred to
Yarmirr v Northern Territory of Australia (1998) 156 ALR 370 at 397 – 400, referred to

DANIEL & OTHERS FOR THE NGARLUMA PEOPLE, MONADEE & OTHERS FOR THE YINDJIBARNDI PEOPLE, HOLBOROW (NEE COSMOS) & OTHERS FOR THE YABURARA & MARDUDHUNERA PEOPLES AND DALE & OTHERS FOR THE WONG-GOO-TT-OO PEOPLE v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA & OTHERS
WAG 6017 of 1996
and part of WAG 127 of 1997
and part of WAG 6256 of 1998

R D NICHOLSON J
14 March 2001
PERTH

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAG 6017 of 1996
and part of WAG 127 of 1997
and part of WAG 6256 of 1998

BETWEEN:

DANIEL & OTHERS FOR THE NGARLUMA PEOPLE AND MONADEE & OTHERS FOR THE YINDJIBARNDI PEOPLE
FIRST APPLICANTS

HOLBOROW (NEE COSMOS) & OTHERS FOR THE YABURARA & MARDUDHUNERA PEOPLES
SECOND APPLICANTS

DALE & OTHERS FOR THE WONG-GOO-TT-OO PEOPLE
THIRD APPLICANTS

AND:

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA & OTHERS
RESPONDENTS

JUDGE:

R D NICHOLSON J

DATE:

14 MARCH 2001

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. These reasons address objections concerning the admissibility of evidence, which objections arose on a voir dire in relation to the evidence of Mr Robinson, an expert anthropologist.  The third applicants seek to have admitted into evidence certain portions of Mr Robinson’s field notes recording communications…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Daniel v State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 223
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Daniel v State of Western Australia revolved around the admissibility of certain evidence related to communications made to an expert anthropologist, Mr Robinson, by parties involved in a native title claim. The third applicants sought to admit into evidence portions of Mr Robinson's field notes, which recorded conversations with parties or members of an applicant group or others. The first applicants and the first respondents objected to the admissibility of these documents and related viva voce evidence. The first applicants sought a wide-ranging exclusion of the evidence, while the first respondents focused their objections on specific aspects.

The legal issues that the court needed to address were primarily concerned with the admissibility of the field notes and viva voce evidence under the Evidence Act. Specifically, the court had to determine whether these communications could be admitted as admissions or as hearsay evidence, and if so, whether they should be excluded or limited in their use. The court needed to consider whether the evidence was relevant for purposes other than proving the truth of the matters asserted, and whether the opportunity for cross-examination provided sufficient safeguards to ensure the reliability of the evidence. The case drew on previous rulings, including Daniel v State of Western Australia [1999] 94 FCR 537, which had addressed the admissibility of similar evidence in the context of client legal privilege.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the statutory framework provided by the Evidence Act, particularly sections 56, 60, 79, and 136. The court emphasised the importance of ensuring that expert opinions are based on specialised knowledge and that the hearsay rule does not act as a barrier to relevant evidence. The court also noted that the field notes in question were made by an expert anthropologist, and therefore, the principles governing the admissibility of expert evidence were particularly pertinent. The court considered the submissions of the parties and highlighted the need for due regard to be given to the authorities cited, including Gleeson CJ's comments in HG v R and the High Court's ruling in Lee v R. The court concluded that while the evidence might be relevant for purposes other than proving the truth of the matters asserted, its admissibility would depend on whether it met the criteria set out in the Evidence Act.

The final orders of the court were that certain portions of Mr Robinson's field notes and related viva voce evidence were to be admitted into evidence, subject to the conditions set out in the court's ruling. The court also made orders regarding the conditions under which the evidence could be used, ensuring that the opportunity for cross-examination provided adequate safeguards to protect the reliability of the evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

These reasons address objections concerning the admissibility of evidence, which objections arose on a voir dire in relation to the evidence of Mr Robinson, an expert anthropologist. The third applicants seek to have admitted into evidence certain portions of Mr Robinson’s field notes recording communications to him by parties or members of an applicant group or others. Additionally, the third applicants seek to have admitted certain viva voce evidence taken on the voir dire in relation to those documents. Objections are raised on the part of the first applicants and the first respondents. Broadly expressed, the first applicants seek wide-ranging exclusion of the documents and viva voce evidence to which they have objected. The first respondents confine their objections to certain limited aspects of that evidence.Nature of the documentary evidence The communications in issue were those which were the subject of the ruling in Daniel v State of Western Australia [1999] 94 FCR 537 given on 25 October 1999. The effect of that ruling was that the first applicants were found to be entitled to maintain the claim which they had made for client legal privilege in communications to Mr Robinson until such time as his expert report was introduced into evidence. That occurred on 20 June 2000. However, on 12 June 2000 the field notes now sought to be admitted into evidence were made available on behalf of the first applicants to other parties. It is important to have in mind that the documentary evidence in issue here is in the nature of field notes made by the expert anthropologist. In Daniel v State of Western Australia [2000] FCA 858 I referred to what was said by Gleeson CJ in HG v R (1999) 160 ALR 554 at 563 – 4 to the effect that there is an importance in ensuring that the opinions of expert witnesses are confined, in accordance with S 79 of the Evidence Act, to opinions which are wholly or substantially based on their specialised knowledge. I also there referred relevantly to the statement by the High Court in Lee v R (1998) 157 ALR 394 at 402 to the effect that while s 60 was intended to work a considerable change to the common law, it was not intended to provide a gateway for the proof of any form of hearsay, however remote. Additionally, I set out the reasoning in Quick v Stoland Pty Ltd (1998) 157 ALR 615 to the effect that s 60 prevents the application of the hearsay rule to evidence which is admitted as relevant pursuant to s 56, the admission to which s 60 operates being the testing of the basis of the specialised knowledge of the expert pursuant to s 79. Once in for that other purpose the evidence is in for all purposes unless limited by s 136 in accordance with the requirements of it. I also referred in the prior decision to the reasoning of Blackburn J in Milirrpum v Nabalco Pty Ltd (1970) 17 FLR 141 at 161 which makes apparent that in the context which he was addressing (prior to the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)) anthropologists would not be allowed to give evidence in the form that a particular Aboriginal witness told them that a particular land belonged to a particular tribe. In the same reasons I also referred to the statement by Olney J in Yarmirr v Northern Territory of Australia (1998) 156 ALR 370 at 397 – 400. Those considerations remain relevant and need to be borne in mind in considering the objections in relation to the documentary evidence. It did not seem to me from the submission for the parties that due regard was paid to the matters made apparent by those authorities. Expert guidelines

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.