Daily Telegraph Newspaper Company Limited v McLaughlin

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read
1 CLR 479

[PRIVY COUNCIL.]

DAILY TELEGRAPH NEWSPAPER CO. LTD. APPELLANTS McLAUGHLIN

[ON APPEAL FROM THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA.] Special leare to appeal from High Court-Reasons for refuning-Judgment appealed

from unattended with sufficient doubt.

Special leave to appeal to His Majesty in Council from a judgment of the High Court will not be granted by the Judicial Committee, even in a case involving a large amount of money and important questions of law, where it appears to them that the judgment from which leave to appeal is sought is plainly right or unattended with sufficient doubt to justify the granting of leave.

Observations of Lord Watson in La Cité de Montreal v. Les Ecclésias'iques du Seminaire de St. Sulpice de Montréal, 14 App. Cas., 660, at p. 662, as to the rules to be followed in granting special leave to appeal from the Supreme Court of Canada, applied.

Petition for special leave to appeal from the judgment of the High Court in McLaughlin v. Daily Telegraph Newspaper Co. Ltd. (ante p. 243) dismissed with costs on this ground.

PETITION for special leave to appeal to His Majesty in Council from the decision of the High Court (ante, p. 243).

The judgment of their Lordships was delivered by

LORD MACNAGHTEN. As this is the first instance in which an application has been made for special leave to appeal to His Majesty from a decision of the High Court of Australia, their Lordships think it desirable to state the principles which, in their opinion, ought to guide this Board in tendering advice to His Majesty in such a case. The High Court occupies a position of

* Present - LORD MACNAGHTEN, LORD DAVEY, LORD ROBERTSON, LORD LINDLEY and SIR ARTHUR WILSON.

1 CLR 480

great dignity and supreme authority in the Commonwealth. No appeal lies from it as of right to any tribunal in the Empire. There can be no appeal at all unless His Majesty, by virtue of his Royal prerogative, thinks fit to grant special leave to appeal to himself in Council. In certain cases touching the Constitution of

McLAUGHLIN the Commonwealth the Royal prerogative has been waived. In

all other cases it seems to their Lordships that applications for special leave to appeal from the High Court ought to be treated in the same manner as applications for special leave to appeal from the Supreme Court of Canada, an equally august and inde- pendent tribunal. And their Lordships think that they cannot do better than repeat the observations which were made by Lord Watson, in delivering the judgment of this Board in the case of a petition to Her late Majesty, in which the City of Montreal was the applicant; Lu Cité de Montréal v. Les Ecclésiastiques du Seminaire de St. Sulpice de Montréal (14 App. Cas., 660, at p. 662).

It is the duty of their Lordships," said Lord Watson in that case, "to advise Her Majesty in the exercise of her prerogative, and in the discharge…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Daily Telegraph Newspaper Company Limited v McLaughlin and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1904] UKPCHCA 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Daily Telegraph Newspaper Company Limited v McLaughlin, the petitioner sought special leave to appeal to His Majesty in Council from a decision of the High Court of Australia. The dispute involved the validity of a power of attorney executed by the plaintiff, which the petitioner claimed was void due to the plaintiff's alleged unsound mind at the time of signing. The High Court found the power of attorney to be void, leading to the petitioner's appeal to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council. The Judicial Committee considered the principles guiding special leave to appeal from the High Court and the necessity for the judgment to be either plainly right or attended with sufficient doubt to warrant an appeal. The Committee found that the High Court's judgment was correct and dismissed the petition with costs.

The legal issues before the court involved the principles of granting special leave to appeal from the High Court and the validity of the power of attorney. The petitioner argued that the case involved significant financial stakes and questions of law that warranted an appeal. The court considered whether the judgment was plainly right or sufficiently doubtful to justify an appeal. The Judicial Committee examined the High Court's reasoning and found it to be sound, based on the facts and applicable legal precedents.

The Judicial Committee concluded that the High Court's judgment was correct and not sufficiently doubtful to warrant an appeal. They noted that the High Court had carefully reviewed the facts and reached a conclusion that the power of attorney was void due to the plaintiff's lack of understanding at the time of signing. The Committee found no reason to doubt the High Court's findings and dismissed the petition for special leave to appeal. The petition was dismissed with costs, indicating the Judicial Committee's view that the appeal was not warranted under the circumstances.