FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| DAB16 v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR | [2018] FCCA 3957 |
| Catchwords: MIGRATION – Protection Visa – whether Immigration Assessment Authority’s decision affected by jurisdictional error – where no error established in Immigration Assessment Authority’s decision – application dismissed |
| Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.36(2)(a), 5J(5)(d) |
| Applicant: | DAB16 |
| First Respondent: | MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION |
| Second Respondent: | IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT ATHORITY |
| File Number: | PEG 486 of 2016 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Vasta |
| Hearing date: | 28 November 2018 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 28 November 2018 |
| Delivered at: | Perth |
| Delivered on: | 28 November 2018 |
REPRESENTATION
| Solicitor for the Applicant: | Ms H. Smart |
| Counsel for the First Respondent: | Ms S. Oliver |
| Solicitors for the First Respondent: | Australian Government Solicitor |
ORDERS
That that the Applications filed 13 October 2016 and 27 September 2018 are dismissed.
That the Applicant pay the costs of the First Respondent fixed in the sum of $7,467.00.
| FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT PERTH |
PEG 486 of 2016
| DAB16 |
Applicant
And
| MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION |
First Respondent
| IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY |
Second Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
(Ex Tempore)
On 20 September 2016, the Immigration Assessment Authority (“the IAA”) affirmed a decision of the delegate not to grant DAB16 a protection visa.
The circumstances leading to that in short compass are these. The Applicant claims that he is a Hazara Shia from Balochistan in the Quetta district of Pakistan. He claimed that anti-Shia militias target Hazaras for harm in his hometown, and he knows of many Hazaras who were killed in his hometown. He said that he worked at a clothing store at a market, and that he and his employer received threatening letters.
At different times, he has said that there were many letters left outside the shop at night, and there were two to three letters addressed to him and his employer. He has said that these letters were from the LEJ, or the Sepah Wahabi. Most of the storeowners in the market were Hazara, and many people stopped working at the market.
He has also made claims about his fiancée. He said that his fiancée received threats in 2011 and was called an infidel because she worked for the United Nations providing therapy to disabled people.
He claimed that four of her colleagues were abducted by anti-Shia militias and killed. At another time, he said that his fiancée worked for the Red Cross or an NGO, but he could not remember whether it was for the Red Cross or for the UN. At other times, he said that the four colleagues that were abducted were English, and that they were beheaded, and that this happened two weeks after his fiancée left her job after she was threatened in person by members of LEJ at the hospital where she works. He claimed that she now works for a doctor’s clinic.
He said that in November 2011 the shop owner that he worked at, sold the business and went to Canada. The Applicant said that after…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read DAB16 v Minister for Immigration and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] FCCA 3957
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court was whether the delegate of the Minister had failed to adequately consider the applicant's claims of past persecution and fear of future persecution, particularly in light of the evidence presented. This involved an examination of whether the delegate had applied the correct legal test for assessing protection claims and whether the delegate's findings were supported by the evidence.
Judge Vasta found that the delegate had failed to properly consider the applicant's evidence regarding past persecution and the specific circumstances that would lead to a well-founded fear of future persecution. The Court applied the principles established in cases concerning the assessment of protection visa applications, emphasizing the need for a thorough and objective evaluation of all relevant evidence and claims. The delegate's decision was found to be affected by jurisdictional error due to this failure in assessment.
The Court ordered that the decision of the Minister be set aside and remitted to the Minister for redetermination according to law.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA) reviewed DAB16's claims and found inconsistencies in his story, questioning his credibility. The IAA considered the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) reports, which indicated that while there was a risk of targeted harm against Hazara Shias in Balochistan, the risk was lower in other parts of Pakistan, such as Lahore. The IAA concluded that DAB16 could reasonably relocate to Lahore, where he would not face a real risk of significant harm, and therefore, he did not meet the criteria for a protection visa. DAB16 filed a review application challenging the IAA's decision, arguing that the IAA failed to properly assess his claims and relied on incorrect information from the DFAT reports. However, the court found no jurisdictional error in the IAA's decision, as the conclusions were open on the evidence and the IAA appropriately considered the country information available to them.
The case of DAB16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection commenced when the applicant, DAB16, applied for a protection visa which was ultimately refused by the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA). On 13 October 2016, DAB16 lodged an application for judicial review of the IAA's decision in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, seeking to challenge the IAA's decision on two grounds: the IAA failed to assess his claims properly, and the IAA relied on incorrect information, specifically DFAT reports, which prejudiced his claim. The matter was initially heard on the basis of the original grounds, but during the proceedings, it became clear that the true contention was whether the IAA's conclusions were open on the evidence provided. On 27 September 2018, DAB16 filed an amended originating application, refining his grounds for review. The substantive hearing took place on 28 November 2018, before Judge Vasta in Perth. During the hearing, the applicant conceded that the IAA's assessment of the risk of persecution in his hometown was correct, but argued that the same level of risk should apply to Lahore, where the IAA believed relocation was reasonable. The Court found that the IAA's conclusions were open on the evidence, and there was no jurisdictional error in the IAA's decision, leading to the dismissal of the applicant's review application. Costs of $7,467.00 were awarded to the Minister.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the Immigration Assessment Authority's decision affected by a jurisdictional error in failing to assess the applicant's claim as required by law and the rules of procedural fairness?
2. Did the Immigration Assessment Authority's reliance on the DFAT reports constitute a jurisdictional error by using incorrect information, thereby undermining and prejudicing the applicant's claim?
3. Was there a jurisdictional error in the Immigration Assessment Authority's conclusion that the applicant did not have a well-founded fear of persecution if he were to return to Pakistan, particularly with respect to the consideration of the applicant's ethnicity as a Shia Hazara?
4. Did the Immigration Assessment Authority err in finding it reasonable for the applicant to relocate to Lahore, thereby failing to meet the criteria for complementary protection under the Migration Act 1958?
5. Was there a jurisdictional error in the Immigration Assessment Authority's reliance on DFAT reports regarding the presence of a Hazara community in Lahore, despite the applicant's contention that such a community does not exist?
Held
1. Was the Immigration Assessment Authority's decision affected by a jurisdictional error in failing to assess the applicant's claim as required by law and the rules of procedural fairness?
The court concluded that the claims made by the applicant regarding procedural fairness were an attempt at merits review, and that the IAA had considered the matters and reached a conclusion that was open on the evidence. As a result, the application on this ground was dismissed.
2. Did the Immigration Assessment Authority's reliance on the DFAT reports constitute a jurisdictional error by using incorrect information, thereby undermining and prejudicing the applicant's claim?
The court concluded that the applicant had not provided conclusive proof that the DFAT reports were incorrect, and that it was for the IAA to decide whether or not to accept the information in the reports. Therefore, there was no jurisdictional error in relying upon the DFAT reports, and the application on this ground was dismissed.
3. Was there a jurisdictional error in the Immigration Assessment Authority's conclusion that the applicant did not have a well-founded fear of persecution if he were to return to Pakistan, particularly with respect to the consideration of the applicant's ethnicity as a Shia Hazara?
The court concluded that the IAA had considered the impact of the applicant's ethnicity on his potential relocation to Lahore and found that it was reasonable for the applicant to relocate to Lahore. As a result, the application on this ground was dismissed.
4. Did the Immigration Assessment Authority err in finding it reasonable for the applicant to relocate to Lahore, thereby failing to meet the criteria for complementary protection under the Migration Act 1958?
The court concluded that the IAA had considered the personal circumstances of the applicant and his fiancée and found it reasonable for the applicant to relocate to Lahore. As a result, the application on this ground was dismissed.
5. Was there a jurisdictional error in the Immigration Assessment Authority's reliance on DFAT reports regarding the presence of a Hazara community in Lahore, despite the applicant's contention that such a community does not exist?
The court concluded that the applicant had not provided conclusive proof that there were no Hazaras in Lahore, and that it was for the IAA to decide whether or not to accept the information in the DFAT reports. As a result, the application on this ground was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Federal Circuit Court of Australia, in the case of DAB16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, reviewed the decision made by the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA) regarding the applicant's claim for a protection visa. The applicant, a Shia Hazara from Balochistan, Pakistan, argued that he faced persecution due to his ethnicity and religious beliefs if he were to return to Pakistan. The court assessed several key issues, including whether the IAA's decision was affected by jurisdictional error, the use of incorrect information, and the IAA's conclusion on the applicant's potential relocation within Pakistan.
Firstly, the court examined whether the IAA's decision was tainted by a jurisdictional error, particularly in failing to assess the applicant's claims as required by law and the principles of procedural fairness. The applicant argued that the IAA's conclusion was illogical and irrational, suggesting that the IAA did not sufficiently consider the evidence presented. However, the court found that the IAA had, in fact, considered the applicant's claims comprehensively. The IAA's reasoning process, while not explicitly mentioning the applicant's ethnicity in certain paragraphs, demonstrated an overarching consideration of the applicant's status as a Shia Hazara throughout the decision-making process. The court held that the IAA's conclusions were open on the evidence presented, and thus, there was no jurisdictional error in this regard.
Secondly, the court addressed whether the IAA's reliance on the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) reports constituted a jurisdictional error. The applicant contended that the DFAT reports incorrectly stated the existence of a Hazara community in Lahore, thereby undermining his claim. However, the court found that the applicant had not provided conclusive evidence to refute the DFAT reports. The IAA was entitled to rely on the DFAT reports as official documents, and it was for the IAA to determine the credibility and relevance of the information. The court concluded that there was no jurisdictional error in the IAA's use of the DFAT reports.
Thirdly, the court scrutinized the IAA's conclusion that the applicant did not have a well-founded fear of persecution if he were to return to Pakistan, particularly in relation to his ethnicity as a Shia Hazara. The IAA had considered the risk of targeted harm against Hazara Shias in Balochistan, based on the DFAT reports, and concluded that the applicant would face a real chance of serious harm if he returned to his hometown. However, the IAA also assessed that there was a lower risk of such harm in Lahore, where a significant number of Hazaras reside, according to the DFAT reports. The court found that the IAA's conclusion was supported by the evidence and did not constitute a jurisdictional error.
Fourthly, the court evaluated whether the IAA erred in finding it reasonable for the applicant to relocate to Lahore, thereby failing to meet the criteria for complementary protection under the Migration Act 1958. The applicant argued that the IAA ignored the fact that he would be identifiable as a Hazara Shia in Lahore and thus, it should not have been reasonable for him to relocate there. The court noted that the IAA had considered the personal circumstances of the applicant and his fiancée, including their ability to adapt and find employment in Lahore. The IAA concluded that it was reasonable for the applicant to relocate to Lahore, which the court found to be a conclusion open on the evidence. Therefore, there was no jurisdictional error in this regard.
Lastly, the court assessed whether there was a jurisdictional error in the IAA's reliance on DFAT reports regarding the presence of a Hazara community in Lahore, despite the applicant's contention that such a community does not exist. The court found that it was for the IAA to determine the credibility of the DFAT reports and that the applicant had not provided sufficient evidence to prove that the DFAT reports were incorrect. The IAA's reliance on the DFAT reports did not constitute a jurisdictional error.
In conclusion, the Federal Circuit Court of Australia found no jurisdictional error in the IAA's decision and dismissed the applicant's application for judicial review. The court held that the IAA's assessment of the applicant's claims was comprehensive, and its conclusions were supported by the evidence. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that the IAA's decision on a protection visa application will be upheld if it is based on a reasoned and evidence-supported assessment, even if the applicant disagrees with the outcome.