CZT16 v Minister for Home Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CZT16 & ORS v MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS & ANOR [2020] FCCA 1451
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Protection visa – whether Tribunal erred in its approach to the plausibility of first applicant’s claims – whether Tribunal’s reasoning was baseless – whether decision unreasonable, illogical or irrational – what constitutes evident and intelligible justification – application dismissed.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.32, 32(2)(aa), 36, 36(2), 36(2)(aa) (b) & (c), 36(2A), & 65

Cases cited:

Thevendram v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 1910
W148/00A v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 679
Abebe v Commonwealth (1999) 197 CLR 510
Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Guo Wei Rong (1997) 191 CLR 559
CQG15 v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection (2016) 253 FCR 496
Minister for Immigration & Citizenship v SZMDS (2010) 240 CLR 611
Minister for Immigration & Border Protection v SZVFW [2018] HCA 30
DAO16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 2
Minister for Immigration & Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332
Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Stretton (2016) 237 FCR 1

First Applicant: CZT16
Second Applicant: CZU16
Third Applicant: CZV16
Fourth Applicant: CZW16
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number: ADG 122 of 2018
Judgment of: Judge Heffernan
Hearing date: 3 March 2020
Delivered at: Adelaide
Delivered on: 4 June 2020

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Peter Barnes
Solicitors for the Applicant: MSM Legal
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms Graycar
Solicitors for the Respondents: Sparke Helmore Lawyers

ORDERS

  1. The application is dismissed.

  2. The applicants are to pay the costs of the first respondent as agreed or taxed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT ADELAIDE

ADG 122 of 2018

CZT16

First Applicant

CZU16

Second Applicant

CZV16

Third Applicant

CZW16

Fourth Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This is an application for judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’) dated 1 March 2018. That decision affirmed an earlier decision of a delegate of the first respondent, made on 23 March 2015, refusing to grant the applicants protection visas under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘the Act’).

  2. On 24 February 2020, an Amended Application was filed and the application proceeded on the basis of the following single ground:

    “1.The AAT committed jurisdictional error in finding, at [64], that the First Applicant faces a “remote” rather than “real” risk of significant harm at the hands of her uncle if she were to return to Albania

    Particulars:

    a.An integer of the First Applicant’s claim for protection arises from her involvement as a “matchmaker” between her cousin, X and a worker at one of her mother’s vineyards. Their liaison was objected to by X’s father, who arranged for X to marry another man. X committed suicide.

    b.The First Applicant claimed that X’s father, her uncle, blamed her for his daughter’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CZT16 v Minister for Home Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCCA 1451
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Judge Heffernan considered an application by CZT16 and another applicant (the applicants) seeking judicial review of a decision made by the Minister for Home Affairs. The dispute concerned the plausibility of the first applicant's claims in relation to a protection visa application.

The court was required to determine whether the Tribunal erred in its approach to assessing the plausibility of the first applicant's claims, specifically whether the Tribunal's reasoning was baseless, unreasonable, illogical, or irrational. The applicants also contended that the Tribunal failed to provide an evident and intelligible justification for its findings.

Judge Heffernan applied principles from established case law, including *Thevendram v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs*, which clarified that a Tribunal does not err in law by making a factually incorrect finding if there is some material to support it. However, a conclusion lacking probative material or based on a non-existent fact, or a decision not made through a rational process, can constitute an error. The court also considered the definition of implausibility as something beyond human experience or inherently unlikely, as per *W148/00A v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs*. The applicants argued that the Tribunal had not identified inconsistencies in the evidence and, having found the applicant credible, was bound to assess the realistic chance of feared events occurring. The Minister, conversely, argued that the applicants were seeking an impermissible merits review of a factual finding. The court referred to the test in *Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS*, which states that a decision is not illogical or irrational if reasonable minds might differ on the conclusions drawn from the evidence. The court found that the applicants had not demonstrated that only one conclusion was open on the evidence, that the Tribunal's decision was not open on the evidence, or that there was no logical connection between the evidence and the conclusions drawn.

The application was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On the issue of plausibility assessments in refugee matters, the applicants referred the Court to certain passages in the decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court in Thevendram v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs[15] (‘Thevendram’):“A Tribunal does not err in law by making a “wrong” finding of fact. The principle thus expressed is that conclusion of fact, however unlikely, cannot be a “wrong” conclusion if there is some material to support it. That principle does not extend to a conclusion made in the absence of probative material or a conclusion based on the existence of a fact that does not exist. Ground for review will be shown, however, by failure of the Tribunal to observe the requirement of the Act that the decision be made by rational process … The Tribunal must give “proper, genuine and realistic consideration upon the merits to the material questions of fact before it.”[16](emphasis added)[15] [2000] FCA 1910 (‘Thevendram’).[16] Applicants’ Outline of Submissions, filed 18 February 2020, 8, quoting Thevendram [38]-[39] (Merkel J). The applicants submitted that the Tribunal failed to identify any inconsistencies, vagueness or lack of detail in the wife’s evidence that would lead to a conclusion of implausibility. The Court was referred to case law, including W148/00A v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs,[17] in which Lee J described implausibility in the following terms: “A circumstance is “implausible” if it is beyond human experience of possible occurrences, that is to say, inherently unlikely.”[18] It was further argued that the Tribunal could not have established an implausibility finding on the facts before it because the wife’s version of evidence had not been discredited.[19][17] [2001] FCA 679.[18] Ibid, [21] (Lee J).[19] Applicants’ Outline of Submissions, filed 18 February 2020, 9 [34]. Relying on Abebe v Commonwealth[20] and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Guo Wei Rong,[21] the applicant submitted that the Tribunal, upon finding that the appellant was credible, was bound to assess whether there was a real chance the events may occur as the applicant feared they would, yet the Tribunal did not accept the applicant’s fears to be realistic. This conclusion, on the applicant’s case was legally unreasonable and reached without logical or probative basis.[20] (1999) 197 CLR 510 [85] (Gleeson CJ and McHugh J).[21] (1997) 191 CLR 559 [576] (Brennan CJ, Dawson, Toohey, Gaudron, McHugh and Gummow JJ). For the above reasons, counsel for the applicants argued that irrationality and illogicality grounds had been made out, rendering it permissible for the Tribunal’s findings to be scrutinised by the Courts. It was submitted that, “there is no logical connection between the evidence – including the country information – and the inferences and conclusions drawn.” [22]For that reason, jurisdictional error was demonstrated. The first respondent submitted that the applicants sought to challenge a factual finding within the jurisdiction of the Tribunal which amounted to a request to engage in an impermissible merits review. The threshold is as stated in Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS (‘SZMDS’):[23][23] (2010) 240 CLR 611 (‘SZMDS’).“The test for illogicality or irrationality must be to ask whether logical or rational or reasonable minds might adopt different reasoning or might differ in any decision or finding to be made on evidence upon which the decision is based. If probative evidence can give rise to different processes of reasoning and if logical or rational or reasonable minds might differ in respect of the conclusions to be drawn from that evidence, a decision cannot be said by a reviewing court to be illogical or irrational or unreasonable, simply because one conclusion has been preferred to another possible conclusion.”[24][24] Ibid [131]. …“A decision might be said to be illogical or irrational if only one conclusion is open on the evidence, and the decision maker does not come to that conclusion, or if the decision to which the decision maker came was simply not open on the evidence or if there is no logical connection between the evidence and the inferences or conclusions drawn. None of these applied here.”[25][25] Ibid [135].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.