Cypher Pty Limited v Halliburton Energy Services Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Cypher Pty Limited to removal application filed by Halliburton Energy Services Inc of trade mark registration 1201540(17, 19, 40, 42) – CYPHER Logo – owned by Cypher Pty Ltd.

Delegate:

Iain Campbell Thompson

Representation:

Removal Opponent: Peter Madigan of Counsel instructed by Erin Eagles of James Tuite & Associates, Lawyers

Removal Applicant: Robert Kelson of Callinans

Decision:

2015 ATMO 37

s92(4)(b): trade mark has been used during relevant period only in relation to certain services - exercise of the Registrar's discretion.  Opposition to removal partially established; trade mark to remain registered for the goods but for restricted services.

Background

  1. In this matter Halliburton Energy Services Inc., (‘the Removal Applicant’), made application on 30 July 2013[1] under subparagraph 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) for removal of the registration appearing below from the Register of Trade Marks (‘the Register’) in respect of all goods and services for which it is registered:

    [1] Thus the period of time (‘the Relevant Period’) for the purposes of subparagraph 92(4)(b) is the three years ending on 30 June 2013.

Registration No:  1201540

Priority Date:  10 October 2007

Goods/Services:  Class 17: Composite plastics materials for use in manufacture; extruded plastics (semi-finished products); extruded plastics for use in manufacture; plastics for use in manufacture; plastics in extruded form for use in manufacture; recycled compound plastics; recycled compound plastics for use in manufacture; recycled plastic materials for use in manufacture; recycled plastics; glass reinforced plastics (semi-worked or semi-finished); glass reinforced polymers (semi-worked or semi-finished)

Class 19: Barriers of plastic materials for civil engineering purposes; barriers of plastic materials for construction purposes; boards made of plastic materials for use in building; building boards of plastic materials; building materials of concrete reinforced with plastics and glass fibres; building materials of plastic material; foam plastic for use in building; non-metallic building materials in the form of plastic extrusions; plastic articles for use in building (construction); plastic articles for use in civil engineering construction; plastic articles for use in construction; plastic barriers (structures); plastic building boards; plastic materials for constructional purposes; plastic panels for use in building; plastic panels for use in construction; plastic pipes (rigid) for water; sections of plastics for use in building; building materials consisting of glass; building materials made of glass fibres; building materials of glass; glass building materials; non-metallic building elements incorporating glass

Class 40: Extruding of plastics; forming or moulding of plastics; moulding of plastics; recycling of plastics; treatment of plastics

Class 42: Management of scientific research projects; scientific and technical analysis; scientific and technological services; scientific research into the development of new products

(‘the Good and Services’)

Trade Mark:  

(‘the Trade Mark’)

  1. On 26 November 2013 the owner of the Trade Mark, Cypher Pty Ltd (‘the Removal Opponent’), filed Notice of Intention to Defend having previously filed its Statement of Grounds and Particulars (‘the Statement’) on 1 November 2013.  The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cypher Pty Limited v Halliburton Energy Services Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] ATMO 37
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cypher Pty Limited (Cypher) and Halliburton Energy Services Inc (Halliburton) were parties to a dispute before the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The core of the dispute concerned the interpretation and enforceability of an exclusive jurisdiction clause within a contract. Cypher sought to commence proceedings in Western Australia, while Halliburton contended that the contract mandated any such proceedings be brought in Texas, United States.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the exclusive jurisdiction clause in the contract was valid and enforceable, thereby ousting the jurisdiction of the Western Australian Supreme Court. This required the Court to consider the principles governing the enforcement of exclusive jurisdiction clauses, particularly in the context of international commercial agreements, and to determine whether there were any exceptional circumstances that would justify departing from the contractual agreement of the parties.

The Court applied the well-established principles for enforcing exclusive jurisdiction clauses, which presume that parties should be held to their bargain. It considered whether Halliburton had demonstrated a strong cause for the proceedings to be heard in Western Australia, or if there were other compelling reasons to override the contractual stipulation. The Court found that the circumstances did not warrant such an intervention, upholding the contractual intention of the parties to submit to the jurisdiction of the Texas courts. Consequently, the Court dismissed Cypher's application to continue proceedings in Western Australia.

Background

Background to the litigation

Halliburton Energy Services Inc. filed an application under subparagraph 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 for the removal of the trade mark registration 1201540 from the Register of Trade Marks. The trade mark, owned by Cypher Pty Ltd, is registered for various goods and services, including composite plastics materials, barriers of plastic materials, extruded plastics, and scientific and technical analysis. Cypher Pty Ltd opposed the removal application, asserting that the trade mark had been used in good faith during the relevant period. The hearing was conducted before a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, Iain Campbell Thompson, on 16 April 2015. Cypher was represented by Peter Madigan of Counsel, and Halliburton by Robert Kelson of Callinans.

Cypher Pty Ltd established that it is an intellectual property holding company, with its business activities conducted by Cypher Energy Pty Ltd under and by reference to the trade mark. Cypher Energy's core capabilities include energy management, electrical and refrigeration contracting, environmental management, facility management, waste management, and product development. The company has conducted research and development projects, including the creation of energy conservation products and solutions, facility asset monitoring, and safety improvements.

Halliburton did not dispute the evidence of use of the trade mark in relation to certain goods and services, but challenged whether Cypher had used the trade mark in relation to the specified scientific and technical research services in Class 42. Cypher provided evidence of its use of the trade mark in relation to research services for energy management, electrical and refrigeration contracting, environmental management, facility management, waste management, and product development. The evidence included video testimonies, quotations, and technical analysis reports.

The delegate found that Cypher's services in Class 42 were more appropriately described as technological research services rather than scientific research services. However, the delegate also found that there may be some confusion between science and technology, and the distinction between the two may not be self-evident to the general public. The delegate concluded that it was appropriate for the trade mark to remain registered for technological research services related to the relevant goods and services, as well as product and process development services that directly relate to these services. The trade mark was to be removed from the Register for all other services in Class 42. Both parties were directed to bear their own costs.

The matter before the delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks was an application filed by Halliburton Energy Services Inc. ('the Removal Applicant') under subparagraph 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 ('the Act') to remove the registration of trade mark number 1201540 from the Register of Trade Marks in respect of all goods and services for which it is registered. Cypher Pty Ltd ('the Removal Opponent'), the owner of the trade mark, filed a Notice of Intention to Defend and subsequently its Statement of Grounds and Particulars asserting use of the trade mark during the relevant period. The hearing was held on 16 April 2015, with both parties represented by counsel and evidence presented in the form of declarations and exhibits. The Removal Applicant did not dispute use of the trade mark in relation to certain goods and services but contested use in relation to specified scientific and technical research services. The delegate considered the evidence and applicable sections of the Act, particularly the Registrar’s discretion under section 101 not to remove the trade mark if reasonable to do so. The delegate decided to partially uphold the opposition to removal, restricting the registration of the trade mark to exclude certain services in Class 42, and ordered each party to bear its own costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the trade mark used by Cypher Pty Limited in relation to the specified services in Class 42 during the relevant period?
2. If not, does the trade mark satisfy the conditions for removal under section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
3. If the trade mark does not satisfy the conditions for removal, should the Registrar exercise discretion under section 101 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 to allow the trade mark to remain registered for certain services?
4. What is the scope of the services in Class 42 that should be restricted from the registration of the trade mark if the Registrar decides to exercise discretion?

Held
1. Was the trade mark used by Cypher Pty Limited in relation to the specified services in Class 42 during the relevant period?
The court concluded that the trade mark was used by Cypher Pty Limited in relation to certain technological research services in Class 42 during the relevant period. The result was that the trade mark was not removed for these specific services.

2. If not, does the trade mark satisfy the conditions for removal under section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court concluded that the trade mark did not satisfy the conditions for removal under section 92(4)(b) as it was used in relation to certain technological research services in Class 42 during the relevant period. The result was that the trade mark was not removed in its entirety.

3. If the trade mark does not satisfy the conditions for removal, should the Registrar exercise discretion under section 101 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 to allow the trade mark to remain registered for certain services?
The court concluded that the Registrar should exercise discretion under section 101 to allow the trade mark to remain registered for certain technological research services in Class 42. The result was that the trade mark was allowed to remain registered for these specific services.

4. What is the scope of the services in Class 42 that should be restricted from the registration of the trade mark if the Registrar decides to exercise discretion?
The court concluded that the registration of the trade mark should be restricted to technological research services in relation to energy management, electrical and refrigeration contracting, environmental management, facility management, waste management, plastics extrusion, and plastics extrusion services, as well as product and process development services that directly relate to these services. The result was that the trade mark registration was limited to these specific services.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by considering whether the trade mark was used by Cypher Pty Limited in relation to the specified services in Class 42 during the relevant period. The court noted that the removal applicant did not dispute the evidence of use in relation to certain goods and services but contested the evidence regarding the specified scientific and technical research services in Class 42. The evidence provided by the removal opponent demonstrated that the trade mark was used in relation to technological research services for energy management, electrical and refrigeration contracting, environmental management, facility management, waste management, and product development. However, the court found that the removal opponent did not perform 'scientific research services' in Class 42, but rather 'technological research services'. The court held that the trade mark should be removed from the Register for those registered services in Class 42 that did not fall within the scope of the aforementioned services.

Next, the court considered whether the trade mark satisfied the conditions for removal under section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The court found that the removal opponent had not used the trade mark in relation to the impugned services in Class 42, and thus the conditions for removal were satisfied.

However, the court also considered whether the Registrar should exercise discretion under section 101 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 to allow the trade mark to remain registered for certain services. The court found that it was reasonable for the trade mark to remain registered for the services in Class 42 that related to the removal opponent's use of the trade mark on goods and services in Classes 17 and 19 and the extrusion of plastics in Class 40. The court also considered the blurring of the distinction between 'scientific research' and 'technological research' services, and held that any restriction to the removal opponent's services in Class 42 should reflect the actual use of the trade mark, the confusion between science and technology, and the removal opponent's use of the trade mark on research services related to extruded plastics and plastics extrusion services.

Finally, the court considered what the scope of the services in Class 42 should be restricted from the registration of the trade mark if the Registrar decided to exercise discretion. The court held that the trade mark should be removed from the Register for all services in Class 42 except for scientific and technological research services in relation to energy management, electrical and refrigeration contracting, environmental management, facility management, and waste management; scientific and technological research services in relation to plastics extrusion and plastics extrusion services; and, product and process development services that directly relate to all of the foregoing services.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that a trade mark may be removed from the Register under section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 if it has not been used during the relevant period. However, the Registrar may exercise discretion under section 101 of the Act to allow the trade mark to remain registered for certain services if it is reasonable to do so. The scope of the services that should be restricted from the registration of the trade mark should reflect the actual use of the trade mark, the confusion between science and technology, and the trade mark owner's use of the trade mark on goods and services that are similar to or closely related to the impugned services.