MIGRATION – mandatory cancellation of visa – substantial criminal offending - Iraq national – Class XB, Subclass 200 Refugee visa – failure to pass character test – serious offending – whether another reason mandatory cancellation should be revoked – Ministerial Direction No. 110 applied – expectation of Australian community - best interest of minor children - ties to Australia – legal consequences of removal – decision affirmed
Direction No. 110 – Migration Act 1958 – Direction under section 499: Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Country Information Report: Iraq (16 January 2023)
Statement of Reasons
On 20 September 2022 a delegate of the Minister, administering the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘the Minister’), cancelled CTWK's Class XB, Subclass 200 Refugee visa under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘the Act’).
On 17 October 2022 CTWK provided a response to the decision requesting revocation of the decision to cancel his visa for other reasons:
3.1 I am a refugee who faces the real likelihood of being killed if I am forcibly returned to Iraq;
3.2 My wife, and daughter (18) and son (12) are residents of Australia;
3.3 My sister has recently arrived in Australia as a refugee;
3.4 I have diverse employable skills and a good work history in Australia;
3.5 My family face severe hardship without me present in Australia to financially support them;
3.6 My family will face extreme hardship culturally and will continue to be shamed;
3.7 I have a place to live when I am released from prison;
3.8 My offending was isolated and opportunistic, I will not reoffend;
3.9 In sentencing me the judge said there was nothing to indicate an apparent risk of me reoffending in this way;
3.10 I have no support in Iraq, no ability to earn money, obtain a place to live or receive necessary medical and mental health treatment;
3.11 I have PTSD from…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read CTWK and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs... and more:
CTWK, an Iraqi national, has brought an appeal against the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs seeking to have his visa cancelled under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). CTWK was sentenced to three and a half years imprisonment for the sexual penetration of a child under 16 and sexual activity in the presence of a child under 16. The primary issue for the Tribunal to determine is whether there are other reasons to revoke the mandatory cancellation of CTWK’s visa. The Tribunal found that CTWK’s strong ties to Australia, including his long residence, work history, and involvement in the Chaldean community, and the best interests of his minor son, are significant factors in favour of revoking the visa cancellation. However, the Tribunal ultimately concluded that the seriousness of CTWK’s criminal offending and the protection of the Australian community from such conduct outweighed these considerations.
The Tribunal considered the primary consideration of protecting the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct, the best interests of minor children, and CTWK’s ties to Australia. While acknowledging the severity of CTWK’s crimes, the Tribunal recognised his long-standing residence in Australia, his contributions to the community, and his role as a father to his minor son. The Tribunal noted that CTWK had a close relationship with his son, providing financial and emotional support, and that his removal would have a significant impact on his son’s well-being. Despite these considerations, the Tribunal found that the gravity of CTWK’s offending, which involved the exploitation and sexual abuse of vulnerable teenage girls, necessitated the protection of the Australian community. The Tribunal determined that the mandatory visa cancellation should not be revoked, and affirmed the Minister’s decision.
Background
Background to the litigation
At the hearing of his application on 29 and 30 April 2025 CTWK was self-represented and Ms Kaylla Theocharous, appeared for the Minister. The Minister lodged a set of paginated G-Documents, summons documents from the Victorian Department of Justice and Community Safety, Victoria Police and medical records from International Health and Medical Services (IHMS). CTWK submitted numerous statements from family.BACKGROUND CTWZ is a 48 year old Iraq national born in Kuwait. CTWK arrived in Australia on 14 February 2013 on a Class XB, Subclass 200 Refugee visa having been recognised by the United Nations High Commissioner of Refugees (‘UNHCR’) as a Refugee on 27 July 2011. CTWK was 35 at the time he arrived with his wife and 2 children and has not left Australia since. CTWZ attended school in Kuwait until he was around 14, the equivalent of year 8, when his family moved to Iraq during the Kuwait/Iraq war. In Iraq CTWK lived under the Saddam Hussein regime, witnessed war, siege, and general civil unrest. During this period CTWK and his family experienced poverty due to the sanctions imposed upon citizens, witnessed daily violence including killings, explosions, bombings, and insurgency. CTWK is an Arabic speaking practicing Christian having been raised in the Chaldean Catholic Church. From 1995, CTWK served his three-year compulsory military service in the Iraqi Army as a soldier. From 1998-2010 CTWK worked as a police officer, and he also worked at KBR Government Solutions for the U.S. Embassy at the USA controlled airports in Iraq. In 2001 CTWK’s mother died suddenly form a cardiac arrest and in 2010 his father was murdered. CTWK witnessed ISIS members decapitating his father. CTWK has 3 sisters and a brother, all have left Iraq, he has a brother and sister in the US, a sister in Australia and another sister in Lebanon. CTWZ married in 2000 and has 2 children aged 21 and 14. In 2015 CTWZ and his wife separated. In 2010 fearing for his safety CTWZ fled Iraq having received four bullets in an envelope being told to leave in 24 hours or he and his family would be killed. CTWZ and his family went to Turkey where they lived for 2 years prior to being granted refugee visas to Australia. In Turkey CTWZ worked in construction and other jobs to support his family. CTWZ undertook English language courses when he arrived in Australia and prior to his incarceration CTWZ worked fulltime in numerous roles. As a warehouse packer in Dairy Country Cheese Factory from February 2014 to February 2018 and as a cleaner for Cabin Services Australia from March 2018 to February 2021.LEGISLATION Mandatory visa cancellation in circumstances of a substantial criminal record arises under s 501(3A) of the Act. This is one of a number of ways in which a person may fail the character test in s 501(6). A substantial criminal record is defined as including the situation where a person has been sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 12 months or more (s 501(7)(c)). A mandatory cancellation decision may be revoked upon application where a person is found to pass the character test, or where there is another reason to revoke the decision (s 501CA(4)). A compulsory source of guidance has been issued in the form of Direction No. 110 (‘the Direction’). I will refer to the factors identified in the Direction below, and also note that considerations are to be informed by the following principles:(1)Australia has a sovereign right to determine whether non-citizens who are of character concern are allowed to enter and/or remain in Australia. Being able to come to or remain in Australia is a privilege Australia confers on non-citizens in the expectation that they are, and have been, law-abiding, will respect important institutions, such as Australia’s law enforcement framework, and will not cause or threaten harm to individuals or the Australian community. (2)The safety of the Australian Community is the highest priority of the Australian Government. (3)Non-citizens who engage or have engaged in criminal or other serious conduct should expect to be denied the privilege of coming to, or to forfeit the privilege of staying in, Australia. (4) The Australian community expects that the Australian Government can and should refuse entry to non-citizens, or cancel their visas, if they engaged in conduct, in Australia or elsewhere, that raises serious character concerns. This expectation of the Australian community applies regardless of whether the noncitizen poses a measureable risk of causing physical harm to the Australian community. (5)Australia has a low tolerance of any criminal or other serious conduct by visa applicants or those holding a limited stay visa, or by other non-citizens who have been participating in, and contributing to, the Australian community only for a short period of time. (6)With respect to decisions to refuse, cancel, and revoke cancellation of a visa, Australia may afford a higher level of tolerance of criminal or other serious conduct by non-citizens who have lived in the Australian community for most of their life, or from a very young age. (7) Decision-makers must take into account the primary and other considerations relevant to the individual case. In some circumstances, the nature of the non-citizen’s conduct, or the harm that would be caused if the conduct were to be repeated, may be so serious that even strong countervailing considerations may be insufficient to justify not cancelling or refusing the visa, or revoking a mandatory cancellation. (8)The inherent nature of certain conduct such as family violence is so serious that even strong countervailing considerations may be insufficient to justify not cancelling or refusing the visa, or revoking a mandatory cancellation, even if the information available at the time of consideration suggests that the noncitizen does not pose a measureable risk of causing physical harm to the Australian community. ISSUES
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Accordingly, the issue for consideration by the Tribunal is whether the cancellation of CTWK visa should be revoked, taking into account the relevant considerations in the Direction. In essence, the Tribunal must be satisfied there is another reason why the original decision should be revoked.EVIDENCECTWK’s Offending The following table has been derived from a national criminal history check relating to CTWK, produced by the Australian Criminal Intelligence Commission on 2 August 2024: Following a guilty plea, Her Honour Justice Wilmot, imposed a term of 3 years 6 months years’ imprisonment, with a non-parole period of 2 years 4 months years. In her sentencing remarks, her Honour described CTWK’s offending, the background to the offending and the impact on the victim:you have pleaded guilty to one charge of sexual penetration of a child under 16 and one charge of sexual activity in the presence of a child under 16. The offending took place on one occasion on the night of 21 January 2021 and the early hours of the following morning. Two incidents make up the rolled-up charge forming Charge 1 on the indictment. One of those incidents was in the presence of another child which is Charge 2.You, a 43-year old man, were living in a share house and the girls were taken to your bedroom, where they were introduced to you.You and A gave the girls whiskey and what is described in the prosecution summary as “weed”, which the four of you smoked using a bong. You and A…talked to each other in Arabic and did not involve the two complainants in any conversation. Ms Fenner (Pseudonym) began to feel unwell as a result of smoking the drug. She lay down on the floor and Ms Lennon (Pseudonym) sat on the bed. A then had penis/vagina sex with Ms Lennon. While he did this, you penetrated her mouth with your penis so she was being penetrated by two men at the same time. You ejaculated in her mouth. This is part of Charge 1 which is a rolled-up charge.This activity was in the presence of Ms Fenner, who witnessed it and that is Charge 2. She used her phone to contact her brother asking him to pick her up as she felt uncomfortable and wanted to leave. Ms Lennon put on her clothes and walked with Ms Fenner to the front door. Ms Fenner left and met her brother a short distance away. Ms Lennon returned to your bedroom and had another bong. She then fell asleep on your bed, wearing only underwear and a jumper. When she awoke later in the morning, you were having penis/vagina sex with her. She pushed you away, collected her clothing and left. She went to the train station and caught a train to a station near her home where she was collected by her father.Ms Lennon provided a victim impact statement in which she described the very severe impact your offending has had on her. She is suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder and anxiety. She has given up going to school and no longer sees her friends. She and her family moved house as she feared that A would find her. She cannot be alone and her mother has had to stop working to be with her. At the time of writing last September, she was waiting for a place for treatment at the Gatehouse Clinic and she had a mental health worker through the youth service known as Orygen.This was extremely serious offending. You were many years older than the girls with an age difference of some 30 years. Although the offending occurred over a short period of one night, in effect, and was isolated and opportunistic, there are a number of aggravating features. You callously exploited two vulnerable teenage girls in a location that was unknown to them, giving them alcohol and drugs to render them even more vulnerable. You then sexually abused Ms Lennon in a crude and self-entitled way with no regard for her wishes or welfare. You and the other offender treated the girls in a despicable way by not even including them in any conversation or communication, but instead, treating them as objects. I treat those matters as aggravating factors.The second incident, part of Charge 1, occurred when you sexually penetrated Ms Lennon when she was asleep and that is a serious aggravating factor, as the learned prosecutor described it.In September 2021, you were assessed by the forensic psychologist, Ms Carla Ferrari, who took a detailed personal history from you. That is the source of much of what follows. You were born in Kuwait and you have reported that you had a good upbringing in your family. But because of the war there, the family had to relocate to Iraq in 1991 when you were aged 14 and you had no schooling after that. Your life in Iraq was spent in poverty due to sanctions imposed on citizens during the regime of Saddam Hussein, and you witnessed daily violence, including killings, explosions, bombings and insurgency.In 1995, you were conscripted into the Iraqi Army for three-year military duty where you served as a soldier. You then became a police officer from 1998 to 2010. Your mother died from natural causes in 2001 when she was 42. In 2010, your father was murdered by ISIS members. He was decapitated in your presence. At that time, your government position, working at the US Embassy, in addition to or as part of your police work meant that you were under threat from ISIS. Two of your sisters were displaced by ISIS and put in tents to live. Fearing for your family, you left for Turkey and you lived there for two years before being granted a refugee visa to come to Australia..PRIMARY CONSIDERATIONSPrimary Consideration 1: Protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct (paragraph 8.1)
Decision
Reasons for decision
The Tribunal found that CTWK’s strength, nature and duration of ties to Australia as a primary consideration, weighs in favour of revocation of his visa cancellation as he had lived in Australia for a considerable period of time, contributed to the Australian community through his solid work history, had financially and emotionally supported his family and was involved in the Chaldean Community. Best interests of minor children in Australia affected by the decision The Tribunal must determine whether or not a decision not to revoke the visa cancellation is in the best interests of a child affected by the decision (8.4(1)). The interests of children should be considered individually, and a range of specific factors are identified as relevant (8.4(3)-(4)).SubmissionsCTWK In CTWK’s personal circumstances form in his revocation request dated 13 October 2022 he advises:Currently my son is impacted by not having me physically present. To not see him play sport or discuss his interests or play video games with him. My absence has him lonely at timesThe impact on my son would be life changing. As the prospect of being returned to Iraq would almost guarantee my being killed my son will be without a father. My son will also be exposed to my recent past earlier than we desire for him to know and at such a crucial age could put him at risk of poor mental health. If removed, i am also unable to return to work and make money that will give my son the best opportunities in schooling/education going on holidays and undertaking extra curriculum activities such as sport or a hobby. I am only 45 i have many working years left. Without my financial contribution my son will miss out on a lot. CTWK submitted:·He had a very close relationship with his son ·That his son and daughter lived with their mother, but he was a large presence in their lives, supporting them financially, emotionally and before going to gaol saw them regularly·Spoke to his son as much as he could when he was in prison and now speaks to him daily and has had visits from him since being in detention ·His son was missing him greatly wanting to know when he would be home·The evidence from his separated partner and daughter demonstrated he was a loving and caring father who played a positive role in his son’s life·His son was at an age when he needed his father to help him develop into a good young man.Respondent The respondent acknowledges that CTWK has one minor son who resides in Australia and one adult daughter. The Respondent acknowledged that CTWK and his family members gave evidence that he has a very close relationship with his children. The Respondent accepted the evidence that CTWK has daily contact with his son, discusses his son's life with him and provides support, additionally his son has been visiting in immigration detention most recently for CTWK’s birthday. The respondent acknowledges that the applicant has asserted that he may not be able to financially support his son if he is removed to Iraq.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Following a guilty plea, Her Honour Justice Wilmot, imposed a term of 3 years 6 months years’ imprisonment, with a non-parole period of 2 years 4 months years. In her sentencing remarks, her Honour described CTWK’s offending, the background to the offending and the impact on the victim:you have pleaded guilty to one charge of sexual penetration of a child under 16 and one charge of sexual activity in the presence of a child under 16. The offending took place on one occasion on the night of 21 January 2021 and the early hours of the following morning. Two incidents make up the rolled-up charge forming Charge 1 on the indictment. One of those incidents was in the presence of another child which is Charge 2.You, a 43-year old man, were living in a share house and the girls were taken to your bedroom, where they were introduced to you.You and A gave the girls whiskey and what is described in the prosecution summary as “weed”, which the four of you smoked using a bong. You and A…talked to each other in Arabic and did not involve the two complainants in any conversation. Ms Fenner (Pseudonym) began to feel unwell as a result of smoking the drug. She lay down on the floor and Ms Lennon (Pseudonym) sat on the bed. A then had penis/vagina sex with Ms Lennon. While he did this, you penetrated her mouth with your penis so she was being penetrated by two men at the same time. You ejaculated in her mouth. This is part of Charge 1 which is a rolled-up charge.This activity was in the presence of Ms Fenner, who witnessed it and that is Charge 2. She used her phone to contact her brother asking him to pick her up as she felt uncomfortable and wanted to leave. Ms Lennon put on her clothes and walked with Ms Fenner to the front door. Ms Fenner left and met her brother a short distance away. Ms Lennon returned to your bedroom and had another bong. She then fell asleep on your bed, wearing only underwear and a jumper. When she awoke later in the morning, you were having penis/vagina sex with her. She pushed you away, collected her clothing and left. She went to the train station and caught a train to a station near her home where she was collected by her father.Ms Lennon provided a victim impact statement in which she described the very severe impact your offending has had on her. She is suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder and anxiety. She has given up going to school and no longer sees her friends. She and her family moved house as she feared that A would find her. She cannot be alone and her mother has had to stop working to be with her. At the time of writing last September, she was waiting for a place for treatment at the Gatehouse Clinic and she had a mental health worker through the youth service known as Orygen.This was extremely serious offending. You were many years older than the girls with an age difference of some 30 years. Although the offending occurred over a short period of one night, in effect, and was isolated and opportunistic, there are a number of aggravating features. You callously exploited two vulnerable teenage girls in a location that was unknown to them, giving them alcohol and drugs to render them even more vulnerable. You then sexually abused Ms Lennon in a crude and self-entitled way with no regard for her wishes or welfare. You and the other offender treated the girls in a despicable way by not even including them in any conversation or communication, but instead, treating them as objects. I treat those matters as aggravating factors.The second incident, part of Charge 1, occurred when you sexually penetrated Ms Lennon when she was asleep and that is a serious aggravating factor, as the learned prosecutor described it.In September 2021, you were assessed by the forensic psychologist, Ms Carla Ferrari, who took a detailed personal history from you. That is the source of much of what follows. You were born in Kuwait and you have reported that you had a good upbringing in your family. But because of the war there, the family had to relocate to Iraq in 1991 when you were aged 14 and you had no schooling after that. Your life in Iraq was spent in poverty due to sanctions imposed on citizens during the regime of Saddam Hussein, and you witnessed daily violence, including killings, explosions, bombings and insurgency.In 1995, you were conscripted into the Iraqi Army for three-year military duty where you served as a soldier. You then became a police officer from 1998 to 2010. Your mother died from natural causes in 2001 when she was 42. In 2010, your father was murdered by ISIS members. He was decapitated in your presence. At that time, your government position, working at the US Embassy, in addition to or as part of your police work meant that you were under threat from ISIS. Two of your sisters were displaced by ISIS and put in tents to live. Fearing for your family, you left for Turkey and you lived there for two years before being granted a refugee visa to come to Australia..PRIMARY CONSIDERATIONSPrimary Consideration 1: Protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct (paragraph 8.1)