CSQG and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

CSQG and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2020] AATA 2050 (1 July 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:2019/6472          

Re:CSQG

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndDGNS

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Member L M Gallagher

Date:1 July 2020

Place:Perth

The reviewable decision, being the AAT1 decision dated 12 September 2019, is affirmed.

..........................[sgd]..............................................

Member L M Gallagher

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care – whether there was a change in care –
actual care – extent of care – inconsistent evidence – conflicting evidence – no pattern of care – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) – ss 49, 50, 54A, 54F, 54G, 54H, 55C
Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) – s 87AA

CASES

Child Support Registrar v MQMV [2019] FCA 1171
P v Child Support Registrar [2014] FCAFC 98
P v Child Support Registrar [2013] FCA 1312
Parent A and Child Support Registrar and Anor [2013] AATA 562
Polec & Staker & Anor [2011] FMCAfam 959
Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2)

(1979) 2 ALD 634



SECONDARY MATERIALS

Guides to Social Policy Law: Child Support Guide – Chapter 2.2.1

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member L M Gallagher

1 July 2020

BACKGROUND

  1. The Applicant and the Other Party are the separated parents of two children. The present application relates to one of those children (the child), who is now 21 years of age.

  2. On 6 November 2001, a child support case was registered in relation to the child


    (R1, T26, page 213).

  3. Departmental records[1] refer to the Other Party as having 100% care of the child from


    6 June 2011 (R1, T26, page 215).

    [1] The Department of Human Services, as it was then known, was renamed Services Australia (the Agency) on 29 May 2019. For ease of reference, the term ‘Agency’ has been adopted throughout this decision, whether it be referring to a point in time where it was known as ‘Services Australia’ or, as it was previously known, as the ‘Department of Human Services’.

  4. On 19 November 2012, the Applicant wrote to Services Australia (the Agency) advising that since 19 September 2012, the child had been in his care two nights per fortnight


    (R1, T5, page 32).[2]  This information was not actioned at the time it was received, and the Agency apologised for the oversight (R1, T8, page 37).

    [2] By notifying the Agency of the claimed change in the percentage of care, the Applicant effectively requested that there be a change to the assessment of child support on the basis that the care of the child had changed.

  5. On 24 April 2014, the Child Support Registrar…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CSQG and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 2050
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a review of a child support percentage of care determination. The applicant, CSQG, sought to have a previous determination, which stated the other party had 100% care of the child, revoked and replaced. The dispute centred on the extent of CSQG's actual care of the child from 19 September 2012 onwards. The Child Support Registrar was also a party to the proceedings.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the existing percentage of care determination made on 6 June 2011 was still correct as at 19 September 2012. If it was found to be incorrect, the Tribunal then needed to determine the new percentage of care and the date from which that new determination should have effect. This involved assessing whether there had been a change in the pattern of care during the relevant period, which was from 19 September 2012 to 4 May 2017.

The Tribunal considered conflicting evidence from the applicant and the other party regarding the applicant's care arrangements. The applicant provided various statements and evidence suggesting different levels of care over time, including periods of shared care and 100% care. Conversely, the other party contended that the applicant had not had significant care of the child and that the applicant's claims were inconsistent and untrue. The Tribunal applied the ordinary meaning of "pattern of care," as interpreted in *Parent A and Child Support Registrar and Anor* [2013] AATA 562, which allows for flexibility and does not require unbending regularity, but rather a regular and intelligible form discernible in the actions or situations.

Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed the existing determination of percentage of care. This decision was based on the finding that the evidence did not establish a consistent or discernible pattern of care that would warrant revoking the previous determination. The Tribunal noted that the child had turned 18 by the time of the application, rendering any new determination from that point of little practical benefit.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal notes additional witness statements provided in support of the Other Party, by witnesses who did not give evidence during the hearing:(a)The Other Party’s sister;[22](b)The Other Party’s ex-partner;[23](c)The child’s tutor;[24](d)The Other party’s father;[25] (e)The Other Party’s friend;[26] and(f)The Other Party’s neighbour.[27]EVIDENCE AND PARTIES’ CONTENTIONS[22] Witness statement located at R1, T9, page 42 (dated 5 April 2014).[23] Witness statement located at R1, T9, page 43 (dated 1 April 2014) and at R1, T19 pages 123 and 124 (dated 3 March 2019).[24] Witness statement located at R1, T9, page 44 (dated 25 March 2014).[25] Witness statement located at R1, T19, page 120 (dated 18 March 2019).[26] Witness statement located at R1, T19, page 121 (dated 17 March 2019).[27] Witness statement located at R1, T19, page 122 (dated 13 March 2019).The Applicant’s evidence In his documentary evidence, the Applicant stated that his care of the child was as follows:(a)Two nights per fortnight since 19 September 2012 (as at 19 November 2012);[28][28] R1, T5. (b)Shared care[29] from 2008 to 2013, regular care[30] from May 2014 to [29] In this context, shared care is defined to be at least 35% to less than 65% of the care of the child (the Guide at 2.2.1).[30] Refer to footnote 10 above.May 2016 and the child being 100% in his care from May 2016 onward;[31](c)Every second weekend from 2003 to 2007, 50% of the time while he was working an eight days on/six days off roster from 2008 to 2013, every second weekend from May 2014 to May 2016 plus an eight-week trip and full-time from 6 May 2016 onward;[32] (d)50% of the time between January 2010 and September 2013, every other weekend plus eight weeks full-time between October 2013 and 2015 and 100% of the time from May 2015;[33] and(e)100% care of the child from 2015 and shared care prior to that.[34][31] A1, page 18.[32] A1, page 54[33] R1, T12.[34] R1, T27, page 260. At hearing, the Applicant gave evidence that he had had very difficult dealings with the Agency over the years. The Applicant said that he had, over the years, notified the Agency many times of the level of care he had of the children and nothing had ever transpired from it (transcript, page 18 [5]-[20]). The Applicant said that throughout 2011 and 2012 he had been going through a lot of personal difficulties (transcript, page 19 [15]). As to the Applicant’s care of the child from 2012 (transcript, pages 19 [25-45] and 20 [5-40]:CSQG: … Exact dates, you know, days I can’t recall but there was a time between 2008 and 2013 when I was on an eight and six roster that I had care of both kids 50 per cent of the time. Especially with [the child]. And then after around 2014 there was, as I stated, it was every second weekend on top of European trips that I had [the child] with me and [the child’s sibling] at the time from 2014 to 2016. And then obviously from 2016 to this very day, you know, and obviously he’s over 18 at the moment but he was a hundred per cent in care. So the kids or especially [the child] was never a hundred per cent care in her – she never had a hundred per cent care at all, it was always, as I stated there on the list. You know, working on an eight and six roster, which was a week on week off I had the kids, I had [the child] especially week on week off for that period of time.MEMBER: Could I just ask a question there, CSQG? So your letter T5 or I think it’s page 1 of the tender bundle where you’ve said:Two nights per fortnight since 19 September 2012.Now, in his opening Mr Fittock said that that was the case right up until 6 May 2016. But what I think I’ve just heard from you is more in accordance with the care record on page 54 of the tender bundle where you’ve talked about where it was 50 per cent when you were on the eight six roster and then went up to every second weekend more from 2014. So, Mr Fittock, do you see that that’s different?MR FITTOCK: Yes, I acknowledge that, Member.CSQG: At the time - sorry, Member.MEMBER: Yes, go ahead CSQG?‑‑‑At the time on the tender bundle the T5 where that was written by myself soon after that things changed with the care arrangements basically straight after, you know, straight after that. So at that time in that state of mind that I was in, you know, I was thinking I was doing the right thing and everything by being – you know, letting them know. But then the problem that started happening after things changed and I started making the phone calls to the Department and that’s where things started going pear shaped, you know.MEMBER: All right, well, then if that’s the case then - - -?‑‑‑And I never heard anything. I never heard anything. Sorry.MEMBER: I’ll ask you the same question I asked Mr Fittock then, if Mr Fittock doesn’t think it’s right and you don’t either. Is that in his opening he said that that was the case up until 6 May ‘16 but you’re saying that shortly after you wrote that the situation changed. So when would you say that changed?[The child] has been in my care two nights per fortnight since 19 September 2012.But you’re saying shortly after. So this was November 2012 that you wrote it, was it shortly after that or you can’t really say? I appreciate it’s a while ago but you seem to remember that it changed?‑‑‑Look, it was a while ago. We were on a 50 – I had [the child] on an eight six roster, then it did change for a very brief time, which I let the Department know and I put it in writing. And then after that it – basically within two or probably about two months after that.So early 2012?‑‑‑It just went – yes, after, you know, probably around just before, you know, Christmas time things just changed and it went back to normal. But then I did attempt many, many times to call the Department and then I never heard anything from them for a long, long while. And, yes, I just ‑ ‑ ‑All right, so I’ll just take that to be your evidence rather than what Mr Fittock said in opening. And I think, Mr Fittock, you seem happy with that?MR FITTOCK: (Indistinct), Member.(Emphasis added.)The Applicant’s witnessesFriend A

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 12 September 2019, the AAT1 affirmed the objection decision (the reviewable decision) (R1, T2). On 9 October 2019, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal’s General Division for a review of the reviewable decision on the basis that the Applicant disagreed with the reviewable decision and had further evidence to support the Applicant’s care percentage (R1, T1, page 2).ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION The issues for determination by this Tribunal are:(a)Whether the existing determination of percentage of care made on 6 June 2011 should be revoked and replaced. This requires the Tribunal to determine what percentage of care the Applicant and the Other Party each had of the child from 19 September 2012.(b)If so, that is, if the Tribunal finds that there was a change in the percentage of care from 19 September 2012 such that a new determination of percentage of care should be made:(i)What is the new percentage of care determination?(ii) What is the date from which the new percentage of care determination should have effect for the purposes of child support? This date will be either:· From the date the objection was lodged[3], which was on 9 February 2019[4]; or· From the date that the change in care was notified, being 19 November 2012. This will be the case only if there were special circumstances that prevented the objection from being lodged at the time it was required to be lodged, namely within 28 days of the original decision[5]. The period of time that needs to be considered in the context of special circumstances is the period between 24 April 2014, when the original decision was made, and 9 February 2019, when the objection was lodged.[3] Section 87AA(1) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) (the Collection Act) provides that where an objection is not lodged within 28 days of a percentage of care determination, and the objection is allowed in a way that has the effect of varying the percentage of care determination or substituting a new care percentage determination, the objection decision will have effect from the date the objection was lodged. In this context, a percentage of care determination includes a decision not to revoke an existing percentage of determination (Child Support Registrar v MQMV [2019] FCA 1171).[4] The Tribunal notes that the child was already 18 years of age by 9 February 2019 and the Child Support Assessment had ended. Therefore, a new percentage of care determination from this date would be of no practical benefit to the Applicant or to the Other Party.[5] Section 87AA(2) of the Collection Act provides that the Registrar may determine that the 28-day objection period be extended to such longer period as the Registrar determines appropriate if the Registrar is satisfied that special circumstances prevented the objection being lodged within the stipulated timeframe. In that situation, the objection decision has effect as if the objection were lodged within the 28-day timeframe and therefore will have effect from the date that the original decision had effect (being 19 November 2012 in the present matter).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

At hearing, the Other Party also submitted (transcript, pages 60 [30-40] and [45] and 61 [5] and [20]):…This whole process is – not process – this whole idea that CSQG had any of this time of care is really become so confusing because it just really didn’t happen, and that’s the truth. There never was a change in circumstances, and if you can refer back to my statement, which points out views of what I have been living with, with my children, there is no – the whole idea that there’s dates all over the place is just clinging to straws because none of it is true. There’s so many contradictions, even with CSQG’s statement, and then his witness’s [sic] statements, they don’t marry up to what CSQG has claimed, and he’s claiming so many different dates that actually it’s just – anyway, none of it makes any sense and none of it is marrying up…… …overall CSQG has missed out on many years of having time with the kids because he went along and he did what he wanted to do in his life, he went along, got well-paying jobs, he accumulated a lot of wealth. He missed out on taking the kids to birthday parties, to school. He missed out on the struggles of homework, doing assignments, he missed out on the struggles of bringing up teenagers, picking them up in the middle of the night, constantly. He missed all of that, and he won’t be able to ever tell you about doing any of that because it didn’t – it didn’t happen…… If we can just refer to page 111 of T19 in a text message that I have presented that admits the (indistinct) to me, in not a very nice way, “So you have 100 per cent of [the child] so you have 100 per cent of all the costs.” And that is exactly what has happened in the last 16 years of being divorced...CONSIDERATIONWhether the existing determination of percentage of care made on 6 June 2011 should be revoked and replaced The first matter for the Tribunal’s consideration is whether, as at September 2012, the percentage of care determination made on 6 June 2011, which referred to the Other Party as having 100% care of the child, is no longer correct. If so, then the next step for the Tribunal is to revoke the existing determination and replace it with a different determination of percentage of care as at that date. If not, then the existing percentage of care determination remains in place and that ends the Tribunal’s consideration of the matter. As the relevant care period has now passed, the Tribunal must determine the percentage of care by, in turn, determining the pattern of care that occurred during the relevant period, being 19 September 2012 to 4 May 2017.[52][52] Refer to footnote 8 above. The phrase ‘pattern of care’ is not defined in the Assessment Act. The meaning of the term was considered in the decision of Parent A and Child Support Registrar and Anor [2013] AATA 562. At [33] the decision states:The phrase ‘pattern of care’ is not given any special meaning for the purposes of the Assessment Act. Having regard to the text of ss 49 and 50 of that Act, and the content and purposes of Subdivision B of Division 4 of Part 5, the phrase can be interpreted according to its ordinary meaning. A pattern may be construed to mean a regular and intelligible form or sequence discernible in certain actions or situations, on which the prediction of successive or future events may be based. While these features may be necessary to establish a pattern of care, to my mind, in the wide variety of circumstances that may arise between parents in respect of care for children, especially where communication is afflicted by conflict and reason may be upset by emotional turmoil, room should be given for flexibility in the arrangement of care for children. In other words, the pattern looked for is not one characterised by precise conformation of detail, day by day, or by unbending regularity. Some accommodation may be expected for vicissitudes of circumstance in the care of a child, although the extent to which a pattern of care may bend or flex to accommodate variation is a matter to be determined in the facts and circumstances of each case. This interpretation is consistent with the Guide, which provides that that [sic] minor departures from the normal care of the child will not constitute a change to the pattern of care.(Emphasis added and footnotes omitted.)