CSO19 v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CSO19 v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2019] FCCA 3212
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Application for review of decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA) – whether the applicant was denied the opportunity to meaningfully present his claims and evidence – whether the IAA denied the applicant procedural fairness – no jurisdictional error revealed – application dismissed.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.36, 46A, 473DA, 473DD, 476

Cases cited:

AMF15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 68; (2016) 241 FCR 30; (2016) 338 ALR 551
BVD17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] HCA 34; (2019) 93 ALJR 1091
Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v CRY16 [2017] FCAFC 210; (2017) 253 FCR 475

Applicant: CSO19
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Second Respondent: IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY
File Number: SYG 1761 of 2019
Judgment of: Judge Nicholls
Hearing date: 31 October 2019
Date of Last Submission: 31 October 2019
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 14 November 2019

REPRESENTATION

Applicant: In person
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms R. Francois
Solicitors for the Respondents: Clayton Utz

ORDERS

  1. The application made on 11 July 2019 is dismissed.

  2. The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs set in the amount of $7467.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT SYDNEY

SYG 1761 of 2019

CSO19

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This is an application made pursuant to s.476 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”) on 11 July 2019, seeking review of the decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority (“the IAA”) which, on 7 June 2019, affirmed the decision of the Minister’s delegate (“the delegate”) not to grant a Safe Haven Enterprise Visa (“SHEV”) (Subclass 790) (a “protection visa”) to the applicant.

  2. In evidence before the Court is a bundle of relevant documents, filed and tendered by the Minister (“the Court Book” – “CB” – “RE1”).

Background

  1. The applicant is a citizen of Pakistan (item 6 at CB 3 and item 17 at CB 42) and Shia Islam religion (item 13 at CB 3 and item 33 at CB 44). He arrived in Australia on 5 June 2013 (item 46 at CB 49). The applicant applied for a protection visa, which was received by the Minister’s department on 23 June 2017 (CB 129.4, CB 130.3, and CB 25 – CB 75 generally). The applicant received a letter acknowledging receipt of a valid application for a protection visa from the Minister’s department on 28 July 2017 (CB 128 – CB 131). He made his claims to protection in a written statement that was attached to the application for the protection visa (CB 71 – CB 75).

  2. An officer of the Minister’s department wrote to the applicant on 28 July 2017 requesting that the applicant provide further documentary evidence of his: “…identity, nationality or citizenship…” pursuant to s.91W(1) of the Act, within 28 days…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CSO19 v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCCA 3212
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, CSO19, sought judicial review of a decision made by the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA). The core of the dispute concerned whether the applicant had been denied procedural fairness by the IAA, specifically in relation to his ability to meaningfully present his claims and supporting evidence. The matter was heard by Judge Nicholls in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia.

The legal issues before the Court were whether the IAA had denied the applicant procedural fairness by failing to afford him a meaningful opportunity to present his claims and evidence, and whether this failure constituted jurisdictional error.

Judge Nicholls reasoned that the applicant had been provided with ample opportunity to submit supporting documents. The application form itself, lodged on 22 June 2017, explicitly requested certified copies of documents that would support the claim for protection. The applicant, who declared he could read, write, and speak English, had assistance in completing the form and was not in detention at that time. He had over a year before being taken into remand to provide documents, many of which related to events in Pakistan that predated his detention. While the applicant later claimed to have "paper clippings" and the possibility of voice recordings and a letter from a Shia organisation, these were not provided to the delegate or the IAA. The delegate had, in fact, accepted the factual matters that these documents were intended to corroborate. The Court found no satisfactory explanation for the applicant's failure to provide the alleged corroborating evidence, nor any indication that his detention prevented him from meaningfully presenting his case. Consequently, no jurisdictional error was revealed.

The application was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, referred to as CSO19, lodged an application on 22 June 2017 for a visa under the Migration Act 1958. He included a written statement with his application, outlining his circumstances and claims for protection. The form he used for the application clearly indicated that he could speak, read, and write English, and it did not require legal assistance to provide supporting documents. The applicant received some help from the Refugee Advice and Casework Service (RACS) in completing the application form. Importantly, at the time of lodging the application, he was not in remand or detention, and there is no dispute that he had over 22 months to provide any additional documents that could support his claims.

On 5 July 2018, the applicant was taken into remand. Despite having ample time prior to his remand, he did not submit any additional documents that he now claims would have supported his case. The documents in question all related to events that occurred in Pakistan several years before his remand. During his telephone interview with the delegate on 4 April 2019, while he was in remand, the applicant mentioned that he had "paper clippings" of events in 2008 in Pakistan. He also indicated that his father might have voice recordings of threatening phone calls, although he did not specify which calls and confirmed that they would not be in English. Additionally, he mentioned the possibility of submitting a letter from a Shia organisation to verify the attacks he endured in Pakistan. However, he did not provide any of these documents to the delegate at that time, and the delegate accepted the matters that these documents were said to corroborate.

The matter of CSO19 v Minister for Immigration has its origins in an application for review filed by the applicant, CSO19, against a decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA). The applicant lodged an application on 22 June 2017, seeking to challenge the IAA's decision that allegedly denied him procedural fairness by not allowing him to meaningfully present his claims and evidence. This application for review was filed well before the applicant was taken into remand on 5 July 2018, providing ample time for the applicant to furnish supporting documents. The applicant was interviewed by the delegate via telephone on 4 April 2019, while in remand, and again raised the issue of corroborating documents that he claimed he wanted to present but did not. Despite being on notice for over a year before his remand, the applicant did not satisfactorily explain why he did not provide these documents earlier. This application for review is before the court on the basis of an alleged denial of procedural fairness by the IAA, with the applicant contending that he was not given a meaningful opportunity to present his claims and evidence.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

He made his application on 22 June 2017 (“Part B” at CB 29). The form that he used for that purpose included the following information (“Part A” at CB 26):“Other evidence and supporting documentsYou should provide with your application certified copies of:·any documents/evidence that you think will support your claim for protection;…” It is to be remembered that in the same application form the applicant declared that he could speak, read, and write, English (item 29 at CB 44). It did not require the services of a lawyer to provide documents which the applicant now says would have supported his case. In any event, he had some assistance in completing the form from RACS (item 7 at CB 38). At this time (22 June 2017), there is no dispute, that the applicant was not in remand or in detention. The application for the visa was accompanied by a written statement made by the applicant (CB 71 – CB 75). While there is a “disclaimer” in the statement as to the claimed limitations of the assistance offered by RACS, what remains is that at least 22 months before the delegate’s decision, let alone the period of the assessment by the IAA, the applicant would have been on notice that if he wanted to submit documents in support of his application, he should do so (see further below as to the documents he now says he wanted to provide). The applicant was taken into remand, on his own submission to the Court, on 5 July 2018. That is, the applicant had over a year from when he was put on notice to provide documents to support his case, to provide such documents. There was no satisfactory explanation from the applicant now to explain why he did not do so. As set out below, the documents in question all related to events in Pakistan, and predated, by some years, his being taken into remand. The applicant was interviewed by the delegate by telephone on 4 April 2019 (CB 135). The applicant, by that time, was being held in remand. Before the Court the applicant submitted (no evidence was provided) that he had told the Minister’s department that he had “paper clippings” of events in 2008 in Pakistan. The matter of corroborating documents that the applicant now says he wanted to put before the IAA, was raised before the delegate (at CB 148.8 – CB 149.2):“At the end of the interview, the applicant stated that he had some of the threatening letters and that his father may have voice recordings of the threatening phone calls. The applicant did not state which phone calls his father may have voice recordings of and confirmed that such calls would not be in English. I note that even if a voice recording was submitted, verifying the identities of the interlocutors and details of the call would be indiscernible. The applicant also stated that he could submit a letter from “a Shia organisation” which could verify the attacks he endured in Pakistan. The applicant was on remand during the time of the interview with the delegate. However, this of itself does not lead to any indication that he was denied a meaningful opportunity to present relevant evidence, or more importantly, given the circumstances, to meaningfully present his claims to the delegate. The matters which these documents were said to corroborate were accepted by the delegate.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant was denied the opportunity to meaningfully present his claims and evidence to the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA).
2. Whether the IAA denied the applicant procedural fairness in the assessment of his visa application.
3. Whether the applicant's late submission of documents could have reasonably been accommodated by the IAA.
4. Whether the applicant's status as being in remand affected his ability to meaningfully present his claims and evidence to the IAA.
5. Whether the IAA's acceptance of the matters corroborated by the documents the applicant now claims he wanted to submit indicates a denial of procedural fairness.

Held
1. Whether the applicant was denied the opportunity to meaningfully present his claims and evidence to the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA): The court held that the applicant was not denied the opportunity to meaningfully present his claims and evidence to the IAA, and dismissed the application.
2. Whether the IAA denied the applicant procedural fairness in the assessment of his visa application: The court held that the IAA did not deny the applicant procedural fairness, and dismissed the application.
3. Whether the applicant's late submission of documents could have reasonably been accommodated by the IAA: The court held that the applicant's late submission of documents could not have reasonably been accommodated by the IAA, and dismissed the application.
4. Whether the applicant's status as being in remand affected his ability to meaningfully present his claims and evidence to the IAA: The court held that the applicant's status as being in remand did not affect his ability to meaningfully present his claims and evidence to the IAA, and dismissed the application.
5. Whether the IAA's acceptance of the matters corroborated by the documents the applicant now claims he wanted to submit indicates a denial of procedural fairness: The court held that the IAA's acceptance of the matters corroborated by the documents the applicant now claims he wanted to submit does not indicate a denial of procedural fairness, and dismissed the application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia in CSO19 v Minister for Immigration comprehensively analyzed the applicant's claims regarding procedural fairness during the assessment of his visa application. The court examined the applicant's assertion that he was not afforded the opportunity to meaningfully present his claims and evidence to the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA). It was noted that the applicant had ample time to provide supporting documents, as indicated by the application form he completed on 22 June 2017, which explicitly stated the necessity of submitting relevant evidence. Despite this, the applicant did not submit the claimed documents until much later, even after he was taken into remand on 5 July 2018.

The court also scrutinized whether the IAA denied the applicant procedural fairness in the assessment of his visa application. The applicant's claims that his status in remand impeded his ability to present evidence were analyzed in detail. The court concluded that the applicant had sufficient notice and opportunity to submit documents supporting his claims well before the assessment period. The court highlighted that the applicant had over a year from when he was put on notice to provide documents, yet he failed to do so without a satisfactory explanation. Furthermore, the court found that the applicant's mention of "paper clippings" and other documents during his interview with the delegate on 4 April 2019 did not substantiate a denial of procedural fairness.

The issue of whether the applicant's late submission of documents could have reasonably been accommodated by the IAA was also addressed. The court reasoned that the documents in question pertained to events in Pakistan and predated the applicant's remand. The applicant's failure to submit these documents despite having been on notice for over a year undermined his claim of a meaningful presentation of evidence. The court relied on the principle that procedural fairness does not guarantee a perfect process but requires the applicant to make reasonable efforts to provide necessary evidence within the provided timelines.

Moreover, the court examined whether the applicant's status in remand affected his ability to meaningfully present his claims and evidence to the IAA. Despite the applicant's status in remand during the interview with the delegate, the court found no indication that this affected his opportunity to present relevant evidence. The applicant's reference to documents during the interview, even while in remand, did not substantiate a denial of procedural fairness. The matters which these documents were said to corroborate were accepted by the delegate, indicating that the applicant's claims were considered in the assessment process.

Finally, the court addressed whether the IAA's acceptance of the matters corroborated by the documents the applicant now claims he wanted to submit indicates a denial of procedural fairness. The court found that the acceptance of the matters by the delegate, even without the claimed documents, did not reveal a jurisdictional error or a denial of procedural fairness. The applicant's failure to provide the documents in a timely manner did not prejudice his case, as the delegate accepted the claims based on the information available at the time. The court's decision emphasized that procedural fairness requires the applicant to make reasonable efforts to provide necessary evidence, which the applicant did not do in this case.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the application for review of the IAA's decision, finding no jurisdictional error or denial of procedural fairness. The applicant was given ample opportunity to submit relevant evidence, and his failure to do so, despite being on notice for over a year, did not substantiate a claim of procedural unfairness. The court's decision underscores the principle that procedural fairness requires reasonable efforts by the applicant to present necessary evidence within the provided timelines.