CRWR and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

CRWR and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 3506 (2 October 2024)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:2022/2054          

Re:CRWR  

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:The Hon. P Goward AO, Senior Member

Date:2 October 2024

Place:Sydney

DECISION

Pursuant to section 43(1)(c) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the decision under review is set aside and remitted to the Respondent with the direction that the Applicant’s statement of participant’s supports be varied so as to specify the following as reasonable and necessary supports:

(a)30 hours annually psychology support;

(b)12 hours annually physiotherapy support;

(c)52 hours annually occupational therapy support, and additionally, 26 hours support for occupational therapist travel;

(d)80 hours annually for other therapies (inclusive but not limited to music therapy, speech therapy, exercise physiology, hippotherapy and swimming);

(e)30 hours annually for behaviour support plan, including development and training;

(f)70 hours annually Support Coordination (Level 2);

(g)$2,321.00 to fund the purchase of a ‘freedom wheels modified bike’ in accordance with the quotation provided.

.........................[sgd]...............................................

The Hon. P Goward AO, Senior Member

Catchwords

National Disability Insurance Scheme – Reasonable and necessary – expert or advocate – independence of expert evidence – evidence, probative value – parent disability – music therapy – independent – autism level 2 – responsibilities, expectations of parents – representation by parent with disability – internet access – decision under review set aside and remitted.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013

Cases

BIJD and National Disability insurance Agency [2018] AATA 2971
Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No.2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Mulligan and National Disability insurance Agency [2015] FCA 544
National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF [2020] FCAFC 79

Secondary Materials

NDIS Operational Guidelines - Reasonable and necessary supports, dated 6 October 2023
The National Disability Insurance Scheme Pricing Arrangements and Price Limits 2023-24

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Hon. P. Goward AO, Senior Member

2 October 2024

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant is a 16-year-old boy with Autism level 2 (ASD) who became a participant in the National Disability insurance Scheme (the Scheme) several years ago.

  2. On 1 September 2021 the Respondent approved a statement of participant supports, included in a NDIS plan. The plan included core supports, capacity building supports and funding for capital supports (a bicycle) once a quote for assistive technology had been provided.

  3. On 30 November 2021, the Applicant, through his father and Child Representative lodged an application for review of the decision. The decision was then reviewed internally and varied by the Respondent. A statement of participant supports was approved on 6 January 2022, with a review date of 1 January 2023.

  4. On 10 March 2022, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the internal review decision. For a range of reasons, including non-appearances at direction hearings by the Applicant’s Representative and extensive delays in the provision of evidence, the case then languished. Meanwhile,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CRWR and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 3506
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by the Applicant, CRWR, for review of a decision made by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) regarding funding for supports under the National Disability Insurance Scheme. The Applicant, who has Autism Spectrum Disorder Level 2, sought funding for various therapies and supports, including music therapy, psychology, physiotherapy, occupational therapy, and case coordination. The NDIA had made an offer of support, but the Applicant contended that this offer did not adequately address his reasonable and necessary needs. The Tribunal, presided over by Senior Member P Goward AO, was tasked with determining whether the disputed supports met the criteria of being reasonable and necessary under the Scheme.

The central legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the specific therapies and supports requested by the Applicant, including additional hours of behaviour support, psychology, physiotherapy, occupational therapy, and music therapy, were reasonable and necessary. Furthermore, the Tribunal had to consider the appropriate level and hours of case coordination required, particularly in light of the Applicant's complex needs and the significant impairments of his father, who is also an NDIS participant. The Tribunal also needed to assess the probative value of the evidence presented, including expert evidence and the testimony of the Applicant's father, who has significant personal health challenges.

The Tribunal's reasoning involved a detailed consideration of each requested support against the legislative framework of the NDIS, specifically sections 34(1)(c), (d), and (e) and Rules 3.1, 3.2, 3.4, and 5.1. The Tribunal accepted the NDIA's proposal for an updated Behaviour Support Plan, finding the proposed 30 hours per year reasonable and necessary. It also accepted the NDIA's offer for specified hours of psychology, physiotherapy, and occupational therapy, noting minor gaps in the requested hours for psychology and physiotherapy that would be addressed. The Tribunal acknowledged the Applicant's father's difficulties in managing the NDIS process and his concerns about discrimination, while also noting that a support coordinator had commenced working with them, a fact not initially disclosed. The Tribunal's approach to additional evidence, including that provided by the music therapist after her initial appearance, was also a key aspect of its reasoning.

The Tribunal ultimately set aside the NDIA's decision and remitted the matter for reconsideration. This was based on the Tribunal's findings that certain supports were reasonable and necessary and that the NDIA's original decision did not adequately address the Applicant's needs. The Tribunal indicated it would address the specific hours for psychology and physiotherapy and the issue of additional travel hours for therapists.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal also heard evidence from the Applicant’s father, Mr Graham Shaw, Psychologist, Ms Emma Townsend, Music Therapist, Ms Paige McGowan, Behaviour Therapist, Mr Cody Barrett, Physiotherapist, and Mr Josh Stubing, Occupational Therapist. After the music therapist, Ms Emma Townsend, had appeared before the Tribunal, she provided, as requested, additional evidence, which was accepted by the Tribunal. The Applicant’s Representative sought leave to file a reply to this submission and this was granted. The Tribunal’s approach to this additional material is discussed in later paragraphs of this decision.BACKGROUND The Applicant lives with his father nine days a fortnight and spends the remaining five days each fortnight with his mother and other family, who live approximately one hour away. The Applicant attends a local high school in a supported learning class but is apparently an intelligent young man with strong interests in history and music. He is graded in karate. He is independent in mobility and self-care, although his father considers his son’s ASD compromises his self-care and his failure to perform household tasks such as meal preparation. He is isolated socially and has difficulty with social communications, although limited evidence was available about social interactions at his mother’s home. The Applicant’s father is a former nurse; he is also, reportedly, a participant in the Scheme. Since the father’s impairments are significant considerations in this matter, for completeness they are, as described in a 2023 Occupational Therapy by Daniel Martin of Community Therapy: Schizophrenia (in remission), Major depressive Disorder, Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, Autism Spectrum Disorder Level 1, fracture to L5 vertebrae, L4/L5 disc herniation and compression, asthma, and allergy to mould. The Tribunal notes the fracture is an injury and while no date was provided for the injury, the first reference known to the Tribunal dates from a medical certificate of 13 January 2020, provided by reliance Medical Practice, so the fracture is well over four and a half years old. The Applicant’s father presented as a caring parent, calm, fluent and informed, but apparently unable to provide information and evidence in a timely and organised manner. He appeared to recognise his difficulties in managing the NDIS process and pointed out several times during the hearing that it would have been better had his son received legal representation and that he felt overwhelmed by the process. The Applicant’s father was also strongly of the view, as he expressed several times during the hearings, that he and his son were being denied appropriate supports through the lack of case coordination and discrimination against them on the grounds of Indigeneity. He omitted to advise the Tribunal that a support coordinator, Level 2, had commenced working with the Applicant and himself, which the Tribunal has inferred from on an email received from the Support Coordinator providing additional evidence on behalf of the Applicant after the hearing’s conclusion.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

While the Applicant contended that all requested supports were reasonable and necessary, the Respondent contended that the case had not been made that each of the disputed supports was reasonable and necessary, variously relying on section 34 (1) (c), (d) and (e) and Rules 3.1; 3.2; 3.4; 5.1 (b), (c). The contentions will be addressed in more detail as each requested support is considered in the following section.Reasons for Decision At the outset, the Tribunal notes that the Respondent offered additional hours of behaviour support to develop a new Behaviour Support plan for the Applicant. Although the Applicant did not request such a support, the behavioural therapist, Ms Paige McGowan, told the Tribunal the Applicant’s plan needed updating. It had not been updated for two years and the Applicant was expressing increasing concern about his independence. The Tribunal accepts the Respondent’s proposal for an updated Behaviour Support Plan of 30 hours per year, including training, replacing 20 hours for planning and finds there is sufficient evidence that this expanded support is reasonable and necessary. The Tribunal accepts that the Respondent offered to fund specified therapies, to be made up from a combination of 30 hours of psychology; 15 hours of physiotherapy and the funding of a new support in the form of 52 hours of occupational therapy. There are gaps of several hours in the hours requested by the Applicant for psychology and physiotherapy which the Tribunal will address. Additionally, the Respondent agreed to fund a global 80 hours of other therapies, in which the Applicant’s requested supports of music therapy, exercise physiology, hippotherapy, swimming, could be included in some combination. With respect to these requested supports, the Tribunal’s task is to determine whether any of these should be treated as separate items, with additional and specified funding provided. The issue of additional travel hours for therapists to attend the Applicant’s home will be treated separately to the requested supports themselves.Case Coordination While the Respondent offered to provide 70 hours of case coordination at Level 2 standard, the Applicant considered that his complex needs, when combined with those of his father (who is also a NDIS participants) warranted 30 hours case coordination at the higher standard of Level 3, with a further 70 hours at Level 2 acceptable to him. The Applicant’s Representative advised the Tribunal that he, as a participant in the Scheme, was already in receipt of Level 3 support coordination, but that it had been difficult to find case coordinators. As he told the Tribunal:“[W]e’ve engaged probably over the last seven years something like 20 level 2 support coordinators and out of those I would say that perhaps three have actually given it a good attempt to do their job and then have come unfortunately, they’ve either had a resignation in the company and weren’t able to provide the level of support that [the Applicant] needed or realised that his needs were beyond their capabilities”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established