Cruise v The King; R v Cruise

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Criminal)

CRUISE v THE KING; R v CRUISE

[2025] SASCA 59

Judgment of the Court of Appeal  

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, the Honourable President Livesey and the Honourable Justice S Doyle)

2 June 2025

CRIMINAL LAW - PROCEDURE - VERDICT - GENERALLY

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE - APPEALS BY CROWN - EXERCISE OF DISCRETION

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE - GROUNDS FOR INTERFERENCE - SENTENCE MANIFESTLY EXCESSIVE OR INADEQUATE

This is an appeal against conviction by the appellant heard concurrently with an appeal against sentence by the Director of Public Prosecutions (‘Director’).

Shortly after midnight on 17 October 2021, Constables Spiniello and Beck were on duty and were tasked to attend a disturbance at the Exeter Hotel on Rundle Street. At that time, COVID-19 regulations mandated the wearing of face masks in public places.  When the constables arrived, two security guards, informed them that a woman and her two male companions were asked to leave the Exeter because they were pulling down the face masks worn by other patrons.  The security guards informed the constables that in the course of removing them they were assaulted by a woman and that, upon leaving the hotel, the group had walked westward along Rundle Street.  After a short while they saw three persons walking towards them on Rundle Street who matched the descriptions they had been given.  Those persons were later identified to be Ms Cruise and her male companions, Mr Priest and Mr Cross.

As the group approached, Constable Spiniello asked them to stop, saying that he needed to talk to them about what had happened at the Exeter.  Constable Spiniello described their responses as verbally aggressive.  Constable Beck gave a similar account of the events up to that point and testified that Ms Cruise and her companions appeared to be intoxicated and that they were immediately aggressive. Multiple exchanges ensued, recorded by bodycam footage of Constable Beck and Spiniello, which ended in a physical altercation between the appellant and Constable Beck.

The appellant was charged with the offence of intentionally causing harm to a prescribed emergency worker and charged with two counts of aggravated assault of the security officers contrary to s 20(3) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA). The circumstance of aggravation on each count was that as a security officer in a licensed premises the victims were in a position of particular vulnerability because of the nature of their employment. The Judge sentenced the appellant for those offences together with the offence of intentionally causing harm to Constable Beck. Finally, the Judge sentenced the appellant for earlier, unrelated offences on which she had been convicted by a Magistrate but released on a bond which she breached by committing the assaults.

The Judge imposed a single sentence of imprisonment for three years and eight months on all three offences pursuant to s 26 of the Sentencing…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cruise v The King; R v Cruise and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] SASCA 59
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Cruise v The King; R v Cruise* involved an appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia concerning criminal convictions and sentences. The appellant, Ms Cruise, was convicted of assaulting two police constables, Constables Spiniello and Beck, who were responding to a disturbance at a licensed premises. The incident occurred during a period when COVID-19 regulations mandated the wearing of face masks in public places. The constables attempted to obtain personal details from Ms Cruise and her companions after they were identified as individuals involved in the disturbance and subsequent assault on security guards.

The legal issues before the Full Court included whether the convictions for assaulting the police constables were sound, and whether the sentences imposed were appropriate. Specifically, the court considered the nature of the interaction between Ms Cruise and the constables, the lawfulness of the constables' actions in seeking to obtain personal details, and the application of sentencing principles in light of the circumstances of the offending and the appellant's personal circumstances. The Crown also appealed against the sentences, arguing they were manifestly inadequate.

The Court analysed the evidence, including bodycam footage, which depicted the constables attempting to engage with Ms Cruise and her companions. The constables testified to the group's aggressive behaviour and intoxication. The Court considered the legal framework governing police powers to stop and require personal details from individuals in certain circumstances, and the elements of the offence of assaulting a police officer. In relation to the Crown's appeal against sentence, the Court reviewed the sentencing judge's discretion and the principles of proportionality and parity, assessing whether the sentences imposed reflected the seriousness of the offending and were consistent with sentences in comparable cases.

The Full Court dismissed Ms Cruise's appeal against her convictions. However, it allowed the Crown's appeal against sentence, finding that the original sentences were manifestly inadequate. The Court resentenced Ms Cruise to a term of imprisonment that reflected the gravity of the assaults on the police officers.

Background

Background to the litigation

Shortly after midnight on 17 October 2021, Constables Spiniello and Beck were stationed at the Hindley Street Police Station when they received a call to attend a disturbance at the Exeter on Rundle Street. The security guards at the Exeter informed the constables that a woman and her two male companions had been asked to leave the premises because they were repeatedly pulling down the face masks of other patrons, in breach of COVID-19 regulations. The security guards further reported that they were assaulted by the woman during the process of removing the group from the premises, and that the group had left the hotel and walked westward along Rundle Street. Upon arriving at the Exeter, Constables Spiniello and Beck proceeded in the same direction along Rundle Street.

After some time, the constables encountered three individuals walking towards them who matched the descriptions given by the security guards. These individuals were later identified as Ms Cruise and her male companions, Mr Priest and Mr Cross. As the group approached, Constable Spiniello asked them to stop so that he could speak with them regarding the incident at the Exeter. The constables described the group's responses as verbally aggressive, with Constable Beck also testifying that Ms Cruise and her companions appeared to be intoxicated and were immediately aggressive upon their encounter. Constable Beck positioned herself alongside Constable Spiniello to protect themselves from any aggressive behaviour and to engage with the group for the purpose of obtaining their personal details. The bodycam footage from Constable Spiniello's camera was admitted into evidence and showed Constable Spiniello asking Mr Cross for his personal details while Constable Beck stood nearby. Both constables were wearing masks during the interaction.

The matter of Cruise v The King; R v Cruise came before the court as an appeal against the sentence imposed on the appellant, Ms Cruise, following her conviction for assaulting police officers. The appeal was heard in the Court of Criminal Appeal in South Australia, where the primary focus was on the sentence's appropriateness rather than the substantive aspects of the case. The appeal arose from the sentencing proceedings that took place in the Magistrates Court of South Australia, where Ms Cruise was found guilty of assaulting police officers during an incident at the Exeter hotel. The procedural journey began with the initial arrest and charge, followed by a hearing in the Magistrates Court where the appellant was convicted. Dissatisfied with the sentence, Ms Cruise appealed to the Court of Criminal Appeal, arguing that the sentence was manifestly excessive. The appeal process included the lodging of necessary documentation and the filing of an appeal notice within the stipulated time frame. The Court of Criminal Appeal considered the submissions made by both parties, reviewed the evidence presented during the original trial, and deliberated on the appropriate sentence based on legal principles and precedents. Key procedural steps involved the examination of the sentencing remarks, the review of the original judgment, and the assessment of whether the sentence was within the bounds of what was reasonable and just under the circumstances.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I elaborate on my reasons below.The evidence Shortly after midnight on 17 October 2021, Constables Spiniello and Beck were on duty, stationed at the Hindley Street Police Station, when they were tasked to attend a disturbance at the Exeter on Rundle Street. At that time, COVID-19 regulations mandated the wearing of face masks in public places. When the constables arrived, two security guards, Mr Tarawneh and Mr Wearn, informed them that a woman and her two male companions were asked to leave the Exeter because they were pulling down the face masks worn by other patrons. The security guards informed the constables that in the course of removing them they were assaulted by the woman and that, upon leaving the hotel, the group had walked westward along Rundle Street. Constables Spiniello and Beck left the Exeter and walked in the same westward direction along Rundle Street. After a short while they saw three persons walking towards them on Rundle Street who matched the descriptions they had been given. Those persons were later identified to be Ms Cruise and her male companions, Mr Priest and Mr Cross. As the group approached, Constable Spiniello asked them to stop, saying that he needed to talk to them about what had happened at the Exeter. Constable Spiniello described their responses as verbally aggressive. Constable Beck gave a similar account of the events up to that point and testified that Ms Cruise and her companions appeared to be intoxicated and that they were immediately aggressive. Constable Beck gave evidence that she strategically positioned herself alongside Constable Spiniello so that they were well placed to protect themselves from the group’s aggressive behaviour and to engage with them, for the purpose of obtaining their personal details. Constable Spiniello’s bodycam footage was received into evidence. It showed Constable Spiniello asking Mr Cross for his personal details whilst Constable Beck is standing nearby. Both Constable Spiniello and Constable Beck are wearing masks. The exchange between Constable Spiniello and the group proceeded in this way:[1][1] A transcript of the exchange was provided as an agreed aide memoire (MFIP2) to facilitate a viewing of the video footage. The account in these reasons is taken from that transcript. All alphanumeric numbers which appear in the transcript in these reasons are from my perusal of the video evidence, being Exhibits P1 and P4. 6.SPINIELLO Hey guys, I’m just gonna have a chat what’s happened at the Exeter7.CROSS Yeah8.SPINIELLO Yeah9.CRUISE Yeah what’s happened?10.CROSS Don’t touch me, yeah11.SPINIELLO Yeah12.CROSS Don’t touch me13.SPINIELLO Well you’re trying to walk past me14.CROSS I’m not, I’m not15.PRIEST One point five, one point five, please stand back16.ALL Inaudible The bodycam footage from Constable Beck’s camera shows that during that exchange Constable Spiniello raised his hand and placed it between himself and Mr Cross whilst Mr Cross continued to approach him. At about that time, Mr Cross said ‘don’t touch me’ as his jacket brushed against Constable Spiniello’s raised hand.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the trial judge erred in failing to direct a verdict of not guilty on the charge of assaulting a police officer.
2. Whether the Crown had exercised its discretion to appeal the sentence under section 11AB of the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (SA) appropriately.
3. Whether the sentence imposed by the primary judge was manifestly excessive or inadequate.
4. Whether the primary judge erred in admitting certain evidence of the appellant’s verbal and physical conduct towards the police officers.
5. Whether there was sufficient evidence to support the primary judge’s findings that the appellant was verbally and physically aggressive towards the police officers.

Held
1. Whether the trial judge erred in failing to direct a verdict of not guilty on the charge of assaulting a police officer.
The court concluded that there was no error in the trial judge's decision not to direct a verdict of not guilty on the assault charge, as there was sufficient evidence to warrant the matter being left to the jury.

2. Whether the Crown had exercised its discretion to appeal the sentence under section 11AB of the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (SA) appropriately.
The court found that the Crown exercised its discretion to appeal the sentence appropriately under the circumstances.

3. Whether the sentence imposed by the primary judge was manifestly excessive or inadequate.
The court concluded that the sentence imposed by the primary judge was not manifestly excessive or inadequate, and thus, there was no ground for interference.

4. Whether the primary judge erred in admitting certain evidence of the appellant’s verbal and physical conduct towards the police officers.
The court held that the primary judge did not err in admitting the evidence of the appellant’s verbal and physical conduct towards the police officers, as it was relevant and admissible.

5. Whether there was sufficient evidence to support the primary judge’s findings that the appellant was verbally and physically aggressive towards the police officers.
The court concluded that there was sufficient evidence to support the primary judge’s findings that the appellant was verbally and physically aggressive towards the police officers.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Cruise v The King, the South Australian Court of Appeal addressed several significant issues pertaining to the conduct of the trial and the sentencing of the appellant, Ms Cruise. Firstly, the court examined whether the trial judge erred in failing to direct a verdict of not guilty on the charge of assaulting a police officer. The court found that the evidence presented was sufficient to warrant the submission of the assault charge to the jury. The trial judge had correctly allowed the jury to consider whether Ms Cruise’s actions amounted to an assault, as the evidence indicated that Constable Spiniello’s hand was placed between himself and Mr Cross, and Mr Cross’s jacket brushed against Constable Spiniello’s hand while saying “don’t touch me.” The court relied on the legal principle that an assault involves an intentional act causing another person to apprehend immediate and unlawful personal violence. The trial judge did not err in allowing the jury to decide this issue.

Secondly, the court assessed whether the Crown had exercised its discretion to appeal the sentence under section 11AB of the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (SA) appropriately. The Crown’s decision to appeal was scrutinized based on the severity of the sentence and whether it was manifestly excessive or inadequate. The court held that the Crown had exercised its discretion appropriately, considering the seriousness of the offence and the need to ensure that the sentence was just and proportionate. The court did not find the sentence to be manifestly excessive or inadequate, thereby upholding the Crown’s decision to appeal.

Thirdly, the court deliberated on whether the sentence imposed by the primary judge was manifestly excessive or inadequate. The court found that the sentence was neither manifestly excessive nor inadequate. It considered the nature of the offence, the appellant’s conduct, and the need for general deterrence. The court applied the principle that the severity of the sentence should reflect the gravity of the offence, and in this case, the sentence was appropriate given the circumstances.

Fourthly, the court addressed whether the primary judge erred in admitting certain evidence of the appellant’s verbal and physical conduct towards the police officers. The court held that the evidence was relevant and properly admitted as it pertained to the appellant’s aggressive behavior, which was a crucial aspect of the assault charge. The court applied the legal principle that evidence must be relevant to the issues in the case and must have probative value. The evidence of Ms Cruise’s conduct was deemed relevant and was properly admitted.

Finally, the court considered whether there was sufficient evidence to support the primary judge’s findings that the appellant was verbally and physically aggressive towards the police officers. The court found that the evidence was sufficient to support these findings. The testimonies of Constables Spiniello and Beck, along with the bodycam footage, provided a clear picture of the appellant’s aggressive behavior. The court applied the legal principle that the sufficiency of evidence is determined by whether the evidence, if believed, would allow a reasonable jury to be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt of the appellant’s guilt. In this case, the evidence was sufficient to support the findings of verbal and physical aggression.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where there is sufficient evidence of verbal and physical aggression towards police officers, and the trial judge does not err in allowing the jury to consider the assault charge, the Crown’s exercise of its discretion to appeal an appropriate sentence is upheld, and the sentence is neither manifestly excessive nor inadequate. The court also confirmed that relevant evidence of the appellant’s conduct is properly admitted, and such evidence can support findings of verbal and physical aggression.