Cranney v National Australia Bank

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Cranney v National Australia Bank [2011] FCA 1336

Citation: Cranney v National Australia Bank [2011] FCA 1336
Appeal from: National Australia Bank Ltd v Cranney & Anor [2011] FMCA 169
Parties: ROHAN GEOFFREY CRANNEY and DAVID KENNETH CRANNEY v NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK and CHRISTOPHER MEL CHAMBERLAIN
File number(s): NSD 516 of 2011
NSD 517 of 2011
Judge: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 22 November 2011
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – urgent interlocutory applications on the morning of hearing of the appeals to adjourn the hearing of the appeals – Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37M – whether it is in the interests of justice to adjourn the hearing – was there reasonable explanation for the delay – apparent inaction by solicitors - comparison of relative prejudices to each party - ability to relist without substantial delay - capacity of costs fixed and to be paid within 28 days to partially overcome prejudice to opposing party - ongoing sale of secured assets proceeding in the meantime - possibility of costs order personally against allegedly delaying solicitor if appropriate
Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37M
Cases cited: Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175
Date of hearing: 21 November 2011
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 27
Counsel for the Appellants: J Chambers
Solicitor for the Appellants: Jackson Lalic Lawyers
Counsel for the First Respondent: JT Johnson
Solicitor for the first Respondent: TurksLegal

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 516 of 2011

BETWEEN:

ROHAN GEOFFREY CRANNEY
Appellant

AND:

NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK
First Respondent

CHRISTOPHER MEL CHAMBERLAIN
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

21 NOVEMBER 2011

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Upon the Appellant’s solicitors giving an undertaking to pay the requisite filing fees, grant leave to the Appellant to file in Court the Interlocutory Application dated 18 November 2011 and an affidavit in support sworn by Rohan Cranney on 18 November 2011.

2.The Interlocutory Application be returnable instanter.

3.The time for service of the Interlocutory Application and affidavit in support be abridged to 6.00 pm on 18 November 2011.

4.The hearing listed on 21 November 2011 be adjourned to 17 February 2012 at 10.15 am.

5.The appeal be heard concurrently with proceedings NSD 517 of 2011.

6.The Appellant file and serve 5 copies of an outline of submissions, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm twenty (20) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal.

7.The Respondents file and serve 5 copies of their outline of submissions, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm ten (10) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal.

8.Outlines of submissions are not to exceed 10 pages in length (including any annexures).

9.The Appellant file and serve 5 copies of the Part C…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cranney v National Australia Bank and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 1336
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Cranney v National Australia Bank involved the appellants, Rohan Geoffrey Cranney and David Kenneth Cranney, appealing against a decision of the Federal Magistrate to set aside their personal insolvency agreements and make sequestration orders against them. The appeals were set to be heard on 21 November 2011, but the appellants sought an adjournment due to delays in preparing the appeals. The appellants had engaged a solicitor to handle the appeals but alleged that the solicitor had not taken the necessary steps to prepare the appeals in time. The court was required to determine whether the adjournment of the appeals was in the interests of justice, considering the potential prejudice to the respondent, National Australia Bank Ltd, and the appellants' circumstances.

The court acknowledged the unsatisfactory nature of the situation but found that the appellants were not directly responsible for the delay. It was noted that the appellants had personal difficulties, including eviction from their family farm, which had impacted their ability to provide necessary documents to the solicitor. The court also considered that the respondent had not suffered any obvious prejudice as the sale of the secured assets was continuing. The court found that the interests of justice could be served by granting the adjournment, provided certain conditions were met. The appellants were required to pay the respondent's costs within 28 days, and the respondent was granted leave to apply for a costs order against the solicitor.

In light of the above, the court granted the adjournment applications and made several orders, including the adjournment of the appeals to 17 February 2012, the payment of costs by the appellants, and the respondent's leave to seek a costs order against the solicitor. The court also set out specific filing and service requirements for the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Upon the Appellant’s solicitors giving an undertaking to pay the requisite filing fees, grant leave to the Appellant to file in Court the Interlocutory Application dated 18 November 2011 and an affidavit in support sworn by Rohan Cranney on 18 November 2011.

2. The Interlocutory Application be returnable instanter.

3. The time for service of the Interlocutory Application and affidavit in support be abridged to 6.00 pm on 18 November 2011.

4. The hearing listed on 21 November 2011 be adjourned to 17 February 2012 at 10.15 am.

5. The appeal be heard concurrently with proceedings NSD 517 of 2011.

6. The Appellant file and serve 5 copies of an outline of submissions, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm twenty (20) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal.

7. The Respondents file and serve 5 copies of their outline of submissions, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm ten (10) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal.

8. Outlines of submissions are not to exceed 10 pages in length (including any annexures).

9. The Appellant file and serve 5 copies of the Part C Appeal Book, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm five (5) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal.

10. Each party file and serve a list of authorities and legislation in accordance with Practice Note CM 2.

11. Within 28 days, the Appellant do pay the First Respondent’s costs thrown away by reason of the adjournment in both NSD 516 of 2011 and NSD 517 of 2011 fixed in total for both applications at $5,900, including the costs of the interlocutory applications.

12. The First Respondent have leave to file and serve within 28 days an interlocutory application seeking a third party costs order against the solicitor referred to in the affidavit of Mr Rohan Geoffrey Cranney dated 18 November 2011 to be listed for hearing on 17 February 2012 at 10.15 am.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

1. Upon the Appellant’s solicitors giving an undertaking to pay the requisite filing fees, grant leave to the Appellant to file in Court the Interlocutory Application dated 18 November 2011 and an affidavit in support sworn by Rohan Cranney on 18 November 2011.

2. The Interlocutory Application be returnable instanter.

3. The time for service of the Interlocutory Application and affidavit in support be abridged to 6.00 pm on 18 November 2011.

4. The hearing listed on 21 November 2011 be adjourned to 17 February 2012 at 10.15 am.

5. The appeal be heard concurrently with proceedings NSD 516 of 2011.

6. The Appellant file and serve 5 copies of an outline of submissions, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm twenty (20) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal.

7. The Respondents file and serve 5 copies of their outline of submissions, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm ten (10) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal.

8. Outlines of submissions are not to exceed 10 pages in length (including any annexures).

9. The Appellant file and serve 5 copies of the Part C Appeal Book, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm five (5) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal.

10. Each party file and serve a list of authorities and legislation in accordance with Practice Note CM 2.

11. Within 28 days, the Appellant do pay the First Respondent’s costs thrown away by reason of the adjournment in both NSD 516 of 2011 and NSD 517 of 2011 fixed in total for both applications at $5,900, including the costs of the interlocutory applications.

12. The First Respondent have leave to file and serve within 28 days an interlocutory application seeking a third party costs order against the solicitor referred to in the affidavit of Mr Rohan Geoffrey Cranney dated 18 November 2011 to be listed for hearing on 17 February 2012 at 10.15 am.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For reasons which follow, the adjournment was granted on terms. BACKGROUND The appeals relate to a decision of a Federal Magistrate given on 31 March 2011 (National Australia Bank Ltd v Cranney & Anor [2011] FMCA 169) in which the personal insolvency agreements of each of the appellants was set aside pursuant to s 222(1) and s 222(5) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (the BA). Sequestration orders were made against each of the appellants and they were ordered to pay costs of the first respondent. It is unnecessary at present to go into detail as to the reasoning of the judgment save to observe that a number of features of the appeals appear to challenge factual findings in the judgment. It is not possible at this stage, however, to express any concluded view as to the strength of the appeals. The circumstances giving rise to the adjournment applications were outlined in detail in an affidavit of Mr Rohan Geoffrey Cranney (Mr Cranney) sworn on 18 November 2011, the appellant in proceeding NSD 516 of 2011, both on his own behalf and on behalf of his brother, Mr David Kenneth Cranney, the appellant in proceeding NSD 517 of 2011. Mr Cranney explained that each of the appellants in April 2011 instructed an identified solicitor (the solicitor) to appeal the Federal Magistrate’s decision. Notices of appeal were filed on 21 April 2011. Mr Cranney says that in about late July or early August 2011, he received from the solicitor a copy of the orders made by Emmett J in relation to the conduct of the appeals. Thereafter, during the period between August and early November 2011 the solicitor sent ‘numerous requests’ for documents which had been relied upon in the Federal Magistrates Court proceedings. This was necessary because the solicitor had not then appeared on behalf of the appellants in those proceedings. Mr Cranney says that he and his brother complied with those requests to the best of their ability but the circumstances were very difficult as:(a)my family, my brother’s family and our parents were on notice that were to be evicted from the family farm at Collendina, New South Wales in July or August 2011;(b)in about mid-July 2011, my brother relocated his family to central New South Wales;(c)in anticipation of the eviction, I packed up the records held by me and my brother in relation to the Federal Magistrate Court proceedings into boxes and placed them in storage in Albury for safe keeping on about 11 August 2011;(d)on 12 August 2011, my family and my parents were evicted from the family farm;(e)upon being evicted, I had to relocate my wife and children to Sydney;(f)I spent 3 weeks from the date of the eviction in Corowa packing up the contents of my family’s home and those of my parents at the family property; and (g)thereafter, I relocated to Sydney to join my family and find work. Mr Cranney says that since the commencement of the appeals, either he and/or his father, Mr Geoff Cranney, have been in contact with the solicitor. As a result of a discussion with the solicitor, he understood that the solicitor was able to and presumably would attend to any outstanding matters so as to be in a position to run the appeals on its scheduled date of 21 November 2011.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As to prejudice to the first respondent, I was informed that the sale of the farm is continuing. At no time had the appellants sought a stay. It was not evident that there was to be an obvious prejudice suffered by the first respondent. From the first respondent’s perspective, while the uncertainty surrounding the situation was unsatisfactory, it was possible to make some provision for that prejudice by orders for costs to be payable within a short period of time (if not forthwith as sought by the first respondent) and also giving the first respondent liberty to apply for a costs order against the solicitor personally, if such a course were deemed to be appropriate. I stress that at this stage the solicitor has had no opportunity to be heard in relation to the matter. CONCLUSION In those circumstances I acceded to the adjournment applications and made the following orders:NSD 516 of 2011:1.Upon the Appellant’s solicitors giving an undertaking to pay the requisite filing fees, grant leave to the Appellant to file in Court the Interlocutory Application dated 18 November 2011 and an affidavit in support sworn by Rohan Cranney on 18 November 2011. 2.The Interlocutory Application be returnable instanter. 3.The time for service of the Interlocutory Application and affidavit in support be abridged to 6.00 pm on 18 November 2011. 4.The hearing listed on 21 November 2011 be adjourned to 17 February 2012 at 10.15 am.5.The appeal be heard concurrently with proceedings NSD 517 of 2011. 6.The Appellant file and serve 5 copies of an outline of submissions, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm twenty (20) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal. 7.The Respondents file and serve 5 copies of their outline of submissions, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm ten (10) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal. 8.Outlines of submissions are not to exceed 10 pages in length (including any annexures). 9.The Appellant file and serve 5 copies of the Part C Appeal Book, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm five (5) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal. 10.Each party file and serve a list of authorities and legislation in accordance with Practice Note CM 2. 11.Within 28 days, the Appellant do pay the First Respondent’s costs thrown away by reason of the adjournment in both NSD 516 of 2011 and NSD 517 of 2011 fixed in total for both applications at $5,900, including the costs of the interlocutory applications. 12.The First Respondent have leave to file and serve within 28 days an interlocutory application seeking a third party costs order against the solicitor referred to in the affidavit of Mr Rohan Geoffrey Cranney dated 18 November 2011 to be listed for hearing on 17 February 2012 at 10.15 am. NSD 517 of 2011:1.Upon the Appellant’s solicitors giving an undertaking to pay the requisite filing fees, grant leave to the Appellant to file in Court the Interlocutory Application dated 18 November 2011 and an affidavit in support sworn by Rohan Cranney on 18 November 2011. 2.The Interlocutory Application be returnable instanter. 3.The time for service of the Interlocutory Application and affidavit in support be abridged to 6.00 pm on 18 November 2011. 4.The hearing listed on 21 November 2011 be adjourned to 17 February 2012 at 10.15 am.5.The appeal be heard concurrently with proceedings NSD 516 of 2011. 6.The Appellant file and serve 5 copies of an outline of submissions, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm twenty (20) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal. 7.The Respondents file and serve 5 copies of their outline of submissions, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm ten (10) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal. 8.Outlines of submissions are not to exceed 10 pages in length (including any annexures). 9.The Appellant file and serve 5 copies of the Part C Appeal Book, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm five (5) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal. 10.Each party file and serve a list of authorities and legislation in accordance with Practice Note CM 2. 11.Within 28 days, the Appellant do pay the First Respondent’s costs thrown away by reason of the adjournment in both NSD 516 of 2011 and NSD 517 of 2011 fixed in total for both applications at $5,900, including the costs of the interlocutory applications. 12.The First Respondent have leave to file and serve within 28 days an interlocutory application seeking a third party costs order against the solicitor referred to in the affidavit of Mr Rohan Geoffrey Cranney dated 18 November 2011 to be listed for hearing on 17 February 2012 at 10.15 am.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Further, there was no guarantee that there would be legal representation for the appellants as it was made clear and there was no evidence to support the fact that there would be capacity to put Jackson Lalic in funds sufficient for the purposes of the appeals and to brief counsel. CONSIDERATION I accept the submission for the first respondent that the state of affairs is very unsatisfactory and that the apparent absence of any steps at all by the solicitor requires explanation. That said, there appears also to be extenuating circumstances insofar as the personal affairs and circumstances of the appellants are concerned. At least on the face of the matter at present, it would be difficult to hold them directly responsible for the absence of steps taken to prosecute the appeals. I accept the submissions for the appellants that the interests of justice may be more efficiently served in the most constructive way if the appellants are legally represented. There is no prospect, it seems, of representation if the adjournment applications were to be refused. Further, it is possible to re-list the appeals within a relatively short timeframe. As to prejudice to the first respondent, I was informed that the sale of the farm is continuing. At no time had the appellants sought a stay. It was not evident that there was to be an obvious prejudice suffered by the first respondent. From the first respondent’s perspective, while the uncertainty surrounding the situation was unsatisfactory, it was possible to make some provision for that prejudice by orders for costs to be payable within a short period of time (if not forthwith as sought by the first respondent) and also giving the first respondent liberty to apply for a costs order against the solicitor personally, if such a course were deemed to be appropriate. I stress that at this stage the solicitor has had no opportunity to be heard in relation to the matter. CONCLUSION In those circumstances I acceded to the adjournment applications and made the following orders:NSD 516 of 2011:1.Upon the Appellant’s solicitors giving an undertaking to pay the requisite filing fees, grant leave to the Appellant to file in Court the Interlocutory Application dated 18 November 2011 and an affidavit in support sworn by Rohan Cranney on 18 November 2011. 2.The Interlocutory Application be returnable instanter. 3.The time for service of the Interlocutory Application and affidavit in support be abridged to 6.00 pm on 18 November 2011. 4.The hearing listed on 21 November 2011 be adjourned to 17 February 2012 at 10.15 am.5.The appeal be heard concurrently with proceedings NSD 517 of 2011. 6.The Appellant file and serve 5 copies of an outline of submissions, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm twenty (20) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal. 7.The Respondents file and serve 5 copies of their outline of submissions, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm ten (10) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal. 8.Outlines of submissions are not to exceed 10 pages in length (including any annexures). 9.The Appellant file and serve 5 copies of the Part C Appeal Book, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm five (5) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal. 10.Each party file and serve a list of authorities and legislation in accordance with Practice Note CM 2. 11.Within 28 days, the Appellant do pay the First Respondent’s costs thrown away by reason of the adjournment in both NSD 516 of 2011 and NSD 517 of 2011 fixed in total for both applications at $5,900, including the costs of the interlocutory applications. 12.The First Respondent have leave to file and serve within 28 days an interlocutory application seeking a third party costs order against the solicitor referred to in the affidavit of Mr Rohan Geoffrey Cranney dated 18 November 2011 to be listed for hearing on 17 February 2012 at 10.15 am. NSD 517 of 2011:1.Upon the Appellant’s solicitors giving an undertaking to pay the requisite filing fees, grant leave to the Appellant to file in Court the Interlocutory Application dated 18 November 2011 and an affidavit in support sworn by Rohan Cranney on 18 November 2011. 2.The Interlocutory Application be returnable instanter. 3.The time for service of the Interlocutory Application and affidavit in support be abridged to 6.00 pm on 18 November 2011. 4.The hearing listed on 21 November 2011 be adjourned to 17 February 2012 at 10.15 am.5.The appeal be heard concurrently with proceedings NSD 516 of 2011. 6.The Appellant file and serve 5 copies of an outline of submissions, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm twenty (20) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal. 7.The Respondents file and serve 5 copies of their outline of submissions, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm ten (10) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal. 8.Outlines of submissions are not to exceed 10 pages in length (including any annexures). 9.The Appellant file and serve 5 copies of the Part C Appeal Book, as described in Practice Note APP 2, not later than 4.00 pm five (5) clear working days before the date fixed for the hearing of the appeal. 10.Each party file and serve a list of authorities and legislation in accordance with Practice Note CM 2. 11.Within 28 days, the Appellant do pay the First Respondent’s costs thrown away by reason of the adjournment in both NSD 516 of 2011 and NSD 517 of 2011 fixed in total for both applications at $5,900, including the costs of the interlocutory applications. 12.The First Respondent have leave to file and serve within 28 days an interlocutory application seeking a third party costs order against the solicitor referred to in the affidavit of Mr Rohan Geoffrey Cranney dated 18 November 2011 to be listed for hearing on 17 February 2012 at 10.15 am.