CQMS Pty Ltd v Esco Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

CQMS Pty Ltd  v Esco Corporation [2014] APO 54

Patent Application:                   2003275124

Title:Coupling arrangement

Patent Applicant:  Esco Corporation

Opponent:  CQMS Pty Ltd

Delegate:  R Subbarayan

Decision Date:  29 July 2014

Hearing Date:  7 May 2014, in Canberra

Catchwords:  PATENTS – opposition to grant of patent – all claims found to be clear, fairly based, novel and inventive – costs awarded against opponent.

Representation:  Patent applicant: Stephen Burley of Counsel assisted by Stephen Worthley of Minter Ellison

Opponent: Fisher Adams Kelly

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                   2003275124

Title:Coupling arrangement

Patent Applicant:  Esco Corporation

Date of Decision:  29 July 2014

DECISION

Opposition is wholly unsuccessful. The claimed invention is clear, fairly based, novel and inventive. Costs awarded against the opponent. The application is to proceed to grant if an appeal against this decision is not filed within the relevant period.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. Patent application 2003275124 in the name of Esco Corporation was filed on 22 September 2003 as a PCT application and claims priority from US application 60/411762 filed on 19 September 2002. The application was advertised as accepted on 23 September 2010. On 23 December 2010 CQMS Pty Ltd filed a notice of opposition to the grant of the patent under section 59 of the Patents Act. The opposition was heard in Canberra on 7 May 2014. While the Applicant appeared in person, the Opponent only filed written submissions for the hearing comprising submissions in chief received on 23 April 2014 and further submissions received on 6 May 2014.

    Grounds of Opposition

  2. The application has been opposed on the grounds of Novelty, Inventive Step, Clarity and Fair Basis.

    Evidence

  3. Evidence in Support comprises:

    ·Statutory Declaration dated 22 March 2013 by Dr John De Wit with exhibits JDW-01 to JDW-03

  4. Evidence in Answer comprises:

    ·A first Statutory Declaration dated 8 June 2013 by Hezekiah Russel Holland

    ·A second Statutory Declaration dated 21 August 2013 by Hezekiah Russel Holland

  5. Evidence in Reply comprises:

    ·Statutory Declaration dated 20 November 2013 by Dr John De Wit with exhibits JDW-04 to JDW-08

    Onus of Proof

  6. The examination request for this patent application was filed on 19 November 2007.  As a consequence, substantive amendments of the Patents Act brought about by the Intellectual Property Laws Amendment (Raising the Bar) Act 2012 do not apply to the present application. This includes the amendment to subsection 60 (3A) that allows the Commissioner to refuse a patent application if satisfied on the balance of probabilities that a ground of opposition exists.

  7. Consequently the former standard for opposition proceedings applies and the opponent must establish that it is clear or practically certain that the patent is invalid (F Hoffman La Roche AG v New England Biolabs Inc [2000] FCA 283 at [29], [67]; 50 IPR 305 at 311, 319; Commissioner of Patents v Sherman [2008] FCAFC 182 at [18], [22]; 79 IPR 426; Genetics Institute Inc v Kirin-Amgen Inc [1999] 92 FCR 106 at [17]).

    Specification

  8. The present invention relates…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CQMS Pty Ltd v Esco Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] APO 54
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of CQMS Pty Ltd v Esco Corporation, CQMS Pty Ltd opposed the grant of a patent to Esco Corporation for a coupling arrangement, specifically a lock for releasably securing a wear member to an excavating bucket of an excavator. The dispute was heard by the Australian Patent Office, with the decision rendered by Delegate R Subbarayan on 29 July 2014. The primary legal issues addressed by the court were the novelty, inventive step, clarity, and fair basis of the patent claims. The court examined the claims to determine whether they met the necessary criteria for patentability and whether the invention was sufficiently distinct from prior art.

The court began by interpreting the claims, emphasizing that they should be read from the perspective of a person skilled in the art. It found that the resilient member must provide sufficient resistance to prevent unintentional movement of the locking member from the locking position while still allowing for easy and reliable actuation. The court also clarified that the term "movement" in the claims referred to rotational movement rather than axial movement.

Regarding novelty, the court assessed whether the invention was anticipated by prior art documents cited by CQMS. It found that none of the cited documents disclosed all the features of the claimed invention. Specifically, the court determined that the locking members in the cited documents did not rotate within the resilient members as required by the claims, and the resistance provided by the springs in the prior art was insufficient to meet the criteria set by the claims.

The court did not consider the inventive step ground as CQMS did not press this issue. Concerning clarity and fair basis, the court found that the claims were sufficiently clear and fairly based on the specification, dismissing CQMS's arguments regarding these grounds.

Ultimately, the court ruled that the patent application met all the requirements for grant, finding the invention novel, inventive, clear, and fairly based. The opposition was wholly unsuccessful, leading the court to award costs to Esco Corporation. The decision allowed the patent application to proceed to grant, provided no appeal was filed within the relevant period.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.