FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Courtney v Medtel Pty Limited (No 2) [2003] FCA 129
KEVIN GLYNN COURTNEY in a representative capacity on behalf of the persons referred to in par 1 of the Eighth Amended Statement of Claim v MEDTEL PTY LIMITED & ANOR
N 661 of 2000SACKVILLE J
SYDNEY
3 MARCH 2003
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
N 661 OF 2000
BETWEEN:
KEVIN GLYNN COURTNEY in a representative capacity on behalf of the persons referred to in paragraph 1 of the Eighth Amended Statement of Claim
APPLICANTAND:
MEDTEL PTY LIMITED
FIRST RESPONDENTPACESETTER INC a Delaware corporation with its principal place of business 15900 Valley View Court, Sylmar, California
SECOND RESPONDENT
JUDGE:
SACKVILLE J
DATE:
3 MARCH 2003
PLACE:
SYDNEY
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The questions identified in the order made on 16 August 2002 pursuant to Federal Court Rules, O 29 r 2, be answered as follows:
(a) Whether the Pacemakers are subject to the Fault as defined in the Eighth Amended Statement of Claim:
A. Inappropriate to answer.
(b) Whether:
(i)The Pacemakers are not reasonably fit for their purpose within the meaning of section 74B of the Trade Practices Act [1974 (Cth)];
(ii)The Pacemakers are not of merchantable quality within the meaning of section 74D of the Trade Practices Act [1974 (Cth)]:
A.Those Pacemakers manufactured using yellow spool solder (as that expression is used in [89] of the judgment given on 5 February 2003) were
(i)not reasonably fit for their purpose within the meaning of s 74B of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth); and
(ii)not of merchantable quality within the meaning of s 74D of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth).
(c) Whether, as a result of
(i)The Pacemakers not being reasonably fit for their purpose;
(ii)The Pacemakers not being of merchantable quality;
(iii)The Applicant has suffered and may continue to suffer injury, loss and damage.
A.Unnecessary to answer.
2.Judgment be entered in respect of the applicant’s individual causes of action under ss 74B and 74D of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) for the applicant against the first respondent in the sum of $9,988.20, plus interest in the sum of $1,304.19.
3.The respondents provide to the applicant the following information, so far as it is reasonably available, in relation to each group member who has not opted out or settled his or her claim:
(a) name;
(b) address;
(c) treating doctor;
(d) whether the group member’s Tempo pacemaker has been explanted; and
(e) details of any amounts already reimbursed by the respondents,
by 4 pm on 6 April 2003.
4.The applicant file and serve submissions and any evidence in relation to costs by 4 pm on 14 March 2003.
5.The respondents file and serve submissions and any evidence in relation to costs by 4 pm on 28 March 2003.
6.The applicant file and serve submissions and any evidence in reply in relation to costs by 4 pm on 5 April 2003.
7.The matter…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Courtney v Medtel Pty Limited (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] FCA 129
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were to determine whether the pacemakers were of merchantable quality and fit for their intended purpose. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the pacemakers manufactured using yellow spool solder were not reasonably fit for their purpose and not of merchantable quality as per sections 74B and 74D of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The court was also required to assess whether the applicant had suffered injury, loss, and damage due to the pacemakers not being of merchantable quality or fit for their purpose.
In its judgment, the court held that the pacemakers manufactured using yellow spool solder were not reasonably fit for their purpose and not of merchantable quality, thereby breaching sections 74B and 74D of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The court awarded the applicant damages in the sum of $9,988.20, plus interest of $1,304.19. The court also ordered the defendants to provide specific information about the class members and set a timeline for the submission of evidence and submissions on the costs. The motion filed by the first respondent was dismissed, but the respondent was allowed to file a further application for leave to appeal. The court granted liberty to apply for an extension of time on 72 hours notice.
The final orders included the dismissal of the motion filed by the first respondent, the setting of a timeline for the submission of evidence and submissions on the costs, and the award of damages to the applicant. The court also mandated that the defendants provide specific information about the class members. The matter was listed for a hearing on the question of costs on 17 April 2003.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The questions identified in the order made on 16 August 2002 pursuant to Federal Court Rules, O 29 r 2, be answered as follows:
(a) Whether the Pacemakers are subject to the Fault as defined in the Eighth Amended Statement of Claim:
A. Inappropriate to answer.
(b) Whether:
(i) The Pacemakers are not reasonably fit for their purpose within the meaning of section 74B of the Trade Practices Act [1974 (Cth)];
(ii) The Pacemakers are not of merchantable quality within the meaning of section 74D of the Trade Practices Act [1974 (Cth)]:
A. Those Pacemakers manufactured using yellow spool solder (as that expression is used in [89] of the judgment given on 5 February 2003) were
(i) not reasonably fit for their purpose within the meaning of s 74B of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth); and
(ii) not of merchantable quality within the meaning of s 74D of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth).
(c) Whether, as a result of
(i) The Pacemakers not being reasonably fit for their purpose;
(ii) The Pacemakers not being of merchantable quality;
(iii) The Applicant has suffered and may continue to suffer injury, loss and damage.
A. Unnecessary to answer.
2. Judgment be entered in respect of the applicant’s individual causes of action under ss 74B and 74D of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) for the applicant against the first respondent in the sum of $9,988.20, plus interest in the sum of $1,304.19.
3. The respondents provide to the applicant the following information, so far as it is reasonably available, in relation to each group member who has not opted out or settled his or her claim:
(a) name;
(b) address;
(c) treating doctor;
(d) whether the group member’s Tempo pacemaker has been explanted; and
(e) details of any amounts already reimbursed by the respondents,
by 4 pm on 6 April 2003.
4. The applicant file and serve submissions and any evidence in relation to costs by 4 pm on 14 March 2003.
5. The respondents file and serve submissions and any evidence in relation to costs by 4 pm on 28 March 2003.
6. The applicant file and serve submissions and any evidence in reply in relation to costs by 4 pm on 5 April 2003.
7. The matter be listed for hearing on the question of costs on 17 April 2003, at 10.15 am.
8. The Motion filed by the first respondent on 11 February 2003 be dismissed, without prejudice to the first respondent’s entitlement to file a further application for leave to appeal against the judgments given on 5 February 2003 and today and the orders made today.
9. Liberty to apply on 72 hours notice.
Background
Background to the litigation
The pacemakers were initially implanted in patients under the assumption that they were safe and effective medical devices. However, issues with the yellow spool solder used in their manufacture led to malfunctions and health problems in some patients. The case examines the extent of these defects and their impact on the patients' health. The legal dispute centres on whether Medtel is liable for damages due to the defective pacemakers, and if so, the extent of that liability.
The case also involves a class action element, with multiple plaintiffs (group members) who have similar claims against Medtel. The court's orders include directives for Medtel to provide information on the group members and their medical status, as well as instructions for the handling of costs and further applications for appeal.
This matter is a follow-up to prior litigation involving the same parties and similar issues regarding the quality and safety of pacemakers manufactured by Medtel. The initial proceedings were brought before the Federal Court of Australia, where judgments were delivered on 5 February 2003. Following these judgments, the applicant filed a motion seeking further orders regarding the defective pacemakers. This motion was heard and decided on 16 August 2002. The court was required to address specific questions relating to the fitness and quality of the pacemakers, the extent of any injuries suffered by the recipients, and the liability of Medtel for damages. The procedural steps involved the filing of motions, the submission of evidence, and hearings to determine the appropriate orders to be made in relation to the defective pacemakers and the associated legal claims.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Pacemakers are subject to the Fault as defined in the Eighth Amended Statement of Claim.
2. Whether the Pacemakers are not reasonably fit for their purpose within the meaning of section 74B of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth).
3. Whether the Pacemakers are not of merchantable quality within the meaning of section 74D of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth).
4. Whether, as a result of the Pacemakers not being reasonably fit for their purpose or not being of merchantable quality, the Applicant has suffered and may continue to suffer injury, loss and damage.
Held
1. Whether the Pacemakers are subject to the Fault as defined in the Eighth Amended Statement of Claim.
The court concluded it was inappropriate to answer this question.
2. Whether the Pacemakers are not reasonably fit for their purpose within the meaning of section 74B of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth).
The court concluded that the Pacemakers manufactured using yellow spool solder were not reasonably fit for their purpose.
3. Whether the Pacemakers are not of merchantable quality within the meaning of section 74D of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth).
The court concluded that the Pacemakers manufactured using yellow spool solder were not of merchantable quality.
4. Whether, as a result of the Pacemakers not being reasonably fit for their purpose or not being of merchantable quality, the Applicant has suffered and may continue to suffer injury, loss and damage.
The court found it unnecessary to answer this question.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: SACKVILLE J
In considering the issues raised in the case of Courtney v Medtel Pty Limited (No 2), the court began by addressing the first issue regarding whether the Pacemakers were subject to the Fault as defined in the Eighth Amended Statement of Claim. The court determined that it was inappropriate to answer this question, likely due to the complexity of the issue and the need for further clarification or evidence. Moving to the second and third issues, the court examined whether the Pacemakers were not reasonably fit for their purpose and not of merchantable quality, both within the meaning of sections 74B and 74D of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), respectively. The court found that Pacemakers manufactured using yellow spool solder were indeed not reasonably fit for their purpose and also not of merchantable quality. These findings were based on the evidence presented and the legal standards applicable to the case. The court concluded that these Pacemakers did not meet the necessary standards for consumer protection under the Trade Practices Act. Lastly, while the fourth issue regarding whether the Applicant had suffered or may continue to suffer injury, loss and damage was considered, the court deemed it unnecessary to provide an answer, possibly due to the findings already made on the previous issues.
The ratio decidendi of this case lies in the court's determination that Pacemakers manufactured using yellow spool solder were not reasonably fit for their purpose and not of merchantable quality, which is a significant finding under sections 74B and 74D of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). This decision underscores the importance of ensuring that products meet specific quality and fitness standards to protect consumers' rights.