Coull v Nationwide News Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

Coull v Nationwide News Pty Ltd [2007] NTSC 47

PARTIES:RAYMOND PATRICK COULL

v

NATIONWIDE NEWS PTY LTD

(ACN 008 438 828)

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY exercising Territory jurisdiction

FILE NO:45 of 2005 (20528121)

DELIVERED:  25 September 2007

HEARING DATES:  18 - 20 June 2007

JUDGMENT OF:  THOMAS J

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:T Molomby SC

Defendant:N Swan and G McAvaney

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:Povey Stirk

Defendant:Minter Ellison

Judgment category classification:        C

Judgment ID Number:  tho200705

Number of pages:  57

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT ALICE SPRINGS

Coull v Nationwide News Pty Ltd [2007] NTSC 47
No.  45 of 2005 (20528121)

BETWEEN:

RAYMOND PATRICK COULL

Plaintiff

AND:

NATIONWIDE NEWS PTY LTD

(ACN 008 438 828)

Defendant

CORAM:     THOMAS J

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 25 September 2007)

  1. This is a claim by the plaintiff seeking damages for defamation.  The claim is in respect of an article published in the Centralian Advocate and the Northern Territory News on 7 December 2004.  This article, the plaintiff claims, conveyed of the plaintiff the defamatory imputation that he brutally bashed Lenny Frank on the face with a rock, causing gruesome injuries.  By reason of the publications of the matters complained of, the plaintiff claims he has been subjected to hatred, ridicule and contempt and suffered distress and damage to his reputation.

  2. The plaintiff claims damages, aggravated and exemplary damages, interest pursuant to s 84 of the Supreme Court Act 1979 (NT), and costs.

  3. Particulars of aggravated and exemplary damages are as follows:

    “(a)The defendant’s report of the court hearing on 1 December 2004 misrepresented the facts in a most unfair and irresponsible manner, which must have been known to the defendant.  Important aspects of the evidence were entirely omitted, principally that Ms Wendy Frank, a prosecution witness, had claimed responsibility for the assault of which the plaintiff was accused, and that the complainant Mr Frank had admitted that he had instigated the physical altercation between himself and the plaintiff.

    (b)The misrepresentations of the evidence was so clear and fundamental, and the damage to the plaintiff’s reputation by the article so serious and obvious, that the defendant must have decided that it could get away with flouting the plaintiff’s rights with such contempt because he would not have the means to seek recourse.

    (c)The articles were written in a sensational style and given maximum prominence, in order to attract readers for the commercial benefit of the defendant.

    (d)The defendant refused to apologise, though requested to do so in letters dated 19 April 2005 from the plaintiff’s then solicitor, which pointed out the errors in the article, and enclosed a transcript of the hearing for reference.”

  4. It is not in dispute that the defendant is an incorporated company and is the publisher of the Centralian Advocate and the Northern Territory News.  It is not in dispute the defendant published the article, which is the subject of the dispute, in both the Centralian Advocate and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Coull v Nationwide News Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NTSC 47
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Coull brought an action against Nationwide News Pty Ltd, seeking damages for defamation arising from an article published in the Centralian Advocate on 7 December 2004. The article reported on the criminal prosecution of Coull for the aggravated assault of Lenny Frank. The defendant claimed that the article was a fair and accurate report of legal proceedings under s 5 of the Defamation Act 1989 (NT) and at common law. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the defendant's publication of the article constituted defamation, and if so, whether it was protected by the statutory or common law defence of fair and accurate reporting of legal proceedings.

The court considered the nature of the publication, the context in which it was made, and the extent to which it accurately reflected the proceedings. The court found that the article contained statements that were defamatory of Coull, such as the suggestion that he and Wendy Frank discussed disposing of Lenny Frank's body in a wheelie bin, believing him to be dead. The court also noted the widespread circulation of the newspaper in the region, which would have exposed Coull to significant reputational harm. However, the court determined that the publication was a fair and accurate report of the legal proceedings, as it accurately reflected the evidence given in court and did not contain any extraneous or prejudicial material. The court concluded that the statutory and common law defences of fair and accurate reporting applied, and therefore the publication was not defamatory.

The court entered judgment in favour of the plaintiff in the sum of $13,344.00.

Orders

Orders of the court

I enter judgment in favour of the plaintiff in the sum of $13,344.00.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is the position of the defendant that the published article, which is the subject of complaint, was a fair and accurate report of legal proceedings pursuant to s 5 of the Defamation Act 1989 (NT) and at common law, namely the criminal prosecution of the plaintiff for the aggravated assault of Lenny Frank.Background to the Proceedings On 1 December 2004, the plaintiff entered a plea of not guilty to a charge of aggravated assault upon Lenny Frank in the Court of Summary Jurisdiction. Evidence was given during the course of the day by Dr Jacob Ollapallil Jacob, Lenny Frank, Wendy Frank and Karl Robert Day. The matter was adjourned for further hearing on 11 January 2005. On 7 December 2004, the following article was published on the front page and page 2 of the Centralian Advocate (Exhibit P1):“‘Dead’ man flees wheelie bin graveBash victim overhears horror planby Rebecca FalconerA WOMAN and her lover discussed dumping her brother’s battered body in a wheelie bin, unaware he was listening to them, a court heard.Wendy Nicole Frank told the Alice Springs Magistrates Court that she and Raymond Patrick Coull discussed how to dispose of her brother Lenny’s body as he lay on the floor.Ms Frank said: ‘We thought he was dead.’‘We thought to dispose it, we’d put Lenny’s body into a wheelie bin, then put the body into one of the utes that we had outside and then dispose that into a well.’‘But we argued the fact that he’s my brother and how would I know if he’s dead yet.’Mr Frank earlier told the court he was left laying on the floor of his mother’s Tennant Creek flat after Coull repeatedly bashed him with a rock.But he said after hearing the couple’s conversation, he mustered the strength to flee, before collapsing in the street outside. Mr Frank told the court that he heard Coull suggest to his sister that they grab his body, chuck him in the car and throw him down a mine shaft.Investigating officer Senior Constable Robert Day described in court Mr Frank’s injuries as gruesome.He said: ‘Mr Frank had extensive facial injuries, the like of which I’ve never seen before or since.’‘There was blood and skin flaps hanging down his face in various locations.’The court heard the incident happened after Mr Frank, who admitted to being drunk, began arguing with the pair over the state of his mother’s house.ArgumentThe defence also alleged that Mr Frank smashed a window on a door and that there was a further argument that he caused Ms Frank to miscarry after he attacked her.Alice Springs-born Ms Frank admitted in court that she had lied in her police statement.Although on the record of interview she denied it, she claimed in court she was drunk and that she lied for several reasons, including because she wanted to take the blame for the attack.She also said: ‘I was just trying to make a good name for myself with the police because the police that was interviewing me, I had a crush on him.’Magistrate John Birch adjourned the Coull’s hearing last Wednesday to January 11 next year.He faces the charge of aggravated assault.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Audit Bureau of Circulations in regards to the Northern Territory News and Centralian Advocate were tendered and marked Exhibit P3. The Ray Morgan readership survey showing the Northern Territory News was read by 50.7 percent of the population aged over 14 in the Darwin/Alice Springs base and the Centralian Advocate by just over 75.6 percent of the population of Alice Springs aged over 14 years at the relevant times was tendered as Exhibit P4.Evidence given by Raymond Patrick Coull in the Defamation Proceedings Mr Coull gave evidence that he has lived in the Northern Territory for 23 years. He stated he had lived and worked in Darwin for 12 months, Tennant Creek three years, Borroloola two years, Katherine six months and Alice Springs for 17 years. There was a break after 2000 when he went to Adelaide for four years. Mr Coull stated that a week after the incident which was the subject of the charge against him of aggravated assault, Lenny Frank was released from hospital and came round with five drunken aboriginal men and got stuck into him. Mr Coull gave evidence he left for Adelaide the next day and stayed there for four years. He returned to Alice Springs in 2004 when he was offered a position with the Northern Territory Government and came back for the job. This employment went for three months. He was before the Court of Summary Jurisdiction in relation to the incident with Mr Frank on 1 December 2004. The case was adjourned. Mr Coull went back to Adelaide but had to return for the court case and has stayed in Alice Springs since that time. He stated he could not afford to go back to Adelaide. He stated when he worked in Darwin he was concreting, working with 30 or 40 other employees. His work in Katherine was in a gold mine and would have involved 50 or 60 people. During this time he knew the names of the other employees and “knocked around with them”. In Tennant Creek he worked at the mine for three years with about 30 to 40 other employees. In Borroloola he worked in the construction industry for two years with a small crew of people. Mr Coull gave evidence that during the time he has been in the Northern Territory he has been a reader of the Northern Territory News and had read the Centralian Advocate from time to time. He stated everybody he knew would be reading the article about him. He saw the articles on the same day that they were published. He saw the headlines in the front of the newsagency. He read the article in the Centralian Advocate back at his hostel. He then went to the library and checked on the computer. He was on the front page of the Northern Territory News as well. He was shocked to read the article in the Centralian Advocate was about him. When he read the article, he said he was shocked and humiliated. He knew his friends and children would be reading it. He was fearful of retaliation. He had children in Darwin and Alice Springs who were of an age they could read. He was concerned about what could happen to his children at school. He was worried Mr Frank’s relatives would hassle his children at school.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.