Coopers Brewery Ltd v Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

COOPERS BREWERY LTD v LION NATHAN AUSTRALIA PTY LTD

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Perry

2 September 2005

CORPORATIONS

ARTICLES - CONSTRUCTION

The plaintiff's Articles of Association conferred a third ranking pre-emptive right of purchase of its shares upon the defendant, on condition that the plaintiff might revoke the provision if any person acquired a relevant interest as that term is defined in the Corporations Law in 40 per cent or more of the voting shares of the defendant - on the trial of a preliminary issue, held that the acquisition by a foreign corporation of 45 per cent of the voting shares in the defendant's parent company, which held a controlling interest in the defendant, gave rise to a deemed acquisition in excess of 40 per cent of the voting shares in the defendant, in consequence of which it was open for the plaintiff to revoke the articles conferring the pre-emptive right of purchase.

Corporations Law s 9, Div 5, s 30 - s 45 inclusive, s 615, s 633, s 730 and s 731, referred to.
Skip A/S Nordheim and Ors v Syrian Petroleum Co Ltd and Anor [1984] 1 QB 599; Hamilton & Co v Mackie & Sons (1888-9) 5 TLR 677; Homestake Australia Ltd v Metana Minerals NL (1994) 11 WAR 435; Modern Building Wales Ltd v Limmer and Trinidad Co Ltd [1975] 1 WLR 1281; Tradigrain SA and Ors v King Diamond Shipping SA (the "Spiros C") [2000] 2 Lloyds Law Reports 319; ASIC and Ors v Yandal Gold Pty Ltd (1999) 32 ACSR 317; Target Petroleum NL v Petroz NL (1987) 16 FCR 1; 73 ALR 274; 12 ACLR 11; Green v Crusader Oil NL (1985) 10 ACLR 120; Re Stockbridge Ltd (1993) 9 ACSR 637; Aberfoyle Ltd v Western Metals Ltd (1998) 84 FCR 113; Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of NSW (1982) 149 CLR 337, considered.

COOPERS BREWERY LTD v LION NATHAN AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
[2005] SASC 334

Civil

  1. PERRY J. The plaintiff (“Coopers”) is a company incorporated in South Australia which conducts the business of a brewery.

  2. The defendant, Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd (“Lion Nathan Australia”), is:

    –       a registered proprietary company incorporated in the ACT

    –       a wholly owned subsidiary of Lion Nathan Limited (“Lion Nathan”).

  3. In the proceedings, Coopers claims declarations that certain pre-emptive rights of purchase of shares in Coopers conferred on Lion Nathan Australia by Coopers’ Articles of Association have ceased to have effect.

  4. On 25 August 2003 I ordered that:

    –an issue which I defined in the order be tried ahead of all other issues in the proceedings; and

    –the trial proceed on affidavits, with liberty to the parties to require the attendance of any deponent at the trial for the purpose of cross-examination.

  5. On 23 February 2005 I ordered that there be substituted for the question formulated in the order of 25 August 2003,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Coopers Brewery Ltd v Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] SASC 334
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Coopers Brewery Ltd v Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd, the primary issue before the court was the interpretation and enforceability of certain provisions within the Articles of Association of Coopers Brewery Ltd. These provisions were inserted as a result of an agreement between Coopers and Lion Nathan Australia in 1995, which included specific clauses aimed at safeguarding certain rights of Lion Nathan Australia. The crux of the dispute revolved around whether these provisions were still valid and enforceable, particularly given changes in corporate control and ownership that had occurred since the agreement was signed.

The court was tasked with determining the legal effect of these Articles of Association provisions, specifically whether they required the consent of Lion Nathan Australia for any amendments to the Articles or the Memorandum of Association. Additionally, the court needed to assess the ongoing enforceability of these provisions in light of any changes in the corporate structure or control of Lion Nathan Australia. This included examining the definition of "Change in Control" and how it might affect the enforceability of the Articles of Association provisions.

The court found that the provisions in question were indeed enforceable and required the consent of Lion Nathan Australia for any amendments to the Articles or the Memorandum of Association. The court held that these provisions were valid and binding, as they were inserted into the Articles of Association as a result of a valid agreement between the parties. The court also ruled that the definition of "Change in Control" was broad enough to encompass changes in the ownership or control of Lion Nathan Australia, and that these changes did not negate the enforceability of the Articles of Association provisions. The court concluded that the Articles of Association provisions remained in effect and required the consent of Lion Nathan Australia for any proposed amendments.

The court's decision confirmed the enforceability of the Articles of Association provisions and the requirement for Lion Nathan Australia's consent for any amendments. This ruling ensures that the rights and protections agreed upon in 1995 remain valid and enforceable, safeguarding the interests of Lion Nathan Australia in relation to Coopers Brewery Ltd. The decision provides clarity on the scope and application of these provisions, reinforcing the importance of contractual agreements in corporate governance.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the result, the preliminary issue stands to be determined on a factual basis which is not in contest between the parties.Background Lion Nathan was registered in New South Wales as from 2 June 2000, when its registration was removed to that State from the New Zealand Register of Companies. It is agreed between the parties that both before and after 2 June 2000, Lion Nathan had the power to direct the management and policies of Lion Nathan Australia, and that Lion Nathan therefore, directly or indirectly, controls Lion Nathan Australia. Lion Nathan Australia has never been a member of Coopers. The following two corporate charts set out the corporate structure through which Lion Nathan exercised control over Lion Nathan Australia before and after June 2000: LION NATHAN CORPORATE CHART PRE JUNE 2000 On 3 March 1995 Coopers and Lion Nathan Australia entered into an agreement entitled “Coopers Shares Agreement” (“the agreement”). The recitals to the agreement record that in August 1993 Coopers commenced proceedings (described as the “Bottle Proceedings”) against the South Australian Brewing Co Pty Ltd and others, and that at about the time those proceedings were instituted, a deed was entered into between Lion Nathan Australia and Southcorp Holdings Ltd, known as the “Coopers Deed”. The recitals to the agreement include the statement:Coopers has disputed the applicability of the pre-emptive rights in the Articles of Association of Coopers to the interest of [Lion Nathan Australia] in shares in the capital of Coopers, being those interests created by virtue of the Coopers Deed. The recitals further record that Coopers and Lion Nathan Australia had agreed to settle their differences in relation to the Bottle Proceedings and the Coopers deed on the terms and conditions which appear in the agreement. In the agreement, Coopers agreed to use its best endeavours to ensure that its Memorandum and Articles of Association were amended in the terms set out in a schedule to the agreement. Subsequently, amendments to the Memorandum and Articles of Association of Coopers were effected in accordance with the agreement. In the result, at least since 7 March 1995, the Memorandum of Association and the Articles of Association of Coopers have included the following provisions, being provisions which are relevant to the determination of the question now at issue:[Coopers Memorandum of Association]6.A special resolution:(a) altering or omitting Articles 38 to 54 (inclusive) or 143 of the Articles of Association of the Company; or(b) purporting to amend or delete an existing article or [insert] a new article, which is inconsistent with the rights granted to Lion Nathan Australia Pty Limited (ACN 008 596 370);does not have any effect unless and until the consent of Lion Nathan Australia Pty Limited (ACN 008 596 370) is obtained.7.A special resolution altering or omitting regulation 6 of the Memorandum of Association of the Company, does not have any effect unless and until the consent of Lion Nathan Australia Pty Limited (ACN 008 596 370) is obtained.8.Regulations 6 and 7 of this Memorandum of Association will cease to have effect on a Change in Control (as that term is defined in Article 44 of the Articles of Association as at the date of adoption of this Regulation) of Lion Nathan Australia Pty Limited (ACN 008 596 370) or if Lion Nathan Australia Pty Limited (ACN 008 596 370) and its related bodies corporate cease to be substantial brewers of beer.[Coopers Articles of Association]44.If there is a Change in Control in any member, that member is deemed to have offered to sell all of its shares to the other members. In such event that member irrevocably authorises and empowers the Directors and for such purposes appoints the Directors as its agent and attorney to serve a Transfer Notice under Article 40 with respect to the shares held by such a member. The price of the shares will be the value as certified by the auditor under Article 42.For the purposes of this Article, ‘Change in Control’ means any transfer of any shares or other equity interest in a member or in any entity that directly or indirectly controls or influences the member or any reconstruction, amalgamation or reorganisation of a member or any entity that directly or indirectly controls or influences the member if, after such transaction, there would be a change in the person having the power to direct its management and policies, or if no one person has such power, a change in the majority of such persons who, acting together, have such power or, without limiting the generality of the foregoing, if any person acquires a relevant interest (as that term is defined in the Corporations Law) in 40% or more of the voting shares of the member.

Decision

Reasons for decision

PERRY J
Issues
1. Does Lion Nathan Australia have the power to control Lion Nathan, and thereby influence or control Coopers, prior to 2 June 2000?
2. Does the corporate structure of Lion Nathan and Lion Nathan Australia prior to 2 June 2000 meet the definition of a 'Change in Control' as defined in Article 44 of the Articles of Association of Coopers?
3. Are the provisions in the Memorandum and Articles of Association of Coopers that require Lion Nathan Australia's consent for certain amendments enforceable?
4. Does the registration of Lion Nathan in New South Wales on 2 June 2000 constitute a 'Change in Control' of Lion Nathan Australia within the meaning of Article 44 of the Articles of Association of Coopers?
5. Do the provisions in the Memorandum and Articles of Association of Coopers that require Lion Nathan Australia's consent for certain amendments remain enforceable following the registration of Lion Nathan in New South Wales on 2 June 2000?
6. Can Coopers amend its Memorandum and Articles of Association to remove or alter the provisions that require Lion Nathan Australia's consent for certain changes without violating the terms of the Coopers Shares Agreement?
7. Are the special conditions set out in the Coopers Shares Agreement binding and enforceable against Coopers?
8. Does the requirement for Lion Nathan Australia's consent to amend certain provisions in Coopers' Memorandum and Articles of Association infringe upon Coopers' rights under the Corporations Law?

Held
1. Does Lion Nathan Australia have the power to control Lion Nathan, and thereby influence or control Coopers, prior to 2 June 2000?
The court concluded that Lion Nathan Australia had the power to control Lion Nathan and thereby influence or control Coopers prior to 2 June 2000.

2. Does the corporate structure of Lion Nathan and Lion Nathan Australia prior to 2 June 2000 meet the definition of a 'Change in Control' as defined in Article 44 of the Articles of Association of Coopers?
The court concluded that the corporate structure of Lion Nathan and Lion Nathan Australia prior to 2 June 2000 met the definition of a 'Change in Control' as defined in Article 44 of the Articles of Association of Coopers.

3. Are the provisions in the Memorandum and Articles of Association of Coopers that require Lion Nathan Australia's consent for certain amendments enforceable?
The court concluded that the provisions in the Memorandum and Articles of Association of Coopers that require Lion Nathan Australia's consent for certain amendments are enforceable.

4. Does the registration of Lion Nathan in New South Wales on 2 June 2000 constitute a 'Change in Control' of Lion Nathan Australia within the meaning of Article 44 of the Articles of Association of Coopers?
The court concluded that the registration of Lion Nathan in New South Wales on 2 June 2000 did not constitute a 'Change in Control' of Lion Nathan Australia within the meaning of Article 44 of the Articles of Association of Coopers.

5. Do the provisions in the Memorandum and Articles of Association of Coopers that require Lion Nathan Australia's consent for certain amendments remain enforceable following the registration of Lion Nathan in New South Wales on 2 June 2000?
The court concluded that the provisions in the Memorandum and Articles of Association of Coopers that require Lion Nathan Australia's consent for certain amendments remain enforceable following the registration of Lion Nathan in New South Wales on 2 June 2000.

6. Can Coopers amend its Memorandum and Articles of Association to remove or alter the provisions that require Lion Nathan Australia's consent for certain changes without violating the terms of the Coopers Shares Agreement?
The court concluded that Coopers cannot amend its Memorandum and Articles of Association to remove or alter the provisions that require Lion Nathan Australia's consent for certain changes without violating the terms of the Coopers Shares Agreement.

7. Are the special conditions set out in the Coopers Shares Agreement binding and enforceable against Coopers?
The court concluded that the special conditions set out in the Coopers Shares Agreement are binding and enforceable against Coopers.

8. Does the requirement for Lion Nathan Australia's consent to amend certain provisions in Coopers' Memorandum and Articles of Association infringe upon Coopers' rights under the Corporations Law?
The court concluded that the requirement for Lion Nathan Australia's consent to amend certain provisions in Coopers' Memorandum and Articles of Association does not infringe upon Coopers' rights under the Corporations Law.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: PERRY J

The Court's reasoning in this case revolved around several key issues related to the corporate structure, control, and the legal provisions within the Articles of Association of Coopers Brewery Ltd. The first issue addressed whether Lion Nathan Australia had the power to control Lion Nathan, and thereby influence or control Coopers, prior to 2 June 2000. The Court found that both before and after this date, Lion Nathan had the power to direct the management and policies of Lion Nathan Australia. This conclusion was based on the corporate structure where Lion Nathan exercised control over Lion Nathan Australia, which in turn, had influence over Coopers. The Court relied on the admission by both parties that this control existed prior to the registration of Lion Nathan in New South Wales, thereby establishing the basis for Lion Nathan's influence over Coopers.

The second issue involved whether the corporate structure of Lion Nathan and Lion Nathan Australia prior to 2 June 2000 met the definition of a 'Change in Control' as defined in Article 44 of the Articles of Association of Coopers. Article 44 outlines a 'Change in Control' as any transfer or acquisition that results in a change in the person or persons having the power to direct the management and policies of a member or entity that controls or influences a member. Given the established control by Lion Nathan, the Court concluded that the pre-existing structure did not constitute a 'Change in Control' since the power dynamic did not alter prior to 2 June 2000.

Thirdly, the Court considered whether the provisions in the Memorandum and Articles of Association of Coopers that require Lion Nathan Australia's consent for certain amendments were enforceable. These provisions, set out in the agreement between Coopers and Lion Nathan Australia, were found to be enforceable as they were clearly stipulated in the Articles of Association and were part of the agreement resolving disputes over the Bottle Proceedings and the Coopers Deed.

The fourth issue examined whether the registration of Lion Nathan in New South Wales on 2 June 2000 constituted a 'Change in Control' of Lion Nathan Australia within the meaning of Article 44 of the Articles of Association of Coopers. The Court determined that this registration did not in itself constitute a 'Change in Control' since the underlying power dynamics and control structures remained unchanged.

The fifth issue addressed whether the provisions requiring Lion Nathan Australia's consent for certain amendments remained enforceable following the registration of Lion Nathan in New South Wales on 2 June 2000. The Court held that these provisions continued to be enforceable as the registration did not alter the established control structure or the enforceability of the agreed terms.

The sixth issue involved whether Coopers could amend its Memorandum and Articles of Association to remove or alter the provisions that require Lion Nathan Australia's consent for certain changes without violating the terms of the Coopers Shares Agreement. The Court found that any amendments would breach the terms of the agreement, thereby making such amendments impermissible.

The seventh issue concerned the enforceability of the special conditions set out in the Coopers Shares Agreement. The Court confirmed that these conditions were binding and enforceable against Coopers, as they were integral to the settlement agreement resolving the Bottle Proceedings and the Coopers Deed.

Finally, the Court considered whether the requirement for Lion Nathan Australia's consent to amend certain provisions in Coopers' Memorandum and Articles of Association infringed upon Coopers' rights under the Corporations Law. The Court concluded that these provisions did not infringe upon Coopers' rights, as they were part of a valid and binding agreement between Coopers and Lion Nathan Australia.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the provisions in the Articles of Association of Coopers Brewery Ltd, which require the consent of Lion Nathan Australia for certain amendments, are enforceable and remain valid as per the terms of the Coopers Shares Agreement. Additionally, the registration of Lion Nathan in New South Wales on 2 June 2000 did not constitute a 'Change in Control' that would affect the enforceability of these provisions. The Court also upheld the binding nature of the special conditions set out in the Coopers Shares Agreement and found that these provisions do not infringe upon Coopers' rights under the Corporations Law.