Coopers Brewery Ltd v Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

COOPERS BREWERY LTD v LION NATHAN AUSTRALIA P/L

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Bleby, The Honourable Justice Gray and The Honourable Justice Anderson)

19 October 2005

CORPORATIONS - CONSTITUTION AND LEGAL CAPACITY - MEMORANDUM AND ARTICLES OF ASSOCIATION - ARTICLES OF ASSOCIATION - PARTICULAR ARTICLES -- CONSTRUCTION

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS

Articles of Association – Construction – Articles conferring third ranking pre-emptive right of purchase upon appellant – Article permitting revocation of pre-emptive right without appellant’s consent if a change in control of appellant occurred – Acquisition by foreign corporation of 45% of voting shares in appellant’s parent company and where parent company held controlling interest in appellant – Whether foreign corporation acquired “relevant interest” within meaning of Articles of Association – Whether “change in control” of respondent within meaning of Memorandum of Association – Terms incorporated into a contract – Application of these principles to Article 44 – Importation of definition of “relevant interest” from s 9 and Div 5 of Corporations Law – Whether importation included s 33 Corporations Law – Imported definition of “relevant interest” to be consistent with other provisions of Article 44 – Appeal dismissed.

Corporations Law s 9, s 11(a), Div 5 s 30 - s 45 inclusive, s 235, s 615; Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 140, referred to.
Tradigrain SA v King Diamond Shipping SA [2000] 2 Lloyd's Rep 319; Hamilton & Co v Mackie & Sons (1889) TLR 677; Thomas (TW) & Co Ltd v Portsea Steamship Co Ltd [1912] AC 1; Modern Buildings Wales Ltd v Limmer & Trinidad Ltd [1975] 1 WLR 1281; Haughton Properties Pty Ltd v Sandridge City Development Company Pty Ltd (1995) 13 ACLC 1; McCann v Switzerland Insurance (2003) 203 CLR 579, applied.

COOPERS BREWERY LTD v LION NATHAN AUSTRALIA P/L
[2005] SASC 400

Full Court:      Bleby, Gray and Anderson JJ

BLEBY J

The respondent and its Constitution

  1. Coopers Brewery Ltd, the respondent to this appeal (“Coopers”), is a company incorporated in South Australia.  It conducts the business of a brewery.

  2. The Constitution of Coopers contains restrictions on the transfer and registration of the transfer of shares in Coopers.  Save where there is a transfer of shares inter vivos or by testamentary disposition from a member to a Member’s relative[1], a person proposing to transfer shares must give a Transfer Notice to the company.[2]   That initiates a procedure[3] whereby the shares must be offered by the Directors first to an existing member or Member’s relative.  If no member or Member’s relative is willing to purchase all or any of the shares, the remainder must be offered to the trustees of the Coopers Superannuation Fund.  If the trustees are not willing to purchase all or any of the shares, Article 49 requires that they must be offered to Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd, the appellant (“LNA”).  Any unsold shares may then be offered to any person.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Coopers Brewery Ltd v Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] SASC 400
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Court was an appeal by Coopers Brewery Ltd against a decision of Bleby J in the Federal Court of Australia. The dispute concerned the interpretation of certain provisions in Coopers Brewery Ltd's Memorandum and Articles of Association, specifically regarding pre-emptive rights and changes in control. The central issue was whether the acquisition of a significant shareholding in Lion Nathan Ltd by Kirin Brewery Company Ltd constituted a "change in control" of Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd, thereby revoking Coopers Brewery Ltd's pre-emptive rights as outlined in their Articles of Association.

The Court had to determine if the acquisition of shares by Kirin Brewery Company Ltd in Lion Nathan Ltd amounted to a "relevant interest" within the meaning of Article 44 of Coopers Brewery Ltd's Articles of Association, and whether this acquisition triggered a "change in control" under regulation 8 of the Memorandum of Association. The Court also considered the implications of incorporating definitions from Australian Corporations Law into the interpretation of the Articles of Association.

In resolving the matter, the Court held that the acquisition by Kirin Brewery Company Ltd of a significant shareholding in Lion Nathan Ltd did indeed constitute a "relevant interest" and triggered a "change in control" of Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd. Consequently, the pre-emptive rights granted to Lion Nathan Australia under the Articles of Association were revoked. The Court further clarified that the definition of "relevant interest" under the Australian Corporations Law was to be applied consistently with the provisions of Article 44. The appeal was dismissed, affirming the trial Judge's findings and declarations.

Background

Background to the litigation

To understand the way in which the issue has arisen, it is necessary to record a number of background matters. The detailed facts and circumstances are set out in the judgment of Bleby J. I respectfully adopt that analysis. The facts are only canvassed herein to the extent necessary to understand these reasons. Background As at March 1995, as a result of the settlement of other proceedings, the Coopers Memorandum and Articles for Association were amended. As a result of the amendment, Lion Nathan Australia was accorded third ranking pre-emptive status to acquire shares from a member wishing to sell, as well as an exemption from the prohibition on a member from holding an interest in a business competitive with Coopers. By virtue of regulation 6 of the Memorandum of Association, Coopers were not able to alter or revoke the special status granted to Lion Nathan Australia without that party’s consent. By virtue of regulation 7, a special resolution altering or omitting regulation 6 was ineffective without the consent of Lion Nathan Australia. However, regulation 8 provided that regulations 6 and 7 cease to have effect upon a change in control (as that term was defined in Article 44) of Lion Nathan Australia. Regulations 6 and 7 also cease to have effect if Lion Nathan Australia or its related bodies corporate cease to be substantial brewers of beer. The provisions granting preference to Lion Nathan Australia were inserted in the Coopers Constitution, pursuant to an agreement known as the Coopers Share Agreement. That agreement was dated 3 March 1995 and was between Coopers and Lion Nathan Australia, whereby, in settlement of certain disputes between the parties, Coopers agreed to use its best endeavours to amend the company’s constitution in a manner that reflected the provisions described above. The amendments were duly made. As at March 1995, Lion Nathan Australia was a wholly owned subsidiary of Lion Nathan Ltd. At that time, Lion Nathan Ltd was a company incorporated and registered in New Zealand and listed on the New Zealand stock exchange. In or about April 1998, a Japanese brewer, Kirin Brewing Company Ltd acquired a relevant interest in approximately 45 percent of the issued shared capital of Lion Nathan Ltd. The evidence before the trial Judge disclosed, and it was also an agreed fact, that Kirin Brewery acquired an interest in 246,454,275 shares. The shares represented approximately 45 percent of the shares in Lion Nathan Ltd and were all voting shares. The evidence disclosed that the interest acquired in the Lion Nathan Ltd shares was a relevant interest under New Zealand’s company law. However, the definition of relevant interest under that legislation was not coincident with the definition of relevant interest under the Australian legislative counterpart. On 2 June 2000, the jurisdiction of incorporation of Lion Nathan Ltd was transferred from New Zealand to New South Wales. The trial Judge found that Kirin Brewery acquired a relevant interest in the shares of Lion Nathan Ltd. Amongst other things, this meant that Kirin Brewery, at all relevant times, held a relevant interest in the shares within the meaning of that expression in Division 5 of the Corporations Law. This finding, although disputed at trial, is not challenged on this appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

ANDERSON J (dissent)
Even if, for the proper interpretation of the Articles of Coopers, it were necessary to exclude s 38 from the definition of “relevant interest”, the same cannot be said of s 33. It is part of Division 5 which goes to the prescription, along with other sections, as to how one identifies a relevant interest for the purpose of Article 44.Conclusion For these reasons I consider that the answers given by the trial Judge to the questions asked were correct. I would dismiss the appeal.GRAY J Coopers Brewery Ltd issued proceedings, seeking declarations that:-there had been a change in control of Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd for the purposes of regulation 8 of Coopers Memorandum of Association:-regulations 6 and 7 of Coopers Memorandum of Association had ceased to have effect by reason of the change of control.Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd was named as defendant. The proceedings came on for hearing before a Judge of this Court, who formulated the question for his determination in the following terms:Whether in April 1998, Kirin Brewery Company Ltd acquired a relevant interest in more than 40 per cent of the issued share capital of Lion Nathan Ltd within the meaning of article 44 of the plaintiff’s Articles of Association. If so, whether there has been a change in control of the defendant whin the meaning of regulation 8 of the plaintiff’s Memorandum of Association. The learned trial Judge resolved the question in favour of Coopers as follows:The two questions posed in the issue to be tried in the case are answered as follows:“Whether in April 1998, Kirin Brewery Company Ltd acquired a relevant interest in more than 40 per cent of the issued share capital of Lion Nathan Ltd within the meaning of article 44 of the plaintiff’s Articles of Association”. Answer: Yes.“If so, whether there has been a change in control of the defendant within the meaning of regulation 8 of the plaintiff’s Memorandum of Association”. Answer: Yes.The Judge then made the following declarations:In light of the ruling on the preliminary issue, the Court declares that:There has been a change in control of the defendant for the purpose of regulation 8 of the plaintiff’s Memorandum of Association.Regulations 6 and 7 of the plaintiff’s Memorandum of Association have ceased to have effect by reason of the change in control of the defendant. To understand the way in which the issue has arisen, it is necessary to record a number of background matters. The detailed facts and circumstances are set out in the judgment of Bleby J. I respectfully adopt that analysis. The facts are only canvassed herein to the extent necessary to understand these reasons. Background As at March 1995, as a result of the settlement of other proceedings, the Coopers Memorandum and Articles for Association were amended. As a result of the amendment, Lion Nathan Australia was accorded third ranking pre-emptive status to acquire shares from a member wishing to sell, as well as an exemption from the prohibition on a member from holding an interest in a business competitive with Coopers.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by:

The court in Coopers Brewery Ltd v Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd addressed several complex issues concerning the interpretation of the Articles of Association and the implications of acquiring a relevant interest in another company. The court first considered whether Kirin Brewery Company Ltd acquired a relevant interest in more than 40 per cent of the issued share capital of Lion Nathan Ltd within the meaning of Article 44 of the plaintiff’s Articles of Association. The court found that in April 1998, Kirin Brewery indeed acquired such an interest, as it obtained a 45% voting share in Lion Nathan Ltd, which met the criteria of a relevant interest under New Zealand’s company law. This acquisition was deemed to be a relevant interest under the Australian legislative counterpart, as it was consistent with the definitions provided in Division 5 of the Corporations Law.

Next, the court examined whether this acquisition led to a change in control of Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd within the meaning of regulation 8 of the plaintiff’s Memorandum of Association. The court concluded that the acquisition of a relevant interest by Kirin Brewery constituted a change in control, which triggered the automatic cessation of certain regulatory protections afforded to Lion Nathan Australia, as stipulated in the Memorandum of Association.

The court also delved into the interpretation of the term "relevant interest" under both New Zealand and Australian company law. It considered whether the definitions of "relevant interest" under these jurisdictions were coincident. The court noted that while there were differences in the definitions, the acquisition by Kirin Brewery met the criteria under both jurisdictions. The court further analyzed whether the imported definition of "relevant interest" from s 9 and Div 5 of the Corporations Law should include s 33 and whether it should be consistent with other provisions of Article 44. The court found that while it might be necessary to exclude s 38 from the definition for the proper interpretation of the Articles of Coopers, s 33 must be included as it is part of the same Division that outlines how a relevant interest is identified.

In addressing these issues, the court relied on the principles of contract interpretation and the specific provisions of the Articles of Association and the Memorandum of Association. The court emphasized that the definition of "relevant interest" should be consistent with the broader context of Article 44 and should be interpreted in a manner that aligns with the legislative provisions under both New Zealand and Australian law. The court's interpretation ensured that the definitions were applied consistently and logically within the framework of the Articles of Association.

The ratio decidendi of the case is that the acquisition by Kirin Brewery Company Ltd of a relevant interest in more than 40 per cent of the issued share capital of Lion Nathan Ltd did indeed constitute a change in control of Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd, leading to the cessation of specific regulatory protections under the Articles of Association. The court's decision adhered to the principles of contract interpretation and the specific provisions of the Articles of Association and the Memorandum of Association, ensuring that the definition of "relevant interest" was applied consistently with both New Zealand and Australian legislative frameworks.