Cook and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

Cook and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) [2019] AATA 1511 (27 June 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2018/3754

Re:Wallace Cook

APPLICANT

AndTelstra Corporation Limited

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member D K Grigg

Date:27 June 2019

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

..............................[SGD].......................................

Member D K Grigg

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION - employees - whether applicant’s hearing loss is an “injury” or “disease” under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 – whether there has been an increase in the degree of permanent impairment suffered by the applicant, of 5% or more, as a result of his accepted noise induced hearing loss such that further compensation for permanent impairment and non-economic loss is payable under sections 24 and 27 of the Act - decision under review affirmed.

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

CASES

Australian Postal Corp v Simon John Burch [1998] FCA 944

Comcare v Laidlaw[1999] FCA 40

Kennedy Cleaning Services Pty Ltd v Petkoska (2000) CLR 286

O’Kane and Comcare [2013] AATA 722

Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May (2016) 257 CLR 468

Re Sandercock and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission[2013] AATA 517

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member D K Grigg

27 June 2019

INTRODUCTION & CLAIMS HISTORY

  1. Mr Wallace Cook is 76 years of age. For 40 years, between December 1957 and January 1997, Mr Cook was employed as a Technician by Telstra.[1]

    [1]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T22, page 82, Report of Dr Allison, dated 1 March 2018.

  2. In October 2001 Mr Cook lodged a workers’ compensation claim under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (“the Act”) for hearing loss.[2] Telstra is a licensee[3] under the Act and as such self-insures its workers’ compensation claims. The relevant provisions of the Act which refer to Comcare apply to Telstra as a licensee under the Act.

    [2]     Exhibit 1, ST Documents, ST5, page 1, Statement of Mr Cook, dated 17 October 2001.

    [3] Section 4 of the Act defines a “licensee” to mean “a Commonwealth authority or a corporation that is licensed, or that is taken to be licensed, under Part VIII.”

  3. In February 2002 Professor Bruce Black, Otolaryngologist, reported that Mr Cook’s hearing loss was most probably caused by his work at Telstra.[4]

    [4]     Exhibit 1, ST Documents, ST2, page 3, Report of Professor Black dated 20 February 2002.

  4. A determination was issued by Telstra accepting liability to pay compensation for bilateral hearing loss assessed at 27.6% on 22 February 2002.[5]

    [5]     Exhibit 1, ST Documents, ST6, Correspondence issued by GIO to Mr Cook dated 22 February 2002.

  5. On 5 March 2002 Mr Cook lodged a further workers’ compensation claim for the permanent injury of “hearing loss, associated with high-pitched tinnitus”.[6] Mr Cook contended that he was entitled to an additional 5% in respect of permanent tinnitus and that his total binaural hearing loss was 40%.[7]

    [6]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T6, pages 16 - 26, Compensation Claim for Permanent Injury dated 5 March…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cook and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 1511
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for compensation by Mr Cook against Telstra Corporation Limited. Mr Cook sought further compensation for permanent impairment and non-economic loss, alleging an increase in his hearing loss of 5% or more, stemming from his accepted noise-induced hearing loss during his employment with Telstra. The dispute centred on whether the deterioration in Mr Cook's hearing constituted an "injury" or "disease" under the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (Cth) and whether Telstra was liable for this further impairment.

The court was required to determine whether Mr Cook's hearing loss constituted an "injury" or "disease" for the purposes of the Act, and crucially, whether there had been an increase in the degree of permanent impairment of 5% or more as a result of his accepted noise-induced hearing loss. This would determine his eligibility for further compensation under sections 24 and 27 of the Act.

The court considered the evidence of Mr Cook and Dr Allison, an expert called by Telstra. Dr Allison's reports and oral evidence indicated that while loud noise damages hair cells in the cochlea, this damage does not typically worsen once noise exposure ceases. Dr Allison opined that Mr Cook's significant hearing deterioration, particularly the absence of a characteristic "notch" at the 4kHz frequency in recent tests and the widespread decline across all frequencies, suggested causes other than noise-induced hearing loss, such as hereditodegenerative factors or presbycusis. The court found no corroborating evidence of further noise exposure after Mr Cook ceased employment with Telstra, nor evidence that Telstra was responsible for any such post-employment damage. Consequently, the Tribunal was not satisfied that Mr Cook's further hearing loss was attributable to his accepted compensable condition or that there had been a significant increase in impairment warranting additional compensation under the Act.

The Tribunal affirmed the reviewable decision, finding that no additional compensation was payable to Mr Cook under sections 24 and 27 of the Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At the hearing Telstra called Dr Allison to give evidence. Mr Cook also gave evidence at the hearing. Evidence of Mr Cook Mr Cook demonstrated at the hearing the degree to which he had to turn up the volume on his hearing aids in order to hear. There is no dispute about the extent of Mr Cook’s hearing loss. Mr Cook says that there is no history of deafness in his family and no identified hereditodegenerative diseases causing his hearing loss. Mr Cook explained that his hearing loss has deteriorated significantly and there are three parts of that hearing loss:(a)40% of his hearing loss has already been compensated for;(b)8.2 or 8.3% is not compensable as it related to age-related hearing loss; and(c)a disputed 22.3 or 23% hearing loss. Mr Cook submits that the 8.3% age related hearing loss (which is based on the NAL tables) already takes into account any hereditodegenerative causes.Report of Dr Allison dated 1 March 2018 A summary of Dr Allison’s opinion is set out in paragraph 17 above.Report of Dr Allison dated 27 September 2018[29][29] Exhibit 7, Report of Dr Allison, dated 27 September 2018. In September 2018 Telstra provided Dr Allison with further audiology reports and the report of Dr Cooney (see paragraph 9 above). Dr Allison then provided a supplementary report. In that report Dr Allison explained:·Loud noise damages hair cells in the cochlea, the hearing organ.·The cochlea is coiled, like a seashell. Within the cochlea there are 20000 hair cells. The hair cells that respond to low frequencies are at the centre of the cochlea, with high frequency stimuli being picked up by hair cells in the outer part.·Damage is caused by a combination of the volume of the noise, the length of exposure and the repetition, together with a person’s individual susceptibility to noise induced hearing loss.·The activities of daily living even including listening to television at very high volume, using headphones, mowing and boating do not cause noise induced hearing loss.·The audiogram [provided by Mr Cook] does not provide any insight into the progression of Mr Cook’s hearing loss after he ceased employment with Telstra and there was no further excessive noise exposure.·There is always a degree of deterioration over time due to presbyacusis in a person of Mr Cook’s age. However, his hearing has deteriorated significantly and this is due to hereditodegenerative causes.·The damage does not worsen once loud noise exposure has ceased(emphasis added)Oral evidence of Dr Allison At the hearing Dr Allison explained:·that there are basically two types of hearing loss…conductive where there is a blockage [and] …sensorineural deafness which involves the hearing nerve not working properly (which can occur for example from exposure to excessive noise).·Presbycusis refers to hearing loss due to age. The amount of loss varies. Age related hearing loss within certain limits is referred to a presbycusis.·People sometimes lose their hearing rapidly and there is no known reason or apparent cause – if way outside normal parameters, it is referred to as hereditodegenerative.·Noise damage damages hair cells in the cochlea.·Noise induced hearing loss is characterised by high frequency sensory neural deafness and it is always around the 4kHz frequency. ·Initially will see a “notch” on the hearing test around 4 kHz frequency. As hearing deteriorates, there may be other areas of problems indicated on hearing test results as well.·It is a stated opinion of the Australian Society for Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery that noise induced hearing loss does not get worse when the noise exposure ceases.·Exposure to loud TVs and headsets, for example, do not in general cause hearing loss.·Mr Cook’s hearing tests show no noise damage in the last 15 years.·The hearing test results from 1 February 2002[30] show that:[30] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T5, page 15, Hearing Assessment Report (attachment) to Report of Clare O’Rourke, Audiologist, dated 1 February 2002.oIn the right ear there is not much evidence of noise damage and indicates there is something else involved with Mr Cook’s hearing loss. oThe right ear is not showing damage at 4kHz frequency.oThere is clearly noise damage in the left ear.·The angiogram from 23 November 2017 shows:oSignificant additional deafness.oThe notch effect at 4kHz is totally gone and the other frequencies have dropped down as well indicating worsening damage other than from noise.·He compared the binaural hearing loss between the 2002 and 2017 tests:“if Mr Cook had noise damage it should be worse at 4,000 cycles…because that’s the frequency that’s affected by loud noise. Now, in the 15 years … between 2002 and 2017 his hearing loss deterioration, every frequency has deteriorated…that shows that this cannot be noise damage that’s caused Mr Cook’s additional deafness”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Therefore, the Tribunal finds that no additional compensation is payable to Mr Cook under sections 24 and 27 of the Act.DECISION The reviewable decision is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As explained by Dr Allison, Mr Cook’s Compensable Condition was caused by a physiological change therefore his hearing loss is best characterised as an “injury”. Section 7(6) of the Act has no application in this matter.CONSIDERATION It is not in dispute that Mr Cook’s hearing loss has deteriorated. Mr Cook says he has been exposed to high levels of noise between 2003 and 2018. There is no corroborating evidence of this. There is also no evidence that Telstra is responsible for any noise related damage incurred by Mr Cook after he left his employment. The Tribunal notes that in 2003 Dr Cooney also reported that Mr Cook had not been exposed to any work related noise since 1997.[33][33] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T11, page 43, Report of Dr Cooney dated 26 February 2003. At the hearing Dr Allison explained that when people have hearing loss which is outside the normal variant with no apparent cause, it is the common practice to refer to this as resulting from hereditodegenerative causes, because it cannot be blamed just on presbycusis (i.e. age related causes). Based on the medical evidence available, the Tribunal is not satisfied that Mr Cook’s further deterioration in his hearing loss is attributable to his Compensable Condition and is not satisfied on the evidence that his reported symptomology can be attributed solely or significantly to events which took place 24 years ago. As was explained by Dr Allison, constitutional and hereditodegenerative factors are of great importance when considering unexplained hearing loss. In relation to Mr Cook’s submission that the 8.3% age related hearing loss (which is based on the NAL tables) already takes into account any hereditodegenerative causes, no documentation was produced to support this contention. Mr Cook was given leave after the hearing to provide an appropriate reference but despite his endeavours he was unable to obtain any corroborating information. There was no independent expert medical evidence to contradict Dr Allison’s opinion or to support Mr Cook’s contentions. Section 24(1) of the Act provides for payment of compensation only where it is the ‘injury’ which results in the permanent impairment. There is no medical evidence before the Tribunal to support Mr Cook’s contention that the Compensable Condition has resulted in his level of impairment beyond that already compensated. Further, there is no medical evidence before the Tribunal which indicates that that there has been an increase of 10% in the WPI resulting from the tinnitus as required by section 25(4) of the Act. If Mr Cook has suffered further injuries from new noise exposure, it is not the responsibility of Telstra. Therefore, the Tribunal finds that no additional compensation is payable to Mr Cook under sections 24 and 27 of the Act.DECISION The reviewable decision is affirmed.