Construction Forestry Mining Energy Union v Bovis Land Lease Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Construction Forestry Mining Energy Union v Bovis Lend Lease Pty Ltd

[2008] FCA 1669

CONTRACTS – settlement agreements – whether court may have regard to what the parties said or did during the course of the settlement negotiations – whether settlement agreement to be construed objectively according to what a reasonable person would understand by the language in which the parties have expressed the agreement in light of mutual understandings, context and purpose of agreement – extent to which court may consider extrinsic evidence in construing a settlement agreement

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 53B

Asciano Services Pty Ltd (formerly Pacific National (ACT) Limited) v Commissioner of Taxation [2008] FCA 1401 cited
Commissioner of Taxation v Hadidi (1994) 51 FCR 453 cited
Golf Australia Holdings Ltd v Buxton Construction Pty Ltd [2007] VSCA 200 followed

CONSTRUCTION FORESTRY MINING AND ENERGY UNION and COMMUNICATIONS ELECTRICAL ELECTRONIC ENERGY INFORMATION POSTAL PLUMBING AND ALLIED SERVICES UNION v BOVIS LEND LEASE PTY LTD

VID 792 of 2008

GORDON J
11 NOVEMBER 2008
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 792 of 2008

BETWEEN:

CONSTRUCTION FORESTRY MINING AND ENERGY UNION
First Applicant

COMMUNICATIONS ELECTRICAL ELECTRONIC ENERGY INFORMATION POSTAL PLUMBING AND ALLIED SERVICES UNION
Second Applicant

AND:

BOVIS LEND LEASE PTY LTD
Respondent

JUDGE:

GORDON J

DATE OF ORDER:

11 NOVEMBER 2008

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The matter be stood over to a date to be fixed.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


The text of entered orders can be located using eSearch on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 792 of 2008

BETWEEN:

CONSTRUCTION FORESTRY MINING AND ENERGY UNION
First Applicant

COMMUNICATIONS ELECTRICAL ELECTRONIC ENERGY INFORMATION POSTAL PLUMBING AND ALLIED SERVICES UNION
Second Applicant

AND:

BOVIS LEND LEASE PTY LTD
Respondent

JUDGE:

GORDON J

DATE:

11 NOVEMBER 2008

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 23 September 2008, the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (the “CFMEU”), the Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union (the “CEPU”) (collectively, the “Unions”) and Bovis Lend Lease Pty Ltd (“Bovis”) entered into a Deed of Release (“the Deed”).  The Deed, arrived at after a long and difficult negotiation process facilitated by the District Registrar of this Court as mediator, was at the time thought to signal the end of a protracted battle between the Unions and Bovis over a new system for regulating the entry and exit of workers at four Bovis construction sites in Victoria.

  2. Earlier in 2008, Bovis had advised the Unions of its intention to implement a new swipe card access system known as the Blue Glue System (“the BGS”).  The essence of the BGS was that each worker would be required at the time of induction to a site to obtain a swipe card with a unique identification number (“induction” or “identification” number), and bearing the worker’s photograph, in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Construction Forestry Mining Energy Union v Bovis Land Lease... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 1669
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Construction Forestry Mining Energy Union (Union) brought an action against Bovis Land Lease Pty Ltd (Bovis) regarding the interpretation of the terms of a Deed. The Union argued that Bovis was not entitled to require workers to submit to photographs at the time of induction, which would be stored in a database linked to their swipe cards. Bovis maintained that the Deed permitted it to impose such a requirement. The matter was brought before the court, which was tasked with determining the correct interpretation of the Deed and whether Bovis's requirement for photographs violated any terms of the Deed. The Unions originally brought three claims, but during the trial, they abandoned the third claim and conceded that if the first claim failed, the second claim would also fail. The primary issue for the court to decide was the construction of the terms of the Deed, specifically whether Bovis was permitted to impose a requirement for workers to submit to photographs at the time of induction.

The court examined the terms of the Deed and considered the material upon which the Unions relied to establish the making of any representation to the effect alleged by the Unions. The court found that the material did not establish the making of any such representation. After carefully considering the evidence and arguments presented, the court concluded that the Deed permitted Bovis to impose a requirement that workers submit to photographs at the time of induction, with such photographs to be kept in a database along with other induction information and linked to the swipe cards. Consequently, the application was dismissed.

ORDERS:
1. The matter be stood over to a date to be fixed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The matter be stood over to a date to be fixed.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The dispute in Construction Forestry Mining Energy Union v Bovis Land Lease Pty Ltd revolves around the interpretation of the terms of a Deed that governs the relationship between the Unions and Bovis concerning the implementation of a Building and Construction Improvement Scheme (BCIS). The Unions argue that the Deed prohibits Bovis from requiring workers to submit to photographs at the time of induction, while Bovis contends that the Deed permits such a requirement. The Unions filed proceedings on 26 September 2008, asserting three claims: (1) that the requirement for workers to submit to photographs upon induction and the storage of these photographs in a database linked to their swipe cards constituted a breach of the Deed; (2) unlawful industrial action under s 38 of the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005; and (3) an unlawful lockout in violation of s 494(3) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996. The Unions abandoned their third claim at trial, conceding that if their first claim failed, the second claim would also fail. They argued that the proper construction of the terms of the Deed and the representations upon which they had relied supported their position.

The matter commenced with the Unions filing proceedings on 26 September 2008. Initially, three claims were made: a breach of the Deed, unlawful industrial action under the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005, and an unlawful lockout under the Workplace Relations Act 1996. At the trial, the Unions conceded that if the first claim failed, the second claim would also fail. The Unions conceded that their Deed claim was framed as a breach of the Deed and as a claim of equitable estoppel, relying on the same material to establish both the proper construction of the Deed's terms and the representations upon which they had reasonably relied. The court had to determine the construction of the Deed's terms, and after considering the material presented, concluded that the Deed permits Bovis to impose a requirement that workers submit to photographs at the time of induction.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GORDON J
The Unions refused to accede to this direction on the basis of their understanding of the Deed, which was that in addition to the condition of the Deed that photographs not be displayed on the swipe cards, it was also the effect of the Deed that Bovis could not require that workers submit to photographs at all. EXISITING PROCEEDINGS, ISSUES AND CONCLUSION On 26 September 2008, this dispute over the meaning of the Deed led the Unions to file the current proceedings (VID 792 of 2008). Initially, three claims were made by the Unions - namely, that the requirement that workers submit to photographs upon induction, with such photographs to be stored in a database linked to their swipe cards, constituted: (1) a breach of the Deed; (2) unlawful industrial action under s 38 of the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) (“the BCII Act”) in that it resulted in a restriction or limitation on the performance of work imposed by Bovis; and (3) an unlawful lockout in violation of s 494(3) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) (“the WRA”) in that the photograph requirement amounted to a condition precedent to entry to a Bovis site such that failure to comply led to the exclusion of workers. At trial, however, the Unions abandoned the third claim and conceded that, if they failed with respect to the first claim, then the second claim would also fail because, if the photograph requirement was not a breach of the Deed, then any complaint about it must be deemed to have been released and thus now be barred. The Unions also conceded that although the Deed claim was framed as a claim alleging breach of the Deed and as a claim of equitable estoppel, they relied on the same material to establish both (1) the proper construction of the terms of the Deed, and (2) representations upon which it was alleged that the Unions had reasonably relied to their detriment in assuming that workers would not be required to submit to photographs (and thus entering the Deed and releasing their claims). The determinative issue in this matter is the construction of the terms of the Deed. The material upon which the Unions relied as bearing upon the construction questions and establishing representations did not establish the making of any representation to the effect alleged by the Unions. And having carefully considered that material I have reached the conclusion, for reasons which follow, that the Deed permits Bovis to impose a requirement that workers submit to photographs at the time of induction, with such photographs to be kept in a database along with other induction information and linked to the swipe cards. Accordingly, the application must be dismissed. THE DEED AND ITS CONSTRUCTION The starting point is the terms of the Deed. The Deed begins by reciting much of the factual and procedural background just adverted to and states that the parties have reached agreement in relation to the implementation of the BGS. Notably, nowhere in the Deed is the BGS defined. The operative part of the Deed is divided into six sections: (1) definitions; (2) obligations of Bovis; (3) obligations of the Unions; (4) release; (5) other matters (i.e. steps to be taken by each side to give effect to the Deed); and (6) general (i.e. boilerplate provisions such as choice of law, merger, severance, and so forth).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GORDON J

The central issue in this case was the construction of the terms of the Deed and whether it permits Bovis to impose a requirement that workers submit to photographs at the time of induction. The Unions argued that the Deed implied a condition that workers would not be required to submit to photographs, and they relied on certain representations made by Bovis to support this argument. The court considered the terms of the Deed, including its definitions, obligations of the parties, and the release provisions. The Deed does not explicitly define the BGS, and the court found that the terms of the Deed allow Bovis to impose a requirement for photographs at induction and store them in a database linked to the swipe cards.

The court concluded that the material relied upon by the Unions did not establish any representation that workers would not be required to submit to photographs. The Unions' claim was framed as both a breach of the Deed and equitable estoppel, but the court found that the material in question was relevant only to the construction of the Deed's terms. Since the Deed does not prohibit the requirement for photographs, the Unions' claim based on the Deed's terms failed. The court also found that the Unions' reliance on the same material for both the construction of the Deed and the equitable estoppel claim was inappropriate. Therefore, the court dismissed the Unions' application.