Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v One Key Workforce Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v One Key Workforce Pty Ltd [2020] FCAFC 27

Appeal from:

Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v One Key Workforce Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 153

Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v One Key Workforce Pty Ltd (Federal Court of Australia, NSD 2058/2016, Orders dated 28 February 2019)

File number: NSD 373 of 2019
Judges: MCKERRACHER, FARRELL AND MARKOVIC JJ
Date of judgment: 28 February 2020
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – where declaration made that enterprise agreement is void and of no effect – where monies ordered to be held on trust pending outcome of appeal – where orders provided that monies be distributed to CFMMEU members with an interest in the trust monies if the appeal was dismissed or discontinued – where appeal to Full Court dismissed – where the question of distribution of trust monies remitted to the primary judge – where the primary judge ordered on the remitter that trust monies be distributed to the first respondent to be dealt with by its liquidators in accordance with their statutory responsibilities – whether the primary judge’s exercise of discretion miscarried – whether the primary judge erred in having regard to views of the Full Court – whether the primary judge erred in having regard to the nature of the proceeding – whether the primary judge erred in having regard to a potential contravention of s 596AB of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – no error shown – leave to appeal granted – appeal dismissed

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – applications to adduce further evidence on appeal – where the further evidence only became available after the first instance proceeding and was relevant to subject matter of appeal – where the further evidence responded to a new argument made on appeal by the other party – applications granted

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 596AB

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 27

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 36.57

Cases cited:

Ashby v Slipper (2014) 219 FCR 322

Decor Corporation Pty Ltd v Dart Industries Inc (1991) 33 FCR 397

House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499

Reece v Webber (2011) 192 FCR 254

Date of hearing: 26 August 2019
Registry: New South Wales
Division: Fair Work Division
National Practice Area: Employment & Industrial Relations
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 109
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr B Walker SC and Ms C Howell
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr B O’Donnell QC and Mr E Robinson
Solicitor for the Applicant: Slater & Gordon Lawyers
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Allens
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

NSD 373 of 2019
BETWEEN:

CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MARITIME, MINING AND ENERGY UNION

Applicant

AND:

ONE KEY WORKFORCE PTY LTD ACN 605 016 206

First Respondent

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

Second Respondent

JUDGES:

MCKERRACHER, FARRELL AND MARKOVIC JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

28 FEBRUARY 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Leave be granted to the applicant to appeal from the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCAFC 27
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court involved a dispute between the Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union (CFMMEU) and One Key Workforce Pty Ltd (OKW) over the validity of an enterprise agreement. The CFMMEU sought a declaration that the enterprise agreement was void and of no effect, and the court granted this relief. The primary issue before the court was whether the primary judge's exercise of discretion in ordering the distribution of trust monies was correct. The CFMMEU argued that the primary judge miscarried in his exercise of discretion by having regard to the views of the Full Court, the nature of the proceeding, and a potential contravention of a certain section of the Corporations Act. The court found no error in the primary judge's decision and granted leave to appeal, but ultimately dismissed the appeal.

The court also considered applications to adduce further evidence on appeal. Both parties made applications to adduce further evidence in the appeal, which were not made in conformity with the Federal Court Rules. However, neither party complained about this, and the court decided to dispense with compliance with the relevant rule. The CFMMEU sought to admit an affidavit from a senior national legal officer, which provided details on the proposed settlement and the amounts that CFMMEU members were expected to receive. The court granted leave to both parties to adduce further evidence in the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave be granted to the applicant to appeal from the orders made on 28 February 2019 in proceeding NSD 2058/2016 and to file its notice of appeal in the form of annexure PJP4 to the affidavit of Phillip John Pasfield sworn on 14 March 2019.

2. Leave be granted to the applicant to adduce further evidence in the appeal in the form of the affidavit at annexure PJP5 to the affidavit of Phillip John Pasfield sworn on 15 August 2019.

3. Leave be granted to the first respondent to adduce further evidence in the appeal in the form of the affidavit at annexure ADM-1 to the affidavit of Alexander David Monaghan sworn on 23 August 2019.

4. The appeal be dismissed.

5. Order 2 of the orders made on 20 March 2019 in proceeding NSD 2058/2016 be vacated.

6. The appellant pay the first respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before proceeding further it is convenient to set out the background to the appeal and the applications that are now before us. BACKGROUND OKW, formerly known as RECS (Qld) Pty Ltd, was part of a group of companies which together operated a business known as One Key Resources. It was a labour hire business which on-hired its employees to clients in a range of industries including the black coal mining industry. OKW primarily hired employees as casual workers. Casual employment was not permitted under the Black Coal Mining Industry Award 2010 (Award). Between March and August 2015 OKW recruited Messrs Kevan O’Brien, Reuben Raymond and Vernon Marfell as employees. In August 2015 a process was initiated by which each of Messrs O’Brien, Raymond and Marfell was invited to vote on a proposed enterprise agreement. On 25 August 2015, in response to an email request, each of those employees voted in favour of the proposed enterprise agreement. The proposed enterprise agreement was then submitted to the FWC for approval and on 30 October 2015 the FWC granted its approval. The agreement as approved became known as the RECS (Qld) Pty Ltd Enterprise Agreement 2015 (Enterprise Agreement). No application for leave to appeal from the FWC’s decision was made pursuant to s 604 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (Fair Work Act). On 28 November 2016 the CFMMEU (which at the time was known as the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union) commenced proceeding NSD 2058 of 2016 against OKW as first respondent and the FWC as second respondent by filing an originating application in this Court for relief under s 39B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) (First Instance Proceeding). In its application the CFMMEU sought an order declaring that the Enterprise Agreement was void and of no effect; in the alternative, a writ of certiorari quashing the approval by the FWC of the Enterprise Agreement; and in the further alternative, a writ of mandamus directed to the FWC. On 8 November 2017 the primary judge ordered that the parties bring in short minutes to give effect to the reasons published by his Honour on that day: see Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v One Key Workforce Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 1266 (CFMEU v One Key). The primary judge concluded that the approval of the Enterprise Agreement should be quashed and a declaration made that the Enterprise Agreement is void and of no effect. His Honour found that the Enterprise Agreement was not an agreement susceptible of approval by the FWC under s 186 of the Fair Work Act: see CFMEU v One Key at [7]. On 23 November 2017 the primary judge made the following orders (November 2017 Orders):1.Subject to Order 2, the approval by the Fair Work Commission of the RECS (QLD) Pty Ltd Enterprise Agreement 2015 on 30 October 2015 in proceedings AG 2015/5383 as recorded in [2015] FWCA 7516 is void and of no effect.2.These Orders operate on and from the 22nd day after the date of this Order. On 27 November 2017 OKW commenced proceeding NSD 2073 of 2017 by filing a notice of appeal from Order 1 of the November 2017 Orders which gave effect to his Honour’s reasons in CFMEU v One Key (Appeal Proceeding). On 29 November 2019, OKW filed an interlocutory application in the Appeal Proceeding in which it sought an order that Order 1 of the November 2017 Orders does not come into operation and has no force and effect until further order or until all avenues of appeal are exhausted and are unsuccessful, and an order that the exercise by the CFMMEU or any other person of any rights of any kind whatsoever as a result of Order 1 of the November 2017 Orders is stayed as against OKW until further order or until all avenues of appeal are exhausted and are unsuccessful (Interlocutory Application).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In our opinion leave to appeal should be granted. The order made by the primary judge disbursing the Trust Monies is in substance final. It has the practical effect of determining the fate of those monies on a final basis. There is thus a prima facie case for leave to appeal. The matter is not without its complexity and we are satisfied that the decision is attended by sufficient doubt to warrant its reconsideration on appeal. Further, we accept that there will be substantial injustice to the CFMMEU and its members if leave is refused, supposing the decision of the primary judge to be wrong. Applications to adduce further evidence on appeal Each of the CFMMEU and OKW made applications to adduce further evidence in the appeal. Those applications were not made in conformity with r 36.57 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (Rules) in that they were filed beyond the time permitted in that rule. However, neither party made any complaint about that. To the extent required we would dispense with compliance with r 36.57 of the Rules. In its application, the CFMMEU seeks to admit into evidence an affidavit affirmed by Adam John Walkaden, senior national legal officer employed by the mining and energy division of the CFMMEU, on 15 August 2019. In summary Mr Walkaden deposes to the following matters:(1)the CFMMEU is in the final stages of negotiating an agreement with companies in the One Key Resources Group and the Fircroft Group whereby payments will be made to certain members of the CFMMEU who are employees or former employees of companies which form part of the One Key Resources Group and the Fircroft Group and also employees of OKW (Proposed Settlement). As at the date of Mr Walkaden’s affidavit no former employee of OKW or the One Key Resources Group or the Fircroft Group had received any payments;(2)if the CFMMEU is successful in the appeal it is expected that CFMMEU members who are former employees of OKW will receive two sums of money for their unpaid entitlements, one from the Trust Monies and one from the Proposed Settlement;(3)Mr Walkaden has caused a schedule to be prepared, which is annexed to his affidavit, setting out the names of those members and detailing the approximate amounts they would receive from distribution of the Trust Monies and the further amount to which it is anticipated they would be entitled as a result of the Proposed Settlement. He also annexed a document explaining the methodology used to estimate these entitlements; (4)Mr Walkaden has undertaken some sample calculations based on detailed information about five individual employees to test the reliability of his assessment and “indicative testing” based on “common hourly rates and rostering patterns”. Those calculations and his analysis are also annexed to his affidavit; and(5)Mr Walkaden has not been able to calculate the precise amount of outstanding entitlements for each member as he does not have all the relevant information but has taken steps, which he sets out, to confirm that if members receive both of the payments set out in the schedule referred to at subpara (3) above they will not receive in excess of their total outstanding entitlements.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 20 March 2019 the primary judge, having noted that the CFMMEU had filed an application for leave to appeal from the orders made on 28 February 2019, ordered that:1.Order 2 of the Order made on 28 February 2019 be vacated.2.Order 1 of the Order made on 28 February 2019 will not come into effect until further order of the Court.(Original emphasis.)THE PRIMARY JUDGMENT After setting out the history of the First Instance Proceeding and the Appeal Proceeding the primary judge noted at [10]-[11] that:10In May 2018, the Full Court published its reasons for decision: One Key Workforce Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2018] FCAFC 77, (2018) 277 IR 23. In summarising its conclusions, the Full Court said (at 73): [234]In short, although he made some errors, the primary judge was correct to find that the Commissioner fell into jurisdictional error by failing to have regard to the content and terms of the explanation [OKW] purportedly gave the three employees when reaching his satisfaction that s 180(5) had been complied with. The primary judge was also correct to find that the Commissioner had not reached the requisite state of satisfaction that the Agreement had been genuinely agreed to by the employees covered by it. Consequently, the basis for the exercise of the power conferred on the Commission to approve the Agreement was absent. It follows that the declaration the primary judge made should be set aside and different relief granted, but the appeal should otherwise be dismissed.On 28 August 2018, the Full Court made orders giving effect to its reasons. The declaration was set aside but the Full Court ordered that the Agreement be quashed. One issue of concern to the Full Court was the fate of the monies held in trust in accordance with Order 3 as made on 21 December 2017. In addressing that concern, the orders made by the Full Court on 28 August 2018 of present relevance are the following:5.Order 3 of the orders made by the primary judge on 21 December 2017 be set aside and, until further order, the monies referred to in order 2 of those orders remain in the trust account administered by Ashurst Australia.6.The question of what further orders are to be made arising from order 5 be remitted to the primary judge for determination.One of the concerns of the Full Court would appear to be that the order made in December 2017 confined the deployment of monies to “members of the [CFMMEU] … claiming an interest therein”, namely the employees of [OKW] who were also members of the CFMMEU. Confined in that manner, the employees of [OKW] who were not members of the CFMMEU – but who also would have accrued entitlements – would not benefit from the deployment of the $1 million trust monies.11If the $1 million is confined to the CFMMEU employees, those employees will not receive their full entitlements; if the $1 million is to be deployed to all employees, the amount each employee would receive is comparatively negligible.(Original emphasis.)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The principles governing an application for leave to appeal were not in dispute. An applicant for leave must demonstrate that the decision of the primary judge is attended by sufficient doubt to warrant its reconsideration by a Full Court and that substantial injustice would result if leave were refused, supposing the decision to be wrong: Decor Corporation Pty Ltd v Dart Industries Inc (1991) 33 FCR 397 (Decor Corporation) at 398-399. Leave will more readily be granted in the case of an interlocutory decision that determines a substantive right: Decor Corporation at 400. In Ashby v Slipper (2014) 219 FCR 322 at [46] Mansfield and Gilmour JJ said:In Johnson Tiles Pty Ltd v Esso Australia Pty Ltd (2000) 104 FCR 564 at [43], citing Ex parte Bucknell (1936) 56 CLR 221 at 225, French J, with whom the other members of the Court agreed, said that a “prima facie case exists for granting leave to appeal” if the judgment, although interlocutory, has the practical operation of finally determining the rights of the parties. The CFMMEU submits that the decision of the primary judge is interlocutory because it does not finally determine the rights of the parties in a principal cause pending between them but deals with an ancillary issue, namely the disposition of the Trust Monies. However, the CFMMEU also submits that the primary judge’s decision, although interlocutory, effectively determined a substantive right. OKW opposes the grant of leave to appeal. It says that the primary judge’s decision is not attended by sufficient doubt to warrant the grant of leave to appeal, that refusing leave to appeal would bring finality to the long running litigation and that the proposed appeal does not involve any important question of law. In our opinion leave to appeal should be granted. The order made by the primary judge disbursing the Trust Monies is in substance final. It has the practical effect of determining the fate of those monies on a final basis. There is thus a prima facie case for leave to appeal. The matter is not without its complexity and we are satisfied that the decision is attended by sufficient doubt to warrant its reconsideration on appeal. Further, we accept that there will be substantial injustice to the CFMMEU and its members if leave is refused, supposing the decision of the primary judge to be wrong. Applications to adduce further evidence on appeal Each of the CFMMEU and OKW made applications to adduce further evidence in the appeal. Those applications were not made in conformity with r 36.57 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (Rules) in that they were filed beyond the time permitted in that rule. However, neither party made any complaint about that. To the extent required we would dispense with compliance with r 36.57 of the Rules. In its application, the CFMMEU seeks to admit into evidence an affidavit affirmed by Adam John Walkaden, senior national legal officer employed by the mining and energy division of the CFMMEU, on 15 August 2019. In summary Mr Walkaden deposes to the following matters:(1)the CFMMEU is in the final stages of negotiating an agreement with companies in the One Key Resources Group and the Fircroft Group whereby payments will be made to certain members of the CFMMEU who are employees or former employees of companies which form part of the One Key Resources Group and the Fircroft Group and also employees of OKW (Proposed Settlement). As at the date of Mr Walkaden’s affidavit no former employee of OKW or the One Key Resources Group or the Fircroft Group had received any payments;(2)if the CFMMEU is successful in the appeal it is expected that CFMMEU members who are former employees of OKW will receive two sums of money for their unpaid entitlements, one from the Trust Monies and one from the Proposed Settlement;(3)Mr Walkaden has caused a schedule to be prepared, which is annexed to his affidavit, setting out the names of those members and detailing the approximate amounts they would receive from distribution of the Trust Monies and the further amount to which it is anticipated they would be entitled as a result of the Proposed Settlement. He also annexed a document explaining the methodology used to estimate these entitlements; (4)Mr Walkaden has undertaken some sample calculations based on detailed information about five individual employees to test the reliability of his assessment and “indicative testing” based on “common hourly rates and rostering patterns”. Those calculations and his analysis are also annexed to his affidavit; and(5)Mr Walkaden has not been able to calculate the precise amount of outstanding entitlements for each member as he does not have all the relevant information but has taken steps, which he sets out, to confirm that if members receive both of the payments set out in the schedule referred to at subpara (3) above they will not receive in excess of their total outstanding entitlements.