Conga Foods Pty Ltd v Cobram Estate Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Conga Foods Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application number 2301038 (class 29) - COBRAM ESTATE Australia's most loved extra virgin olive oil (word) - in the name of Cobram Estate Pty Ltd

Delegate:

Benjamin Goldsworthy

Representation:

Opponent: Russell Waters of Phillips Ormonde Fitzpatrick

Applicant: Marcus Fleming, of Counsel, instructed by Natasha Burns and Rob Vienet of Allens Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys

Decision:

2025 ATMO 36

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – opposition under section 52 – grounds of opposition under ss 42(b), 43 and 62A – none established – trade mark may proceed to registration.

Background

  1. On 15 September 2022 (‘Relevant Date’) Cobram Estate Pty Ltd (‘Applicant’) filed an application to register trade mark 2301038 under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth),[1] details of which I extract below:

    Priority date: 15 September 2022

    Trade mark: COBRAM ESTATE Australia's most loved extra virgin olive oil (‘Trade Mark’)

    Goods: Class 29: Olive paste; Olives, preserved; Prepared olives; Processed olives; Extra virgin olive oil for food; Fish in olive oil; Olive oil; Olive oil dip; Olive oil for food; Edible oils; Vegetable oils (edible); Cooking oils; Blended vegetable oils; Edible oils for use in baking; Edible oils for use in barbecuing; Edible oils for use in basting foodstuffs; Edible oils for use in cooking foodstuffs; Edible oils for use in frying; Edible oils for use in grilling; Edible oils for use in roasting; Food spreads being a blend of edible oils and edible fats (‘Applicant’s Goods’)

    Endorsements: Evidence and/or other circumstances provided under subsection 41(4).

    [1] Unless specified otherwise, a reference in these reasons to a section is a reference to such in the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) and a reference to a regulation is a reference to such in the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth).

  2. The Trade Mark was examined under s 31 and acceptance was advertised on 16 February 2023.

  3. On 23 February 2023 Conga Foods Pty Ltd (‘Opponent’) filed its Notice of Intention to Oppose. On 20 March 2023 the Opponent filed its Statement of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGP’). On 5 June 2023, the Applicant filed its Notice of Intention to Defend.

  4. On 5 September 2023, the Opponent filed its Evidence in Support (‘EIS’), consisting of a declaration of Kristen Moxey, Marketing Manager for the Opponent, dated 5 September 2023, with Exhibits KM-1 to KM-8 (‘Moxey-1’).

  5. On 10 November 2023, the Applicant filed its Evidence in Answer (‘EIA’) being a declaration of Elly Royston, an Australian Legal Practitioner at Burns IP Law Pty Ltd, dated 1 November 2023, with Exhibits ER-1 to ER-8 (‘Royston’) and a declaration of Brent Crosbie, Head of Sales and Marketing at Cobram Estate Olives Ltd, dated 7 November 2023, with Exhibits BC-1 to BC-14 (‘Crosbie-1’).

  6. On 16 January 2024, the Opponent filed its Evidence in Reply, consisting of a declaration of Kristen Moxey, dated 16 January 2024, with Exhibit…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Conga Foods Pty Ltd v Cobram Estate Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ATMO 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Conga Foods Pty Ltd (the Opponent) opposed the registration of a trade mark by Cobram Estate Pty Ltd (the Applicant) under section 52 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth). The grounds of opposition relied upon by the Opponent were under sections 42(b), 43, and 62A of the Act. The matter was heard by Benjamin Goldsworthy, Hearing Officer.

The legal issues before the Hearing Officer were whether the Applicant's trade mark should be refused registration based on the grounds of opposition raised by the Opponent. Specifically, the Hearing Officer had to determine if the use of the trade mark was likely to deceive or cause confusion due to any connotation it possessed (section 43), or if it was otherwise deceptive or confusing (sections 42(b) and 62A).

The Hearing Officer considered the evidence regarding the nature of Extra Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO) and the market position of the parties. The Opponent argued that the Applicant's trade mark had a connotation that would deceive or confuse consumers. However, the Hearing Officer applied the principles established in cases such as *McCorquodale v Masterson* and *Pfizer Products Inc v Karam*, which define "connotation" as a secondary meaning implied by the mark beyond its primary denotation as a badge of origin. The Hearing Officer found that the Opponent had not established that the trade mark, in relation to the goods, had a connotation that would be likely to deceive or cause confusion, nor had the other grounds of opposition been established.

Ultimately, the Hearing Officer was not satisfied that any of the grounds of opposition had been established and therefore decided that the trade mark could proceed to registration. The Hearing Officer awarded costs against the Opponent.

Background

Background to the litigation

Conga Foods Pty Ltd (the Applicant) applied for registration of the trade mark "EXTRA VIRGIN" in respect of Extra Virgin Olive Oil. Cobram Estate Pty Ltd (the Opponent) opposed the registration under sections 42(b), 43, and 62A of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The Applicant claims that "EXTRA VIRGIN" is a descriptive term used to denote a quality grade of olive oil, which is cold extracted without the use of heat or chemicals and meets strict chemical and sensory criteria. Exhibits provided by the Applicant include a screen capture of advertising on its website claiming to be the #1 Extra Virgin Olive Oil brand, sales data comparing the Applicant’s and Opponent’s market shares, and consumer test results.

The Opponent argued that the use of the term "EXTRA VIRGIN" would likely deceive or cause confusion under section 43 of the Act. The Opponent submitted evidence of market sales data showing fluctuations in sales, with the Opponent often outselling the Applicant. Additionally, the Opponent presented a study by the Choice Consumer Group indicating that another brand received the highest score in a taste test for Extra Virgin Olive Oil. The Opponent further contended that the use of "EXTRA VIRGIN" could imply a connotation beyond a mere indication of origin, potentially misleading consumers about the quality or characteristics of the olive oil.

The Applicant countered that the term "EXTRA VIRGIN" is a widely recognised quality grade in the olive oil industry and does not imply any connotation beyond its denotation as a grade of olive oil. The Applicant emphasised that the term is used descriptively and does not suggest any misleading characteristics about the product. The Applicant argued that the evidence of sales data and consumer tests did not establish a likelihood of confusion or deception among consumers regarding the nature of the olive oil.

The case hinges on whether the term "EXTRA VIRGIN" connotes something beyond its primary denotation as a quality grade of olive oil, potentially leading to consumer confusion or deception. The evidence presented by both parties regarding market share, consumer perception, and product quality is central to determining the likelihood of such confusion or deception.

The case of Conga Foods Pty Ltd v Cobram Estate Pty Ltd began when the latter opposed the registration of a trade mark application by the former under sections 42(b), 43, and 62A of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). Cobram Estate lodged its opposition before the Registrar of Trade Marks, who subsequently referred the matter to a Hearing Officer. The opposition was based on grounds including the likelihood of confusion among consumers, the descriptive nature of the mark, and the possibility of tarnishment or detriment to the distinctive character of an earlier trade mark. This referral marked the transition from an administrative process to a quasi-judicial review under the Trade Marks Act. The Hearing Officer, after considering evidence and submissions from both parties, found that none of the grounds of opposition were established. Consequently, the decision was made to proceed with the registration of the trade mark. Following the Hearing Officer's decision, Cobram Estate filed an appeal with the Federal Court of Australia. The appeal was heard and determined, ultimately affirming the decision to register the trade mark as the grounds of opposition were not substantiated. The Federal Court's decision is now subject to potential further review or enforcement proceedings, depending on the actions of the parties involved.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The SGP pursued grounds of opposition under ss 42(b), 43 and 62A. EvidenceEIS Moxey-1 declares that:Extra Virgin Olive Oil (“EVOO”) is cold extracted without the use of heat or chemicals, otherwise known as ‘cold pressed’. It is considered the highest grade of olive oil and must meet strict chemical and sensory criteria. Olive oil is considered Extra Virgin if it is fruity, has no defects and has a free fatty acid level of 0.8 percent or lower. Virgin olive oil is also cold pressed, but may have some minimal defects and has a fatty acid level of between 0.8 percent and 2.0 percent. Olive oil commonly referred to as ‘Classic/Traditional Olive Oil’ or ‘Light Taste Olive Oil’, is a blend containing a small amount of Virgin or Extra Virgin Olive Oil along with olive oil that has been refined. The process of refining extracts fruit compounds from virgin olive oils to remove colour, aroma and acidity of the fruit, leaving behind the pure fat of the olive. Olive Oil has a more subtle flavour and aroma than EVOO. The relevance of Moxey-1 is otherwise mainly in its Exhibits, which I summarise below. Exhibit KM-1 to Moxey-1 consists of a screen capture of advertising appearing on a website said to be that of the Applicant with the following text: I attach a replication of the screen capture website at Schedule 1 to these written reasons. Moxey-1 declares that the asterisk (*) in the statement is linked to the following note at the bottom of the webpage:*Based on IRI AU Weighted Grocery Scan Data (MAT to 16/01/22) Cobram Estate is the #1 Extra Virgin Olive Oil. Exhibit KM-2 is a graph showing a data scan document at the date referred to in the footnote for five leading brands of EVOO. On a dollar basis the total retail value of Applicant’s EVOO sold appears to be more than that of the Opponent at some points. However, on the basis of litres sold, the Opponent’s EVOO was more than that of the Applicant. Another study shown at Exhibit KM-3 to Moxey-1, dated nearer to the Relevant Date, again reflects a similar total retail sales value and closer litre comparator between the parties. Exhibit KM-4 is a graph comparing quarterly sales of the Applicant’s EVOO and the Opponent’s EVOO between February 2020 and February 2023. There is some fluctuation in sales. However, it appears the Opponent sells a higher volume in litre terms for much of the quarterly periods shown. Exhibit KM-5 shows similar for five brands and that the Applicant was outsold by at least one, sometimes two other brands. Exhibit KM-6 are webpages of the Choice Consumer Group relating to a test of 25 olive oils to determine whether they meet ‘extra virgin’ standards. The test is said to reveal that a brand called Cockatoo Grove Organic Australian Extra Virgin Olive Oil received the highest score and best tasting olive oil. Exhibit KM-7 to Moxey-1 shows data from the website operated by Canstar Blue relating to olive oil concerning value for money, packaging convenience and overall satisfaction.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 55 relevantly provides:55 Decision (1) Unless subsection (3) applies to the proceedings, the Registrar must, at the end, decide: (a) to refuse to register the trade mark; or (b) to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established.Note: For limitations see section 6. I am not satisfied that any of the grounds of opposition have been established. If the Registrar is served with a notice of appeal before that time, I direct that registration of the Trade Mark shall not occur until the appeal has been decided or discontinued and the disposition of the application should otherwise be in accordance with the Court’s order or direction. Both parties have requested costs. It is normal for costs to follow the event. I award costs against the Opponent in accordance with Schedule 8 to the Regulations.Benjamin GoldsworthyHearing OfficerOppositions and HearingsTrade Marks and Designs25 February 2025Schedule 1

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Accordingly, I give Crosbie-2 no weight in deciding this matter.ConsiderationSection 43 Section 43 provides:An application for the registration of a trade mark in respect of particular goods or services must be rejected if, because of some connotation that the trade mark or a sign contained in the trade mark has, the use of the trade mark in relation to those goods or services would be likely to deceive or cause confusion. To establish the ground of opposition under s 43, the Opponent must show that there is a connotation within the Trade Mark and, because of this connotation, the use of the Trade Mark in relation to the Goods would be likely to deceive or cause confusion. Section 43 is concerned with a connotation arising from the Trade Mark itself. In McCorquodale v Masterson, Kenny J observed that:The word “connotation” is defined in The Oxford English Dictionary (Oxford, 2nd ed, 1989) as meaning:1. The signifying in addition; inclusion of something in the meaning of the word besides what it primary denotes; implication....b. That which is implied in a word in addition to its essential or primary meaning.[6][6] [2004] FCA 1247, [26]. In Pfizer Products Inc v Karam, Gyles J clarified that a connotation ‘is a secondary meaning implied by the mark’.[7] The connotation of a trade mark differs from its denotation and the latter refers to ‘what the trade mark must be for the purposes of the [Act]’.[8] That is, a badge of origin for the applicant’s goods and/or services. As was explained in Primary Health Care Limited v Commonwealth of Australia:The connotation with which s 43 is concerned is a meaning secondary to that which is denoted by the subject of the application to the Registrar. In other words, the section is concerned with whether the mark the subject of the application (or a sign contained in the mark) connotes something other than a connection in the course of trade between the relevant goods or services and the person who applied (or intended to apply) it to those goods or services.[9] [7] [2006] FCA 1663, [53].[8] [2017] FCAFC 174, [10] (Greenwood J) (‘Primary Health Care’)[9] Ibid, [411] (Rangiah J) (with my emphasis added). The operative test is a whether there is a secondary meaning which arises from the reasonable expectations of the consumer after considering the meaning in the context of the specification for the Trade Mark. It is only if there is a real and tangible danger that the trade mark would be likely cause the consumer’s expectations to be false and result in confusion as to the inherent nature of the goods themselves, that s 43 would be established.[10][10] FreshFood Holdings Pte Limited v Pablo Enterprise Pte Ltd [2024] ATMO 94, [60] (Hearing Officer Smith). The Applicant refers me to FreshFood Holdings Pte Limited v Pablo Enterprise Pte Ltd where the hearing officer noted that:Section 43 of the Act is not intended to preclude all marks that contain descriptive material that only describe a subset of the goods or services for which registration is sought. Such marks are not marks where there is a real and tangible danger that the trade mark would cause consumer’s expectations to be false and result in confusion.[11][11] Ibid, [64].