Commonwealth Superannuation Scheme Board of Trustees v Kitching

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Commonwealth Superannuation Scheme Board of Trustees v Kitching
[2004] FCAFC 299

SUPERANNUATION – retirement on grounds of invalidity – whether one condition ‘connected with’ another – whether causal relationship required.

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Appeal – no appeal against order – literal terms of order not wrong - order accompanied by erroneous statement of legal principle

WORDS AND PHRASES – ‘connected with’

Superannuation Act 1976 (Cth), ss 16, 66
Superannuation Act 1990 (Cth), s 6
Superannuation (Resolution of Complaints) Act 1993 (Cth), ss 12, 13, 37

Baxter Healthcare Pty Limited v Comptroller General of Customs (1997) 72 FCR 467 referred to

Commissioner for Superannuation v Miller (1985) 8 FCR 153 referred to
Commissioner for Superannuation v Perrett (1989) 23 FCR 425 referred to
Commissioner of Superannuation v Benham (1989) 22 FCR 413 referred to
Perrett v Commissioner for Superannuation (1991) 29 FCR 581 applied

Secretary Department of Social Security v Lowe (1999) 92 FCR 26 applied

COMMONWEALTH SUPERANNUATION SCHEME BOARD OF TRUSTEES V JOHN ANDREW KITCHING
W 120 of 2004

RD NICHOLSON, JACOBSON AND BENNETT JJ
18 NOVEMBER 2004
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W 120 of 2004

On appeal from a single judge of the Federal Court of Australia

BETWEEN:

COMMONWEALTH SUPERANNUATION
SCHEME BOARD OF TRUSTEES
APPELLANT

AND:

JOHN ANDREW KITCHING
RESPONDENT

JUDGES:

RD NICHOLSON, JACOBSON & BENNETT JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

18 NOVEMBER 2004

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be allowed;

2.Order 1 of the orders made by the primary judge on 18 May 2004 be set aside; and

3.Substitute in lieu of order 1 the following order:-

“The decision of the Superannuation Complaints Tribunal made 16 May 2002 be set aside and the matter be remitted to the Tribunal for determination according to the reasons of the Full Court given on 18 November 2004.”

4.        No order as to costs.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W 120 of 2004

On appeal from a single judge of the Federal Court of Australia

BETWEEN:

COMMONWEALTH SUPERANNUATION
SCHEME BOARD OF TRUSTEES
APPELLANT

AND:

JOHN ANDREW KITCHING
RESPONDENT

JUDGES:

NICHOLSON, JACOBSON & BENNETT JJ

DATE:

18 NOVEMBER 2004

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal from part of a judgment of Lee J given on 18 May 2004. His Honour, in exercise of the jurisdiction of the Court under s 46 of the Superannuation (Resolution of Complaints) Act 1993 (Cth) set aside a decision of the Superannuation Complaints Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) and remitted the matter to the Tribunal for determination according to law.

  2. The appellant (“the Board”) does not challenge his Honour’s orders setting aside the Tribunal’s decision.  However, the Board contends that his Honour erroneously stated the law according to which the Tribunal was ordered to determine the matter on remittal.

  3. Although ordinarily a right of appeal lies only in respect…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commonwealth Superannuation Scheme Board of Trustees v Kitch... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCAFC 299
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Commonwealth Superannuation Scheme Board of Trustees took action against Mr. Kitching, a former Commonwealth public servant, over the terms of his retirement benefits. Mr. Kitching had initially been granted a Benefit Condition Certificate (BCC) due to a diagnosis of manic depressive psychosis, which rendered him ineligible for full superannuation benefits. However, he later retired on invalidity grounds due to stress and anxiety related to his job at Centrelink. The Board maintained that his retirement was due to the original BCC condition, while Mr. Kitching argued that it was his work-related stress that incapacitated him.

The primary legal issue was whether Mr. Kitching's incapacity for work was caused or substantially contributed to by the condition specified in the BCC or by a connected condition. The Tribunal had to determine whether the invalidating condition was the original BCC condition or the stress and anxiety caused by his job at Centrelink. The Board's decision to affirm the delegate's decision on the basis of the original BCC condition was challenged by Mr. Kitching.

The court found that the Tribunal had erred in its approach to interpreting the relevant legislation. The court clarified that the Tribunal should have considered whether Mr. Kitching's incapacity was caused or substantially contributed to by the BCC condition or a connected condition. The court held that the Tribunal's decision should be set aside and the matter remitted for reconsideration in light of the court's reasoning. The appeal was allowed, and the Board's decision was overturned. The matter was to be remitted to the Tribunal for a new determination based on the court's findings. No order was made as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed;

2. Order 1 of the orders made by the primary judge on 18 May 2004 be set aside; and

3. Substitute in lieu of order 1 the following order:-

“The decision of the Superannuation Complaints Tribunal made 16 May 2002 be set aside and the matter be remitted to the Tribunal for determination according to the reasons of the Full Court given on 18 November 2004.”

4. No order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 37(4) provides that the Tribunal may only exercise the determination-making power under s 37(3) for the purpose of placing the complainant as nearly as practicable in such a position that the unfairness or unreasonableness that the Tribunal has found to exist, no longer exists.Factual Background On 30 September 1986, Mr Kitching commenced employment as a Commonwealth public servant in the Department of Employment, Education, Training and Youth Affairs. From that date Mr Kitching became an eligible employee for the purposes of the 1976 Act. On 14 October 1986 Mr Kitching underwent a medical examination for the purposes of s 16(2) of the 1976 Act. On 6 April 1987 a delegate of the Commissioner issued a BCC for Mr Kitching under s 16(4) of the 1976 Act. The relevant condition which the delegate specified was “manic depressive psychosis”. This was the condition by reason of which the delegate considered that there was a real risk that Mr Kitching would not continue to be an eligible employee until he attained the maximum retiring age. On 17 November 1999 a delegate of the Board approved Mr Kitching’s retirement on invalidity grounds pursuant to s 54H(2) of the 1976 Act. The delegate certified pursuant to s 54C of the 1976 Act that if Mr Kitching retired he would be entitled to receive invalidity benefits under Division 4 of Part V of the 1976 Act. On 18 November 1999 the delegate of the Board formed the opinion, for the purposes of s 66 (2A) of the 1976 Act, that the incapacity which would be the ground for the retirement of Mr Kitching was caused or substantially contributed to by a physical or mental condition specified in the BCC, namely manic depressive psychosis or by a physical or mental condition connected with such a condition. With effect from 31 December 1999 Mr Kitching was retired from the Commonwealth public service on the ground of invalidity. By reason of his work at Centrelink, in particular the need to deal with aggressive and abusive clients, Mr Kitching developed a condition known as generalised anxiety disorder and depression. It was this condition which incapacitated him from work. On 24 February 2000, Mr Kitching requested the Board, pursuant to s 153AH of the 1976 Act to review the decision made by the delegate on 18 November 1999. On 11 October 2000 the Board affirmed the delegate’s decision. On or about 17 November 2000, Mr Kitching lodged a complaint with the Tribunal under s 14(2) of the SRC Act. The complaint sought a decision setting aside the determination made by the Board on 11 October 2000.The Tribunal’s reasons Mr Kitching contended before the Tribunal that the invalidating condition which caused his retirement was stress and anxiety rather than the BCC condition of manic depressive psychosis, or bipolar affective disorder as it is now known. Initially, the Tribunal correctly stated the question which was raised by the review. It said that the question was whether Mr Kitching’s incapacity was caused or was substantially contributed to by the condition specified in the BCC or by a connected condition.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

We note that, although Mr McCormack submitted that the provisions of s 66(2)(c) and s 66(2A)(c) are of a penal nature, in truth these provisions are of benefit to employees. This is because the provisions enable persons who might not otherwise be admitted to membership of a fund, because of a potentially disabling condition, to join the fund. The condition of so doing is that the member will be deprived of a portion of his or her benefits if an incapacitating condition is caused by or substantially contributed to by the disabling condition present at the time when the member joined the fund or by a condition connected with it.Conclusion and Orders For the reasons stated above, we are of the view that the approach to construction of the second limb adopted by the learned primary judge was not open to him. Accordingly, the orders we will make are as follows:-(a) that the appeal be allowed.(b) set aside order 1 of the orders made by the primary judge on 18 May 2004.(c) substitute in lieu of order 1 the following order:-“The decision of the Superannuation Complaints Tribunal made 16 May 2002 be set aside and the matter be remitted to the Tribunal for determination according to the reasons of the Full Court given on 18 November 2004. (d) No order as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.