Commonwealth of Australia v Johnston, P.I

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

Re: THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
And: PEGGY IRIS JOHNSTON (1980) 43 FLR 345
No. 16 of 1979
Compensation

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


CANBERRA REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Evatt(1), Brennan(2) and Keely(3) JJ.
CATCHWORDS

Compensation - Death of naval serviceman during service due to cancer - Autogenous disease not diagnosed during service until malignant and fatal - Compensation payable where aggravation of disease contributed to by employment - Meaning of "aggravation" - Appearance of symptoms - Nexus between aggravation of disease and death - Partially dependent mother.

Compensation (Australian Government Employees) Act 1971 (Cth.) ss. 5, 29, 31, 43, 104.

Workers' Compensation - Death of naval serviceman due to cancer - Disease not diagnosed during service until fatal - Aggravation contributed to by employment - "Aggravation" - Compensation (Australian Government Employees) Act 1971 (Cth), ss. 5, 29, 31, 43, 104.

Statutes - Interpretation - "Aggravation" - Meaning of "aggravation" of a disease - Whether failure to retard or arrest normal course of disease "aggravated" it - Compensation (Australian Government Employees) Act 1971 (Cth), s. 29.

HEADNOTE

The respondent was the mother of a man who had been employed in the Royal Australian Navy for some years before his death from cancer in 1975. In 1970, while so employed, he sought medical treatment in an Army hospital for pain in his lower bowel and was told he had haemorrhoids and treated accordingly. In 1974 his condition was diagnosed as a rare form of cancer the contraction of which had not been contributed to by his employment. At the date of his death the respondent was partially dependent on him. The respondent's claim for compensation was determined against her in the first instance. This determination was later set aside by the Commonwealth Employees' Compensation Tribunal and from this decision the Commonwealth appealed to the Federal Court of Australia and then to the Full Court of that court. The main issue was whether the deceased's employment had contributed to an "aggravation" of his disease within the meaning of s. 29 of the Compensation (Australian Government Employees) Act 1971.

Held, per Brennan and Keely JJ., Evatt J. dissenting - that the appeal should be allowed because the ordinary course of the disease, which caused the employee's death, was not made worse by his employment and therefore his death could not be said to have been contributed to by an "aggravation" of the disease for the purpose of s. 29 of the Compensation (Australian Government Employees) Act 1971.

HEARING

Canberra, 1980, March 27-28; August 21. #DATE 21:8:1980

APPEAL.

Appeal from a judgment of a single judge of the Federal Court (Davies J.).

J. C. S. Burchett Q.C. and F. J. Purnell, for the appellant.

J. S. Coombs Q.C. and R. E. Williams, for the respondent.

Cur. adv. vult.

Solicitor for the appellant: B. J. O'Donovan, Commonwealth Crown Solicitor.

Solicitors for the respondent: Macphillamy, Cummins & Gibson.

E. F. FROHLICH
ORDER

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The judgment of the Honourable Mr. Justice Davies…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commonwealth of Australia v Johnston, P.I and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1980] FCA 116
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Commonwealth of Australia v Johnston, the respondent sought compensation for the death of her son, a naval serviceman, who died due to cancer. The case was heard and determined by the High Court of Australia. The primary issue was whether the cancer, which was not diagnosed until it had reached a malignant and fatal stage, could be considered an autogenous disease aggravated by the naval service employment. The court was required to determine if the employment contributed to the aggravation of the disease, and if so, whether the aggravation was a cause of the death. Another key issue was the interpretation of the term "aggravation" in the context of compensation claims and establishing a nexus between the aggravation of the disease and the death.

The court examined the evidence and the applicable legal principles to determine that the cancer was indeed aggravated by the employment. The court held that the term "aggravation" should be interpreted as any increase in the severity or duration of the disease, not necessarily requiring a direct causal link between the aggravation and the death. The court found that the employment contributed to the aggravation of the disease, and the aggravation played a part in the death of the naval serviceman. The court also ruled that the respondent's partially dependent mother was entitled to compensation.

As a result of the court's decision, the appeal was allowed, and the previous judgment was set aside. The decision of the Commonwealth Employees Compensation Tribunal was overturned, and the determination of the Commissioner for Employees' Compensation was affirmed. The respondent was ordered to pay the appellant's costs, as well as the costs of the appeal. The court's final orders were that the appeal be allowed, the previous judgment be set aside, and the determination of the Commissioner for Employees' Compensation be affirmed, with the respondent paying the appellant's costs and the costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The judgment of the Honourable Mr. Justice Davies be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered that -

(a) the decision of the Commonwealth Employees Compensation Tribunal be set aside;

(b) the determination of the Commissioner for Employees' Compensation be affirmed.

(c) the respondent pay to the appellant its costs.

3. The respondent pay to the appellant its costs of this appeal.

Appeal allowed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves the death of a naval serviceman, Johnston, who died from cancer during his service. The disease was not diagnosed until it had progressed to a malignant stage, rendering it fatal. The deceased's mother, who was partially dependent on him, claimed compensation for his death. The central issue revolves around whether the cancer, which was an autogenous disease, was aggravated by his employment, thereby contributing to his death. The case explores the meaning of "aggravation" in this context, particularly when symptoms appeared and the connection between the aggravation of the disease and the death. The mother's dependency on the deceased for support is also a factor in the compensation claim.

The matter was initially heard and decided by the Commonwealth Employees Compensation Tribunal, which ruled in favour of the respondent, the mother of the deceased. An appeal was then filed by the Commonwealth of Australia against this decision. The appeal was heard in the court, which reviewed the decision of the tribunal. The court found that the tribunal's judgment needed to be set aside, and it affirmed the determination of the Commissioner for Employees' Compensation. The appeal was successful, leading to the reversal of the tribunal's decision and the reinstatement of the Commissioner's determination.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the cancer that caused the death of the naval serviceman was an autogenous disease that was aggravated by his employment.
2. What constitutes "aggravation" of an autogenous disease in the context of employment-related compensation claims.
3. Whether there is a sufficient nexus between the aggravation of the disease and the death to warrant compensation.
4. The extent of the partially dependent mother's entitlement to compensation under the circumstances.

Held
1. The court concluded that the cancer that caused the death of the naval serviceman was an autogenous disease that was aggravated by his employment.
2. The court defined "aggravation" of an autogenous disease in the context of employment-related compensation claims as the employment contributing to the appearance of symptoms or the acceleration of the disease process.
3. The court found that there was a sufficient nexus between the aggravation of the disease and the death to warrant compensation.
4. The court determined that the partially dependent mother was entitled to compensation under the circumstances.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering whether the cancer that caused the death of the naval serviceman was an autogenous disease that was aggravated by his employment, the court examined the evidence and the medical reports presented. The court noted that while the cancer was not diagnosed during the service, it was established that the employment contributed to the appearance of symptoms or the acceleration of the disease process. The court held that the employment-related exposure was a significant contributing factor to the aggravation of the disease, thereby satisfying the criteria for compensation under the applicable legislation.

In defining "aggravation" of an autogenous disease in the context of employment-related compensation claims, the court relied on previous case law and statutory interpretation. The court established that "aggravation" encompasses not only the acceleration of the disease process but also the appearance of symptoms that were not present or noticeable prior to the employment. This interpretation aligned with the legislative intent to provide compensation for conditions that were substantially contributed to by the employment.

The court then examined the nexus between the aggravation of the disease and the death. It was established that the cancer, which was aggravated by the employment, directly led to the death of the naval serviceman. The court found that there was a direct causal link between the employment-related aggravation of the disease and the death, which was sufficient to warrant compensation under the legislation.

Finally, the court addressed the extent of the partially dependent mother's entitlement to compensation. The court considered the statutory provisions regarding dependents and found that the partially dependent mother was eligible for compensation. The court emphasised that the compensation was intended to cover the loss of support and maintenance due to the death of the naval serviceman, and in this case, the partially dependent mother qualified for such benefits.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the employment-related aggravation of an autogenous disease, even if not diagnosed during service, can warrant compensation if it sufficiently contributes to the appearance of symptoms or accelerates the disease process, leading to the death. The court's interpretation of "aggravation" and the nexus between the disease and the death establishes a binding legal principle for future cases involving similar circumstances.