Commissioner of Taxes (Vic) v Phillips

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read
55 CLR 144

THE COMMISSIONER OF TAXES (VICTORIA) APPELLANT PHILLIPS Income Tax (Vict.)-Assessment-Amoun - paid as compensation on termination of

appointment-Lump sum-Capital or income-Income Tax Act 1928 (Vict.) (No. 3701). MELBOURNE, Mar. 5, 6.

The taxpayer was employed as governing director of a company for a period of ten years at a remuneration equivalent to 121 per cent. of the net annual profits. Before the expiration of the period of ten years the company disposed April 27.

of its business to another company and the taxpayer's employment was termin- ated. It was agreed between the company and the taxpayer that he should receive £20,301 as compensation for the termination of his employment, com- puted on a basis of £5,252 a year for the unexpired portion of the period of ten years and payable by monthly instalments.

Held that the monthly payments were of an income nature and liable to Decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria (Full Court): In re Income Tar Acts, (1935) V.L.R. 407, reversed.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of Victoria.

Herman Frank Phillips objected to an assessment to income tax made by the Commissioner of Taxes (Victoria) and requested the Commissioner to transmit the objection to be heard and determined by a Judge of County Courts. The objection came on for hearing

55 CLR 145

before Judge Woinarski, who stated a case, substantially as follows, for the opinion of the Full Court of the Supreme Court

1. Herman Frank Phillips (hereinafter called "the taxpayer ") and his brother Leon Phillips have for many years carried on business in partnership as amusement managers and directors.

2. The partnership has been SO carried on pursuant to a verbal agreement between the partners, one of the terms of which was that all moneys received by either partner from amusement enterprises or other sources and whether by way of capital or income should be brought into the partnership and should belong to the partners in equal shares. The partnership received or was credited with by way of income the whole of the moneys received by each partner as directors' fees, salaries and commission and also as dividends, rents and interest from investments in amusement enterprises and properties.

3. Returns of income have been made and assessments issued under the Income Tax Act 1928 (Vict.) on the footing that the taxpayer and Leon Phillips are partners in equal shares in the business and that all income received by either of them as aforesaid is income of the partnership.

4. For the year ended 30th June 1932 the income of the partner- ship included directors' fees received by the taxpayer and/or Leon Phillips for their services as directors of Luna Park Ltd., Central Theatre Co. Pty. Ltd., and Town Hall Property Co. Pty. Ltd., salaries received by the taxpayer and/or Leon Phillips from various amusement enterprises, dividends upon shares in various companies held by the taxpayer and/or Leon Phillips, and interest upon capital sums invested by the partnership. The partnership furnished…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Taxes (Vic) v Phillips and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1936] HCA 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Commissioner of Taxes (Victoria) appealed to the High Court of Australia against a decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria. The dispute concerned whether a sum of £4,444 paid to the taxpayer, Herman Frank Phillips, constituted assessable income for the year ended 30 June 1932. The taxpayer and his brother operated a business in partnership, and all income received by either partner was treated as partnership income. The taxpayer had an agreement to serve as governing director of a theatre company for ten years, receiving remuneration based on a percentage of net annual profits. This employment was terminated before the ten-year period expired, and the taxpayer received a sum calculated as compensation for the loss of future remuneration.

The legal issue before the High Court was whether the payments received by the taxpayer, which were made pursuant to an agreement to retire him from his position as governing director, were of an income nature and therefore subject to income tax, or if they were capital receipts. The taxpayer contended that these payments were compensation for the loss of his employment and thus capital in nature, while the Commissioner argued they were income. The Supreme Court of Victoria had found in favour of the taxpayer, holding that the payments were not assessable income.

The High Court, by majority, allowed the Commissioner's appeal. The Court reasoned that while the payments were measured by reference to the anticipated loss of future income, they were essentially a substitute for the remuneration the taxpayer would have earned had his employment continued. The agreement to pay the compensation was made in the ordinary course of the partnership's business activities, and the payments were made by instalments over the remaining term of the original employment agreement, mirroring the periodicity of the remuneration that would have been received. The Court distinguished this situation from cases where a capital asset is disposed of, finding that the taxpayer had exchanged a right to future periodical payments for another right to payments of the same periodicity over the same term. Therefore, the payments were considered to be of an income nature.

The High Court ordered that the appeal be allowed, the decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria be set aside, and the question in the special case be answered in the affirmative, meaning the sum of £4,444 was assessable income. The case was remitted to the County Court with this answer, and the taxpayer was ordered to pay the costs of the appeal and the special case in the Supreme Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established