Commissioner of Taxation v Clyne

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read
100 CLR 246

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA CLYNE Income Tax (Cth.)-Provisional tax and contributionWhether within power to

make laws with respect to taxation-Not separate tax but liability ancillary to income tax and social services contribution-Constitutional validity-Matters 1957,

other than taxation-Whether combined in statute imposing taxation-Collection SYDNEY,

of provisional tax not acquisition of property on unjust terms-Prescribed area Nov. 12, 13,

Zone allowances-Discrimination between States or parts of States-Validity of 14, 15;

section introducing discriminatory provision-Invalid ab initio-Never valid part of Principal Act-Preference to one State or part thereof over another State 1958,

or part thereof-The Constitution (63 &64 Vict., c. 12). 88. 51 (ii.) (xxxi.), 55, Apr. 2.

99-Income Tax and Social Services Contributions (Individuals) Act 1956, 8. 12-Income Tax and Social Services Contribution Assessment Act 1936-1956, SS. 79A, 221YA.

The system of provisional tax and contribution as prescribed by Div. 3. Pt. v. of the Income Tax and Social Services Contribution Assessment Act 1936-1956 is within the power conferred on the Parliament of the Common- wealth by S. 51 (ii.) of the Constitution.

So held by the whole Court. Per Dixon C.J., McTiernan, Williams, Kitto and Taylor JJ.: The liability to pay provisional tax and contribution is not a liability to a separate and distinct tax but is ancillary to the liability to income tax and social services contri- bution required by S. 17 of the Assessment Act to be levied and paid upon the taxable income derived during the year of income by any person. The purpose of the provisional tax and contribution provisions is not simply to ensure payment of tax but to bring the discharge of the burden of tax into closer temporal relation with the accrual of the income upon which the tax is levied. The execution of such a policy is fairly within the power in S. 51 (ii.) of the Constitution even if it be described as incidental. The main purpose of that power is expressed by the words " with respect to taxation ". It gives a legis- lative authority which includes prima facie whatever is reasonably and properly incidental to the effectuation of the purpose. There is no reason why the means described in Div. 3 of Pt. v. for giving effect to the principle should not be regarded as proper for the effectuation of the power to make laws in respect to taxation.

100 CLR 247

In imposing provisional tax S. 12 of the Income Tax and Social Services Contribution (Individuals) Act 1956 deals with a liability incidental to the liability to the principal tax and is therefore a provision in a law dealing " only with the imposition of taxation" within the meaning of the first paragraph of S. 55 of the Constitution.

The words imposition of taxation" are not to be construed narrowly in the sense that there must be a distinction between provisions directed to the collection of taxation and the actual grant or imposition of the tax-per Dixon C.J., McTiernan, Williams,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Taxation v Clyne and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1958] HCA 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Commissioner of Taxation brought proceedings against Peter Leopold Clyne to recover £752 in provisional tax and contribution. The taxpayer demurred to the statement of claim, arguing that the legislation under which the provisional tax was imposed was beyond the constitutional powers of the Commonwealth Parliament. The matter was heard by the Full Court of the High Court of Australia.

The legal issues before the Court were whether the imposition of provisional tax and contribution was within the Commonwealth Parliament's power to make laws with respect to taxation under section 51(ii) of the Constitution. Further, the Court had to determine if the legislation contravened section 55 of the Constitution, which restricts laws imposing taxation to matters of taxation only, and if it offended section 51(xxxi) by acquiring property on unjust terms. Additionally, the Court considered whether section 79A of the Assessment Act, which provided zone allowances, discriminated between States or parts of States contrary to section 51(ii) or gave an impermissible preference contrary to section 99 of the Constitution.

The Court held that the system of provisional tax and contribution was within the power conferred by section 51(ii) of the Constitution. It was not a separate tax but a liability ancillary to the primary income tax and social services contribution, designed to bring the discharge of the tax burden into closer temporal relation with the accrual of income. The Court reasoned that this policy was reasonably incidental to the power to legislate with respect to taxation. Furthermore, the Court found that section 12 of the Income Tax and Social Services Contribution (Individuals) Act 1956, which imposed provisional tax, dealt with a liability incidental to the principal tax and therefore fell within the scope of a law dealing "only with the imposition of taxation" as required by section 55. The argument that the collection of provisional tax constituted an acquisition of property on unjust terms under section 51(xxxi) was rejected.

Regarding the zone allowances under section 79A, the Court found that this section, as introduced by Act No. 4 of 1945, was invalid ab initio as it discriminated between States or parts of States contrary to sections 51(ii) and 99 of the Constitution. However, the Court also held that this invalidity did not affect the validity of the Income Tax and Social Services Contribution (Individuals) Act 1956, as only validly enacted provisions of the Assessment Act were incorporated into it. Therefore, the demurrer was overruled.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established