COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE v ROOZBEH ARAGHI and
LUKE JOHNATHON DORSETT
[2013] ACTSC 43 (14 March 2013)
TAXES AND DUTIES – Stamp duties – Contract for sale of Crown lease – completion of sale required within specified period after completion of separate contract between buyer and builder to erect building on land – whether duty assessable on value of building contract – whether there was a “house and land package” or an “off the plan” purchase agreement – whether transfer of Crown lease with building on the land was in conformity with land sale contract – whether ad valorem duty assessable on land sale contract and on transfer of land after completion of building.
ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT) s 79
Community Title Act 2001 (ACT)
Duties Act 1999 (ACT) ss 7, 8, 10, 11, 16, 16A, 16B, 17, 20, 21 and 30
Land (Planning and Environment) Act 1991 (ACT) s 180
Legislation Act 2001 (ACT) s 145
Planning and Development Act 2007 (ACT) s 298
Duties Act 1997 (NSW) s 21(1)
Stamp Duties Act 1920 (NSW) s 41(1)
Archibald Howie Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Stamp Duties(NSW) (1948) 77 CLR 143
Australian Provincial Assurance Co Ltd v Coroneo (1938) 38 SR(NSW) 700
Ball-Guymer v Livantes (1990) 102 FLR 327
Bambro (No. 2) Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Stamp Duties [1963] SR(NSW) 522
Chief Commissioner of State Revenue v Dick Smith Electronics Holdings Pty Ltd (2005) 221 CLR 496
Commissioner of Inland Revenue v New Zealand Forest Research Institute [2000] 1 WLR 1755
Lindquist v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2004] ACTAAT 12 (26 March 2004)
Oakland Property Holdings v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue [2009] NSWSC 1190
Paul v Inland Revenue [1936] SC 443
Roozbeh Araghi and Luke Johnathon Dorsett v Commissioner for Australian Capital Territory Revenue [2010] ACAT 78
Sportscorp v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue [2004] NSWSC 1029
Butt P, Land Law (6th ed, Thomson Reuters, 2010) at [3 12]
Bradbrook AJ, MacCallum SV, Moore AP, Gratton S, Australian Real Property Law (5th ed, Thomson Reuters, 2011) at 784
ON APPEAL FROM THE ACT CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
No. SCA 90 of 2010
Judge: Penfold J
Supreme Court of the ACT
Date: 14 March 2013
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE )
) No. SCA 90 of 2010
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
ON APPEAL FROM THE ACT CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
BETWEEN:
COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE
Appellant
AND:
ROOZBEH ARAGHI and
LUKE JOHNATHON DORSETT
Respondents
ORDER
Judge: Penfold J
Date: 14 March 2013
Place: Canberra
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
The question of law be answered as follows:
QUESTION: Under the Duties Act 1999 (ACT), what value is to be considered in the assessment for duty of an agreement for the sale of a Crown lease by the Land Development Agency, being an agreement under which the buyer is required, before the transfer of the lease is required or able to be completed, to complete a separate contract with a different party for construction…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner for Act Revenue v Roozbeh Araghi and and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] ACTSC 43
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the agreement to convey the land with the building was a separate transaction subject to duty, distinct from the agreement to sell the land itself. The court examined the nature and consideration of the agreement to determine if it constituted a dutiable transaction. The court also had to interpret the relevant statutory provisions and consider whether the Administrative Appeals Tribunal's reasoning in a similar case, Lindquist v Commissioner for ACT Revenue, was applicable.
The court found that the consideration for the agreement to convey the land with the building was the same as the consideration for the agreement to sell the land. The court held that the transaction was not properly identified as a separate dutiable transaction. The court distinguished the current case from Lindquist on the basis that the parties to the agreements were not the same, which affected the identification of the dutiable transaction. The court concluded that the reassessment of duty by the Commissioner was not justified.
The court ordered that the reassessment of duty by the Commissioner was not supported by the evidence and reasoning. The court quashed the decision of the Commissioner to reassess duty on the transaction in question.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Finally, the statement relied on by the appellant, even if accepted as authoritative, or at least correct, does not answer the real question identified as arising in this case (at [79] above), namely, what was the consideration for the agreement under which land with a building on it was to be conveyed to the respondent Buyer. In Lindquist v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2004] ACTAAT 12 (26 March 2004) (Lindquist), the ACT Administrative Appeals Tribunal dealt with a case in which the two owners of a block of land (presumably in fact the holders of the Crown lease over the land) sold the block to themselves (the sellers) and another two people, the Lindquists, to be held as tenants in common as between the sellers and the Lindquists, with the sellers and the Lindquists each holding their half shares as joint tenants. The purchase price of the land was $351,000, of which it seems that half moved, in effect, from the sellers back to themselves. The Lindquists’ agreement to buy a half share in the block “was conditional upon the parties entering a development deed and a building agreement and an acknowledgment that on completion the land would be subject to a mortgage” (at [5]). Duty was assessed on, apparently, the whole purchase price for the block, and the transfer of the block was registered on 25 May 2000, at which point there was no building on the block. The development deed provided for registration of a units plan dividing the block into two units on each of which a residence could be built, and common property, and the Lindquists agreed to buy Unit 1 of the development. One of the sellers entered a building agreement with the Lindquists to build, for a price of $392,000, a residential unit which would be Unit 1. In due course the units plan was registered and the four owners of the block (including Mr and Mrs Lindquist) executed a transfer of Unit 1 to the Lindquists. Following a dispute about the assessment of duty on the transfer of Unit 1, the respondent Commissioner re-assessed the dutiable value of the original transaction to include not just the value of the original contract for sale but also the value of the building agreement. It was this reassessment which was challenged. The AAT concluded as follows: ACAT at [66] distinguished this case on the grounds that it did not “address the issue where the parties in the second agreement were different to the parties of [sic] the first agreement”. I am not convinced that Lindquist was correctly decided, or, at least, that the reasons given by the AAT were sound. The AAT’s conclusion about “the subject matter of the agreement” involved, among other things, a very broad-brush approach to the identification of the transaction that it found to be dutiable, and involved glossing over the inconvenient facts that: The fact that duty is charged on a transaction as if it were a conveyance and not, relevantly, on a conveyance as such seems to require a fairly careful identification of: