Catbagan v Commissioner for Act Revenue

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



CATBAGAN v COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE
(Administrative Review) [2014] ACAT 44

AT 13/76

Catchwords:             ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – duty payable – home buyer concession scheme – dutiable value of land rent lease purchase – purchase condition for vendor to build a dwelling – consideration paid by applicant under contract is referable to house to be built on land - land rent leases are to be treated similar to Crown leases – unencumbered value of land and improvement value to be added for arriving at dutiable value

Legislation:Duties Act 1999, ss 7, 10, 11, 16A, 20, 22 and 252AA

Land Rent Act 2008, ss 7, 8, 16C, 17 and 24

Rates Act 2004, ss 7, 8, 16C, 17 and 24

Taxation Administration Act 1999, ss 108A and 111

Subordinate              

Legislation:Taxation Administration (Amounts Payable – Thresholds – Home Buyer Concession Scheme) Determination 2012 (No 2) (Repealed) (D12012-275)

Taxation Administration (Amounts Payable – Duty)
Determination 2013 (No 2)
(Repealed) (DI2013–174)

Cases:Australian Provincial Assurance Co Ltd v Coroneo (1938) 38 SR (NSW) 700

Archibald Howie Proprietary Limited v Commissioner of Stamp Duties (New South Wales) (1948) 77 CLR 143
Bambro (No 2) Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Stamp Duties (1963) SR (NSW) 522
Commissioner for ACT Revenue v Araghi and Dorsett [2013] ACTSC 43
Commissioner for ACT Revenue v Araghi and Dorsett [2013] ACTCA 54
Sportscorp v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue [2004] NSWSC 1029

Texts/Papers:            Explanatory Statement to the Duties Amendment Bill 2012

Tribunal:                  Dr T. Foley – Senior Member

Date of Orders:  18 July 2014

Date of Reasons for Decision:         18 July 2014

ACT CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL               AT 13/76

BETWEEN:

MARY ANN CATBAGAN

Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:            Dr. T. Foley – Senior Member

DATE:18 July 2014

ORDER

The Tribunal Orders that:

  1. The Tribunal confirms the decision under review.

………………………………..

Dr. T. Foley

Senior Member

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Mary Ann Catbagan (“the applicant”) has sought review of a decision of the Commissioner for ACT Revenue (“the respondent”) to disallow her objection to its refusal of her application for the Home Buyer Concession (“HBC application”) pursuant to the Duties Act 1999 (ACT) (“the Duties Act”) with respect to her purchase of a land rent lease of Block 16 Section 9 Jacka (“the property”) under the provisions of the Land Rent Act 2008 (ACT) (“the Land Rent Act”).

  2. Jurisdiction to review the respondent’s decision is conferred on the Tribunal by section 252AA of the Duties Act and section 108A of the Taxation Administration Act 1999 (ACT) (“the Taxation Administration Act”)].

The Hearing

  1. The matter was heard on 21 February 2014. The Tribunal had before it the documents provided by the respondent on which the respondent’s decision was based (“the T Documents”), the Submissions and Statements of Facts and Contentions of the parties and other exhibits tendered in evidence.  The applicant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Catbagan v Commissioner for Act Revenue and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] ACAT 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Catbagan v Commissioner for ACT Revenue, the applicant, Catbagan, sought a review of the decision by the respondent, the Commissioner for ACT Revenue, which assessed the duty payable on a property transaction. The case was heard by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, which was established under sections 252AA of the Duties Act and 108A of the Taxation Administration Act 1999 (ACT). The hearing took place on 21 February 2014, with the Tribunal reviewing the documents provided by the respondent, the submissions, and other exhibits tendered in evidence. Neither the applicant nor the respondent presented any witnesses, but both parties made submissions. The Tribunal requested further submissions from the parties regarding the applicability of section 22 of the Duties Act.

The central legal issues in the case involved the correct determination of the "dutiable value" of the property in question and the applicability of the Home Buyer Concession Scheme (HBC scheme). The applicant purchased the property for $325,000 and applied for the HBC scheme, which provided for a concession on the duty payable. The respondent, however, assessed the "dutiable value" of the property at $544,000 by adding the 2013 Unimproved Land Value (ULV) of $219,000 to the purchase price. This assessment placed the property outside the upper value threshold for the concession under the Taxation Administration (Amounts Payable – Thresholds – Home Buyer Concession Scheme) Determination 2012 (No 2) (Repealed). Consequently, the respondent assessed the duty payable at $20,470 and issued a Notice of Assessment.

The Tribunal examined the evidence and submissions to determine whether the respondent's assessment of the "dutiable value" was correct and whether the HBC scheme applied. The Tribunal found that the respondent's assessment was accurate, and the property's "dutiable value" was indeed $544,000. The Tribunal confirmed the respondent's decision and held that the applicant was liable to pay the assessed duty of $20,470. The Tribunal's decision was based on the statutory provisions and the evidence presented, which supported the respondent's assessment and the inapplicability of the HBC scheme due to the property's "dutiable value" exceeding the upper threshold.

The final orders of the Tribunal confirmed the decision under review, meaning the respondent's assessment of the duty payable on the property transaction was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal Orders that:

1.

The Tribunal confirms the decision under review.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Jurisdiction to review the respondent’s decision is conferred on the Tribunal by section 252AA of the Duties Act and section 108A of the Taxation Administration Act 1999 (ACT) (“the Taxation Administration Act”)]. The matter was heard on 21 February 2014. The Tribunal had before it the documents provided by the respondent on which the respondent’s decision was based (“the T Documents”), the Submissions and Statements of Facts and Contentions of the parties and other exhibits tendered in evidence. The applicant was not present but submissions were made on her behalf by her husband Mr Jerome Catbagan. The respondent was represented by Mr G. McCarthy of Counsel. The applicant and the respondent called no evidence. Submissions were made on behalf of both parties. At the Tribunal's request the parties filed further submissions after the hearing with respect to the applicability of section 22 of the Duties Act. On 20 March 2013, the applicant entered into a contact for sale with respect to the property (“the contract”).[1] The purchase price stated in the contract was $325,000. At the time the applicant entered into the contract the property was vacant land. The contract provided for a dwelling to be built on the land by the vendor and that completion of the contract was to occur within14 days of the issue of a certificate of occupancy and use for that dwelling. [1] T documents, page 17 The applicant purchased the property as a land rent lease under the provisions of the Land Rent Act. The applicant did not purchase the property in a ballot or by direct sale from the Land Development Agency but by way of transfer from Sirj Group Pty Ltd, a registered affordable housing provider, which itself had acquired the land rent lease in May 2012. On 17 April 2013, the applicant via her solicitor lodged the contract with the respondent for stamping, together with an application for the Home Buyer Concession Scheme (“the HBC scheme”)[2] plus attachments; a transfer [3] and a Conveyance Lodgement Form.[4] Each of the contract, the HBC application and transfer stated the purchase price/consideration as $325,000. Only the Conveyance Lodgement Form is printed to refer to “dutiable value” of the property which was stated as $325,000, consistent with the purchase price disclosed on the other documents lodged.[2] T documents, pages 18-21[3] Exhibit R4[4] T documents, pages 38-39 The respondent assessed the “dutiable value” of the property at $544,000. It did so by adding to the $325,000 expressed as the purchase price on the HBC application, the value of the 2013 Unimproved Land Value of the property (“the ULV”) [ST1] of $219,000. This total of $544,000 took the property outside the then applicable “upper value threshold” for concession of $525,000 under the Taxation Administration (Amounts Payable – Thresholds – Home Buyer Concession Scheme) Determination 2012 (No 2) (Repealed) (D12012-275) [“Disallowable Instrument DI2012-275”]. In the absence of such concession the respondent assessed the duty payable at $20,470 and issued a Notice of Assessment[5] requiring payment of that sum by 18 June 2013.[5] T documents, page 51