Combined Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Galea

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Combined Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Galea & Ors [2020] QSC 338

PARTIES:

COMBINED PROPERTY HOLDINGS PTY LTD

ACN 161 599 444

(plaintiff)

v

PAUL WILLIAM EDWARD GALEA

(first defendant)

and
MICHAEL GEORGE PORTER
(second defendant)
and
SASHWILL PTY LTD ACN 124 191 591 (trading as Porter Galea Lawyers)

(third defendant)

FILE NO/S:

SC No 660 of 2018

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Cairns

DELIVERED ON:

6 November 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Cairns

HEARING DATE:

22 October 2020

JUDGE:

Henry J

ORDERS:

1.   The plaintiff will give security for the defendants’ costs up to the close of pleadings and disclosure in the sum of $75,000 to be either paid into court or secured by provision of a bank guarantee evidenced in a form satisfactory to the Registrar within 21 days of this order.

2.   The proceeding is stayed until such security is provided.

3.   Liberty to apply on the giving of two clear business days notice in writing.

4.   In the event such security is provided:

a.       the plaintiff has leave to amend its claim and third amended statement of claim to add breach of fiduciary duty as a new cause of action;

b.       the plaintiff has leave to amend its third amended statement of claim to plead a breach of duty to warn of economic risk as part of the existing causes of action for breach of contract or negligence.

5.   In respect of both applications, costs reserved.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – SECURITY FOR COSTS – FACTORS RELEVANT TO EXERCISE OF DISCRETION – PLAINTIFF'S OR APPLICANT'S IMPECUNIOSITY – CAUSE OF PLAINTIFF'S OR APPLICANT'S IMPECUNIOSITY – where the impecunious corporate plaintiff claims the defendants caused it loss via their negligence or breach of retainer – where the defendants apply for security for their costs – where the plaintiff claims that the defendants’ wrongs were the cause of its impecuniosity – where the plaintiff entered into a number of convoluted transactions concerning the development of property – where there is a lack of evidence as to the real financial position of the plaintiff – whether and to what extent the defendants should be granted security for their costs   

LIMITATION OF ACTIONS – GENERAL MATTERS – AMENDMENT OF ORIGINATING PROCESSES AND PLEADINGS OUTSIDE LIMITATION PERIOD – AMENDMENTS INTRODUCING NEW CAUSE OF ACTION OR PARTICULARISING CAUSE OF ACTION – where the plaintiff claims the defendants are liable for breach of contract and negligence – where the plaintiff seeks to claim the defendants are additionally liable for breach of contract and negligence because they had knowledge of a risk and a duty to warn of a risk but did not do so – where the plaintiff seeks to amend its originating process to claim the defendants breached their fiduciary duties – whether the amendments in relation to a failure to warn of a risk of economic loss merely involve the particularisation of an existing cause of action or introduce…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Combined Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Galea and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QSC 338
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Combined Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Galea involved a dispute concerning property development at Edmonton, south of Cairns. The plaintiff, Combined Property Holdings Pty Ltd, claimed that the defendants, including Galea, were liable for negligence and breach of contract, among other things. The defendants applied for security for their costs, arguing that the plaintiff's claims were frivolous and that the plaintiff's impecuniosity was not caused by the defendants' actions. The plaintiff argued that the defendants' wrongs were the cause of its impecuniosity and that the defendants should not be granted security for their costs. The case also involved an application by the plaintiff to amend its pleadings to include new causes of action, including breach of fiduciary duty and breach of a duty to warn of economic risk.

The legal issues before the court were whether the defendants should be granted security for their costs, and whether the plaintiff should be granted leave to amend its pleadings to include new causes of action. The court found that the plaintiff's claims were not frivolous and that the defendants' application for security for their costs should be dismissed. The court also found that the amendments sought by the plaintiff did not introduce new causes of action but merely particularised existing causes of action. The court granted the plaintiff leave to amend its pleadings to include the new causes of action.

In dismissing the application for security for costs, the court found that the plaintiff's impecuniosity was not caused by the defendants' actions and that there was a lack of evidence as to the real financial position of the plaintiff. The court found that the plaintiff's claims were not frivolous and that the defendants' application for security for their costs should be dismissed. The court also found that the amendments sought by the plaintiff did not introduce new causes of action but merely particularised existing causes of action. The court granted the plaintiff leave to amend its pleadings to include the new causes of action.

The orders of the court were that the plaintiff would give security for the defendants' costs up to the close of pleadings and disclosure in the sum of $75,000 to be either paid into court or secured by provision of a bank guarantee evidenced in a form satisfactory to the Registrar within 21 days of this order. The proceeding was stayed until such security was provided. The plaintiff was granted leave to amend its claim and third amended statement of claim to add breach of fiduciary duty as a new cause of action and to amend its third amended statement of claim to plead a breach of duty to warn of economic risk as part of the existing causes of action for breach of contract or negligence. In respect of both applications, costs were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiff will give security for the defendants’ costs up to the close of pleadings and disclosure in the sum of $75,000 to be either paid into court or secured by provision of a bank guarantee evidenced in a form satisfactory to the Registrar within 21 days of this order.

2. The proceeding is stayed until such security is provided.

3. Liberty to apply on the giving of two clear business days notice in writing.

4. In the event such security is provided:

a. the plaintiff has leave to amend its claim and third amended statement of claim to add breach of fiduciary duty as a new cause of action;

b. the plaintiff has leave to amend its third amended statement of claim to plead a breach of duty to warn of economic risk as part of the existing causes of action for breach of contract or negligence.

5. In respect of both applications, costs reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before dealing with the discrete applications it is convenient to review some of the evidence of factual background of varying relevance to both applications. As will become apparent there is a lack of clarity in, and documentary support for, some of the more critical features of that evidence. It is a shortcoming of particular importance to consideration of the security for costs application.Background The plaintiff’s claim arises in connection with the property development of a residential subdivision at Edmonton, south of Cairns. Purported ownership of substantial parts of the development land (“the land”) has passed between various entities over time. The plaintiff’s sole director, Geoffrey Vance Landrey, has had direct or indirect connections with each of those entities. Mr Landrey deposes in his first affidavit[3] that in 2004 a number of investors (“the investors”) lent a total of $12 million to his then wife Toni Landrey and that she lent that money to Cairns Development Company No 3 Pty Ltd (“CDC”), secured by a mortgage over the land,[4] which consisted of Lot 1 on RP 717773 and Lot 900 on SP 167091. He deposes that between 2006 and 2007 Mrs Landrey transferred her mortgage to each of the investors as tenants in common in proportion to their respective contribution to the loan of $12 million. There are 42 such investors in an exhibited list of what Mr Landrey describes as a list of “all” investors. [5][3]Court doc 16, Affidavit of Geoffrey Vance Landrey, filed 29 May 2020.[4]Mr Landrey deposed the mortgage was registered but that he could only locate an unstamped copy to exhibit to his affidavit.[5]Court doc 16, Affidavit of Geoffrey Landrey, Exs p 21. Mr Landrey deposes that in 2007 Stony Creek Pty Ltd (“Stony Creek”), of which he was sole director, “acquired” the land from CDC and “agreed to give” new unregistered mortgages over the land to the investors in proportion to their respective investment, with Mrs Landrey’s mortgage being discharged. What, if any, purchase price was paid by Stony Creek to CDC to acquire the land and why the change of ownership occurred is not apparent from Mr Landrey’s affidavit. When, if ever, the investors’ equity in the land was legally preserved during this movement in ownership is muddy. Mr Landrey deposes Stony Creek “agreed to give” them mortgages. He then exhibits what he describes as “an example of one of those unregistered mortgage documents with one of the Investors”. That document bears an execution date of 8 June 2007. The annexure of such an exhibit is presumably intended to convey the impression that such mortgages were in fact given and given around when the change of ownership to Stony Creek occurred in 2007. However, the mortgagee named in that mortgage is Tundra Corp Pty Ltd, which is not one of the investors listed in the aforementioned list of all investors. Such an inconsistency is surprising given Mr Landrey must be well aware his conduct relating to Stony Creek’s purported execution of the investor mortgages is the subject of criminal charges pending against him.[6] That prosecution case alleges in part that Mr Landrey later used false, backdated purported versions of eleven such “mortgages” to advantage the plaintiff company. [6]Court doc 19, Affidavit of Natasha Farr, Exs pp 259-280.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.