Combined Communications Pty Ltd v Combined Communication Solutions Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Combined Communications Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark applications 1452550 and 1452551 (both in Classes 37, 38 and 42) - COMBINED COMMUNICATION SOLUTIONS (Word Mark) and COMBINED COMMUNICATION SOLUTIONS (Logo Mark) - in the name of Combined Communication Solutions Pty Ltd.

Delegate:

Iain Campbell Thompson

Representation:

Opponent: Chris Burgess of Counsel instructed by Nicky Shanks, solicitor and trade mark attorney of Cotters Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys

Applicant: David Stewart of Counsel instructed by Marie Wong, solicitor, of Wrays Intellectual Property

Decision:

2014 ATMO 117

S52 opposition: s44 – comparison of trade marks, discount of words which lack inherent adaptation to distinguish; parties’ composite trade marks not deceptively similar – Opposed Word Trade Mark deceptively similar to Opponent’s Registered Trade Mark. Section 58 and 60 grounds of opposition not established.

Opposed Word Mark refused registration.

No award of costs.

Background

  1. In these proceedings under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) Combined Communications Solutions Pty Ltd (‘the Applicant’) has applied to register the trade marks appearing below:

    Application No: 1452550

    Priority Date:  6 October 2011

    Services:Class 37: Installation, repair and maintenance services in relation to communications systems, apparatus, equipment and installations and parts, fitting and accessories therefor; installation, repair and maintenance services in relation to computer hardware and software and parts, fitting and accessories therefor; installation, repair and maintenance services in relation to electronic and electrical systems, apparatus, equipment and installations, and parts, fittings and accessories therefor

    Class 38: Telecommunications; advisory and consulting services in the field of communications and telecommunications; project management services in the field of communications and telecommunications; rental of communications and telecommunications systems, apparatus, equipment and installations and parts, fittings and accessories therefor; providing user access to global positioning signals and data for navigation and tracking purposes, including vehicle fleet management and asset navigation and tracking; transmission of global positioning signals for navigation and tracking purposes, including fleet management and asset navigation and tracking; communication services for the purpose of tracking speed, direction and location of assets and personnel; communication services for the purpose of transmission of emergency messages; data communication by electronic means including by digital radio, cellular or satellite devices

    Class 42: Design and development of computer software; design and development of renewable energy and battery systems, apparatus, equipment and installations and parts, fitting and accessories therefor; design and development of communications systems, apparatus, equipment and installations and parts, fitting and accessories therefor; rental of computer hardware and software and parts, fitting and accessories therefor

    Trade Mark:  COMBINED COMMUNICATIONS SOLUTIONS

    (‘the Opposed Word Trade Mark’)

    Endorsement: Provisions of paragraph 44(3)(a) and/or Reg 4.15A(3)(a) applied.

    Application No: 1452551

    Priority Date:  6 October 2011

    Services:Class 37: Installation, repair and maintenance services in relation to communications systems, apparatus, equipment and installations and parts, fitting and accessories therefor; installation, repair and maintenance services in relation to computer hardware and software and parts, fitting…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Combined Communications Pty Ltd v Combined Communication Sol... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] ATMO 117
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an opposition by Combined Communications Pty Ltd (the Opponent) to the registration of two trade mark applications by Combined Communication Solutions Pty Ltd (the Applicant). The dispute centred on the Applicant's proposed registration of the trade mark "COMBINED COMMUNICATION SOLUTIONS" and a logo, in relation to telecommunications goods and services. The decision was made by Iain Campbell Thompson, sitting as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks.

The court was required to determine whether the grounds of opposition, including those relating to deceptive or confusing similarity with the Opponent's existing trade marks and business names, had been established. Specifically, the court had to consider the extent to which the Opponent's use of its trade marks and business name, "COMBINED COMMUNICATIONS," was likely to cause confusion with the Applicant's proposed marks, particularly in light of the doctrine of honest concurrent use. The court also had to consider the admissibility and weight of evidence submitted by both parties, including promotional materials and invoices.

The court reasoned that the relevant date for assessing the grounds of opposition was the filing date of the application. It noted that some of the Opponent's evidence did not clearly show the form of the trade mark used in advertisements, and one invoice was addressed to a different entity. The court found that while some evidence suggested a likelihood of confusion, it was of limited weight given the argument for honest concurrent use, which inherently anticipates a degree of confusion. The court distinguished between the use of "Combined Communications" as a business name and its use as a trade mark.

Ultimately, the court refused to register the Opposed Word Trade Mark (application 1452550). However, application 1452551 was permitted to proceed to registration, subject to certain conditions regarding potential appeals and the deletion of an endorsement. The court made no order as to costs, acknowledging that both parties had achieved some degree of success.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The relevant date at which the grounds must be considered is the filing[2] date of the application: Southern Cross Refrigerating Co v Toowoomba Foundry Pty Ltd (1954) 91 CLR 592; The Seven Up Company v O.T. Limited (1947) 75 CLR 203 at 211; Rael Marcus v Sabra International Pty Ltd (1995) 30 IPR 261 at 266.[2] As regards the section 44 ground of opposition the relevant date is the priority date which is here the same as the filing date.Evidence The evidence comprises the following declarations:In Support:Matthew Kelly dated 26 November 2013, with Exhibit MK-1; andTroy Kelly dated 29 November 2013.In Answer Shane William Post dated 30 January 2013, with Exhibits SWP-1 to SWP-1 8Shane William Post dated 28 February 2014 (Second Post Declaration);Terry Crothers dated 28 February 2014;Shirley Ansell dated 28 February 2014;Peter Farley dated 28 February 2014;Stuart Dell dated 28 February 2014;Glen Roberts dated 3 March 2014; andMarc Woods dated 3 March 2014.In ReplyMatthew Kelly dated 2 April 2014;Ian Buckley dated 1 May 2014, together with Exhibit IB-1; andTroy Abel dated 7 May 2014. On 3 September 2014, the Opponent also filed with IP Australia copies of further documents said to be submitted for consideration under Regulation 21.19 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (‘the regs’), which are described by the Opponent as follows:An invoice from a company called Omnitronics Pty Ltd (Omnitronics) dated 18 August 2014 which came to the Opponent’s attention on or about 21 August 2014;Email correspondence titled “Combined Communications NSW” between an employee in the Accounts Payable department of the Opponent and the Supply Chain Logistics Manger of Omnitronics which was sent after the Opponent reported the receipt of the item identified in the Invoice to Omnitronics;A “Booking Confirmation Report” showing that Omnitronics arranged for the relevant article to be collected from the Opponent’s address in New South Wales and delivered to the Applicant in the Northern Territory;An email titled “E-Connote for Shipment date 28/08/2014” attaching a “Manifest Report” and a “Consignment Label” relating to the collection of the relevant article from the Opponent’s address in New South Wales and its delivery to the Applicant’s address in the Northern Territory. In regard to the latter documents, without commenting on the admissibility of such ‘evidence’, I note that the documents generally go to establish the likelihood of confusion. As such (and as it is alleged evidence of a single instance of confusion) they are of no practical weight in these proceedings since honest concurrent use is argued and a degree of confusion is thus foreshadowed: as was observed in New South Wales Dairy Corporation v Murray Goulburn Co-operative Co Ltd [1990] HCA 60; (1990) 171 CLR 363; 97 ALR 73; (1991) 18 IPR 385; 65 ALJR 104; [1991] AIPC 37-031 at [12] of Dawson and Toohey JJ’s judgment:The doctrine of honest concurrent user meant that a degree of confusion had to be tolerated within the system. The mere fact that the use of a mark would be likely to deceive or cause confusion was not necessarily sufficient to support an injunction restraining that use.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Subsection 55(1) provides:55Decision(1)Unless subsection (3) applies to the proceedings, the Registrar must, at the end, decide:(a)to refuse to register the trade mark; or(b)to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established.Note:For limitations see section 6. I refuse to register application 1452550 (the Opposed Word Trade Mark). Application 1452551 may proceed to registration one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar has been served with a notice of appeal before that time, I direct that registration of 1452551 shall not occur until the appeal has been decided or discontinued and that the disposition of the application be in accordance with the Court’s order or direction. It is appropriate in the light of my decision that (if there is no appeal against this decision) the endorsement be deleted from application 1452551 prior to it proceeding to registration.Costs Both parties have had some degree of success in these matters and I accordingly do not award costs.Iain Campbell ThompsonTrade Marks Hearings12 December 2014

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I note that some of the above materials do not show the form of the trade mark used by the Opponent in the advertisements to which Mr Kelly refers and one of the invoices (that from TMPC) is to ‘Combined Communications & Wireless Data Solutions’ – a person other than the Opponent. Further, the Opponent’s word trade mark does not appear in these materials although there is reference to ‘Combined Communications Pty Ltd’ within the body of the advertisements and reference to ‘Combined Communications’ as a business name rather than a trade mark at the base of the advertisements. I will further discuss this use as a business name under the heading ‘Rationale’. Mr Kelly continues:Over the years since first use of the COMBINED COMMUNICATIONS Word Mark and the COMBINED COMMUNICATIONS Logo, the Opponent has also distributed various brochures and leaflets throughout Australia which promote its communications goods and services. Behind Tab 12 of Exhibit MK-1 are copies of a selection of these brochures and related materials, namely:a. A brochure entitled “Taking Wi-Fi Where It’s Never Been Before”. It is my understanding, from the records of the Opponent, that this brochure was mailed by the Opponent to all schools in New South Wales in late 2010 or early 2011.b. A leaflet commencing “Combined Communications is focused on supplying and maintaining reliable, cost effective Wireless Communications Solutions”.c. A copy of a letter which was sent to resellers, existing customers and prospective customers in February 201 1, announcing the appointment of the Opponent as the exclusive Australian distributor for the CAB WATCH range of taxi security camera systems.d. Examples of emails which I sent to taxi companies in South Australia (namely, Yellow Corporation, Uptown Taxis Adelaide and Adelaide Independent Taxis), to which the above mentioned letter was attached.e. A leaflet announcing the appointment of the Opponent as the exclusive Australian distributor for the CAB WATCH range of products. It is my understanding, from the records of the Opponent, that this leaflet was designed in April 2011 and I am aware that the announcement was sent by email to state authorities which had approved the products for use, and to various cab companies soon afterwards.f. A leaflet advertising ‘Hytera’ and the Opponent as an authorised distributor for Hytera Communications Corporation Limited.g. An extract from a magazine entitled “Security Solutions” which featured an advertisement for ‘Hytera’ and for the Opponent as an authorised distributor for Hytera Communications Corporation Limited.h. A ‘Combined Communications’ leaflet from July 2010.i. Brochures promoting the Opponent’s COMBINED COMMUNICATIONS Logo and the ‘GME Commercial’ handheld radios and mobile radios, together with an email which shows that the brochures were designed in March 2010.j. An extract from the September/October 2011 ‘radio’ publication, containing a ‘Hytera DMR Series’ advertisement and a case study which featured the Opponent.k. A print-out from the website entitled “MSS Chooses Hytera DMI?’, which refers to a site radio coverage survey undertaken by the Opponent in 2011 in relation to radio communications services for a landmark building in Sydney, number 1 Bligh Street.The materials behind Tab 12 of Exhibit MK-1 constitute only a small sample of the advertising and promotional materials that the Opponent has distributed in Australia since 2004. The Opponent has been unable to locate a more comprehensive record of its advertising and promotional materials in the time available for filing the Evidence in Support due to its record keeping limitations.