Colosimo v Director of Public Prosecutions

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES SUPREME COURT

CITATION:    Colosimo and Ors v Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) [2005]  NSWSC 854

CURRENT JURISDICTION:           

FILE NUMBER(S):   12745/04

HEARING DATE{S):             25 July 2005

JUDGMENT DATE:               25/08/2005

PARTIES:
Julius Colosimo, Sergio Colosimo and Vincenzo Colosimo - Plaintiffs
Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) - Defendant

JUDGMENT OF:      Johnson J      

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:             Local Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):        ---

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:   Mr C Longley, Magistrate

COUNSEL:
Mr A J Bellanto QC and Mr D Pullinger (Plaintiffs)
Mr P I Lakatos (Defendant)

SOLICITORS:
Bradfield Anderson (Plaintiffs)
S C Kavanagh (Defendant)

CATCHWORDS:
CRIMINAL LAW - offence of affray under s.93C Crimes Act 1900 - elements of offence - proof of offence where several accused persons are charged and precise violent acts of each accused person cannot be identified clearly

ACTS CITED:
Crimes (Local Courts Appeal and Review) Act 2001
Crimes Act 1900
Summary Offences Act 1988
Public Order Act 1986 (UK)

DECISION:
1.  The appeal of each Plaintiff against conviction is dismissed
2.  The Plaintiffs' summons is dismissed.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISION
CIVIL LIST

Johnson J

25 August 2005

12745/2004  Julius Colosimo and Ors v Director of Public Prosections

JUDGMENT

  1. JOHNSON J: This is an appeal under s.52(1) Crimes (Local Courts Appeal and Review) Act 2001 (“Appeal and Review Act”) by the First Plaintiff, Julius Colosimo (“the First Plaintiff” or “Julius”), the Second Plaintiff, Sergio Colosimo (“the Second Plaintiff” or “Sergio”) and the Third Plaintiff, Vincenzo Colosimo (“the Third Plaintiff” or “Vincenzo”) arising from the conviction of the Plaintiffs by Mr C Longley, Magistrate, at the Downing Centre Local Court on 28 July 2004 upon charges of affray under s.93C Crimes Act 1900. 

  2. Following conviction, his Honour fined each of the Plaintiffs the sum of $1,500.00 with an order to pay court costs of $63.00.

    The Present Appeal

  3. The Plaintiffs have exercised a right of appeal to this Court upon grounds that are said to involve questions of law alone: s.52(1) Appeal and Review Act. The Plaintiffs rely upon a number of grounds of appeal, each of which is said to involve a question of law. In due course, it will be necessary to determine the appeals against conviction and to make orders under s.55(1) Appeal and Review Act. 

    History of Proceedings in the Local Court

  4. The incident which has given rise to this prosecution occurred in the Lagoon Bar within the Star City Casino in the early hours of 18 November 2002.  In April 2003, the Plaintiffs were charged with the following offences arising from the incident:

    First Plaintiff

    (a)maliciously inflict grievous bodily harm on Alan Bracamonte: s.35(1)(b) Crimes Act 1900;

    (b)assault occasioning actual bodily harm on Alan Bracamonte: s.59(1) Crimes Act 1900;

    (c)assault upon Jason Wood: s.61 Crimes Act 1900;

    (d)affray: s.93C Crimes Act 1900.

    Second Plaintiff

    (a)maliciously inflict grievous bodily harm on Alan Bracamonte: s.35(1)(b) Crimes Act 1900;

    (b)assault occasioning actual bodily harm on Kevin Bannister:…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Colosimo v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWSC 854
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Colosimo v Director of Public Prosecutions, the appellants, the defendants in the underlying proceedings, sought to appeal their convictions for the offence of affray under section 93C of the Crimes Act 1900. The dispute centred around the adequacy of evidence provided to support the convictions, particularly given the difficulty in attributing specific violent acts to each defendant. The case was heard in the Supreme Court, where the appellants argued that the Magistrate had erred in several respects, including in failing to consider the requisite mental elements for the offence and in adjudicating their cases collectively rather than individually.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Magistrate had erred in law by not explicitly referring to the requisite mental element for the offence as per section 93D(2) of the Act, and whether the Magistrate had erred by considering the appellants' cases as a whole rather than individually assessing the involvement of each appellant in the affray. Additionally, the court had to determine if the evidence was sufficient to support the convictions.

The court found that while the Magistrate did not explicitly refer to section 93D(2) in his judgment, it was open to infer from the evidence, including witness testimonies and the compilation video tape of the incident, that the appellants had the requisite mental element to be found guilty. The court held that the Magistrate's assessment of the appellants' involvement collectively was permissible under the circumstances, particularly as the evidence demonstrated their collective participation in the affray. The court concluded that no error of law had been demonstrated in the proceedings, and dismissed the appeal of each appellant against conviction.

In light of the court's findings, the appeal of each appellant was dismissed, and the summons was dismissed. The court refrained from making an order regarding costs pending further submissions from the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having regard to the oral evidence adduced in the Local Court and having viewed the compilation video tape of the incident, I am satisfied that evidence was adduced which was capable of supporting the finding made by the learned Magistrate. Accordingly, no error of law has been demonstrated in this respect.Conclusion I am not satisfied that the Plaintiffs have made good any of the grounds alleging error of law in the proceedings before the Local Court. In my view, it was open to the learned Magistrate to find each of the Plaintiffs guilty of the offence of affray contained in s.93C of the Act. I determine under s.55(1)(c) Appeal and Review Act that the appeal of each Plaintiff against conviction is dismissed. The Plaintiffs’ summons is dismissed. At the conclusion of the hearing, it was indicated that the parties would seek to make submissions concerning costs after I had published my reasons. In the ordinary course, costs would follow the event and the Plaintiffs would be ordered to pay the costs of the Defendant of the proceedings. However, I will refrain from making any order as to costs until the parties have had an opportunity to make submissions on that issue.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In my opinion, no error of law has been demonstrated in the manner alleged in Ground 1.Ground 2 – The Magistrate Erred in Law in Not Applying s.93D(2) Crimes Act 1900 to his Deliberations Mr Bellanto QC submits that the learned Magistrate made no reference to s.93D(2) in his judgment and thereby erred in law in failing to have regard to the requisite mental element for an offence under s.93C of the Act. Mr Bellanto QC next submitted, under this heading, that each of the Plaintiffs were not proved to have the requisite intent. Mr Lakatos submits that, whilst there was no specific reference to s.93D(2) in the learned Magistrate’s judgment, a finding was made that the Plaintiffs had “applied their minds to the situation”. This finding was made by his Honour following a submission on behalf of the Plaintiffs in the Local Court that the prosecution must show “that the accused applied their mind to something taking place and got involved with that mindset” (Transcript, 28 July 2004, T9.22). Although the learned Magistrate did not refer, in terms, to the elements contained in s.93D(2) of the Act, I am not satisfied that the learned Magistrate misdirected himself in law in this respect. The mental element in s.93D(2) is expressed in the alternative. The first alternative requires an “intent to use or threaten violence”. The second alternative requires an awareness that the person’s “conduct may be violent or threaten violence”. The second alternative involves a lesser mental element. His Honour used the language of the submission advanced on behalf of the Plaintiffs in rejecting that submission. Insofar as Mr Bellanto QC submits that each of the Plaintiffs were not proved to have had the requisite intent, I take this submission to mean that there was an error of law in that the evidence before the Local Court was not capable of supporting a finding of the requisite mental element. I accept the submission of Mr Lakatos, for the Defendant, that the mental state of the Plaintiffs may be inferred from their actions: Thomas v The Queen (1959-1960) 102 CLR 584 at 596; Vallance v The Queen (1961) 108 CLR 56 at 82. There was evidence before the learned Magistrate in the form of the oral evidence from witnesses and, in particular, the compilation video tape which demonstrated that the Plaintiffs acted in a manner which was capable of supporting an inference that each of them had the requisite mental element under s.93D(2) of the Act. The actions of the Plaintiffs as depicted on the video provided a strong foundation for such a conclusion. In my opinion, the Plaintiffs have not made good the error of law alleged in Ground 2.Ground 3 – The Magistrate Erred in Law in Adjudicating the Cases of the Plaintiffs Globally Rather than Each Case on its Merits Senior Counsel for the Plaintiffs submitted that, while the conduct of the Plaintiffs can be taken together, there is still a requirement that each individual said to be involved in the affray be found guilty according to his own involvement. It was submitted that the learned Magistrate did not take account of this suggested requirement and merely found that the Plaintiffs were involved and were therefore, as a group, guilty of the offence charged.