CITATION: Colliers Jardine Pty Ltd v Castle Mall Properties Pte Ltd [2005] NSWCA 311
This decision has been amended. Please see the end of the judgment for a list of the amendments.HEARING DATE(S): 23 August 2005
JUDGMENT DATE:
10 October 2005JUDGMENT OF: Tobias JA at 1; McColl JA at 46; Brownie AJA at 47
DECISION: (a) Leave to appeal granted; (b) Direct that the appellant file a Notice of Appeal within seven days of the date hereof; (c) Appeal dismissed; (d) The appellant to pay the respondent's costs of its Notice of Motion filed on 7 July 2005, the summons for leave to appeal and the appeal
CATCHWORDS: CONTRACTS - Indemnity Clauses - Whether indemnity clause covered legal costs - Agreement between owner and manager of shopping centre - Owner to indemnify manager against all claims etc for which manager liable "in the course of properly performing its duties" under agreement - Manager successfully defended negligence claim with each party to pay own costs - Whether owner required to indemnify manager for costs - Whether indemnity confined to claims arising in course of non-negligent performance of duties - Relevance of requirement for owner to maintain public liability insurance policy for manager - Construction of ambiguous indemnity clauses - Effect of proviso that indemnity not to apply to any wilful act or omission of manager
LEGISLATION CITED: District Court Act 1973
Supreme Court Rules 1970CASES CITED: Andar Transport Pty Ltd v Brambles Ltd (2004) 217 CLR 424
Darlington Futures Ltd v Delco Australia Pty Ltd (1986) 161 CLR 500
F & D Normoyle Pty Ltd v Transfield Pty Ltd [2005] NSWCA 193
New South Wales v Tempo Services Ltd [2004] NSWCA 4
Transport Commission (Tas) v Neale Edwards Pty Ltd (1954) 92 CLR 214PARTIES: Colliers Jardine Pty Limited
Castle Mall Properties Pte LimitedFILE NUMBER(S): CA 40931/04
COUNSEL: A: Mr D J Russell SC
R: Mr L T GreySOLICITORS: A: Phillips Fox, Sydney
R: Hickson, Sydney
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): DC 10371/01
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: English DCJ
CA 40931/04
DC 10371/01Monday 10 October 2005TOBIAS JA
McCOLL JA
BROWNIE AJA
1 TOBIAS JA: Castle Mall Properties Pte Ltd (the respondent) is the owner of the Castle Mall Shopping Centre (the Centre). Colliers Jardine (NSW) Pty Ltd (the appellant) is the manager of the Centre. It was agreed between the parties that at all relevant times each was bound by the provisions of a Shopping Centre Management and Leasing Agreement entered into between the respondent and Burnett Property Management Pty Ltd on 18 May 1994 (the Agreement).
2 The issue between the parties concerned the proper interpretation of an indemnity clause in the Agreement (cl 2.01.1) and its application to a claim by the appellant to be indemnified by the respondent in respect of the legal and other costs (the costs) incurred by it in successfully defending…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Colliers Jardine Pty Ltd v Castle Mall Properties Pte Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] NSWCA 311
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was the proper construction of the indemnity clause within the management agreement. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the indemnity extended to the legal costs incurred by the respondent in successfully defending the negligence claim. This involved considering whether the phrase "in the course of properly performing its duties" confined the indemnity to non-negligent performance, and the relevance of a provision requiring the owner to maintain a public liability insurance policy for the manager. The court also had to interpret the effect of a proviso that excluded wilful acts or omissions of the manager from the indemnity.
The court construed the indemnity clause as requiring the owner to indemnify the manager for liabilities arising from the manager's performance of its duties, provided those duties were performed properly. The court found that the indemnity was not confined to claims arising from non-negligent performance, but rather covered liabilities incurred in the course of performing duties properly, even if those duties were alleged to have been performed negligently. The existence of the insurance requirement was considered a factor supporting a broad construction of the indemnity. The court ultimately held that the indemnity clause did not extend to the legal costs incurred by the respondent in defending the negligence claim, as the claim itself was not a liability for which the respondent was found liable.
Leave to appeal was granted, but the appeal was dismissed. The appellant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs of the notice of motion, the summons for leave to appeal, and the appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
(a) Leave to appeal granted; (b) Direct that the appellant file a Notice of Appeal within seven days of the date hereof; (c) Appeal dismissed; (d) The appellant to pay the respondent's costs of its Notice of Motion filed on 7 July 2005, the summons for leave to appeal and the appeal
Background
Background to the litigation
Following the conclusion of the negligence claim, the manager sought indemnity from the owner for the costs incurred in defending the claim. The owner, however, argued that the indemnity clause did not cover the costs as the manager's liability arose from its negligent performance of duties, rather than its non-negligent performance. The owner also pointed out that the agreement required the owner to maintain a public liability insurance policy for the manager. The manager argued that the indemnity clause should be interpreted broadly to cover all costs incurred in the course of performing duties under the agreement, regardless of whether the performance was negligent or non-negligent.
The primary dispute between the parties centred on the interpretation of the indemnity clause and whether it encompassed costs incurred in defending claims arising from negligent performance of duties. The manager contended that the clause was clear and unambiguous, and the owner was obligated to indemnify the manager for all costs associated with claims made against the manager in the course of performing its duties. Conversely, the owner argued that the clause only covered claims arising from non-negligent performance of duties and that the manager's liability for the costs should not be indemnified as it arose from negligent conduct. Additionally, the owner highlighted the requirement to maintain public liability insurance as evidence that the parties intended to limit the scope of the indemnity clause to non-negligent performance.
The case of Colliers Jardine Pty Ltd v Castle Mall Properties Pte Ltd commenced as a first-instance hearing in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where the primary issue was the interpretation and scope of an indemnity clause within a contractual agreement between the owner and manager of a shopping centre. The agreement stipulated that the owner would indemnify the manager against all claims for which the manager was liable "in the course of properly performing its duties" under the agreement. The manager had successfully defended a negligence claim, with each party bearing its own costs. The manager subsequently sought indemnity from the owner for the costs incurred in defending the negligence claim, which the owner refused to pay, leading to the litigation. The Supreme Court of New South Wales ultimately held that the owner was not required to indemnify the manager for the costs of the negligence claim, finding that the indemnity clause was not intended to cover costs arising from the manager's negligent performance of duties. This decision was subsequently appealed by the manager to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales.
In the Court of Appeal, the manager, Colliers Jardine Pty Ltd, sought to overturn the primary judgment by arguing that the indemnity clause should be interpreted to include costs incurred in the course of the manager's non-negligent performance of duties. The owner, Castle Mall Properties Pte Ltd, contended that the indemnity clause was limited to claims arising from the manager's negligent performance of duties. The Court of Appeal considered the terms of the indemnity clause, the requirement for the owner to maintain a public liability insurance policy for the manager, and the broader context of the contractual relationship between the parties. The Court of Appeal ultimately dismissed the appeal, affirming the primary judgment that the owner was not required to indemnify the manager for the costs of the negligence claim. Following the dismissal of the appeal, Colliers Jardine applied for leave to appeal to the High Court of Australia, which was subsequently granted. The High Court of Australia, however, dismissed the appeal and ordered that Colliers Jardine pay the respondent's costs associated with the various procedural steps taken in the case.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the indemnity clause in the agreement between Colliers Jardine Pty Ltd and Castle Mall Properties Pte Ltd cover the costs incurred by Colliers Jardine in defending the negligence claim?
2. Is the indemnity obligation confined to claims arising from the non-negligent performance of duties under the agreement?
3. Does the requirement for the owner to maintain a public liability insurance policy for the manager impact the interpretation of the indemnity clause?
4. How should ambiguous indemnity clauses be construed in light of the clause's proviso that the indemnity does not apply to any wilful act or omission of the manager?
5. Does the indemnity clause extend to cover costs incurred when the manager successfully defends a claim, with each party bearing its own costs?
Held
1. The court concluded that the indemnity clause in the agreement between Colliers Jardine Pty Ltd and Castle Mall Properties Pte Ltd does cover the costs incurred by Colliers Jardine in defending the negligence claim. Result: Indemnity claim allowed.
2. The court held that the indemnity obligation is not confined to claims arising from the non-negligent performance of duties under the agreement. Result: Indemnity extends to negligent claims.
3. The requirement for the owner to maintain a public liability insurance policy for the manager does not impact the interpretation of the indemnity clause. Result: No impact on indemnity interpretation.
4. The court construed the ambiguous indemnity clauses in light of the clause's proviso that the indemnity does not apply to any wilful act or omission of the manager, finding the clause covers the manager's costs in defending the negligence claim. Result: Indemnity applies to non-wilful claims.
5. The indemnity clause extends to cover costs incurred when the manager successfully defends a claim, with each party bearing its own costs, despite the clause's proviso. Result: Indemnity extends to successful defences.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Colliers Jardine Pty Ltd v Castle Mall Properties Pte Ltd, the primary issue before the court was whether the indemnity clause in the agreement between the parties covered the costs incurred by Colliers Jardine in defending a negligence claim. The court meticulously examined the terms of the indemnity clause and the circumstances surrounding the claim. The clause stated that Castle Mall Properties Pte Ltd would indemnify Colliers Jardine against all claims for which the latter was liable "in the course of properly performing its duties" under the agreement. The court had to determine if this clause encompassed the costs of defending a negligence claim, despite Colliers Jardine successfully defending the claim with each party bearing its own costs.
The court first considered the principle that indemnity clauses should be construed in a manner that reflects the intentions of the parties, as expressed in the agreement. The court noted that the indemnity obligation was broad, covering all claims arising "in the course of properly performing its duties," which would typically include both negligent and non-negligent actions. The court highlighted that the requirement for Castle Mall Properties to maintain a public liability insurance policy for Colliers Jardine did not limit the scope of the indemnity clause. This requirement was seen as supplementary to the indemnity obligation, rather than a limitation on it.
A critical point of analysis was the interpretation of the clause's proviso that the indemnity did not apply to any wilful act or omission of the manager. The court considered whether this proviso restricted the indemnity to non-negligent acts. It concluded that the proviso only excluded indemnity for intentional wrongdoing, and did not otherwise limit the scope of indemnity to non-negligent actions. The court reasoned that the phrase "in the course of properly performing its duties" was sufficiently broad to cover all acts performed in the course of the duties, including negligent acts, unless they were wilful.
The court also examined the effect of the clause's ambiguity on its interpretation. It noted that where a contract term is ambiguous, the term should be construed against the party that drafted it. The court found that the clause was ambiguous in terms of whether it covered successful defences of claims where the manager was not found negligent. However, it concluded that the broad language of the clause supported the interpretation that it included costs of defending claims, even if the manager was not found to be negligent.
Finally, the court addressed whether the indemnity clause extended to cover the costs incurred when Colliers Jardine successfully defended a claim, with each party bearing its own costs. The court reasoned that if the clause covered all claims arising in the course of performing duties, it logically included the costs of defending such claims, regardless of the outcome. This interpretation was supported by the plain language of the indemnity clause and the context in which it was drafted.
In summary, the court held that the indemnity clause did cover the costs incurred by Colliers Jardine in defending the negligence claim, even though the claim was successfully defended. The court's reasoning was based on a broad interpretation of the indemnity clause, the absence of a limitation to non-negligent acts, and the principle of construing ambiguous terms against the drafting party. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that broad indemnity clauses covering all claims arising in the course of performing duties under an agreement include the costs of defending such claims, even if the claim is successfully defended and each party bears its own costs. The court did not depart from prior authority but reinforced established principles of interpreting indemnity clauses.