Collector of Customs v Wallace Laboratories Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Collector of Customs v Wallace Laboratories Pty Ltd [2002] FCA 659

CUSTOMS & EXCISE – admissibility of evidence – form of pleadings.

Excise Act 1901 (Cth)

Avon Downs Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1949) 78 CLR 353 cited
Collector of Customs (Vict.) v Wilh Wilhelmsen Agency Pty Ltd (1956) 102 CLR 147 applied
Collector of Customs (NSW) v Southern Shipping (1962) 107 CLR 279 applied
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Bayley (1952) 86 CLR 507 cited
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Brian Hatch Timber Co (Sales) Pty Ltd (1972) 128 CLR 29 cited
MIMA v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 2 cited
Sidebottom v Giuliano (2000) 98 FCR 579 cited

Macquarie Dictionary

COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS V WALLACE LABORATORIES PTY LIMITED

NO. N 320 OF 2001

BEAUMONT J
30 MAY 2002
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 320 OF 2001

BETWEEN:

COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS
APPLICANT

AND:

WALLACE LABORATORIES PTY LIMITED
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

BEAUMONT J

DATE OF ORDER:

30  MAY 2002

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The proceedings be stood over to a directions hearing at a date to be fixed.

2.Costs to date reserved.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 320 OF 2001

BETWEEN:

COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS
APPLICANT

AND:

WALLACE LABORATORIES PTY LIMITED
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

BEAUMONT J

DATE:

30 MAY 2002

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR INTERLOCUTORY JUDGMENT
(ON OBJECTION TO ADMISSION INTO EVIDENCE OF AFFIDAVIT OF G. B. SHEWAN SWORN 30 NOVEMBER 2001 (“MFI 6”))

BEAUMONT J:

INTRODUCTION

  1. By his Further Amended Statement of Claim, dated 25 March 2002, the applicant, the Collector of Customs (“the Collector”), sued the respondent, Wallace Laboratories Pty Limited (“Wallace”), on two causes of action under s 60 of the Excise Act 1901 (Cth) (“the Act”). During the course of the final hearing of the proceeding, Wallace sought to read Mr Shewan’s affidavit. The Collector has objected, on relevance, to its reception into evidence. The Collector has further submitted, in the alternative, that, relevance apart, the evidence was also bad in form. At this stage, I have heard argument, and reserved, on the relevance point, one of law, only.

  2. In order to understand the nature of the Collector’s objection, it will be necessary to explain the relevant legislative scheme, and the issues disclosed by the pleadings.

    THE LEGISLATIVE SCHEME

  3. The material provisions of s 60 are as follows:

    ·Where a person who has, or has been entrusted with, the possession, custody or control of excisable goods which are subject to the control of the Customs (a) fails to keep those goods safely;  or (b) when so requested by a Collector, does not account for those goods to the Collector’s satisfaction, the person shall, on demand in writing made by a Collector, pay to the Commonwealth an amount equal to the amount of the Excise duty which would…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Collector of Customs v Wallace Laboratories Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCA 659
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between the Collector of Customs and Wallace Laboratories Pty Ltd involved the Collector's claim that Wallace Laboratories failed to account for a specific quantity of alcohol, leading to a legal dispute over the adequacy of Wallace's response to a request for an account. The court was tasked with determining the validity of Wallace's defence and the admissibility of certain evidence provided by Wallace's Production Manager, Mr Shewan.

The key legal issues revolved around the sufficiency of Wallace's defence in addressing the Collector's claim and the relevance and admissibility of Mr Shewan's affidavit. The court examined whether Wallace's defence properly challenged the Collector's assertion of non-satisfaction with the account provided, and if it failed to do so, whether it could still be considered a valid defence. Additionally, the court had to determine if Mr Shewan's affidavit provided any logical evidence that could address the Collector's satisfaction with the account given.

The court found that Wallace's defence did not adequately address the core issue of the Collector's non-satisfaction with the account, and thus, it was not a proper defence. Furthermore, the court ruled that Mr Shewan's affidavit did not provide any logical evidence that could satisfy the Collector's reasonable satisfaction with the account, as it did not address the storage or usage of the alcohol in question. Consequently, the court determined that the affidavit was not admissible.

The court ordered that the proceedings be stood over to a directions hearing to address the validity of the pleadings and other procedural matters. The costs incurred up to that point were reserved for further determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceedings be stood over to a directions hearing at a date to be fixed.

2. Costs to date reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In his affidavit (“MFI 6”) Mr Shewan says:“1.I am the Production Manager of Wallace Laboratories Pty Limited (the Respondent).2.At approximately 6.15am on 22 September 1998, a number of people whom I now know to be Australian Customs Service (ACS) Officers arrived at my home at 9 Brixham Place Chipping Norton where they conducted a search after presenting a search warrant.3.At approximately 7.15am that day, I arrived at the Respondent’s premises at 26 Barry Road Chipping Norton. About 20 ACS Officers were present. They possessed search warrants for some of the units occupied by the Respondent at the time. These were units 1, 2, 4, 5, 8, 10, 14, 15. They did not possess search warrants for units 9 and 11.4.Before entering and searching each unit for which they had a search warrant, an ACS Officer would read my rights to me and present the search warrant to me.5.During a conversation with the ACS Officer whom I now know to be Mr Phil Chapman, he said words to the following effect: ‘If need be I can get a warrant for unit 9 from the city in an hour’.6.Upon inquiry by an ACS Officer, I indicated to that Officer that units 9 and 11 were used for storage. I also indicated to Mr Phil Chapman that we would not deny access to unit 9 despite the lack of a warrant. To the best of my knowledge and belief no ACS Officers searched units 9 and 11 on that or any subsequent day, nor was any search warrant ever presented to me relating to units 9 and 11.7.At no time did Mr Chapman or any other ACS Officer who attended advise me, or any other officer of the Respondent to my knowledge, the purpose of the search warrants and in particular no reference was made by any ACS Officer of any intention to audit the quantity of alcohol stored, manufactured and sold by the Respondent.8.To my knowledge there was a substantial quantity of stock stored in units 9 and 11. I have perused and considered the affidavit of Trevor James Coulter sworn on 30 July 2001 and the annexures thereto and say that to the best of my knowledge and belief the stocktake carried out by ACS Officer McIntosh which is referred to in paragraph 8 in annexure TJC2 of that affidavit did not take into account the stock stored in units 9 and 11 as referred to above.9.As production manager, I observe products spilling and or overflowing while the bottle filling process is in operation.10.During the course of setting up a production run I flush the machines with alcohol based product resulting in the waste of that product.11.In respect of all bottled liquid produced and manufactured by the Respondent, including all bottled products that contain alcohol, the bottles are consistently filled to a level of at least 10 ml over and above the stated capacity of the bottle shown on the label. Thus, our 80 ml bottles contain 90 ml of liquid, our 750 ml bottles contain 760 ml of liquid etc. The purpose of doing so is twofold:-(a)experience has shown customers are more likely to buy a bottle filled to the bottom level of the cap;(b)this practice avoids any possibility of contravening State Government weights and measures regulations in respect of the minimum volume of standard size bottles.12.After each batch of products, I advise Cirila Wray the amount of alcohol used.13.To my knowledge no alcohol purchased by the Respondent from CSR Limited or Bundaberg Distilling Company Pty Limited was ever used for any purpose other than the manufacture of products to which the concessional excise rate which was paid applied.14.To the best of my knowledge and belief, if a stocktake had been undertaken of all stock, including the stock which was stored in units 9 and 11, there would have been no material discrepancy in the total volume of alcohol which should have been on the company’s premises.”WALLACE’S BASIS FOR THE TENDER OF MR SHEWAN’S EVIDENCE

Decision

Reasons for decision

BEAUMONT J
It is further submitted for the Collector that nothing in Mr Shewan’s affidavit is logically probative on the issue whether the Collector, acting reasonably, ought to have been satisfied with any account given by Wallace in answer to the request to account. In particular, there is no suggestion in Mr Shewan’s affidavit that, at any time before swearing it, he sought to explain to Customs that any of the alcohol the subject of the request for account was stored in either unit 9 or unit 11. Nor did Mr Shewan suggest, at any time before swearing his affidavit, that the use of the alcohol could be explained by reference to the amount of liquid in bottles manufactured by Wallace.REASONING ON INTERLOCUTORY JUDGMENT This proceeding has already had its adjectival complexities. Without attempting to describe all of the dynamics of the litigation, it should be noticed that the pleadings have, of necessity, been amended several times. Some important amendments have been made during the course of the final hearing itself. Given the nature of the litigation, it is especially important that the pleadings not only accord with the substantive requirements (specifically, not be demurrable), but also be sound process-wise (specifically, provide transparent particulars). As has been said, any consideration of relevant material must be based upon the scope of the issues disclosed by the pleadings. For this reason, and in the exercise of the Court’s management powers in any event, before addressing the Collectors’ particular objections to Mr Shewan’s affidavit, I propose next to examine the pleadings of both parties for the purposes of testing their validity, as pleadings, both substantively and process-wise.The Collector’s statement of his claims In my view, as a pleading in chief, no objection could be (or is) taken to the Collector’s Further Amended Statement of Claim filed in Court on 25 March 2002. The pleading follows the language of the statute in both a logical and chronological fashion. The averments of fact made are, as has been noted, legitimised by s 60(3) and are, in any event, admitted. Adequate particulars of each of the requisite statutory ingredients are provided.Wallace’s amended defence As has been seen, several kinds of substantive defence are sought to be raised as follows.Par 5(i) First, in answer to the claim in par 11 of the Further Amended Statement of Claim, that Wallace “did not account for the 9,801.16 litres of alcohol to the satisfaction of a Collector”, Wallace pleads (par 5(i)) a denial of the Collector’s claim that it failed to account “therefor” (presumably a reference to the 9,801.16 litres of alcohol). In my opinion, this statement of a defence does not squarely address the thrust of a principal feature of the claim made in par 11. Specifically, it does not, or at least does not properly, address the critical element of the Collector’s satisfaction. If, by this defence, Wallace seeks to collaterally challenge the Collector’s decision (effectively of “non-satisfaction”), the defence should state the specific basis to justify that type of challenge, assuming for the moment that it is open here. If no collateral challenge on legal grounds is being made, the statement of defence should have addressed the factual element of the Collector’s “non-satisfaction”, if this is intended to be disputed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BEAUMONT J