Collector of Customs v Wallace Laboratories Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Collector of Customs v Wallace Laboratories Pty Ltd [2002] FCA 1341

CUSTOMS & EXCISE –whether the respondent failed to “account” to the satisfaction of a Collector under Excise Act 1901 (Cth) s 60 – scope of judicial review – procedural aspects.

Excise Act 1901 (Cth) ss 60; 162C(1)(e)

Avon Downs Pty Limited v The Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1949) 78 CLR 353 applied

Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355 cited

COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS V WALLACE LABORATORIES PTY LIMITED

NO. N 320 OF 2001

BEAUMONT J

31 OCTOBER 2002
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 320 OF 2001

BETWEEN:

COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS
APPLICANT

AND:

WALLACE LABORATORIES PTY LIMITED
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

BEAUMONT J

DATE OF ORDER:

31 OCTOBER 2002

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The matter be stood over for further argument at a date to be fixed.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 320 OF 2001

BETWEEN:

COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS
APPLICANT

AND:

WALLACE LABORATORIES PTY LIMITED
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

BEAUMONT J

DATE:

31 OCTOBER 2002

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR INTERLOCUTORY JUDGMENT
(ON ISSUES TENDERED BY PARAGRAPH 3 OF THE AMENDED DEFENCE DATED 6 AUGUST 2002)

BEAUMONT J:

INTRODUCTION

  1. These reasons should be read in conjunction with my reasons dated 30 May 2002, and those dated 21 and 22 October 2002 (see [2002] FCA 659; [2002] FCA 1339 and [2002] FCA 1340).

  2. The parties have now addressed the issues of fact and law tendered by par 3 of the defence as follows:

    “3.In respect of paragraph 11 of the Applicant’s Further Amended Statement of Claim:

    (i)        The Respondent says as follows:

    (a)The quantity of 9,801.16 litres of alcohol referred to in paragraphs 10 and 11 in the Applicant’s Further Amended Statement of Claim was said to be a purported shortfall in the recorded use of the 21,600 litres of spirit supplied to the Respondent and referred to in paragraphs 6 and 7 and the 8,800 litres of spirit supplied to the Respondent and referred to in paragraph 6A and 7A of the Applicant’s Further Amended Statement Of Claim;

    (b)The purported shortfall was allegedly arrived at by Compliance Officers from Customs, being servants of the Applicant, who conducted an audit of the records kept by the Respondent on 22 September 1998;

    (c)The Respondent by letter dated 29 October 1998 denied any shortfall and, through its solicitors, made several requests for the Applicant to supply particulars of the audit so that the cause of the discrepancy could be ascertained.

    (d)In associated proceedings brought by a servant of the Applicant in the Local Court against the Respondent for the retention of certain goods and business records seized by Customs officers during the aforesaid audit, the said servant of the Applicant undertook to the Respondent to supply the particulars…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Collector of Customs v Wallace Laboratories Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCA 1341
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Collector of Customs v Wallace Laboratories Pty Ltd was a case in the Federal Court of Australia where the Collector of Customs sought to recover excise duty from Wallace Laboratories Pty Ltd, claiming that the company had failed to account for a shortfall in the usage of concessional spirit. The dispute centered on two separate shortages of concessional spirit identified by Customs through audits of Wallace's records. For the first shortage of 9,801.16 litres of alcohol, Customs demanded excise duty and, after a correction, settled on a demand of $364,701.16. For a subsequent shortage of 835 litres of alcohol, Customs initially demanded $45,557.60 in excise duty, later corrected to $43,279.70.

The primary legal issues before the court involved whether the Collector of Customs was entitled to demand excise duty from Wallace Laboratories Pty Ltd based on the alleged shortfalls in concessional spirit. The court had to determine whether the Collector's demand for excise duty was reasonable and whether there were procedural errors in the process that would render the Collector's decision unlawful. Wallace Laboratories Pty Ltd argued that the Collector had failed to provide adequate particulars of the audit and that the demand for duty was unreasonable due to procedural deficiencies.

In delivering the judgment, the court found that the Collector's decision to demand excise duty was not unreasonable. The court held that the Collector's reasoning process was within the limits of judicial review, and there was no basis to infer that the Collector had failed in the discharge of his exact function according to law. The court emphasized that the Collector was entitled to rely on the results of the audit to conclude that Wallace Laboratories Pty Ltd had not satisfactorily accounted for the shortfall in concessional spirit. The court also dismissed Wallace Laboratories Pty Ltd's arguments regarding procedural flaws, finding that these issues were extrinsic to the substantive question of whether the account provided by Wallace was satisfactory.

The court ordered that the matter be stood over for further argument at a date to be fixed, indicating that additional submissions were needed before a final decision could be made.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The matter be stood over for further argument at a date to be fixed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Although, as noted on 30 May 2002, the relevant formal averments were not disputed on the pleadings, and although Wallace Laboratories Pty Ltd (“Wallace”), in its own case, tendered all of the correspondence between the parties, in this connection, the Collector of Customs (“the Collector”) relies, by way of background, upon affidavit evidence by Alan Michael Burke, Taxation Officer (Compliance Team Manager, Excise Business Line, assigned to the Australian Taxation Office), to the following effect:(1) First cause of action·By permit issued in January 1996, Wallace was given approval by the Australian Customs Service (“Customs”) to take delivery from CSR Ltd of concessional spirit in specified quantities.·By another permit issued in January 1996, Wallace was given approval by Customs to take delivery from Bundaberg Distilling Co Pty Ltd of concessional spirit in specified quantities.·By letter to Wallace dated 24 November 1998, Customs wrote about “the need for [Wallace] to account for the usage of the concessional spirit supplied to it”, and referred to Customs’ audit of records taken from Wallace on 22 September 1998 as follows:“The records were for bulk spirit and packaged products. The audit looked at the opening stocks on hand, receipts, transfers in, transfers out, production usage and stated strengths, cleaning loss, sales and closing stocks and covered the period from 6 March, 1996, to 22 September, 1998, inclusive. The result of the audit showed a shortfall in the recorded use of concessional spirit by the company. It amounts to an apparent discrepancy, overall, of 9,801.16 litres of alcohol, using the stated strengths in the company records.”(The correspondence mentioned in Mr Burke’s affidavit was also later tendered by Wallace and became Exhibit “2”.)The letter requested Wallace “to account for the 9,801.16 litres of alcohol, which appear to be unaccounted for in your records, by 7 December, 1998”.·By letter to Wallace dated 21 December 1998, Customs referred to “the shortage of 9,801.16 litres of alcohol established following [the] audit ... ,” and stated:“Since no correspondence has been received to explain the shortages ... , I [on behalf of the Regional Director] consider any explanation to be unsatisfactory.”Having cited the provisions of s 60 of the Excise Ac t 1901 (Cth) (“the Act”), the letter stated:“Therefore in accordance with the provisions of Section 60(1) of the Excise Act 1901, I demanded payment of $374,404.31 being an amount equal to the Excise Duty payable on the unaccounted for goods if they had been entered for home consumption on this date.An explanation of how the amount was calculated is attached.”The letter concluded by mentioning that application may be made to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for review of the decision.·By letter to Wallace dated 24 August 2000, Customs stated that it had been recognised that an incorrect Excise Tariff Item (ETI) has been used in calculating the amount demanded in the Custom’s letter dated 21 December 1998, and that demand was revoked, but an enclosed demand for $364,701.16 substituted, applying a different Item. The enclosed demand, also dated 24 August 2000, referred to “the shortage of 9.801.16 litres of alcohol established following an audit of records taken by Customs ... on 22nd September 1998”, and stating that “no satisfactory explanation has been provided to account for the shortages on 24th November 1998”.(2) Second cause of action·By letter to Wallace dated 24 August 2000, Customs referred to “an audit conducted of [Wallace’s] use of concessional spirit for the period 22 September 1998 to 16 June 1999”, stating that Wallace’s “bond records were [discovered to be] incomplete ...”; and that “a reconciliation of receipts, production and sales was [then] conducted”; and that several production runs totalling the use of 835 litres of alcohol “cannot be accounted for by sales ...”. Wallace was requested to account for the 835 litres.·By letter to Wallace dated 6 March 2001, Customs referred to “the shortage of 835 litres of alcohol established following an audit of records taken by Customs ... in June 1998”, and demanded the payment of duty in the amount of $45,557.60.·By letter to Wallace dated 7 August 2001, Customs, recognising an error in the amount of alcohol, revoked this demand, and made a fresh demand for $43,279.70.(B) Evidence relied on by Wallace

Decision

Reasons for decision

(Mr and Mrs Wray are officers of Wallace.)CONCLUSIONS ON THE ISSUES TENDERED BY PARAGRAPH 3 It will be convenient to group these issues into several sections and consider them in turn.(1) Paragraphs 3(i) and (ii) As has been seen, par 3(i) proceeds to allege, in essence, a number of matters, namely –o3(i) (a) and (b) – The “purported shortfall” was arrived at by Customs after an audit on 22 September 1998.o3(i)(c) – Wallace’s solicitors’ letter dated 29 October 1998 denied any shortfall and requested audit particulars.o3(i)(d) and (e) – Customs undertook to supply audit particulars, but, despite requests, they were not supplied.o3(i)(f) – Customs did not return the bulk of Wallace’s records seized on 22 September 1998 until after the statutory demand (dated 21 December 1998). It is then pleaded (par 3(ii)) that it was not open to the Collector, acting reasonably, to conclude that Wallace had failed to account to his satisfaction. As has been mentioned in my earlier reasons and, in particular by my adoption here of the classic observations of Dixon J in Avon Downs Pty Limited v The Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1949) 78 CLR 353 (at 360), although the Collector’s decision is not unexaminable, there are well established limits to the scope of judicial review in this kind of statutory context. It will be recalled that one ground for review is, as Dixon J expressed it (at 360):“If the result appears to be unreasonable on the supposition that he addressed himself to the right question, correctly applied the rules of law and took into account all the relevant considerations and no irrelevant considerations, then it may be a proper inference that it is a false supposition. It is not necessary that you should be sure of the precise particular in which he has gone wrong. It is enough that you can see that in some way he must have failed in the discharge of his exact function according to law.” It will be noted that Dixon J is here describing a particular kind of flaw, in principle, in the process of reasoning itself, rather than a procedural defect. (Such a defect is, indeed, relied upon in par 3(iii), to be considered below.) Yet the matters pleaded in pars 3(i)(a) – (f) are not only procedural in character, they are extrinsic to the process of reasoning of the Collector on the material question, viz. whether Wallace’s “account” was satisfactory. Indeed, the matters pleaded in pars 3(i)(a) – (f) focus upon the conduct of Customs. They do not purport to address the substantive question for the Collector mentioned. In my opinion, it cannot be said of the Collector’s decision, that, viewed in terms of its result, or otherwise, it was “unreasonable”. Nor, in my view, is there any basis here for drawing an inference of the false supposition of the kind described by Dixon J. On the contrary, pars 3(i) and (ii) proceed upon the impermissible assumption that the legislation requires that the Collector, rather than Wallace, was obliged to account for his actions.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established