CMG Homes Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

CMG Homes Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2019] QCAT 294

PARTIES:

CMG HOMES PTY LTD
(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR 171-18

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

30 September 2019

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Susan Burke

ORDERS:

1.   The Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs of and incidental to the proceedings from 28 May 2018 to 11 September 2018 on a standard basis on the District Court Scale as agreed, or failing agreement as assessed.

2.   The Respondent pay the Applicant’s reasonable costs on an indemnity basis of conducting the proceedings from 11 September 2018 as agreed, or failing agreement as assessed.

3.   The Applicant’s costs will be assessed as follows:

(a)   the Applicant will deliver to the Respondent an itemised claim for costs referring to the relevant items contained in the scale; and

(b)   if within 14 days of that delivery, the parties have not agreed to an amount for costs, the costs shall be assessed by Mr Jeff Peterson of Legal Costs Qld;

(c)    the Respondent will pay the Applicant’s costs (as agreed or assessed) within fourteen (14) days of such agreement or assessment by Mr Peterson of Legal Costs Qld.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – general administrative review – direction to rectify – any relevant change of circumstances between two directions to rectify

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS –  OFFERS OF COMPROMISE, PAYMENTS INTO COURT AND SETTLEMENTS – OTHER MATTERS – building dispute – exercise of discretion to award costs to be exercised judicially – open offer to settle – whether rejection of offer unreasonable – whether result more favourable – right to costs on indemnity basis

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 77
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 100, s 102, s 103, s 105
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2009 (Qld), r 86

Ascot v Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia [2010] QCAT 364
Fenwick v Queensland Building Services Authority [2011] QCAT 262
Fick v Groves (No 2) [2010] QSC 182
Fuge v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2014] QCAT 383
Hazeldene's Chicken Farm Pty Ltd v Victorian WorkCover Authority (No 2) (2005) 13 VR 435
Peat v Payne [2006] QCCTB 127
State of Queensland v Hayes (No 2) [2013] QSC 80
Ralacom Pty Ltd v Body Corporate for Paradise Island Apartments (No2) [2010] QCAT 412

REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Crouch & Lyndon Solicitors

Respondent:

S Tabaiwalu, in-house solicitor for the Queensland Building and Construction Commission

APPEARANCES:

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld).

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Reasons for the Decision in this matter were delivered on 28 June 2019.

  2. The tribunal ordered that direction to rectify no 0103352 dated 1 May 2019 (‘the second DTR’)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CMG Homes Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Com... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCAT 294
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

CMG Homes Pty Ltd sought review of a decision of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC) in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The dispute centred on the QBCC’s issuance of a second direction to rectify (DTR) in relation to alleged defects in a property constructed by CMG. The homeowners had previously complained about the works, leading to a first DTR in 2012. After the QBCC decided not to issue a DTR regarding some issues in 2013, the homeowners made a second complaint in 2018. The QBCC subsequently issued a second DTR, which CMG challenged in QCAT.

The key legal issues before the tribunal were whether the QBCC’s decision to issue the second DTR was legally sound and, relatedly, whether the tribunal should award costs to CMG based on the QBCC’s rejection of an open offer to settle the proceedings. The tribunal needed to assess the merits of the QBCC’s decision and consider the appropriateness of the costs awarded to CMG.

The tribunal found that the QBCC’s decision to issue the second DTR was flawed because there had not been a relevant change of circumstances between the two DTRs. The tribunal also held that the QBCC’s rejection of CMG’s open offer to settle was unreasonable and led to a more favourable result for CMG. Therefore, CMG was entitled to costs on an indemnity basis from 11 September 2018. The tribunal outlined a process for assessing and recovering these costs, including an opportunity for the parties to agree on an amount and, if necessary, for assessment by a costs assessor.

The final orders required the QBCC to pay CMG’s costs from 28 May 2018 to 11 September 2018 on a standard basis and from 11 September 2018 on an indemnity basis. The costs were to be assessed according to a specific process outlined in the orders, ensuring that CMG could recover its legal expenses from the QBCC.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs of and incidental to the proceedings from 28 May 2018 to 11 September 2018 on a standard basis on the District Court Scale as agreed, or failing agreement as assessed.

2. The Respondent pay the Applicant’s reasonable costs on an indemnity basis of conducting the proceedings from 11 September 2018 as agreed, or failing agreement as assessed.

3. The Applicant’s costs will be assessed as follows:

(a) the Applicant will deliver to the Respondent an itemised claim for costs referring to the relevant items contained in the scale; and

(b) if within 14 days of that delivery, the parties have not agreed to an amount for costs, the costs shall be assessed by Mr Jeff Peterson of Legal Costs Qld;

(c) the Respondent will pay the Applicant’s costs (as agreed or assessed) within fourteen (14) days of such agreement or assessment by Mr Peterson of Legal Costs Qld.

Background

Background to the litigation

CMG requests the costs to be assessed as follows:(a)CMG will deliver an itemised claim for costs referring to the relevant items contained in the District Court Scale of Costs;(b)if within 14 days the parties have not agreed to an amount of the costs, the costs will be assessed by Mr Jeff Peterson of Legal Costs Qld; and(c)the QBCC shall pay the costs assessed by Mr Peterson of Legal Costs within 14 days of such agreement or assessment.Background On or about 25 March 2011, CMG entered into a contract with David and Jill Van Dorssen and Carl and Kylie Houlihan (‘the homeowners’) for the construction of a low-set brick dwelling at 18 Haigh Crescent Samford Valley Queensland (‘the property’). On 20 July 2012, the homeowners made a complaint to the QBCC regarding alleged defective works (‘the first complaint’). A direction to rectify was issued by the QBCC on 7 October 2012 (‘the first DTR’) with regard to certain items in the homeowners’ complaint. CMG purported to attend to those works. It was subsequently decided by the QBCC that it would not issue a direction to rectify regarding some outstanding issues including the complaint regarding brick efflorescence. On 24 October 2013, the tribunal delivered a decision in relation to the homeowners’ application to review the QBCC’s decision not to issue a direction to rectify in relation to the outstanding issues. The tribunal’s decision in Van Dorssen and Ors v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2014] QCAT 594 confirmed the QBCC’s decision not to issue a direction to rectify. On 5 February 2018, the homeowners made a further complaint (‘the second complaint’) regarding alleged defects in the works including the issue of excessive slab moisture and efflorescence of the bricks which formed part of the first complaint. It is the subsequent DTR dated 1 May 2019 (‘the second DTR’) from the QBCC to CMG which was the subject of the decision of the tribunal dated 28 June 2019 as a result of an application for review dated 28 May 2018 of the QBCC’s second DTR. Offer to Settle Proceedings On 16 May 2018, CMG’s solicitor forwarded a letter to the QBCC[1] raising concerns about the second DTR and requested the QBCC to withdraw the second DTR.[1]Annexure MC-2 to the affidavit of Mardee Campbell affirmed 16 July 2019. On 28 May 2019, as a result of the QBCC’s failure to withdraw the second DTR, CMG filed an application to review the QBCC’s decision to issue the second DTR. By letter dated 11 September 2018,[2] CMG’s solicitor reiterated their concerns about the second DTR and made an offer to settle the review proceedings on the basis that the QBCC withdraw the second DTR and pay CMG’s costs in the sum of $5,000 within 7 days of the order.[2]Annexure MC-8 to the affidavit of Mardee Campbell affirmed 16 July 2019. The offer dated 11 September 2019 was an open offer made in accordance with Part 8, Division 3 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2009 (Qld) (‘the QCAT Rules’) remaining open until 26 September 2019.Legislation relating to Costs of Proceedings