TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re: Application 982758 in the name of Clipsal Australia Pty Ltd.
Date of Decision:
8 November 2005
Delegate:
Ian Thompson
Representation:
Applicant
Bruce Caine instructed by Madderns, Adelaide
Decision:
Shape of dolly switch and objections in terms of s41(6) – relevant trade and customers to be considered in assessment of whether the trade mark is taken to be capable of distinguishing the designated goods.
Background
1. The details of trade mark application 982758 are as follows:
Appn Number: 982758
Owner: The Clipsal Australia Pty Ltd (‘the owner’)
Priority Date: 19 December 2003
Goods:Class: 9 Electrical wiring accessories which incorporate a rocker switch; electric switches including dimmer switches; and switched power outlets
Trade Mark: “Switch Dolly” (Shape mark)
The trade mark appears thus:
2. The application has been the subject of three adverse examination reports on the dates set out below:
8 April 2004;
16 November 2004;
20 May 2005.
3. In the third examination report, the Examiner maintained the objection that the owner’s shape mark does not relevantly distinguish the owner’s goods within the meaning of section 41 of the Act
4. In the wake of the third examination report, the owner exercised its right to be heard pursuant to sub-section 33(4) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (“the Act”). The hearing was before me, as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, in Adelaide on 16 August 2005. The owner was represented by Mr Bruce Caine, instructed by Madderns, Trade Mark Attorneys.
Evidence
The evidence relied upon by the owner in support of its application is contained in the following statutory declarations which were sworn on the dates set out below:
From Clipsal Date
1. John Harris 22/12/03
2. Maxwell Alexander Goodwin 22/12/03
3. Gary Busbridge 18/12/03
4. John Gerard 18/12/03
5 James Osborne #1 18/12/03
5a. James Osborne #2 13/07/04
Wholesalers
6. John Rhigas (SA) 16/01/04
7. Stephen Robert Howe (NSW) 15/01/04
8. Wayne Sampson (NSW) 22/01/04
Contractors
9. Frank Russo (SA) 29/01/04
10. Vincent Michael Bibby (VIC) 07/01/04
11.Brett Nash (QLD) 13/01/04
12.James Moles (WA) 02/02/04
13.Glen Primrose (WA) 03/03/04
14.Stephen Griffiths (NSW) 19/03/04
15.Kelvin Smith (NSW) 28/02/04
16.Anthony Carlesso (NT) 04/05/04
17.Ian Mansfield (TAS) 18/03/04
Engineer
18.Peter Reedy (NSW) 16/01/04
6. It is Mr Caine’s submission that these declarations show that the owner’s shape mark is inherently adapted to distinguish the Applicant's goods. He says the owner’s shape mark:
1.is an original shape;
2.is a shape that is striking to the eye;
3.is a shape that is not dictated by any function or requirement, but rather is purely aesthetic;
4.is unique to the goods in respect to which registration is sought;
5.is a shape which other traders are not likely without an improper motive to want to use.
See Re Freshfood Holdings Pty Ltd (2005) AIPC 92-074 (I Thompson)
7. Mr Caine observed that the owner’s 30 series Dolly Switch was first designed in April 1970. In…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Clipsal Australia Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] ATMO 64
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the respondents had engaged in exclusionary provisions, specifically by entering into agreements that had the purpose or effect of preventing or hindering the supply of goods to certain customers. The Court was required to determine if these agreements constituted a contravention of section 45 of the *Trade Practices Act 1974* (Cth).
The Court's reasoning focused on the interpretation of the agreements and their likely or actual effect on competition. It applied established principles of competition law, considering the purpose and effect of the arrangements in question. The Court analysed the evidence to ascertain whether the agreements were designed to, or did in fact, substantially lessen competition in the relevant market. The Court found that the agreements did not have the purpose or effect of substantially lessening competition and therefore did not contravene section 45.
Background
Background to the litigation
Clipsal Australia argued that the shape of the dolly switch is inherently adapted to distinguish their goods due to its originality, aesthetic appeal, and distinctiveness. They presented evidence in the form of statutory declarations from various individuals, including wholesalers, contractors, and engineers, to support their claim that the shape is unique and recognisable within the electrical trade. The company also highlighted its substantial investment in promoting the trade mark over the years, amounting to nearly $48 million, and its extensive sales history, exceeding $1.5 billion over thirty-five years.
The Examiner initially objected to the registration of the shape mark, asserting that it did not inherently distinguish Clipsal's goods. However, Clipsal exercised its right to be heard and presented its case before a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. The delegate considered the evidence and the arguments presented by Clipsal's representative, Bruce Caine, who emphasised the shape's distinctiveness and the extensive use and promotion within the trade. Despite acknowledging the uniqueness and recognisability of the shape, the delegate noted that the trade mark's distinctiveness relied heavily on education and promotion within the trade, suggesting a lack of inherent distinctiveness.
Ultimately, the delegate decided to accept the application for possible registration, taking into account the extensive use and recognition of the shape within the trade, the significant sales figures, and the considerable promotional efforts. The decision hinged on whether the trade mark, despite not being inherently distinctive, had become distinctive in fact due to its widespread use and recognition among those in the electrical trade.
Clipsal Australia Pty Ltd's trade mark application 982758, concerning the shape of a dolly switch, encountered significant hurdles during its examination process, culminating in a hearing before a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. Initially filed on 19 December 2003, the application faced three adverse examination reports, culminating in an objection under section 41(6) of the Trade Marks Act 1995, asserting that the shape mark did not inherently distinguish the designated goods. Clipsal Australia Pty Ltd, represented by Bruce Caine of Madderns, exercised its right to be heard, leading to a hearing on 16 August 2005. The owner presented extensive evidence to counter the objections, asserting the shape's distinctiveness and its recognition within the electrical trade. Despite these efforts, the delegate found that while the shape was unique and had become recognisable within the trade, its inherent capacity to distinguish the goods was lacking without the necessity for extensive education and recognition efforts by the trade. The decision to accept the application for possible registration hinged on the substantial use and recognition of the shape mark within the trade, despite its lack of inherent distinctiveness.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the shape mark inherently adapted to distinguish the goods from those of other traders?
2. Does the extent of use of the trade mark by the owner, coupled with the advertising expenditure and declarations from those in the trade, establish that the trade mark distinguishes the goods in fact?
3. Should the trade mark be accepted for possible registration under section 41(6) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)?
4. What is the relevant trade and customer base to be considered in the assessment of whether the trade mark is taken to be capable of distinguishing the designated goods?
Held
1. Is the shape mark inherently adapted to distinguish the goods from those of other traders?
The court concluded that the shape mark lacks inherent capacity to distinguish the goods due to the need for education and recognition within the trade.
2. Does the extent of use of the trade mark by the owner, coupled with the advertising expenditure and declarations from those in the trade, establish that the trade mark distinguishes the goods in fact?
The court concluded that the extent of use, advertising expenditure, and declarations from those in the trade establish that the shape mark distinguishes the goods in fact.
3. Should the trade mark be accepted for possible registration under section 41(6) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)?
The court concluded that the trade mark should be accepted for possible registration under section 41(6) of the Act.
4. What is the relevant trade and customer base to be considered in the assessment of whether the trade mark is taken to be capable of distinguishing the designated goods?
The court concluded that the relevant trade and customer base to be considered is the electrical trade, which consists of electrical contractors, builders, and architects.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The delegate's reasoning commenced by acknowledging the fundamental principles of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), emphasizing that the act establishes a framework for the registration of trade marks that can distinguish goods or services. The delegate cited Branson J's explanation in Blount Inc v. Registrar of Trade Marks, clarifying that the court and the Registrar should approach the registration process with a presumption of registrability, requiring the opponent to prove that the trade mark should not be registered. This presumption aligns with the principles set out in Registrar of Trade Marks v Woolworths Ltd and Lomas v Winton Shire Council, where the burden lies on the respondent to establish the grounds for opposition.
The delegate acknowledged that the shape mark in question was indeed a trade mark, as defined under section 17 of the Act. The mark was used by those in the electrical trade to distinguish the owner's goods from similar products of other traders, fulfilling the criteria of being a sign used to distinguish goods or services in the course of trade. However, the delegate then scrutinized the inherent qualities of the shape mark to determine if it was inherently adapted to distinguish the goods.
Applying the principles from Clark Equipment Co v Registrar of Trade Marks, the delegate considered whether the mark was such that, by its use, the owner was likely to distinguish their goods from those of others. The delegate noted that while the shape mark was unique and distinctive to the owner's design, it required education to recognize it as a trade mark. This necessity for education undermined its inherent distinctiveness. Despite the extensive use and promotion by the owner, the delegate concluded that the shape mark lacked inherent capacity to distinguish the goods due to its need for explanation and education, thus not fulfilling the criteria under section 41(3) of the Act.
Turning to subsection 41(6), the delegate examined whether the trade mark distinguished the goods in fact due to the extent of its use. The owner's significant sales, which exceeded $1500 million over thirty-five years, combined with the advertising expenditure and declarations from those in the trade, indicated that the shape had become recognized as the owner's trade mark within the trade. These factors, along with the minimal sales to the general public, suggested that the shape mark distinguished the goods in practice. The delegate concluded that the owner had demonstrated that the trade mark distinguished the goods in fact, satisfying the conditions under subsection 41(6)(a).
In determining the relevant trade and customer base, the delegate noted that the majority of the sales were to the electrical trade, which included contractors, builders, and architects. These professionals were accustomed to identifying the trade source of the goods by the shape of the switch on the faceplate. The delegate accepted that within this specific trade, the shape mark effectively distinguished the goods from those of other traders.
In conclusion, the delegate decided to accept the application for possible registration. The reasoning highlighted the importance of distinguishing the relevant trade and customer base when assessing the capacity of a trade mark to distinguish goods. The decision emphasized the practical use of the shape mark within the trade and the substantial sales and advertising efforts by the owner, which collectively established the mark's distinctiveness in fact. This decision aligns with the principles that the onus is on the opponent to prove grounds for opposition and that the presumption of registrability should be upheld unless clearly unfounded.