Cleret v Sunshine Coast Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Cleret v Sunshine Coast Regional Council & Anor [2017] QCA 163

PARTIES:

DANIEL CLERET
(appellant)
v

SUNSHINE COAST REGIONAL COUNCIL
(first respondent)
DENISE BROOKS
(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 10291 of 2016
SC No 6701 of 2014

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court at Brisbane – [2016] QSC 208

DELIVERED ON:

1 August 2017

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

24 March 2017

JUDGES:

Morrison JA and Mullins and Flanagan JJ
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the orders made

ORDERS:

1.   Appeal dismissed.

2.   The appellant pay the respondents’ costs of the appeal, to be assessed on the standard basis.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – INTERFERENCE WITH JUDGE’S FINDING OF FACT – FUNCTIONS OF APPELLATE COURT – PROOF AND EVIDENCE – where the appellant owned a restaurant that was inspected by the second respondent as an employee of the first respondent – where the first respondent, relying on the Food Act 2006 (Qld), closed the restaurant – where the appellant brought an action against the first and second respondent for misfeasance in public office, negligence and trespass – where the appellant alleged that the closure notice was issued without power, the respondents were trespassing when the second respondent conducted the inspection, and the respondents were negligent in when conducting the inspections and preparing the reports – where the appeal was dismissed after an eight day trial – where documents were tendered and ten witnesses were called at the trial – where the appellant appeals on the ground that the trial judge made incorrect findings of fact – where the trial judge’s findings relied considerably on an assessment of witness’ credibility – whether the trial judge’s findings are so inconsistent with facts established by the evidence that appellate intervention is necessary

Food Act 2006 (Qld)

Abalos v Australian Postal Commission (1990) 171 CLR 167; [1990] HCA 47, applied
Adamson v Eade
[2009] NSWCA 379, followed
Cleret v Sunshine Coast Regional Council
[2016] QSC 208, related
F Hoffman-La Roche & Co v Secretary of State for Trade and Industry [1975] AC 295, followed
Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118, [2003] HCA 22, applied

COUNSEL:

The appellant appeared on his own behalf
R J Anderson for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

The appellant appeared on his own behalf
Barry Nilsson Lawyers for the respondent

  1. MORRISON JA:  Mr Cleret owned a restaurant at Kenilworth.  An Environmental Health Officer (Ms Brooks) from the Sunshine Coast Regional Council inspected the restaurant on a number of occasions.  She issued notices in relation to it and the restaurant closed in July 2010.  As a result, Mr Cleret’s mortgagee sold the property it was operated on.

  2. Mr Cleret commenced proceedings against the Council and the Council officer, for misfeasance in public office, negligence and trespass.  After an eight day trial his action was dismissed.

  3. Mr Cleret appeals…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cleret v Sunshine Coast Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QCA 163
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mr Cleret appeals against the dismissal of his action against the Sunshine Coast Regional Council and Ms Brooks, an authorised officer of the Council, for misfeasance in public office, negligence and trespass. The primary judge dismissed the appeal following an eight-day trial in which documents were tendered and ten witnesses were called. Mr Cleret appeals on the ground that the trial judge made incorrect findings of fact. The appeal grounds were numerous and largely concerned errors of fact, including the rejection of alleged fraudulent interference with photographs, acceptance of Ms Brooks’ evidence, and denial of natural justice. The appeal court was required to determine whether the trial judge's findings were so inconsistent with facts established by the evidence that appellate intervention was necessary.

The appeal court found that the trial judge's findings were supported by the evidence, and the appeal was dismissed. The court found that the trial judge carefully analysed the evidence, examined Mr Cleret's criticisms, and provided a full explanation of why the findings were made. The court found that the evidence supported the trial judge's findings and his rejection of the evidence of Mr Cleret and his witnesses as relevantly unreliable, and his acceptance of the evidence of Ms Brooks and Mr Diefenbach. The court also found that the failure of the trial judge to make findings in favour of Mr Cleret did not give rise to an apprehension of bias, given the seriousness of the allegations against Ms Brooks and the Council.

The appeal court found that none of the other matters raised by Mr Cleret took the appeal beyond the level of the grounds dealt with above. The appeal court dismissed the appeal and ordered that Mr Cleret pay the respondents' costs of the appeal, to be assessed on the standard basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal dismissed.

2. The appellant pay the respondents’ costs of the appeal, to be assessed on the standard basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Cleret appeals against the dismissal of the action. The amended notice of appeal contains 28 grounds of appeal which largely consist of alleged errors of fact. They can be conveniently categorized as follows:(a)undesignated errors of fact: grounds 2 and 21-26;(b)rejection of alleged fraudulent interference with photographs, and impact on the veracity of photographic evidence in the absence of the original metadata: grounds 1, 11 and 13;(c)acceptance of Ms Brooks’ evidence, particularly as to her inspections, photographs taken by her and alleged fabrication of evidence by her: grounds 3-10, 12, 15 and 18;(d)errors about the hand basin: ground 14;(e)power to suspend the licence and authority to issue notices: grounds 16, 17 and 19;(f)whether Ms Brooks trespassed when she entered the restaurant: ground 20;(g)denial of natural justice because the trial judge selectively dismissed evidence without informing the parties that he intended to do so: ground 27; and(h)apprehension of bias by way of pre-judgment: ground 28.Background facts The background facts concerning the restaurant, its inspections and closure can be taken from the judgment below.[1] None of these are facts in contest.[1]Cleret v Sunshine Coast Regional Council [2016] QSC 208, (Reasons) at [2]-[9]. Internal footnotes omitted.“[2] Mr Cleret commenced to operate the restaurant (on a part time basis) in about 1989. The first recorded inspection by Ms Brooks was in 2006. She also carried out inspections on 31 December 2008, 22 January 2009, 11 March 2009, 2 June 2010 and 25 June 2010. For all save the first of these occasions, there is a document described as a Food Business Inspection Report (Report), the form for each report referring to the Food Act 2006 (Qld). The reports generally recorded that corrective action was required. At least for the later of these inspections and reports, Ms Brooks held authority from the Council: a document dated 9 February 2009 signed by Lisbeth Dean as Executive Director Community Services of the Council recorded the appointment of Ms Brooks as an authorised person for, amongst other things, the Food Act.[3]On about 25 May 2010, Ms Brooks sent an Information Notice to Mr Cleret giving notice of the requirements for hand washing facilities for licenced food premises. The notice advised of a requirement to have a separate hand wash basin, specifying 12 months as the period for compliance.[4]The critical inspection occurred on 25 June 2010. On that occasion, Ms Brooks took a number of photographs. Ms Brooks’ inspection report book contains both the original and the carbon copy of a report bearing that date (Report 11244), stating that she was unable to complete the report, and that she started to write up a new report. The new report (Report 11246) recorded the results of her inspection; that assistance was sought from a police officer stationed at Kenilworth; that the licence had been suspended; that Mr Cleret was to cease to operate the restaurant; and it identified some corrective actions that were required.[5]On 7 July 2010, Ms Brooks went to the restaurant and left three notices attached to the door. Two were Improvement Notices, issued in reliance on s 83 of the Food Act, alleging contraventions of the Act which were likely to continue. Of these, one was dated 6 July 2010, and set out 37 requirements to be complied with. The second was dated 7 July 2010, and required completion of a form called a Food Safety Supervisor Notification. The third notice, dated 6 July 2010, was an Information Notice, also referred to as a suspension notice, issued in reliance on s 83 of the Food Act, and gave notice that the licence for the restaurant under the Food Act had been suspended with immediate effect. All three notices were signed by Mr Jason Brewer, who held the position of Healthy Places Manager with the Council.[6]On 16 July 2010, Ms Brooks again attended at the restaurant. On that occasion, she took some photographs. She completed another report (Report 11258) which contained a note including the words “Please do not operate as advertised for Sunday” and which referred, amongst other things, to the suspension. It also invited a telephone call to Ms Brooks to arrange an inspection, providing a mobile telephone number. She left a copy of that report attached to the door of the restaurant. Mr Cleret did not attempt to arrange an inspection.[7]On 3 August 2010, Mr Cleret sent a letter to the Chief Executive Officer of the Council, apparently intended as an objection to the suspension notice. The document set out criticisms of Ms Brooks, and commented on the inspection of 25 June 2010, and on matters raised in Report 11246, the suspension notice and the Improvement Notice dated 6 July 2010.[8]On 23 August 2010, following a conversation between them, Mr Greg Mulder, the Coordinator Environment Health for the Council, wrote a letter to Mr Cleret, giving notice that he intended to undertake an inspection of the restaurant, and inviting Mr Cleret to contact him to provide a suitable time for the inspection. The letter also stated that Mr Cleret was unable to trade until the premises had been inspected, and the “conditions of the improvement notice” had been complied with. Notwithstanding the invitation, Mr Cleret did not contact Mr Mulder to arrange an inspection.[9]By this time, Mr Cleret had ceased trading. His evidence was that he had continued trading after 25 June 2010, for more than a week. He plainly associated his decision to cease trading with service of the suspension notice and the Information Notices, which occurred on 7 July 2010. On Ms Brooks’ evidence, there were indications on 16 July that Mr Cleret intended to continue trading. However, her evidence did not establish that he continued trading after that date. It is difficult to reach a firm conclusion about the date when Mr Cleret ceased to trade, other than that it was not long after 7 July 2010.”Applicable legal principles

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I intend to deal with the majority of the grounds in categories, and in the course of doing so, I will advert to the competing submissions advanced, but only to the extent necessary to highlight the relevant point.Ms Brooks’ evidence; alleged fabrication of evidence: grounds 3-10, 12, 15 and 18 Mr Cleret’s contentions in this category covered a multitude of complaints about the findings as to Ms Brooks’ evidence, and how events could not have occurred as she said in her evidence. However, he identified several “key issues” as being: (i) the evidence showed that Ms Brooks fabricated report No. 11244; (ii) Ms Brooks tampered with digitally recorded data or caused another person to do so; and (iii) deleted pictures were not accounted for.Inspection 25 June 2010 and Report No. 11244 Because the evidence of the inspection on 25 June 2010, and what occurred in the course of it, was central to a number of Mr Cleret’s contentions, it is appropriate to review it now. Mr Cleret’s submission was that report No. 11244, contrary to Ms Brooks’ evidence, was not made on the restaurant premises. Central to that submission was that Brooks identified the reason why she stopped one report part way through was that water had dripped onto it while in the restaurant kitchen; that could not be true, which showed the report was fabricated.[5] The relevant findings by the learned trial judge are at Reasons [47]-[54].[5]Appellant’s outline, page 3, paragraphs 4-13. Ms Brooks’ evidence in chief as to the inspection was as follows:(a)when she went to do the inspection she had no idea whether the restaurant would be open or whether Mr Cleret would be there;[6][6]AB 536 line 1.(b)at first she said that she went into the restaurant and met Mr Cleret; she could not recall precisely where that occurred, whether it was just inside the kitchen door or at the front counter; she said hello to Mr Cleret;[7][7]AB 500 lines 27-31.(c)then, when asked for greater detail, she said she was outside, and saw a sign that said “open tonight”, so she thought the restaurant was open; she saw people sitting at a table, and concluded that the restaurant was then open for business; she took a photo of the people at the table; she then walked towards the front door and saw Mr Cleret at the table; she greeted him and asked to do an inspection; they then started to walk towards the kitchen;[8][8]AB 500 lines 37-43.(d)she commenced to write report No. 11244 during her inspection on 25 June 2010, and at one point placed it on a bench underneath a microwave oven; she was unable to complete it because Mr Cleret spilt water on it when he reached out to clean the microwave with a sponge;[9][9]AB 499 lines 19-23, AB 512 lines 35-39.(e)she felt that she needed some support with the inspection, so she made phone calls, but unsuccessfully; she then went around to the local police station and spoke to a police officer; she asked him whether Mr Cleret had a liquor licence for the restaurant;[10] [10]AB 499 lines 32-47, AB 507 lines 1-4.(f)she took photographs when inside the kitchen;[11] she may have taken them both before and after she went to the local police station;[12][11]AB 504 line 47 to AB 505 line 4.[12]AB 507 lines 9-11.(g)by reference to the photos in Exhibit 12 she recalled that she went across the road to take photo, including of the advertising sign outside the restaurant;[13][13]AB 509 line 41 to AB 510 line 7.(h)she downloaded the photographs when she returned to her office; she could not recall the sequence in which the photographs were taken, except by relying on the “properties” function in the metadata once the photographs were downloaded;[14](i)she had written on the photographs in Exhibit 12; she explained what she relied upon for that purpose:[15]“What I relied upon was waiting till I got back to the office to download them onto the computer and then get the date and the time from the metadata in the properties box of the computer. The reason I did it that way was that there was so much happening at the time of the inspection that mentally and physically, there’s no way I could have written the time at that time of inspection of those photographs because I was clicking so quickly and having discussions with [Mr Cleret] and making observations in the kitchen that juggling a pen and the camera and writing things would have been impossible to do it all that same time.”(j)it was possible in her writing on the photographs that she got them mixed up, but they were “definitely all taken … on that same day because all the other evidence indicates that”;[16] she was taken through the photographs in Exhibit 12 and identified them as being taken during the inspection;[17](k)she did not give Mr Cleret a copy of report No. 11244; at the end of the inspection she gave him report No. 11246, and told him to cease operation of the food business;[18](l)she discussed with Mr Cleret whether he could clean up by opening time that night; by then it was about 3 pm;[19](m)she wrote the time 1.15 on this report because she had “probably looked at my watch on that particular occasion … or my mobile phone …”;[20] and(n)at the end of the inspection on Friday she went back to her office but did not deal with the documentation until the following Monday.[21][14]AB 508 lines 25-31.[15]AB 509 lines 22-28; see also AB 847 lines 9-28.[16]AB 510 line 26.[17]AB 512-533; AB 537 lines 9-12. From AB 533 photographs from a later time were examined.[18]AB 500 lines 11-21.[19]AB 506 lines 18-25, 38-45.[20]AB 506 lines 34-36.[21]AB 535 lines 32-35.

Decision

Reasons for decision

This ground fails.Apprehension of bias by way of pre-judgment - ground 28 This ground was added by amendment at the commencement of the hearing. As the oral submissions progressed the basis of the contention was that the learned trial judge had ignored the evidence from Mr Cleret and his witnesses. However, this was then clarified as being a contention that the learned trial judge did not make the findings of fact which Mr Cleret said were warranted by that evidence. In particular, complaint was made that his Honour rejected the evidence of Mr Cleret’s witnesses, and consequently accepted Ms Brooks’ evidence on matters such as the timing of her inspection and photographs, and the fact of water dripping on the report book. For the reasons given earlier this ground must fail. In the circumstances of this case, where serious allegations of misfeasance in office, malice and fraud were made against Ms Brooks and the Council, the failure of the trial judge to make findings in favour of Mr Cleret does not give rise to an apprehension of bias. His Honour was well aware of the seriousness of the allegations and the need for the evidence to be clear and cogent before the requisite standard of satisfaction of proof of those allegations could be reached.[142] What followed in the Reasons was a very careful analysis of the evidence, an examination of Mr Cleret’s criticisms of it, and a full explanation of why the findings were made.[142]See, for example Reasons [45], where his Honour referred to that very fact, citing Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336. In my view, the evidence amply supported the learned trial judge’s findings and his rejection of the evidence of Mr Cleret and his witnesses as relevantly unreliable, and, correspondingly, his acceptance of the evidence of Ms Brooks and Mr Diefenbach. This ground fails.Other matters Mr Cleret raised a number of matters that are not included in the grounds dealt with above. None of them take the appeal beyond the level of those grounds. However I will mention some of them, for completeness. Mr Cleret’s notice of appeal raised undesignated errors of fact in grounds 2 and 21-26. There were no particulars given of what they were, and oral argument did not advance them any further. They can be disregarded. Mr Cleret also made allegations that Ms Brooks destroyed her notes and a log book for the car, and thereby the Council thus breached the Public Records Act 2002 (Qld) and the Evidence Act 1977 (Qld).[143] At the trial Mr Cleret raised the destruction of the log book[144] and the method keeping of notes.[145] However, he did not challenge Ms Brooks about the alleged destruction of them. To the extent these matters were raised they were clearly before the learned trial judge and did not impact upon his Honour’s findings.[143]Appellant’s outline page 2 and paragraphs 43-47.[144]AB 807-808, and see Reasons [37]. It appeared the destruction of them was a routine part of Council’s management, rather than anything indicative of malice: appellant’s outline paragraph 46.[145]AB 462.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.