Clavero and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

Clavero and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) [2020] AATA 4167 (19 October 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2020/2763

Re:Roberto Clavero

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President J Sosso

Date:19 October 2020

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal refuses the Applicant’s request for a stay order.

.................................[SGD].......................................

Deputy President J Sosso

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to stay decision of Australian Postal Corporation – whether a stay order would secure the effectiveness of the hearing and determination of the application for review – whether Applicant has prospects of success in substantive application – whether Applicant would suffer financial hardship if stay order refused or granted – whether making of a stay order would guarantee ongoing compensation payments – Applicant’s request for a stay order refused

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

CASES

Australian Postal Corporation v Oudyn [2003] FCA 318

Australian Securities and Investment Commission v Administrative Appeals Tribunal (2009) 181 FCR 130
Avtex Air Services Pty Ltd and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2010] AATA 716
Blackwell and Comcare [2017] AATA 1118
Carson and Telstra Corporation [2001] AATA 648
Clement and Comcare [2006] AATA 705
Commonwealth of Australia and Quirke (1986) 9 ALD 92
Commonwealth Banking Corporation and Iannello (1988) 15 ALD 418
Dekanic and Tax Agents’ Board of New South Wales (1982) 6 ALD 241
Griffiths Grif-Air Helicopters Pty Ltd and Civil Aviation Authority (1993) 31 ALD 380
Lees v Comcare [1999] FCA 753
Re Repatriation Commission and Delkou (1985) 8 ALD 454
Scott and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2009] AATA 798

Telstra Corporation v Hannaford (2006) 151 FCR 253

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President J Sosso

19 October 2020

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 12 September 2019 Mr Roberto Clavero (the Applicant) submitted a claim for compensation to his employer, the Australian Postal Corporation (the Respondent), in relation to “compression of the neck C6 & C7”  which, it was contended, arose in the course of his employment – T4 pp. 26 - 38. Further, the Applicant, in his claim, indicated that he had not previously had “a similar injury/illness” – T4 p. 26.

  2. On 7 November 2019 the Respondent accepted liability for compensation to be paid to the Applicant for “aggravation of the pre-existing multilevel degeneration of the cervical spine” pursuant to s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act) with the date of the disease determined as 26 August 2019, being the date that the Applicant first sought medical treatment for the condition – T22 pp. 106 – 107.

  3. Subsequently, the Respondent accepted liability for the payment of various medical costs pursuant to s 16 of the Act – T24 pp. 112 – 115, T25 pp. 116 – 120, T26 pp. 121 – 125, T35 pp. 148 – 151 and T37 pp. 154 – 157. Further, various determinations were made pursuant to s 19 of the Act in relation to incapacity payments and s 37 in relation to a rehabilitation program.

  4. On 3 February…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clavero and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 4167
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before Deputy J Sosso P of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal concerning an application by the Applicant for a stay order against a decision of the Australian Postal Corporation. The Applicant sought to prevent the cessation of compensation payments pending the determination of his substantive application for review. The core of the dispute revolved around the Applicant's alleged wilful and false representation in his Claim for Rehabilitation and Compensation Form, specifically in answering "No" to having had a similar injury or illness prior to commencing employment.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether a stay order would effectively secure the hearing and determination of the substantive application, whether the Applicant had prospects of success in that application, and whether the Applicant would suffer financial hardship if the stay order were refused. The Tribunal was also required to consider the potential impact of a stay order on other determinations and the Applicant's capacity to repay any compensation received if ultimately unsuccessful.

The Tribunal considered the Applicant's objections to certain documentary evidence, including a pre-employment medical assessment referred to as the "Sunnybank document," which the Applicant argued was unverified and irrelevant. However, the Tribunal noted that while a stay application should not become a preliminary trial, an interim assessment of the application's strength was necessary. The Respondent contended that the Applicant had a history of back and neck pain, had received treatment including steroid injections and scans, and had answered negatively to relevant questions on a pre-employment medical form and his compensation claim form. On its face, the compensation claim form and the "Sunnybank document" appeared to indicate that the Applicant had incorrectly answered key questions regarding his medical history, suggesting a pattern of non-disclosure and potentially wilful false representations.

The Tribunal concluded that, having regard to the apparent discrepancies in the Applicant's documentation and his answers regarding prior medical history, a stay order was not appropriate for securing the effectiveness of the hearing and determination of the substantive application. Accordingly, the Applicant's request for a stay order was refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant contends (IFD para 31) that paragraphs 3.6 – 3.8 of RFSRASA are “unverified conjecture and speculation” and no sworn evidence has been adduced to verify the statements. The following submission was made:“…In short, there is no evidence to support the Respondent’s unverified and unsubstantiated assertions. Whilst the Tribunal is bound by the rules of evidence nevertheless, it is mindful of these rules and practices for the proof of allegations, particularly when a party is on notice that challenges will be made to such unverified and unsworn allegations. A serious allegation should be the subject of a through sworn statement to explain and identify a document of questionable origin.” The Applicant (IFD para 33) outlined a series of objections to the Pre-Employment Medical Assessment document which was referred to as the “Sunnybank document”. The Applicant referred it as an “unverified document” which it contended was not relevant to the determination of 9 April 2020. The Applicant made the following submission (IFD para 33b):“…Accordingly, the Sunnybank document, being an unverified document ostensibly made on or about 1st March 2017 and predating the claim form apparently being the alleged wilful and false statement by more than 2.5 years is not relevant to the issues before the Tribunal…The Sunnybank document does not bear upon the issues before the Tribunal except for the purpose of unsubstantiated and unverified prejudice.” Whilst, as the Tribunal pointed out in Delkou, it is not appropriate for a stay application to morph into a preliminary trial, it is nonetheless incumbent on the Tribunal to make an interim assessment about the strength of an application. It needs to be emphasised that such an assessment is a preliminary one only, and such an assessment by no means should be viewed as a considered view about the strength or weakness of an application. An Interlocutory Hearing has all the shortfalls of a proceeding that is short and lacks the probity and rigour that only a full Hearing can achieve. The key contention of the Respondent is that the Applicant made a wilful and false representation in his Claim for Rehabilitation and Compensation Form by answering “No” to the Question had he had a similar injury/illness. The Tribunal has before it the Form (PT4 pp. 26 – 29), and on its face, it appears to indicate that the Applicant has incorrectly answered the Question. Further, the “Sunnybank document” (SST1 pp. 2 – 10) is also before the Tribunal, and likewise on its face appears to indicate that the Applicant has incorrectly answered key Questions. The relevance of this document is obvious. From the perspective of the Respondent, it discloses a pattern of conduct whereby the Applicant has failed to disclose his medical history. It would, if that be correct, suggest that the Applicant has wilfully engaged in making false representations with the aim of receiving compensation which he was not entitled to.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having regard to the above findings I do not consider the making of a stay order is appropriate for securing the effectiveness of the Hearing and the determination of the substantive application.DECISION The Applicant’s request for a stay order is refused.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant also highlights (IFD para 29) that if a stay order is made there may be consequential effects on other determinations made by the Applicant. In short, a stay order may have a broader impact than simply the determination under review.CONSIDERATIONIntroduction As discussed above, the Tribunal both in Delkou and many subsequent determinations, has considered application for stay orders where payments are involved through the prism of key factors. Those factors are by no means exhaustive of the task required of the Tribunal, and each application brings with it unique facts that require consideration. Nonetheless, the principal factors highlighted in Delkou provide a useful framework. The Tribunal notes, for example, that President Downes in Scott and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2009] AATA 798 at [4] also outlined a non-exhaustive set of factors to be taken into account. President Downes also drew attention to the public interest and questions of timing. A similar list of factors was outlined by Senior Member Tavoularis in Blackwell and Comcare [2017] AATA 1118 at [6] (Blackwell). The above determinations highlight that the Tribunal can take into account, when considering an application for a stay order, a range of matters and it is not helpful to attempt to codify those factors that may be relevant. The parties made specific submissions on both the prospects of success and financial circumstances. Both of these are discussed below. Neither party made specific submissions on the issue of the Applicant’s capacity to repay compensation paid should he be unsuccessful. In part this is due to the Respondent’s submissions (dealt with below) on the limiting effect of a s 14 review determination. For the sake of completeness, the evidence before the Tribunal suggests that if the Applicant was paid further compensation payments and was unsuccessful at the substantive hearing, due to his deleterious financial circumstances, he would find it difficult to repay any compensation moneys paid to him in the interim.Prospects of success The Respondent contends (Respondent’s Further Submissions Relating to Applicant’s Stay Application (RFSRASA) para 3.6) that before starting employment with the Respondent in July 2017, the Applicant had a history of pack pain and was treated with steroid injections of the neck. The Applicant, it is contended, underwent CT scans and CT-guided injections of the cervical spine in 2014 and 2017. Further, the Applicant was prescribed Lyrica for his neck pain. The Respondent further contends (RFSRASA para 3.7) that before starting employment with the Respondent the Applicant underwent a medical examination in March 2017 and in response to Questions as to whether he had ever experienced neck pain, stiff neck or whiplash (Q 36), treatment on back or neck (Q 39) or underwent back or neck x-ray or scan (Q 40) the Applicant answered in the negative. The Respondent (RFSRASA para 3.8) drew the Tribunal’s attention to the Applicant’s Claim for Rehabilitation and Compensation where he answered in the negative to the Question whether he had ever had a similar injury/illness.