Clasul Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Clasul Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia [2016] FCA 1119

File number: NSD 368 of 2013
Judge: FOSTER J
Date of Orders: 30 August 2016
Date of Publication of Reasons: 13 September 2016
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether, pursuant to s 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), the Court should approve and give effect to the settlement of a class action – relevant principles discussed
Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), ss 37AF(1)(b), 33V, 33ZB and 33ZF
Cases cited: Camilleri v Trust Company (Nominees) Ltd [2015] FCA 1468
Date of hearing: 30 August 2016
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 54
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr MBJ Lee SC
Solicitor for the Applicants: Maurice Blackburn Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr S Nixon
Solicitor for the Respondent: Ashurst Australia

ORDERS

NSD 368 of 2013
BETWEEN:

CLASUL PTY LTD (ACN 010 173 029)

First Applicant

CHRISTINE ALBERTA HOSKING

Second Applicant

BURNS BLOODSTOCK

Third Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

JUDGE:

FOSTER J

DATE OF ORDER:

30 AUGUST 2016

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act), The Macquarie Stud, David Baxter and John Baxter be deemed to have effectively opted out of this proceeding notwithstanding that none of them provided an opt out notice to the Court by 9 August 2016 as required by the Orders of the Court made on 12 July 2016 although each of them did provide such a notice to the Court on 22 August 2016. 

2.Pursuant to s 33V and s 33ZF of the Act:

(a)The settlement of the proceeding be approved upon the terms set out in the Deed of Settlement dated 29 June 2016 (Deed) which is Annexure AJW-2 to the affidavit of Andrew John Watson affirmed on 8 July 2016; and

(b)The applicants be authorized nunc pro tunc to enter into and give effect to the Deed for and on behalf of Group Members (as defined in the Fifth Further Amended Statement of Claim filed on 16 March 2016 but not including those persons and entities specified in Order 1 above and those persons and entities who opted out of the proceeding by sending to the Court by 9 August 2016 an opt out notice which notices are contained in a folder of documents identified as “Opt Out Notices – Clasul Pty Ltd ACN 010 173 029 v Commonwealth of Australia NSD368/2013” marked as “Exhibit A” in this proceeding).

3.Pursuant to s 33ZB and s 33ZF of the Act, the persons affected and bound by the orders in par 2 above are the applicants, the respondent and the Group Members other than those who have opted out of the proceeding (as to which see Exhibit A).

4.All previous costs orders made in this proceeding be vacated.

5.Order 9 made on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clasul Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 1119
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Clasul Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia involved a class action proceeding that had been settled. The Federal Court of Australia was required to determine whether to approve and give effect to the settlement under section 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976. The primary legal issue was whether the settlement terms were fair and reasonable and whether the process of informing and obtaining consent from class members was conducted properly. The Court needed to consider the evidence provided by the parties, including the rationale for the settlement and the responses from the class members.

The Court found that the settlement was fair and reasonable based on several factors. The evidence showed that the settlement was negotiated in good faith and that the class members were adequately informed about the terms and their options to opt out. The Court noted that the settlement was the only offer made by the Commonwealth and that the applicants had limited alternatives. The Court also considered the financial implications, including the unpaid fees and the risk of adverse costs orders, which supported the settlement. Given these factors, the Court approved the settlement and dismissed the proceeding, allowing the parties to bear their own costs.

The Court's decision emphasized the importance of a transparent and fair process in approving class action settlements, ensuring that the interests of all class members are considered. The final orders included approval of the settlement, dismissal of the proceeding, and suppression of certain evidence to protect the interests of the parties involved.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act), The Macquarie Stud, David Baxter and John Baxter be deemed to have effectively opted out of this proceeding notwithstanding that none of them provided an opt out notice to the Court by 9 August 2016 as required by the Orders of the Court made on 12 July 2016 although each of them did provide such a notice to the Court on 22 August 2016.

2. Pursuant to s 33V and s 33ZF of the Act:

(a) The settlement of the proceeding be approved upon the terms set out in the Deed of Settlement dated 29 June 2016 (Deed) which is Annexure AJW-2 to the affidavit of Andrew John Watson affirmed on 8 July 2016; and

(b) The applicants be authorized nunc pro tunc to enter into and give effect to the Deed for and on behalf of Group Members (as defined in the Fifth Further Amended Statement of Claim filed on 16 March 2016 but not including those persons and entities specified in Order 1 above and those persons and entities who opted out of the proceeding by sending to the Court by 9 August 2016 an opt out notice which notices are contained in a folder of documents identified as “Opt Out Notices – Clasul Pty Ltd ACN 010 173 029 v Commonwealth of Australia NSD368/2013” marked as “Exhibit A” in this proceeding).

3. Pursuant to s 33ZB and s 33ZF of the Act, the persons affected and bound by the orders in par 2 above are the applicants, the respondent and the Group Members other than those who have opted out of the proceeding (as to which see Exhibit A).

4. All previous costs orders made in this proceeding be vacated.

5. Order 9 made on 12 July 2016 be vacated.

6. Pursuant to s 37AF(1)(b) of the Act, the evidence contained in the affidavit of Andrew John Watson affirmed on 23 August 2016 and filed herein (including Annexure AJW-3 thereto) not be published or disclosed without the prior leave of a Judge to any person or entity other than the applicants, the applicants’ lawyers, the Judge with the carriage of the matter from time to time and officers of the Court to whom it is necessary to disclose the evidence.

7. The proceeding be dismissed:

(a) With each party to bear his, her or its own costs (as the case may be); and

(b) Without prejudice to the parties’ ability to relist the matter for the purpose of seeking orders consequential to the Deed or relating to the security lodged with the Court.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns a proposed settlement of a class action brought by Clasul Pty Ltd against the Commonwealth of Australia. The action involves a group of members who may be affected by the settlement. The settlement was proposed after the applicants and their legal representatives assessed the prospects of success in the case, considering factors such as the likelihood of the Commonwealth appealing any adverse decision, unpaid fees owed to the legal firm Maurice Blackburn, and the potential for an adverse costs order if the Commonwealth were to succeed. The proposed settlement did not provide any compensation to the applicants or group members, nor did it provide payment to Maurice Blackburn or Argentum. The settlement was communicated to the group members, and some opted out of the proceeding. The case came before the court for approval of the settlement terms under section 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth).

The procedural history of this matter involves the filing of a class action by Clasul Pty Ltd against the Commonwealth of Australia. Following negotiations between the parties, a settlement was proposed. The court was required to consider and approve the settlement terms. Affidavits were filed by Mr Watson, a Principal of Maurice Blackburn, and Mr Schimmel, who provided evidence on the compliance with the settlement notice and opt-out orders. The court heard arguments and considered the affidavits before making its decision on the approval of the settlement and other consequential orders.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At pars 42–49 of his Confidential Affidavit, Mr Watson explained his reasons and the rationale for the proposed settlement in some detail. In particular, he took into account the following matters:(a)The assessment of the applicants’ prospects of success given to him by Counsel earlier in 2016;(b)His own assessment of the applicants’ prospects of success; (c)The likelihood that the Commonwealth would appeal any adverse decision;(d)The fact that Maurice Blackburn had not been paid all of the fees and disbursements rendered to Argentum with the consequence that a very substantial sum was then due to Maurice Blackburn;(e)The likelihood that the quantum of the amount ultimately recovered, even if the applicants were largely successful, would not be sufficient to justify the further expenditure of significant funds on legal fees and disbursements for the trial; and(f)The prospect that the applicants may suffer an adverse costs order for many millions of dollars in the event that the Commonwealth was successful in defeating the applicants’ claims. Mr Schimmel’s Evidence In his affidavit, Mr Schimmel proved compliance with the settlement notice and opt out orders which I had made on 12 July 2016. In particular, at pars 92–101, Mr Schimmel provided detailed evidence of such compliance and of group members’ responses to the notice. At those paragraphs, he said:SECTION C – COMPLIANCE WITH THE SETTLEMENT NOTICE ORDERS 92.In order to comply with the Settlement Notice Orders, I caused the following steps to be taken by employees of Maurice Blackburn who I supervise and, through my discussion with those employees and my review of the firm’s files and records, I satisfied myself that these steps were in fact taken. 93.First, in accordance with order 2 of the Settlement Notice Orders, on 15 July 2016 the Notice was sent to the 587 Group Members by post and/or email:(a)557 Notices were sent by email only; (b)of the 557 Notices that were sent by email, we received 65 delivery failure notifications, so these Notices were re-sent by post; (c)29 Notices were sent by post only; (d)one additional Notice was sent both by post and by email. 94.Secondly, between 1 August 2016 and 5 August 2016, Maurice Blackburn received Opt Out Notices from five Group Members who were seeking to opt out of the proceeding. In accordance with order 7 of the Settlement Notice Orders, I caused these Opt Out Notices to be sent to the NSW District Registry of the Court on 8 August 2016. 95.I also gave instructions to Naomi Hatcher, Trainee Lawyer employed in Maurice Blackburn’s Brisbane office, to contact the NSW District Registry in order to inspect the Court file to ascertain the number of Group Members who filed Opt Out Notices. As at the date of affirming this affidavit, a total of 43 Opt Out Notices have been lodged by Group Members (including the five Opt Out Notices received by Maurice Blackburn as described above). SECTION D – RESPONSE OF GROUP MEMBERS TO THE SETTLEMENT 96. Order 4 of the Settlement Notice Orders provides that if any Group Member wishes to oppose the Proposed Settlement, they may provide to Maurice Blackburn a written notice outlining the reasons why they oppose the settlement. 97.As at the date of affirming this affidavit, Maurice Blackburn has not received any written notices of objection from Group Members. 98.I am informed by Ms Hatcher that since sending the Notice to Group Members on 15 July 2016, Maurice Blackburn has received a total of 64 inquiries by telephone, email or post from Group Members in relation to the Proposed Settlement. 99.Subject to supervision by Ms Oliver and me, these inquiries have been primarily handled by Ms Hatcher, Geramie Bruno (Paralegal employed by Maurice Blackburn) and Jordan Mathas-Carleton (Paralegal employed by Maurice Blackburn). Where the inquiries were complex, they were escalated to Ms Oliver. Where necessary, I provided instructions to Ms Oliver, Ms Hatcher and the paralegal team as to how to respond to specific inquiries by Group Members. 100.For the purpose of this affidavit, the information in relation to Group Members’ responses to the settlement has been provided to me by Ms Oliver, Ms Hatcher, Mr Bruno and Mr Mathas-Carleton. 101.Of the 64 enquiries received by Maurice Blackburn, the main themes raised by Group Members were:(a)the nature of the opt out process and next steps; (b)the reasons for the settlement; and (c)whether there were any cost consequences in opting out or remaining in the class action.

Decision

Reasons for decision

More recently, on 2 September 2016, a further Opt Out Notice was received by the Court from Harry Fowler. Mr Fowler did not provide any reason as to why his Opt Out Notice was forwarded to the Court so long after the due date. I am not prepared to allow Mr Fowler to opt out in those circumstances. His Opt Out Notice will be placed into the folder forming part of Exhibit A and will be marked as “MFI-1”. Decision I have carefully considered Mr Watson’s assessment of the applicants’ prospects of success. I have also carefully considered the opinion of Counsel directed to that matter expressed both orally and in writing. I have also weighed in the balance the twin circumstances that the applicants are currently unfunded and that Maurice Blackburn is apparently owed many millions of dollars in unpaid legal fees and disbursements. The case is somewhat unusual in that neither the applicants nor any of the group members are to receive any compensation as part of the settlement. Nor is Maurice Blackburn to be paid any sum on account of fees and disbursements rendered to Argentum. Nor is Argentum to be paid anything at all. These essential features of the settlement were disclosed with clarity in the Notice of Settlement and Opt Out Notice which I ordered to be published and circulated as part of the orders made on 12 July 2016. I am satisfied that the essence of the settlement was notified to most (if not all) of the group members. Many enquiries were received from group members and quite a number have opted out. Finally, I wish to record that no group member attended at Court either on 12 July 2016 or on 30 August 2016 in order to oppose the making of the settlement approval orders. In the end, it seemed to me that the applicants had very little choice but to accept the only offer that the Commonwealth was prepared to make. For all of the above reasons, I made the requested settlement approval orders and other orders on 30 August 2016 in respect of which these Reasons are now published.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I have found his Honour’s distillation of the relevant principles to be most helpful and I propose to apply those principles in the present case to the extent that they are relevant and of assistance. Obviously, the extent to which any one or more particular factors will be taken into account will always depend upon the circumstances of each individual case.CONSIDERATION The orders which I made on 30 August 2016 were supported by Mr Schimmel’s affidavit and also by a confidential affidavit affirmed by Andrew John Watson on 23 August 2016. One of the orders which I made on 30 August 2016 was to suppress the contents of Mr Watson’s affidavit. Of necessity, the existence of that order constrains the contents of these Reasons for Judgment. However, there are some matters to which I take the view I am permitted to refer and I shall now do so.Mr Watson’s Evidence Mr Watson is a Principal of Maurice Blackburn. He is a senior legal practitioner with vast experience in conducting class actions on behalf of plaintiffs. In his affidavit, Mr Watson informed the Court of the course of the settlement negotiations which took place between the parties in May and June 2016. I am satisfied that Maurice Blackburn conducted those negotiations in the interests of the applicants and group members as a whole as rigorously and forcefully as the circumstances of the litigation then permitted. By May 2016, those circumstances included the obvious fact that the case was a difficult one for the applicants and the additional difficulty that Argentum had ceased funding the proceeding, leaving Maurice Blackburn out-of-pocket to the tune of many millions of dollars. In relation to the applicants’ prospects of success, Mr Watson recorded in his affidavit the substance of oral advice given in early 2016 by Counsel briefed to appear in the matter. The substance of that advice was subsequently reduced to writing in a detailed and thorough Confidential Opinion tendered before me at the hearing which took place on 30 August 2016. Mr Watson also placed before the Court his own independent assessment of the applicants’ prospects of success. At pars 42–49 of his Confidential Affidavit, Mr Watson explained his reasons and the rationale for the proposed settlement in some detail. In particular, he took into account the following matters:(a)The assessment of the applicants’ prospects of success given to him by Counsel earlier in 2016;(b)His own assessment of the applicants’ prospects of success; (c)The likelihood that the Commonwealth would appeal any adverse decision;(d)The fact that Maurice Blackburn had not been paid all of the fees and disbursements rendered to Argentum with the consequence that a very substantial sum was then due to Maurice Blackburn;(e)The likelihood that the quantum of the amount ultimately recovered, even if the applicants were largely successful, would not be sufficient to justify the further expenditure of significant funds on legal fees and disbursements for the trial; and(f)The prospect that the applicants may suffer an adverse costs order for many millions of dollars in the event that the Commonwealth was successful in defeating the applicants’ claims. Mr Schimmel’s Evidence