Clarke v Chief Executive Officer of Customs

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Criminal)

CLARKE v CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER OF CUSTOMS

Judgment of The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle

4 May 2005

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL AND INQUIRY AFTER CONVICTION - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - PARTICULAR GROUNDS

The appellant was convicted in the Magistrates Court for offences contrary to the Customs Act 1901 (Cth) - the offences related to the importation of four vehicles, one vehicle in particular that was released on incorrect documents - the appellant appeals those convictions and also the order as to costs - count 1: whether the defendant was the 'owner' of the goods for the purposes of s240(1) of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth) - was the prosecution required to prove which commercial documents had been issued and were required to be kept by the defendant - was the defendant required to keep the documents for the whole of the period referred to in the complaint - count 2: whether the Magistrate erred in finding that the defendant had not made an honest and reasonable mistake - whether the principal offence had been sufficiently proven resulting in the aiding and abetting charge - whether a vehicle was 'no longer subject to the control of Customs' as it had been 'forfeited to the Crown' under s229 - count 3: whether the Magistrate erred in finding that the appellant evaded duty payable with knowledge of incorrect documents - whether the appellant made an honest and reasonable mistake that the duty had been paid - whether liability to pay duty arose if the vehicle was not entered for home consumption - other grounds: whether the Magistrate's reasons were based on the averments in the complaint and on prosecution submissions to the extent that the Magistrate did not properly consider the matter and make independent findings as to the issues - whether the Magistrate erroneously relied on the averments for findings of law or of mixed law and fact - whether the Magistrate erred by admitting tape recorded interviews - whether the order as to costs by the Magistrate was manifestly excessive - appeal dismissed.

Customs Act 1901 (Cth) ss 183C, 71B, 77P(1), 240, 33(1), 229, 4, 234(1)(a), 234(2)(a); Motor Vehicle Standards Act 1989 (Cth), referred to.
R v Buckett (1985) 132 ALR 669, applied.
Giorgianni v The Queen (1985) 156 CLR 473, distinguished.
Ace Customs Services Pty Ltd v Collector of Customs (1991) 104 ALR 463, considered.

CLARKE v CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER OF CUSTOMS
[2005] SASC 165

Magistrates Appeal:  Criminal

  1. DOYLE CJ:          Mr Clarke was charged on complaint with three offences against provisions of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth) (“the Act”).

  2. In brief the offences were failing to keep certain records as required by the Act; aiding and abetting the movement of goods contrary to the Act, and evading duty payable under the Act.

  3. The charges were heard in the Magistrates Court.  After a hearing over several days the Magistrate found the charges proved and found…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clarke v Chief Executive Officer of Customs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] SASC 165
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Clarke v Chief Executive Officer of Customs involves an appeal by Mr Clarke against his convictions in the Magistrates Court for offences related to the importation of four vehicles under the Customs Act 1901 (Cth). The specific charges included allegations that Mr Clarke, acting as a customs broker, failed to keep the necessary documents for one of the vehicles, aided and abetted the movement of a vehicle contrary to the Act, and evaded duty payable by using incorrect documents. The appeal also contested the order regarding costs.

The central legal issues in the case revolved around the interpretation and application of various sections of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth), particularly concerning the definition of "owner" under s 4 and the obligations of an owner or agent to retain commercial documents as outlined in s 240(1). Additionally, the appeal questioned whether the Magistrate correctly assessed whether Mr Clarke made an honest and reasonable mistake and whether the duty was evaded with knowledge of incorrect documents. The appeal also argued that the Magistrate did not properly consider the evidence and submissions, instead relying too heavily on the prosecution's averments and submissions.

The court examined whether the Magistrate properly interpreted the statutory obligations and correctly applied the relevant legal principles. The court found that the Magistrate's reasoning, while using the language of the averments and submissions, did not indicate a failure to consider the evidence or to make independent findings. The court upheld the convictions, concluding that the Magistrate correctly assessed the evidence and applied the law. The appeal was dismissed, and the convictions and the order as to costs were upheld.

In conclusion, the court's decision affirmed the findings and convictions of the Magistrate, rejecting Mr Clarke's grounds of appeal. The reasoning demonstrated that the Magistrate's approach was sufficiently rigorous and that the appeal did not demonstrate any error warranting a reversal of the decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Clarke appeals against the convictions.Background The following matters are either not in contention or are supported by findings by the Magistrate that are no longer challenged, except when I indicate otherwise. Mr Clarke, at all material times, was a customs broker licensed under s 183C of the Act. In November 1998 he acted as broker in relation to the importation into Australia of four motor vehicles. The vehicles were described to Customs (the term used in the Act to refer to the Australian Customs Service) as follows:(a) 1983 Mercedes Benz 500 SEL (#HB677);(b) 1983 Mercedes Benz 190E (#FE384);(c) 1983 BMW 535I (#DZ1622); and(d) 1983 Mercedes Benz 500 SEC (#CL1683). The vehicles were placed in a licensed depot conducted by Austainer Services (“Austainer”) to be held there until they were entered and delivered for home consumption, and released from Customs control. In the ordinary course the goods would be released by Customs giving to the relevant person an authority to deal with a vehicle under s 71B of the Act. That would be subject to payment of the appropriate duty. There was an investigation into the value of the vehicles for duty purposes. I understand that a motor vehicle less than 15 years old attracted a substantial liability to duty that did not apply to a motor vehicle manufactured more than 15 years prior to the time of importing. It turned out that the fourth motor vehicle was manufactured in 1985, and not in 1983 as stated to Customs. Accordingly, it attracted the higher duty. In about June 1999 the first three motor vehicles were entered for home consumption, duty was paid on them, and they were released. Mr Clarke acted as broker or agent in connection with these events. The fourth vehicle remained at the Austainer depot. By s 77P(1) of the Act it was a condition of Austainer’s licence that goods be removed from the depot to a warehouse by the end of the month following their receipt. This was not done. For some time it seems nothing much was done about the fourth vehicle, possibly because the owner was waiting for the 15 years to elapse. Whatever the reason, after some time employees of Austainer began putting pressure on Mr Clarke to deal with the fourth vehicle. It was incurring storage charges. On 23 April 2001 Mr Zanardo, a Customs Officer, spoke to Mr Clarke. Mr Clarke told Mr Zanardo that he did not have the documents required to obtain the release of the fourth vehicle. There is no dispute that he asked Mr Zanardo for some documents, and that Mr Zanardo agreed to help him. Mr Zanardo arranged for Mr Clarke to be given three documents, which were tendered as P7, P8 and P9. Each of them is a copy of the entry for home consumption of one of the other three vehicles. Exhibit P8 related to the first vehicle, a 1983 Mercedes Benz 500SEL. On 23 May 2001 Mr Clarke spoke to Mr Olesen, another Customs Officer. Mr Clarke produced to him the entry for home consumption P8. It is, I understand, common ground that Mr Olesen then provided to Mr Clarke a copy of the “authority to deal” relating to the vehicle recorded on P8. This authority indicates that duty has been paid on the vehicle, the subject of the document. However, the identity of the vehicle referred to is not shown on the “authority to deal”. To identify the vehicle it was necessary to refer to the relevant entry for home consumption, P8. A copy of the authority was tendered as Exhibit P3.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Clarke also disputed the entitlement of the Prosecution to rely on the number of the averments found in the complaint.The Magistrate’s decision The Magistrate accepted the Prosecution case in substance. As to count 1 he found that Mr Clarke, as an agent with respect to the importation of the vehicles, was the “owner” as defined by s 4 of the Act. Accordingly, he was obliged to keep the relevant documents and had not kept them as required. As to count 2 the Magistrate found that the vehicle was moved contrary to the requirements of the Act. That was clearly the case. The Magistrate found that Mr Au was the principal offender, and that Mr Clarke was guilty as an aider and abetter. He found that Mr Clarke did not honestly and reasonably believe that the documents he presented to Austainer entitled him to obtain the release of the motor car. Although the findings are not expressed as clearly as they might be, it is clear enough that he was satisfied that Mr Clarke knew that the documents presented to obtain the release of the vehicle were not the documents required for the purposes of the Act. As to count 3 the Magistrate found that the duty was in fact payable and was evaded by the deception practised on Austainer by Mr Clarke and by Mr Au.Issues on appeal The notice of appeal complains that the Magistrate erred in treating the proceedings as summary proceedings in the criminal division of the Magistrates Court. This ground was not pursued on appeal. Mr Agresta, counsel for Mr Clarke, made a general challenge to the Magistrate’s reasons. He submits, correctly, that a substantial part of the Magistrate’s reasons consists of a repetition of the averments made on the complaint, followed by a repetition of the written submissions by counsel for the Prosecutor, made in response to a submission by the Defence of no case to answer. This was developed into a submission that the Magistrate failed to make findings of fact, and failed to distinguish between finding a case to answer and finding the charges proved beyond reasonable doubt. I do not accept this submission. It was open to the Magistrate, in the circumstances of this case, to make findings in terms of most of the averments, and to follow the sequence of the averments. The averments followed a logical sequence. The same applies to the Prosecutor’s submissions. They worked, in a logical fashion, through the factual issues before the Magistrate. The fact that the Magistrate expressed his findings substantially in the language used in the averments and in the submissions does not support an inference that he simply recited the Prosecution case, without considering its strength. Along the way, the Magistrate made occasional references to the evidence before him. He said that he was making findings. He did not adopt every averment. He made a finding that the Prosecution witnesses were truthful. I am not persuaded that the Magistrate failed to make proper findings of fact. Section 240(1) of the Act imposes the obligation to keep commercial documents on “(1) A person who is the owner of goods imported into Australia …”. The purpose of the provision is to give the Collector of Customs the opportunity to check the correctness of information given to the Collector. Section 4 defines “owner” as follows:Owner in respect of goods includes any person (other than an officer of Customs) being or holding himself out to be the owner, importer, exporter, consignee, agent, or person possessed of, or beneficially interested in, or having any control of, or power of disposition over the goods.I consider that this definition applies to s 240(1). It makes practical sense to require persons who deal with goods for an owner (in the narrow sense of the person entitled to the goods) or who deal with goods for the purpose of their transmission to the owner (in that same sense) to retain “commercial documents” as defined by the Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established