Civmec Electrical and Instrumental Pty Ltd v Southern Cross Electrical Engineering Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Civmec Electrical & Instrumental Pty Ltd v Southern Cross Electrical Engineering Limited & Ors [2019] QSC 300

PARTIES:

CIVMEC ELECTRICAL & INSTRUMENTAL PTY LTD
ABN 20 153 261 511

(applicant)

v
SOUTHERN CROSS ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING LIMITED
ABN 92 009 307 046

(first respondent)
RUSSELL WELSH ADJUDICATOR NO. J79539
(second respondent)
THE ADJUDICATION REGISTRAR, QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION
(third respondent) 

FILE NO:

BS7233 of 2019

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Originating application

DELIVERED ON:

13 December 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

13 September 2019

JUDGE:

Mullins J

ORDER:

1.     Originating application is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS – REMUNERATION – STATUTORY REGULATION OF ENTITLEMENT TO AND RECOVERY OF PROGRESS PAYMENTS – ADJUDICATION OF PAYMENT CLAIMS – where the applicant challenges the adjudicator’s decision for jurisdictional error – where the adjudicator did not have regard to submissions made by the applicant in the adjudication response which he decided were outside the reasons given in the payment schedule – whether it was within the adjudicator’s jurisdiction to decide whether the submissions were properly made

CONTRACTS – BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS – REMUNERATION – STATUTORY REGULATION OF ENTITLEMENT TO AND RECOVERY OF PROGRESS PAYMENTS – ADJUDICATION OF PAYMENT CLAIMS – where the applicant challenges the adjudicator’s decision for jurisdictional error – whether the adjudicator should have considered the pre-adjudication correspondence between the parties to give context to the reasons in the payment schedule for withholding payment

Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld), s 76, s 82, s 85, s 86, s 88, s 101

Bezzina Developers Pty Ltd v Deemah Stone (Qld) Pty Ltd [2008] 2 Qd R 495; [2008] QCA 213, considered
Clarence Street Pty Ltd v Isis Projects Pty Ltd (2005) 64 NSWLR 448; [2005] NSWCA 391, cited
Coordinated Construction Co Pty Ltd v Climatech (Canberra) Pty Ltd (2005) 21 BCL 364; [2005] NSWCA 229, considered
Craig v South Australia (1995) 184 CLR 163; [1995] HCA 58, considered
Façade Treatment Engineering Pty Ltd (in liq) v Brookfield Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd
(2016) 337 ALR 452; [2016] VSCA 247, cited
John Holland Pty Ltd v Roads & Traffic Authority of New South Wales (2007) 23 BCL 205; [2007] NSWCA 19, considered
Kirk v Industrial Court (NSW) (2010) 239 CLR 531; [2010] HCA 1, considered
Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd v Luikens [2003] NSWSC 1140, considered
Northbuild Construction Pty Ltd v Central Interior Linings Pty Ltd [2012] 1 Qd R 525; [2011] QCA 22, considered
Pittwater Council v Keystone Projects Group Pty Ltd [2014] NSWSC 1791, considered
State Water Corporation v Civil Team Engineering Pty Ltd [2013] NSWSC 1879, considered
Thiess Pty Ltd v Warren Brothers Earthmoving Pty Ltd [2012] QSC 373, considered
Trysams Pty Ltd v Club Constructions (NSW) Pty Ltd [2007] NSWSC 941, cited

COUNSEL:

N Andreatidis QC and F J Chen for the applicant

M H Hindman QC and M J…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Civmec Electrical and Instrumental Pty Ltd v Southern Cross... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 300
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Civmec Electrical and Instrumental Pty Ltd v Southern Cross Electrical Engineering Limited, the applicant challenged the adjudicator’s decision regarding the adjudication of payment claims under the Building and Construction Industry Payments Act 2004 (Vic). The primary issue for the court was whether the adjudicator was correct in not considering certain submissions made by the applicant, and whether the adjudicator should have taken into account the pre-adjudication correspondence between the parties to understand the context of the payment schedule's reasons for withholding payment.

The court examined the adjudicator's reasoning and found that the adjudicator did not consider certain submissions made by the applicant that went beyond the reasons given in the payment schedule. The adjudicator noted that these submissions were not contemplated in the statutory requirements and therefore were not considered. The court held that it was within the adjudicator's jurisdiction to decide whether these submissions were properly made and whether they should be considered. Additionally, the court concluded that the adjudicator should have taken into account the pre-adjudication correspondence to provide context to the reasons in the payment schedule, as this correspondence was relevant to the understanding of the claims and the reasons for withholding payment.

The court dismissed the originating application, affirming the adjudicator's decision. The adjudicator's approach to the claims was found to be consistent with the statutory requirements, and the reasons provided in the payment schedule were deemed sufficient for withholding payment. The court found no jurisdictional error in the adjudicator's decision, and thus, the application was unsuccessful.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Originating application is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Although this observation was made in respect of the operation of another provision of BCIPA, it provides the rationale for why any shorthand descriptions in the payment claim and payment schedule must also be intelligible to the adjudicator, in addition to the parties. The decision not to consider material characterised as new reasons In [56] of the adjudication decision, the adjudicator sets out the matters to which he had regard in making the decision and which mirror the matters listed in s 88(2) of the Act. In general terms, the adjudicator dealt with the new reasons he identified as advanced by the applicant in the adjudication response in [51] to [55] of the adjudication decision: “51. The [applicant] has made extensive submissions in its adjudication response.52. The [applicant’s] submissions go well beyond the reasons given in the payment schedule for withholding payment.53. I have not exercised my discretionary right under section 82(5) of the Act to require the [applicant] to resubmit the adjudication response.54. To the extent that the [applicant] has included new reasons for withholding payment contrary to section 82(4) of the act, these have not been considered.55. To remove doubt, where the [applicant] has identified contractual provisions which, in its opinion, the adjudicator is required to consider, as per paragraph 56 below, I confirm that I have considered the construction contract.” Group C claims – extension of time and prolongation Claim 9 in Group C for “extended preliminaries – personnel management and admin” was for $1,613,306 (exclusive of GST). The claim was based on a claim first notified to the applicant in the September claim report and described as relating to the additional time on site extended between the planned Date for Mechanical Completion of 1 June 2018 and the then forecasted target Date for Mechanical Completion of 31 October 2018 (without prejudice to the respondent’s Extension of Time (EOT) entitlement). The applicant in the payment schedule relied on the same six reasons for rejecting each of the Group C claims: “Non-compliance with Subcontract timeframes.No specific entitlement for this type of claim under a provision of the Subcontract.Subcontractor has not accounted for its own delays.Subcontractor has not considered Subclause 9.8Subcontractor has failed to demonstrate compliance with the Subcontract procedure· the Subcontractor failed to meet the requisite time limits as a precondition to any entitlement” It seems that the sixth reason provides the detail for the fifth reason. The respondent grouped the first, fifth and sixth reasons as the “time bar” arguments in section 11.2 of the adjudication application. Sections 11.5 to 11.13 of the adjudication application then dealt generally with the respondent’s response in the payment schedule to the applicant’s time bar arguments for Groups C to F claims, noting that they were only concerned with entitlements and no reasons were advanced in the payment schedule on quantum. The respondent asserted in section 11.11 that the applicant made “broad sweeping allegations of non compliance” with the subcontract procedure or time frame, but the payment schedule did not contain any detail. Section 12 of the adjudication application dealt specifically with claims 9 to 14 in Group C for EOT and prolongation. The respondent in section 12.23 set out its reasons for asserting there were no grounds for the applicant’s time bar argument, as the respondent had regularly and routinely kept the applicant informed of the likely events through a variety of means, including weekly construction reports, field delay forms, program updates and correspondence. The respondent then dealt in section 12.31 with the reasons, including references to clauses in the subcontract, for why the respondent submitted that entitlement was not barred simply because a claim was not submitted in time.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The submissions at the hearing in respect of the Group C claims were developed by reference to claim 9 in Group C. The applicant relied on the same arguments in relation to the other claims in the Group C. There is no basis to reach a different outcome on this application in relation to those other claims, than for claim 9 in Group C. Group D claims - acceleration Group D comprised acceleration claims. To illustrate the applicant’s complaints, submissions focused on claim 15 in Group D which was an acceleration claim for additional management personnel. The applicant’s response in the payment schedule for this claim (which was exactly the same response for all Group D claims) was as follows:“Non-compliance with Subcontract timeframes.No entitlement (See E105-CIV-SCE-131)Subcontractor has not accounted for its own delays and inefficiencies.Subcontractor has failed to demonstrate compliance with the Subcontract procedureSubcontractor failed to meet the requisite time limits as a precondition to any entitlement” The applicant had assessed all claims in Group D at an amount of nil in its payment schedule. The total amount for the Group D claims made by the respondent in its claim was $5,528,842 plus GST that was revised down to $4,643,116.74 plus GST in the adjudication application based on the respondent’s expert report of Mr Worthington. The adjudicator dealt with the generic reasons for the applicant’s refusal of the Group D claims at [1136] to [1139] of the adjudication decision. The adjudicator found at [1136] that “Non-compliance with Subcontract timeframes” was very general and non-specific and was not a valid reason for withholding payment. The same conclusions were applied at [1138] to the reason “Subcontractor has not accounted for its own delays and inefficiencies”. The adjudicator noted at [1139] that in asserting “Subcontractor failed to meet the requisite time limits as a precondition to any entitlement” the applicant had not detailed which provision in the Subcontract upon which it relied to reject the claims and it was therefore not a valid reason for withholding payment. As for the same reasons relied on for the Group C claims, the adjudicator treated the fifth reason in the payment schedule as the detail for the fourth reason. At [1137], the adjudicator observed that, in respect of the reason “No entitlement (See E105-CIV-SCE-131)”, the applicant had provided its response to the respondent’s acceleration claim in which it rejected the claim entirely. It is apparent therefore that the adjudicator had regard to the contents of letter #131 to the extent that it dealt with the applicant’s position on why the respondent had no entitlement to make the acceleration claim. The adjudicator then analysed the Group D claims by reference to entitlement and quantum. The adjudicator noted at [1142] the respondent’s position that:“… it is entitled to acceleration costs for the respondent’s direction to accelerate the performance of the Works pursuant to GCS clause 48.1, which it says falls under the definition of ‘variation’ under GCS clause 1 and for which it is entitled to an adjustment of the subcontract price pursuant to GCS clause.”