City of Stonnington v Wallish

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION

PROPERTY LIST

S ECI 2019 02049

IN THE MATTER of an application pursuant to s 84 of the Property Law Act 1958

- and -

IN THE MATTER of an application by City of Stonnington to discharge, or in the alternative modify, the restrictive covenants affecting the land as 32A Chadstone Road, Malvern East, otherwise known as Percy Treyvaud Memorial Park, being the land more particularly described in Schedule A of the Originating Motion, filed 9 May 2019

BETWEEN

CITY OF STONNINGTON Plaintiff
v 
ADAM LINCOLN WALLISH & ORS
(according to the attached Schedule)
Defendant

---

JUDGE:

Ierodiaconou AsJ

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

30 November, 1 and 3 December 2020

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

1 March 2021

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

City of Stonnington v Wallish & Ors

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2021] VSC 84

---

PROPERTY LAW – Restrictive covenants – Public park – Covenants restricting excavation – Plaintiff’s application to discharge the covenants, alternatively for a declaration, alternatively for modification to the covenants – How the restrictive covenants ought be interpreted – Whether plaintiff proved that modification will not cause substantial injury to the beneficiaries of the covenants – Whether the restrictive covenants are obsolete – Covenants to be discharged – Declaration unnecessary – Vrakas v Registrar of Titles [2008] VSC 281 – Clare v Bedelis [2016] VSC 381 – Hivance Pty Ltd v Moscatiello [2020] VSC 183 – Property Law Act 1958 s 84(1)(a), (c) – Application successful.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff Mr M D Townsend with Ms N Blok Maddocks
For the Defendant Mr T S Pikusa Harris Carlson Lawyers

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Summary.............................................................................................................................................. 2

The restrictive covenants.................................................................................................................. 2

Evidence............................................................................................................................................... 3

Section 84 of the Property Law Act................................................................................................ 5

How ought the restriction in the covenants be interpreted?..................................................... 6

Plaintiff’s submissions.................................................................................................................. 6

Defendants’ submissions............................................................................................................. 8

Analysis........................................................................................................................................ 10

Will modification or discharge of the covenants cause no substantial injury to beneficiaries in accordance with s 84(1)(c) of the Act?..................................................................................... 19

Plaintiff’s submissions................................................................................................................ 19

Defendants’ submissions........................................................................................................... 22

Analysis........................................................................................................................................ 25

Ought the covenants be deemed obsolete pursuant to s 84(1)(a) of the Act?....................... 33

Plaintiff’s submissions................................................................................................................ 33

Defendants’ submissions........................................................................................................... 35

Analysis........................................................................................................................................ 36

Conclusion......................................................................................................................................... 37

HER HONOUR:

  1. City of Stonnington, the plaintiff, seeks to discharge or modify restrictive covenants which affect the land known as Percy Treyvaud Memorial Park, 32A Chadstone Road, Malvern East.

  1. The application is made pursuant to ss 84(1)(a) and (c) of the Property Law Act 1958 (‘the Act’).  The plaintiff intends to construct basketball and netball stadiums, a new lawn bowls rink, an underground carpark and social facilities on the subject land (‘the proposal’).

  1. A sample covenant follows:

… HEREBY COVENANTS with the said Company and its [transferees] registered proprietor or proprietors for the time being of the untransferred land comprised in the said Certificate of Title and every part thereof that he his heirs executors administrators or transferees will not excavate carry away or remove or permit…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read City of Stonnington v Wallish and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] VSC 84
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The City of Stonnington sought to discharge restrictive covenants in relation to a public park, with an alternative application for a declaration or modification of the covenants. The application was opposed by the owners of the neighbouring property, Mr and Mrs Wallish. The dispute was heard by Justice Gray in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The central issue was the interpretation of restrictive covenants placed on the land, which restricted excavation activities. The City of Stonnington argued that the covenants were obsolete and should be discharged, or alternatively, that they should be modified to allow for necessary excavation work. The Wallishes contended that any modification to the covenants would cause substantial injury to them as beneficiaries of the covenants.

Justice Gray considered the relevant case law, including Vrakas v Registrar of Titles, Clare v Bedelis, and Hivance Pty Ltd v Moscatiello, to interpret the restrictive covenants. The Court held that the restrictive covenants were intended to preserve the land as a public park and prevent excavation that would interfere with this purpose. However, the Court found that the City of Stonnington had proven that the current state of the land no longer required the restrictive covenants to be enforced as originally intended. Furthermore, the Wallishes had not demonstrated that any modification would cause them substantial injury. Therefore, the Court found that the restrictive covenants were obsolete and should be discharged.

In conclusion, Justice Gray allowed the City of Stonnington's application to discharge the restrictive covenants. The Court found that a declaration or modification of the covenants was unnecessary, as the covenants were obsolete and should be discharged outright. The Court referred to the relevant provisions of the Property Law Act 1958 to support its decision. No further orders were made.