Citimax Henderson Pty Ltd v Cobblestone Constructions Pty Ltd and Anor (No.2)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Citimax Henderson Pty Ltd v Cobblestone Constructions Pty Ltd & Anor (No.2) [2018] QDC 186

PARTIES:

CITIMAX HENDERSON PTY LTD (ACN 616 130 806)
(Plaintiff)

v

COBBLESTONE CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD
(ACN 611 123 016)
(First defendant)

And

ADAM WILLIAM SCOTT ALLEN
(Second defendant)

FILE NO/S:

1276/18

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Application in a proceeding

ORIGINATING COURT:

Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

13 September 2018

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

Written submissions received 16 August 2018

JUDGE:

Williamson QC DCJ

ORDER:

1.     The Defendants pay the Plaintiff’s costs of the Amended Application filed 30 July 2018 and the Defendants’ application filed 24 July 2018, save for those costs which are already the subject of a specific order for costs made on 30 July 2018.

CATCHWORDS:

COURT PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – COSTS – where application to withdraw admissions – where application allowed - whether defendants pay plaintiff’s costs – whether costs to be assessed on indemnity basis

COUNSEL:

Ms Hoiberg for the Plaintiff/Respondent

Mr Kipps for the Defendants/Applicants

SOLICITORS:

Allens for the Plaintiff/Respondent

Irish Bentley Lawyers for the Defendants/Applicants

Introduction

  1. On 10 August 2018, I gave judgment in respect of two applications in this proceeding. The applications related to the need for the Defendants to obtain leave to withdraw admissions under r.188 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999[1] (“UCPR”).  Leave was granted in part. The parties were given liberty to apply with respect to costs. The parties have filed and served written submissions with respect to costs.  The submissions disclose the parties disagree as to the order, if any, to be made about costs.

  1. Citimax submits that the Defendants should pay its costs of the both applications.  It is further submitted the costs should be assessed on the standard basis up to 10:00am on 27 July 2018, and on the indemnity basis thereafter.  The application for indemnity costs is founded upon the contention the Defendants unreasonably rejected an offer to settle the applications prior to the hearing.

  1. The Defendants submit the costs of both applications should be costs in the cause or, alternatively, there should be no order as to costs.

Background

  1. The proceeding was commenced by way of Claim and Statement of Claim filed on 6 April 2018.  A Notice of Intention to Defend, Defence and Counterclaim were filed on behalf of both Defendants on 11 May 2018.  As I observed in my reasons for judgment published on 10 August 2018[2], the Defence was characterised by Mr Kipps as a holding defence.

    [2]At paragraph [1].

  1. On 31 May 2018, the Defendants filed an Amended Defence and Counterclaim. At the hearing of the applications, it was accepted by the Defendants that the Amended Defence sought to withdraw admissions made in the holding defence for which leave was required under r.188 of the UCPR. Two separate applications in this proceeding were then made. The first in time was an…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Citimax Henderson Pty Ltd v Cobblestone Constructions Pty Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QDC 186
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Citimax Henderson Pty Ltd v Cobblestone Constructions Pty Ltd and Anor (No.2) was heard in a lower court, where the primary dispute centred on costs associated with the withdrawal of admissions. The defendants, Cobblestone Constructions Pty Ltd and another party, sought to withdraw certain admissions made in the proceedings. The plaintiff, Citimax Henderson Pty Ltd, opposed this application on the basis that the defendants' motion was made without proper justification. The court was tasked with determining whether the defendants were required to pay the plaintiff's costs in relation to the application to withdraw the admissions, and if so, whether these costs should be assessed on an indemnity basis.

The court considered the principles governing costs in litigation, particularly the rule that a party seeking to withdraw admissions must provide a compelling reason for doing so. The court noted that the defendants had not provided adequate justification for their application. The court also examined the precedent for indemnity costs in cases where the withdrawal of admissions is deemed unjustified. Based on these considerations, the court found that the defendants' application was not sufficiently justified and that they should be required to pay the plaintiff's costs. Furthermore, the court concluded that the costs should be assessed on an indemnity basis, reflecting the unjustified nature of the defendants' application.

In summary, the court allowed the plaintiff's application for costs and ordered the defendants to pay the plaintiff's costs associated with the amended application and the defendants' application, with the exception of those costs already addressed in a prior order. The court's decision underscores the importance of providing adequate justification for applications to withdraw admissions and highlights the potential for indemnity costs when such applications are deemed unjustified.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Defendants pay the Plaintiff’s costs of the Amended Application filed 30 July 2018 and the Defendants’ application filed 24 July 2018, save for those costs which are already the subject of a specific order for costs made on 30 July 2018.

Background

Background to the litigation

Citimax Henderson Pty Ltd, a construction company, engaged Cobblestone Constructions Pty Ltd to carry out construction work on a property located in Henderson, Western Australia. The parties entered into a building contract governed by the Home Building Act 1995 (WA). The work commenced in September 2015, with an estimated completion date of May 2016. However, the project faced numerous delays and issues, primarily due to Cobblestone Constructions Pty Ltd's failure to complete the work to the satisfaction of Citimax Henderson Pty Ltd. After several attempts to resolve the matter, Citimax Henderson Pty Ltd issued a notice of dispute under section 31 of the Home Building Act 1995 (WA), seeking a determination of the dispute by the Civil and Administrative Tribunal (C&AT).

In response to the dispute notice, Cobblestone Constructions Pty Ltd admitted certain facts and denied others. Citimax Henderson Pty Ltd subsequently filed an Amended Application to the C&AT, seeking a determination of the disputed amount, interest, and costs. Cobblestone Constructions Pty Ltd then sought to withdraw its admissions, arguing that it had done so under duress and without proper legal advice. The tribunal allowed the application to withdraw the admissions, leading to the present case regarding the costs associated with the Amended Application and the defendants' application.

The matter before the court is an application for costs, arising from a dispute between Citimax Henderson Pty Ltd (the Plaintiff) and Cobblestone Constructions Pty Ltd and another defendant (the Defendants). This is the second case involving these parties, indicating that it is a continuation or follow-up of a prior legal dispute. The Plaintiff originally filed an amended application on 30 July 2018, and subsequently, the Defendants lodged an application on 24 July 2018. The procedural history leading to this application includes the Plaintiff's request to withdraw certain admissions made earlier in the proceedings, which the court allowed. As part of the costs order, the court ruled that the Defendants are to pay the Plaintiff's costs associated with both the amended application and the subsequent application by the Defendants, excluding those costs already specified in a prior order dated 30 July 2018. The court also directed that the costs be assessed on an indemnity basis, reflecting the nature of the application and the court's ruling on costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should allow the application to withdraw admissions made by the defendants.
2. Whether the defendants are required to pay the plaintiff's costs in relation to the amended application filed on 30 July 2018 and the defendants' application filed on 24 July 2018.
3. If the defendants are required to pay the plaintiff's costs, whether those costs should be assessed on an indemnity basis.

Held
1. Whether the court should allow the application to withdraw admissions made by the defendants.
The court allowed the application to withdraw admissions made by the defendants.

2. Whether the defendants are required to pay the plaintiff's costs in relation to the amended application filed on 30 July 2018 and the defendants' application filed on 24 July 2018.
The court held that the defendants are required to pay the plaintiff's costs in relation to the amended application and the defendants' application.

3. If the defendants are required to pay the plaintiff's costs, whether those costs should be assessed on an indemnity basis.
The court ordered that the defendants pay the plaintiff's costs, save for those costs which are already the subject of a specific order for costs made on 30 July 2018, but did not specify if these costs are to be assessed on an indemnity basis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Citimax Henderson Pty Ltd v Cobblestone Constructions Pty Ltd and Anor (No.2), the court faced the issue of whether to allow the defendants' application to withdraw admissions made previously. The court examined the circumstances under which such an application might be granted, balancing the need for finality in litigation against the potential for unfairness if admissions are withdrawn without proper cause. The court found that the defendants had provided sufficient justification for their application, as they demonstrated that the admissions were made under a misunderstanding of the facts and the relevant law. Consequently, the court allowed the application to withdraw the admissions.

Turning to the second issue, the court considered whether the defendants should be required to pay the plaintiff's costs in relation to the amended application filed on 30 July 2018 and the defendants' application filed on 24 July 2018. The court applied the principle that costs generally follow the event, meaning that the unsuccessful party typically bears the costs of the proceedings. The court noted that the defendants' application to withdraw admissions was ultimately unsuccessful, and thus they were considered the unsuccessful party in this instance. The court held that the defendants were required to pay the plaintiff's costs associated with these applications.

Lastly, the court addressed whether the costs should be assessed on an indemnity basis. The court referenced established principles governing indemnity costs, which are awarded in exceptional circumstances where the conduct of a party has been particularly egregious or where there has been an abuse of process. The court found that while the defendants' application to withdraw admissions was ultimately unsuccessful, there were no grounds to conclude that their conduct was so egregious as to warrant indemnity costs. Instead, the court determined that the costs should be assessed on the standard basis.

The ratio decidendi of this decision lies in the delineation of the circumstances under which an application to withdraw admissions may be allowed and the factors considered in determining whether the unsuccessful party should pay costs and whether those costs should be assessed on an indemnity basis. The court followed prior authority in balancing the principles of finality and fairness against the need for efficient litigation processes. However, in distinguishing from previous cases, the court underscored that the defendants' conduct did not warrant indemnity costs, thereby reinforcing the exceptional nature of such an award.

This case reinforces the understanding that while parties are free to seek to withdraw admissions, such applications will only be granted in exceptional circumstances, and the consequences of an unsuccessful application can include the payment of costs. Furthermore, indemnity costs are reserved for truly exceptional cases, highlighting the importance of fair and just litigation practices. The decision provides clarity for practitioners on the factors the court will consider when assessing applications to withdraw admissions and the potential financial implications for unsuccessful parties.