Citi Project Marketing (Qld) Pty Ltd v VG Projects Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Citi Project Marketing (Qld) Pty Ltd and Anor v VG projects Pty Ltd and Ors [2017] QSC 65

PARTIES:

CITI PROJECT MARKETING (QLD) PTY LTD
ACN 602 230 419

(first applicant)
SAMSARA ONE PTY LTD ACN 162 172 205
(second applicant)
v
VG PROJECTS PTY LTD ACN 150 396 311
(first respondent)
CHRISTOPHER JOHN VITALE

(second respondent)
PAUL GEDOUN
(third respondent)
POINTCORP HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 168 808 151
(fourth respondent)
SAMUEL BRIAN PATTERSON

(fifth respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 12975 of 2016

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

28 April 2017

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

3 February 2017

JUDGE:

Martin J

ORDER:

1.   The winding up application is dismissed.

2.   It is declared that the Extraordinary General Meeting of 24 December 2016 and the resolutions passed at it were valid.

CATCHWORDS:

CORPORATIONS – WINDING UP – WINDING UP IN INSOLVENCY – OTHER GROUNDS FOR WINDING UP – JUST AND EQUITABLE – IMPOSSIBILITY OF EFFECTIVELY CARRYING ON BUSINESS – where the relationship between shareholders has broken down – whether the corporation is a quasi-partnership – whether the purpose of the corporation has failed – whether the corporation should be wound up on the just and equitable ground

CORPORATIONS – MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATION – MEETINGS – MEETINGS OF DIRECTORS – QUORUM – where Extraordinary General Meeting lacked quorum – where lack of quorum constituted a procedural irregularity – whether that irregularity caused a substantial injustice that could not be remedied by any order of the Court – whether the Extraordinary General Meeting and the resolutions passed at it should be declared valid

Corporations Act 2001

Chalet Nominees(1999) Pty Ltd v Murray [2012] WASC 147

Cumberland Holdings Ltd v Washington H Soul Pattinson & Co Limited (1977) 13 ALR 561

Ebrahimi v Westbourne Galleries Limited [1973] AC 360

Greig v Australian Building Industries Pty Ltd [2002] QSC 138

Guerinoni v Argyle Concrete & Quarry Supplies Pty Ltd (1999) 34 ACSR 469

Malos v Malos (2003) 44 ACSR 511

Morgan v 45 Flers Avenue Pty Ltd (1986) 10 ACLR 692

Neena v ASIC (2011) 198 FCR 32

Netbush Pty Ltd v Fascine Developments Pty Ltd (2005) 189 FLR 320

Re Compaction Systems Pty Ltd [1976] 2 NSWLR 477

Re Dalkeith Investments Pty Ltd (1984) 9 ACSR 247

Re Pembury Pty Ltd [1993] 1 Qd R 125

Re Tivoli Freeholds Ltd [1972] VR 445

Re Yenidge Tobacco Co Ltd [1916] 2 Ch 426

Ruut v Head (1996) 20 ACSR 160

Stapp v Serge Holdings Pty Ltd (1999) 31 ACSR 35

Thomas v Mackay Investments Pty Ltd (1996) 22 ACSR 294

Turner v Ulicorp Pty Ltd [2007] NSWSC 206

Whitehouse v Capital Radio Network Pty Ltd (2004) 13 Tas R 27

COUNSEL:

D Savage QC and M Jones for the second applicant and fifth respondent

P Dunning QC and M D Alexander for the second, third and fourth respondents

SOLICITORS:

Tucker & Cowen for the second applicant and fifth respondent

HWL…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Citi Project Marketing (Qld) Pty Ltd v VG Projects Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QSC 65
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Citi Project Marketing (Qld) Pty Ltd and VG Projects Pty Ltd were parties to a legal dispute heard by the Queensland Supreme Court. The dispute involved an application by Citi Project Marketing to wind up VG Projects on the just and equitable ground and a challenge by VG Projects to the validity of an Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM) held by Citi Project Marketing. The key legal issues included whether the relationship breakdown between the shareholders justified a winding up order under the just and equitable principle and whether the lack of quorum at the EGM constituted a procedural irregularity that caused substantial injustice.

The court found that Citi Project Marketing was not a quasi-partnership, and while there was a breakdown in relationships between the shareholders, this did not prevent the company from functioning and paying its creditors. The company's purpose had not failed, and it was in a liquid state. The court also concluded that there were other avenues for redress available to the shareholder who brought the winding up application. Therefore, the court dismissed the winding up application. Regarding the EGM, the court determined that the absence of a quorum constituted a procedural irregularity but found no substantial injustice caused by this irregularity. The court declared the EGM and the resolutions passed at it to be valid.

The court's final orders were that the winding up application be dismissed and that the EGM of 24 December 2016 and the resolutions passed at it were declared valid.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The winding up application is dismissed.

2. It is declared that the Extraordinary General Meeting of 24 December 2016 and the resolutions passed at it were valid.

Background

Background to the litigation

Citi Project Marketing (Qld) Pty Ltd (Citi) was a company with a small number of shareholders, including Mr Patterson, Mr Gedoun, and Mr Vitale. The relationship between the shareholders deteriorated significantly, leading to a breakdown in their professional and personal relationship. Mr Patterson applied for an Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM) which was called for 24 December 2016. Mr Patterson ensured that the meeting was not quorate, which he argued was an irregularity. However, he did not attend the meeting, which passed resolutions to remove him as a director and replace him with Mr Gedoun. Mr Patterson then applied to the Court for a winding up order against Citi on the grounds that it was just and equitable to do so because of the breakdown in relationships between the shareholders, the failure of the purpose of the corporation, and the impossibility of effectively carrying on business. Citi and other shareholders opposed the application, asserting that the company was functioning well, paying its creditors, and had sufficient assets to meet its liabilities.

The case came before the Court as an application by Mr Patterson for a winding up order against Citi. Mr Patterson argued that the relationship between the shareholders had broken down, making it just and equitable to wind up the company. Citi and other shareholders opposed the application, contending that the company was functioning properly and that there were alternative remedies available to Mr Patterson. The Court heard evidence from the parties and considered the procedural irregularity of the EGM held on 24 December 2016, which Mr Patterson had deliberately rendered inquorate. The Court was required to decide whether this irregularity caused a substantial injustice that could not be remedied by any order of the Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Gedoun deposes to the damage which could be occasioned by a winding up order. He says it would “cause significant detriment to the operations of the Pointcorp Group if Citi was wound up.” This, he says, would come about in at least two ways:(a)first, through the negative publicity which would accompany the making of such an order, and(b)secondly, “the winding up of an entity of [which Mr Vitale and Mr Gedoun] are shareholders and … directors … would be an act of default under many of Pointcorp Group’s loan accounts. Currently there are approximately one hundred loan facilities with different financiers executed by Mr Vitale [and Mr Gedoun] , on behalf of Pointcorp Group.”Conclusion on the winding up application The evidence allows for the following conclusions: (a)Citi is not and never was a quasi-partnership;(b)there has been a breakdown in relationships between the shareholders;(c)the breakdown has not prevented the company from functioning and paying its creditors;(d)Citi’s purpose has not failed;(e)Citi is liquid; and(f)There are other avenues for redress available for Mr Patterson. A winding up order will not be made simply on the demand of a disgruntled shareholder. The application is dismissed.The EGM of 24 December 2016 The Extraordinary General Meeting of 24 December 2016 was called by Mr Patterson and was deliberately rendered inquorate by Mr Patterson. Samsara argues that the absence of a quorum is an irregularity but one that has caused Samsara and Mr Patterson no substantial injustice. Section 1322 of the Corporations Act 2001 deals with irregularities and, so far as is relevant, provides:“(1)In this section, unless the contrary intention appears:(a) a reference to a proceeding under this Act is a reference to any proceeding whether a legal proceeding or not; and(b) a reference to a procedural irregularity includes a reference to:(i)the absence of a quorum at a meeting of a corporation, at a meeting of directors or creditors of a corporation, at a joint meeting of creditors and members of a corporation or at a meeting of members of a registered scheme; and(ii)a defect, irregularity or deficiency of notice or time.(2)A proceeding under this Act is not invalidated because of any procedural irregularity unless the Court is of the opinion that the irregularity has caused or may cause substantial injustice that cannot be remedied by any order of the Court and by order declares the proceeding to be invalid.…(4)Subject to the following provisions of this section but without limiting the generality of any other provision of this Act, the Court may, on application by any interested person, make all or any of the following orders, either unconditionally or subject to such conditions as the Court imposes:(a) an order declaring that any act, matter or thing purporting to have been done, or any proceeding purporting to have been instituted or taken, under this Act or in relation to a corporation is not invalid by reason of any contravention of a provision of this Act or a provision of the constitution of a corporation;(b) an order directing the rectification of any register kept by ASIC under this Act;(c) an order relieving a person in whole or in part from any civil liability in respect of a contravention or failure of a kind referred to in paragraph (a);(d) an order extending the period for doing any act, matter or thing or instituting or taking any proceeding under this Act or in relation to a corporation (including an order extending a period where the period concerned ended before the application for the order was made) or abridging the period for doing such an act, matter or thing or instituting or taking such a proceeding;and may make such consequential or ancillary orders as the Court thinks fit.(5)An order may be made under paragraph (4)(a) or (c) notwithstanding that the contravention or failure referred to in the paragraph concerned resulted in the commission of an offence.(6)The Court must not make an order under this section unless it is satisfied:(a) in the case of an order referred to in paragraph (4)(a):(i)that the act, matter or thing, or the proceeding, referred to in that paragraph is essentially of a procedural nature;(ii)that the person or persons concerned in or party to the contravention or failure acted honestly; or(iii)that it is just and equitable that the order be made; and(b) in the case of an order referred to in paragraph (4)(c)—that the person subject to the civil liability concerned acted honestly; and(c) in every case—that no substantial injustice has been or is likely to be caused to any person.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court found that Citi was not a quasi-partnership and therefore, the breakdown in relationships between the shareholders was not sufficient grounds for winding up the company on the just and equitable ground. The court held that the breakdown had not prevented Citi from functioning and paying its creditors, and the purpose of Citi had not failed. The court also found that there were other avenues for redress available for Mr Patterson, and a winding up order would not be made simply on the demand of a disgruntled shareholder. Regarding the Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM) of 24 December 2016, the court determined that the absence of a quorum constituted a procedural irregularity, but one that did not cause any substantial injustice. Section 1322 of the Corporations Act 2001 was considered, and it was concluded that the irregularity did not cause or may cause substantial injustice that could not be remedied by any order of the Court. Therefore, the EGM and the resolutions passed at it were declared valid. The court's decision highlights the importance of maintaining proper quorum at meetings and the consequences of failing to do so.