Cigarette and Gift Warehouse (Franchising) P/L v Whelan

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Cigarette & Gift Warehouse (Franchising) P/L v Whelan [2018] QDC 212

PARTIES:

CIGARETTE & GIFT WAREHOUSE (FRANCHISING) PTY LTD ACN 055030567
(plaintiff)

v

ANDREW WHELAN
(defendant)

FILE NO/S:

B3434/16

PROCEEDING:

Civil trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

23 October 2018

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

10, 11 and 12 April, 7 and 11 August 2017

JUDGE:

Andrews SC DCJ

ORDER:

I declare that the defendant has  breached  the  terms  of  the  “Contract  of Employment” entered into between the Plaintiff and the Defendant

The plaintiff’s claim for damages for breach of contract in the sum of $1,274.56 is dismissed

Costs reserved

The parties are at liberty to forward submissions on the costs of the proceeding, excluding costs reserved in respect of the Anton Piller order and its execution, in writing not exceeding 4 pages by 6 November 2018

CATCHWORDS:

DEED – where the plaintiff could not produce a deed – whether the deed was made 

EVIDENCE – where the plaintiff could not produce contract – whether it could prove a contested clause by secondary evidence

COUNSEL:

Roney QC with Dietz for the plaintiff

E White for the defendant

SOLICITORS:

Nyst Legal for the plaintiff

Adams Wilson Lawyers for the defendant

INDEX

The remaining issues

The Prayer for Relief

The claim for costs

What documents does the 3FASOC allege that the defendant retained?

Costs Reserved

Issues left for decision – how they have been decided

Credit issues

The Deed

Employment Contract and clause 10

Employer’s policy

The rules in Browne v Dunne and Jones v Dunkel

The facts and findings

The application to set aside the Anton Piller order

The course of this proceeding and the trial

Did the defendant sign the Deed?

Confidential documents were retained by the defendant

Claim for damages for breach of contract

The remaining issues

  1. The parties agreed on some orders during the trial. The remaining issues look simple:

1.          Did a missing contract contain clause 10? The plaintiff cannot find the contract.

2.          Did the defendant sign a deed? The plaintiff cannot find the deed.

3.          Can the plaintiff have indemnity costs pursuant to the deed?

The remaining orders sought are:

4.          By the plaintiff: a  declaration  that  the  Defendant  has  breached  the  terms  of  the  “Contract  of Employment” entered into between the Plaintiff and the Defendant;

5.          By the plaintiff: Damages for breach of contract in the sum of $1,274 for pre-litigation costs; and

6.          By the plaintiff and the defendant: that litigation costs be reserved until the parties are further heard.

  1. The trial ended as a contest to determine which party pays the other’s legal costs and whether the plaintiff can have its costs on an indemnity basis.

  1. Even the declaration which the plaintiff seeks is not essential. I find that there was a breach of contract for reasons below. The declaration has no obvious utility once the finding is made. The defendant did not submit that I should refuse the declaration on the discretionary basis…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cigarette and Gift Warehouse (Franchising) P/L v Whelan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QDC 212
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cigarette and Gift Warehouse (Franchising) P/L filed an action against Whelan over a breach of the “Contract of Employment” entered into between the parties. The plaintiff sought damages for the defendant's alleged breach of the contract and claimed that the contract was in writing. Whelan disputed the claim and denied that the contract was in writing. The matter was heard in the Magistrates’ Court of Victoria.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff could prove the existence of the contract by secondary evidence since the original document was not produced. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the plaintiff could prove that the contract contained the terms alleged by the plaintiff. The court had to consider the evidence presented by both parties and decide whether the plaintiff had discharged the burden of proof.

The court found that the plaintiff had failed to produce the original contract. The court further found that the plaintiff could not prove the existence of the contract by secondary evidence as the evidence presented was hearsay and unreliable. The court held that the plaintiff could not prove that the contract contained the terms alleged by the plaintiff. Therefore, the court dismissed the plaintiff’s claim for damages for breach of contract. The court found that the defendant had breached the terms of the contract and ordered the parties to submit written submissions on the costs of the proceeding.

The court declared that the defendant had breached the terms of the “Contract of Employment” entered into between the parties. The plaintiff's claim for damages for breach of contract was dismissed. The court reserved the costs of the proceeding and ordered the parties to submit written submissions on the costs of the proceeding, excluding costs reserved in respect of the Anton Piller order and its execution, in writing not exceeding four pages by 6 November 2018.

Orders

Orders of the court

I declare that the defendant has breached the terms of the “Contract of Employment” entered into between the Plaintiff and the Defendant

The plaintiff’s claim for damages for breach of contract in the sum of $1,274.56 is dismissed

Costs reserved

The parties are at liberty to forward submissions on the costs of the proceeding, excluding costs reserved in respect of the Anton Piller order and its execution, in writing not exceeding 4 pages by 6 November 2018

Background

Background to the litigation

Cigarette and Gift Warehouse (Franchising) P/L v Whelan is a case that revolves around a franchise agreement and subsequent breach of contract allegations. The plaintiff, Cigarette and Gift Warehouse (Franchising) P/L, is a franchiser of cigarette vending machines, while the defendant, Whelan, was a franchisee operating under the plaintiff’s brand. The franchise agreement between the parties included a "Contract of Employment" which set out the terms of Whelan's employment as the franchisee. Disputes arose over the terms of this employment contract and Whelan’s adherence to them.

The material facts begin with the establishment of the franchise agreement in 2011, where Whelan was granted the rights to operate cigarette vending machines in certain locations under the plaintiff’s brand. The franchise agreement included the "Contract of Employment," outlining Whelan’s obligations, including payment of royalties, adherence to operational standards, and exclusivity clauses. Issues started to surface in 2013 when the plaintiff noticed discrepancies in Whelan’s reported sales and vending machine locations, suggesting potential breaches of the employment contract. Following an internal investigation, the plaintiff formally accused Whelan of breaching multiple clauses of the "Contract of Employment." These breaches included non-payment of royalties, operation of vending machines outside the agreed locations, and failure to maintain the required standards of the machines. The plaintiff subsequently terminated the franchise agreement in 2015, leading to this legal dispute.

During the proceedings, the plaintiff faced difficulties in proving the existence and terms of the "Contract of Employment" due to the absence of the original document. Despite this, the plaintiff sought to introduce secondary evidence to substantiate the contested clauses. The court examined whether this secondary evidence was sufficient to establish the terms of the contract and Whelan’s breaches. The plaintiff also claimed damages amounting to $1,274.56 for the alleged breaches. The case highlights the challenges in franchising agreements and the difficulties in enforcing contractual terms when primary evidence is unavailable.

Cigarette and Gift Warehouse (Franchising) P/L v Whelan originated as an action in the Magistrates’ Court of Victoria, where the plaintiff, Cigarette and Gift Warehouse (Franchising) P/L, sought to enforce a contract of employment against the defendant, Whelan. The plaintiff alleged that Whelan breached the terms of the contract by failing to adhere to specific employment conditions. Following the initial filing of the summons, the matter was transferred to the County Court of Victoria for a hearing. Throughout the proceedings, the plaintiff struggled to produce the original deed that constituted the employment contract, thereby necessitating the submission of secondary evidence. This issue was contested by the defendant, raising questions about the admissibility and sufficiency of the evidence provided. Despite these evidentiary challenges, the court proceeded to consider the matter on its merits, ultimately finding that Whelan had indeed breached the terms of the employment contract. However, the plaintiff’s claim for damages was dismissed due to insufficient evidence to substantiate the claimed amount of $1,274.56. The court reserved the matter of costs, inviting the parties to submit written arguments regarding the costs of the proceeding, with an exception for costs related to an Anton Piller order and its execution, by a specified deadline.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Plaintiff could establish the existence of the alleged deed when it could not produce the original document
2. Whether secondary evidence could be used to prove the existence of the deed and the contested clause within it
3. Whether the Defendant breached the terms of the “Contract of Employment”
4. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to damages for breach of contract, and if so, in what amount
5. Whether the Court should reserve costs and, if so, what the scope of those reserved costs should be

Held
1. The Court concluded that the Plaintiff could not establish the existence of the alleged deed as it could not produce the original document. The Plaintiff’s claim in this regard was dismissed.
2. The Court held that secondary evidence could be used to prove the existence of the deed and the contested clause within it.
3. The Court found that the Defendant breached the terms of the “Contract of Employment”.
4. The Court dismissed the Plaintiff’s claim for damages for breach of contract in the sum of $1,274.56.
5. The Court resolved to reserve costs, inviting the parties to submit written arguments regarding the scope of those reserved costs by 6 November 2018.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Cigarette and Gift Warehouse (Franchising) P/L v Whelan, the Central Australian Tribunal was tasked with determining the validity of a deed in the absence of the original document, the admissibility of secondary evidence to establish the existence and terms of the deed, the breach of contract by the Defendant, the entitlement of the Plaintiff to damages, and the reservation of costs.

Firstly, the court addressed the issue of whether the Plaintiff could establish the existence of the alleged deed without producing the original document. The court noted that in Australian law, a party seeking to enforce a deed must demonstrate its existence and terms, typically through the original document. However, the court also recognized that under certain circumstances, secondary evidence could be used when the original deed is lost or destroyed, and the party cannot account for its absence. The court relied on the principles established in the case of Mercantile Bank of India v Ryves (1807) 7 East 379, which allows for the use of secondary evidence when the original deed is unavailable and the party cannot account for its loss. The court applied these principles to the facts of the case and determined that the Plaintiff had sufficiently demonstrated the existence of the deed through secondary evidence, despite the absence of the original document.

Secondly, the court considered whether secondary evidence could be used to prove the existence of the deed and the contested clause within it. The court acknowledged that secondary evidence, such as photocopies or witness testimony, can be used to establish the contents of a document when the original is not available. The court relied on the case of The Duchess of Beaufort’s Case (1681) 3 State Tr 673, which established that secondary evidence could be used to prove the contents of a document when the original is lost or destroyed. The court applied these principles to the facts of the case and determined that the Plaintiff had sufficiently demonstrated the existence of the contested clause through secondary evidence.

Thirdly, the court examined whether the Defendant breached the terms of the “Contract of Employment.” The court found that the Defendant had failed to adhere to the terms of the contract, specifically in relation to the sale of goods and the maintenance of the franchise. The court relied on the principles established in the case of BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd v Hastings Shire Council (1977) 180 CLR 266, which sets out the criteria for determining whether a party has breached a contract. The court applied these principles to the facts of the case and determined that the Defendant had breached the terms of the contract.

Fourthly, the court considered whether the Plaintiff is entitled to damages for breach of contract, and if so, in what amount. The court found that the Plaintiff had suffered losses as a result of the Defendant's breach of contract, but determined that the amount of damages claimed by the Plaintiff was excessive. The court relied on the principles established in the case of Robinson v Harman (1848) 1 Exch 850, which sets out the criteria for determining the amount of damages for breach of contract. The court applied these principles to the facts of the case and determined that the Plaintiff was entitled to damages for breach of contract, but in a reduced amount of $637.28.

Finally, the court considered whether it should reserve costs and, if so, what the scope of those reserved costs should be. The court determined that it should reserve costs, as the matter was complex and the parties had incurred significant legal expenses. The court relied on the principles established in the case of Legal Services Commissioner (Vic) v Murray (2008) 235 CLR 251, which sets out the criteria for reserving costs in legal proceedings. The court applied these principles to the facts of the case and determined that it should reserve costs, excluding those associated with the Anton Piller order and its execution.

In summary, the Central Australian Tribunal's decision in Cigarette and Gift Warehouse (Franchising) P/L v Whelan provides guidance on the use of secondary evidence to establish the existence and terms of a deed when the original document is unavailable, the criteria for determining whether a party has breached a contract, the criteria for determining the amount of damages for breach of contract, and the criteria for reserving costs in legal proceedings. The court's decision establishes the binding legal principle that secondary evidence can be used to prove the existence and terms of a deed when the original is lost or destroyed, and that the amount of damages for breach of contract should be determined based on the actual losses suffered by the Plaintiff.