Choudhuri v Whight

%PDF-1.5

%????

1 0 obj

<</Type/Catalog/Pages 2 0 R/Lang(en-US) /StructTreeRoot 24 0 R/MarkInfo<</Marked true>>>>

endobj

2 0 obj

<</Type/Pages/Count 3/Kids[ 3 0 R 14 0 R 21 0 R] >>

endobj

3 0 obj

<</Type/Page/Parent 2 0 R/Resources<</XObject<</Image5 5 0 R>>/Font<</F1 6 0 R/F2 8 0 R/F3 10 0 R/F4 12 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI] >>/MediaBox[ 0 0 595.32 841.92] /Contents 4 0 R/Group<</Type/Group/S/Transparency/CS/DeviceRGB>>/Tabs/S/StructParents 0>>

endobj

4 0 obj

<</Filter/FlateDecode/Length 2948>>

stream

x??[[o??~???G??Z/??X,?:n7E???,
?>8??H???fO???J?h???[??f??\?‑.V???x?~???p??&????p???`??yrp>???F??|?????Q??????<???$?D?????S%??i???it?I???]??}????q??w??r??H??e:?2?
,??=?????=`?6???7??l?????9*??|????????Y????P??.1I‑?9??‑??????:??t???w+"]??$?Ss?n??

?D
F?y'?l1????_l?5

D?????K?H?j???a/
C!????????????J?&?
f??XD?:?y?[??x,"????Dm?DdI$8?+??????^?
{2?

??????4L[1]????_HB????*Xm???R?&2??lC?~?*?3???0

?A????JPq????~?|[??6?@????
????(?????w3ME?k????3eq+?8Sk?n???s??

??\???6<?TP??H?@??`@???‑6-??(-={\T?‑???
???z?R?????I-
9??T?L?z`??M????R?:~
??9??@"#??o)?%<y?%Z6??+4?YN8??J?7?<?=?‑H???|l???????S??v??~???48???????Ls????O??R??O??O‑6-~???r??O$??O???????Qu%q?-??I??????r?;??<??D&?????+?6i?J^??D????,#x?g?; w6????+??????U??????9???_j?/????Y???4???`??.?"?1?h-?

????M??????z?u?R^?<w??

a??*??

?K??e?#%m]{.Z?
?mZ??q?yW?+]??*Z?#???v+?d?uX??o?[???IK?K???6????? B????J???=??????i?C??K6?o???C?Y??l?='?-??2RI!G$I?3??\Uc>??
?ub?{?Fy??G?&???

8?V??C??;?2AcU?????????e???????qQ[?~aG?]A6????b$??9iu????VH?J?Fpk??

lUV?B?gH*#?????)J??UK*???\???????bI??bdc?%????Q???????#???D??[???)????E@u?-?G????O?)4xZ?`?P?
???6?d???<$?C?M%<?e{?J?TV?????5?l?;2jP??J]???+????<eg?C?N_?b?I?#[?Z?V??}?u\?.??)?????tLp5Z????=B?M_B?
??????H???|A?26$????P???[TUJ???g??Pv???m2?"Q?q^?b5bW?F????<??<??4?{?-???e???????
KH??B8????c?B?@Sc??MJ?Q???'????5?????Qor?Y??s‑zY?Z?A'?"xi???ZF}^NU???x?????

?:5?????=N????h3]
??????u????Q????{??T??cw?E?l?9r??X??[1]?
m8>ZO????
????>?n?-?,&7-??4?,??'T_C??????????h?????G?3??6?6gv?-?????`??d2B?!1?}?j?L[??[1],?w\L0??~????7n#? k??]?*?#N?-??????????
?Q?.u??
S&O3&#??:?n9?oa??q??m}?~L???q?p+?>CT_1@%?p??.-?6???S?BS?Z?i?#e???EZ'V?6I2?]??o???H?????A\w?M7??<?<n4????)??@|?8?Ad??O_?x???A??@>73*?z
?
???r??1?/???[1]?NoH??J??e?km?y?LDI?r???????N?T?mp?Ip?????
4Q\^??;?"c?????q?y???\?P?TGY?????D!??h??????w?st??????V^B?]GM?????[1]????
5?|???~?????r?u
[1]?????u?5?

7??!?h ?????P????%???????[1]?^j?y??z?v????c?k'??V:nK?5 ?6 ?[
.8???`??????????[1]??w^D???9?*??Q?S??1????

???zH????w?
?Fs[??]5?i??,`?W!??(I`?C???‑?{0K???V???F??{????R??????)?r?}????????wO?a?????Q8?n?????<??.?
???:??
?w??X???/D?????I(?Efk?yg/???Y?????t?mp?7"x'?p?&?\L]2??Oh?`?j??D??U?<???T?E2Y?2??z?H?*7???>O$hV~?h????*?????em‑??iXR???cT|n??E:??????5]=?n:??Q?z?,??x5???d?Z?4?? ???

?`??E?

?e??n????j?Z?????Ml?5???????L??????

????Ux?a??]???|??9Q?]o?:??C<P0ls??FW???u?9?h?n?
{?c????qW$?z?V@GZ!?e??? ??? ???K???s/?`J??-?~u???9_M???dm?g=?Z84?x?'???5???9?????????xu;‑?

?c/?1?‑??v??r????? ?Y#p??

??WU?o?[1]b??A?????[1]?}o???0?I?k<\[1]|L????y

????H)?????????Pt?7[???0+yyh??vSe?t???L?w?]0?EJ?R??'0P???B?(??QNq???".??y?O???????K?u???f?#????B?mKX??@Y9??????d1????

7b??S?2=??(???b??V????9???s?Q?@??Zx?
??fR?qY??
‑?)?*??8??0,?4i?i?qN??q?Fv??????7.?-&?,*????
!?L!@ft????OX??G??#?[1]4?????????@?

endstream

endobj

5 0 obj

<</Type/XObject/Subtype/Image/Width 468/Height 139/ColorSpace/DeviceRGB/BitsPerComponent 8/Filter/DCTDecode/Interpolate true/Length 9771>>

stream

????JFIF``??C

‑ $.' ",#(7),01444'9=82<.342??C

2!!22222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222????

"[1]??[1]

???[1][1]}[1]!1AQa"q2???#B??R??$3br?
%&'()*456789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????[1]

???[1][1][1]w[1]!1AQaq"2?B????#3R?br?
$4?%?&'()*56789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
[1]???(??
??5?+@??N?}

?G????@9??r?~!A????R}Vu?Q‑???????|????????????7????t

?T?V)F????g+aaw{??q??'????h>?X?????]x?.???e???;???p?o???L?e"P???+?4_i‑"??F?

?????????????????}??s%??g+$g??=????qG??W??7???-???HuxW,????????[1]?;??`???~"?D??m???>?:?(?H????
???%s???E??v??:??V??????????W???‑??]?J?&?

???#??*?MWW?????????????@:?*?f??(???????N4}<
?g???????u-
?????#???,??X??w
qQ??c?G?~????U????.q???d??=
?M_(|>?????Q?O$V?-??pcQ?}I?????0??\[frV?(?????^???F
?[?????"? ?r{??5?
?D??F??????x?[?????z??/7???b|?\g??j?rw4QG?????x?Y:e?????Y?L?p??Z???k'??-?5=?Hf‑g???o????@ ????%c'?? ????>?x?<?
??[?`??????^???=C??_?????L?/?????_0???c?MC???????????????7?>z?????_<QS???????{xo?|??????^???=C??_???(???*>??????????????????#????,-o_-?-*??????k?~?????E??(}?????Rm??${?QZQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEKX?-?]"?R?8??3#{???x????????????}1g?G????T??Wg?k????5??R??Op?????Q?g???D??I????>????
*???5???????????c????L??a???????)(?>?t'?????6?+??yx??,cJ?El?????><?K??3^?v?g??,#?b9?????|?????
??G ?????]-t??z?F?b?????????]J??sV?u???????;?w
???~5?????<C?????Gs|g;OB?[1]?+???????\h?????‑???????U?h???????kV??o5[??v????n=[1]?$?_#?????\?W?y???a??W??{??;=3E?????a??/?[??
?o[V?
2\N??????QTd?=??<

??K??"??`??Ta???tp???s?W?|?ST????

Ga??y?W???W?tAu?A??EUA?U[1]?????&???N?LG

?)??????:+B
o?~

??^??V?f?G/4??i:?c?q???IEW;??o???z???V-?z?c?c?9?+???????L?#o?Z?a??????*M?

+????)

+1C??

???G??:ez^???#?V????l7
q?G;?S??)?y?}_??Z???&?t??d????2???5??{_?Mk?h?7P?0??u??Z?=I???

cF????4?N???????e?#? ?[1]???T??????????h?,??q_??<

?@1??S?u?N?o???[@?"??H?rN1s?_e??‑"???U?????3Q4\Y?_Kh?
<w?i?3?????9??0?

???i???;?"???^p??[1]?!????*O?
?T??]o?>??1m-??f-b???????r??????????)?(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??+???f_Y[g?-??1?_BW??????????L?*;?o^???>??\??v?????????????|???A??????c?h????+????}???K1?3
???????_?y??
??b??????[1]n?^3???Y?G????W?|
~!??k)?N+8?[?g???q??x??(????????????[?n?I????I\ep[‑???@?

z???B?????????w?

??iq??3?_???{i???QEB
(??
???.?????N?[0??D^?S??H'????k???=??OR

?H???m???H??'&?o?p]G??O1.?$`?rN}Y?xu???????

h???Q^??G????????m??I?d??E}QJ
@?>&?????????.??lF_&_M?6?? ?K??A??[???v????????"?zTl^??4V????H<?jE?I, H?_??Pkz?1
???_?3j???7??k?z???_?3j???7??j&\
?????,?_????+??????,?_????)@&iQE?EPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEP_>|y?1x???,??A?V9?b???.????????8?s??|?vG???Z?lTw>w?`?pZ?-??????[1]???????#??I??d%`?]?[?=?_?x??q????Q[|????I?;XA?+5???k?z?G?F?????K??4+ ?2:a_????Tw9J?o??f__?c???n}?????)?????e?K?M?

7?OtL???????c??2??????H???)???Z?k?~=??F??????m1?N???~??T??Gc??g???z??q"????^?_2| ???<s
s?K{?6??????

????HlD?
(?????(??=k?]????????a?8_???^]o??s?{?z??6?"????8?NO?\?c'vj????K?7?

??????ygAi???9?

?]o?/O????~??k?|??????????????E?Y?'?%?????/b?;?EF?T?q?=z??V5H`?[1]LN?T?t?{??]k??5-F??u? OUn? ~u?U????k???{?????iy???‑?_SV?z?j?????f???o?
????????f???o?
???f?????gJ??8?_W????gJ??8?J3J?(?
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
???[??u???o??3??"??@x???^??t??wD?G?!???+&9‑)H???
???W??????t??Xu6??????????5?S????j??[??7?????VR??S???
????vP???????+J?????>????I?+?????c;????u?????Q??????Z??i???M??P???!?=???x-??]]En???4?F}I?
??4?_???w?Mr?K?Re??["?c?}u????F?m????-?????;?????4I??r??r??;*{:?kH?'s'????|=y????????9V??N??]?????}???????#??2????-<gd&????
?)????_?????.???? ?A?s?'?kV??N?<????{?????r?z??kA??=|?z?????M??a???J???h??>???>??I
??2‑??(??bk?|+????1?N?

?~?????Us?rBx???$?$?M????\?m>??c????‑??x?Z‑‑????n??????*??W?F??jz?0i0M5??PB
T?????X????v???-Q?:?????NW??2s??'a8?x?%?$??I5????,?4???y????????k??

??i???????#B???????vS?‑??EV?E{?8?>??q????????????
?)?%?F???8??k???7?_?g?E??k:???????5E??r<R,??WBXut5??5d?|9??????U?;7F?5??}?+Z?g?.??o??m??'?B

????rZ‑?_x??FmW??&???}?_x??FmW??&???9?m}????t?????@??}????t?????@?4???????(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(?Z????6??R?????l}=*????/?9x??{C.@????+??6F?
?p???%e?q??J)r??3??|>??K=????t?????=G?????wE?
:?V*FA??4?3???e??c??<???>??q?P???.???G?6??A/?ls?Z?IQ??????W?i??3s7??Y??W???#???+Z??????
??OnA??????Y@p$???*??U?o?&???Q?4??wH??#?g????u????6???Q????????

F?
??^?Z-?3{??*?W?6???7P?????pz??/
^?=?????
?Q?05?P?av?!?t???^???????p?3_^?d?*???????G*
fg?:??[?]??????????{?>‑?.?/?[G?p?????z???a\??Px/??????k????t?
??k???H?c???8?SZ?R??QE????h?+kv??
?nFC? 63??A[?P
?
???
????Z?‑?>??{?nt?W?YSc?+0#9?MttR??Ws???wS\??;K3??|?$?????v???????????[kx?-a??v?
,h3?0*Z)X.QE0
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??$Q??%?]Ua?j?z>??dzu?????U?(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(?_x??????G5????v????I????{V?p7????????ZT?=??‑??&4iYx?:????h??<?d?g??G)??O

?]epw?o?F??-???Cn??_???|Y?????O!?y?[~7c?q????????u??_????Y???m$?rU?p??Gl??+??\?????#?<@?&|???????a]??z.=???x?K?D?n?5

???x,U??b>T???

??xSQ?k?i??j??Q[??/?E?2T?P?8<?J.=‑??u????h?['????a?d?V???
?????]?????A?Q}J/I=?????HC??-+????z?h^??V1???????‑?oO??m??]?xR]???8?k???H????[F??uo"Nng2<Gs??
?>?wT???xyou??6'??y6??G?_?p
q??N?c????????k:Tw???m?E???cbH8??Z??4?SP?qw????Y?M??ke???]??{????????c???]koi? ?2?[?7?????1?9?KR??M^???,7?ZO?D??]A???q?`??<?I
????_E?]B????2
???NF@c?8?E??????gk-???)wv8
Rk?[?
?<??~?o??[k??}x????S??{? I$I!?.?????????@V?{`ubIo?4??`?r+?j0x?F?b???Z??$?w???????5???x???|g????N???K???p??Z???S?x6???‑?}q5?6RM!g;???O?#~??v=3??+?<.?{Xh?jf?R????‑??s???W^6???e??E???????Gl?????\?????FmF?]^????U?UO=?‑???S?????????T??=j???8?E?sz,B???G???s?_7????E?????[???o?M0e???99>?=ESvW>?????????
J??o,?????2X8?;?o????g?????B?N?y?\9bYpA??pqK?P???/?d???o???Y??)??l??_?????|A??

Y?????0?????Y???|:?|]?k???0Af?L??W8

?‑???
?????????;??d???4??V?

????4??i0Rx?<?Z?????|?g??)H?T????

???^I?V??O?Zf???,:V??C??v0;??K????>
??u???k?8u ?????Q??[C??k?9<)?k?b+t?xY??T???Z?u??R1yF??`9???f?}???}o?????/_L?p??!12??y???j?|_{?Y|;???~?sf??F0?T7??$??K?,{?P?????[??-^?X"gH#??Ga^2|=?Z|H‑????????1??8?9??????‑??H|??)5+???7-??!??|
r>?4??????]??????t???F`al???pkz??S?W??z???\??+??0g?????<E?x{?~???W??k$?Y\??c+??o??`??V?+?.> ??u?Y???=?|s???9?^??W?Y_???}z?nex??S
!1?yQ‑p9??y???G>?t?/??G???o????z?_??
(??X??K??^??

??7??yH?????z
??+??i????4???L:?Q0?)??m6?
~I5{????<;???\?- ??`?&bG?R?g??G0X?z???

>?{???

d???(5?>0???????^??W??(
?[@^i??;???zqY‑???<
?}6?T????Kg??????‑??`??V?.??<#s?

"?{??I
q????=??

???I???+?9?&we??<?xa?

y???/??
?=v??s%??,~v#?i?2?????{?n?????????Ap
?D?d?ws???
?????W??x?|K????s?????4????7?@??0??\?-???^j???<C??K|?p?8????|??}9yq?K+??-??ci6'V????1??e??

??c?O?????k????>??=3Q?]??
??????:???%?????ho?z?|F?&???m2?O!?Gr0??9??5C?~+?4o??U??5???.8??q??:???3?L????=?X??){??d )fe,8?*

~???‑1?F??{5?|??JzL??
????Qp??Z??K??????[A????,J?c?????W????'??gO????Sn??[6? C???*?@??m??h??W??FM???w???g t#??9???Q^?m[R?????!???i?"Yf
?/?9??k?B}V?????Xk7?w
?b??2X8?;??=?????{????:??u=??E?[?2P?>~x??W?????????u?CW?a??d??=
s??G0r???????h?DvK0???ei1?n??z?a^1?{?/<W???b
?$r9

$?5???
(?????xj?T????&?+]gN-?<?Lr+
28????j(??Os?7?t???$

[1]?a4????4?????(>??j:?????/??ZJ???
??nB?
02
}Ew4R??q^???k?k??????k0?&[p?+(e?3?!H?j???x???
?i?z<?tD????????
??????h??s????;?gO??sk‑?iB?r??6?
??????l>#???????G?l??

????v??E
?G?!???????E??<?+??yy???==?Z??Z}?tt??-??Xn???
??????E??i?k???Ew5?z????n???#'?'?^?o
???MmOF????I??Yve[nA??O??}E
?n??x???w???6??{j?<v??tT??d|?I????xR??????????n[1]???‑c3
??????(?\?o??6???t??h??

6??[1]a?*????/
?????‑!?nt???K?????
,99???QE??

kH???{?.?K[?&??Q????5???????h?!???
-?

?D'

i?$?=}+?h???gw??^???‑?????i??NZV?d???j??>???Yc?C<A?K?|??T?
\q???J?? ?8??‑

??e?????
+?5???

?U?x3[????x?E???n?)b?,>\2?`?X?8?A????h???xn?I?|?uA'?OQ?dW?\|.??????????????[t??????'?{?5pN???+U??u??=??]>%[??+;
???????<so????[?a????????z?h??.x??Y?+M*???:????r?a?Co8 ?????‑??z??????v?t?<??yl?T?zd[TP????u????O?u?c?i????n?
~j?$??????CQ'???????Y????o=?`?(d??[1]?????*?9P]?*~x?=??P?Zq?‑O5C??H ???r??E?|=?5
?gK???'??L???[???n??H??T?????????R'??q?
D?0?0?Lc?Z???‑?Zv??
in???cR?L????:f?‑?,<?????7??O
??????????Y??|???;V???MCP?<#y????,??e???x?d??w?Qdg

?58~%j?'???!????qtq($c?????_?????h????Of???o?

?????r?,<???
?a?xR?????H?`T???
?????????kS???|Cuuc??%[?B?{?I?1??????,??????‑ ????,???-qa???r0:`??^?w?im?Xu;?G?Y?xA'?;?y?.~?+????.y??<??'???/.?????T?h??????????t[1]Ke??
?SA,????J???O ‑
?]?Y?
?????????jRAsq~?eh?T?y?o??4?[1]x????N????2y
???2??m#?????(?
?t?.m??h/'[???
$??C??q????&?]??????[%????I
ol9n01??uE?#??
??|}???\[?????G-????????x??????4

j??? ??RB?????????????????V?>?<S?j????????*P??Hw=??.?O???e~????=?[1]U
I?

?I=+?h????w
|m?xr?A??t??????????rI????Wg??/R?<?x?\??l#Q2???s?`?s??sE?.?[1]??????77p?Mf???FO??????oZ????

???w?.???p[|??v?>?=??(?????x

?????l?,F??F??]????'????W?A?????g??y?3?v9?{f???Ap??)???

endstream

endobj

6 0 obj

<</Type/Font/Subtype/TrueType/Name/F1/BaseFont/Times#20New#20Roman/Encoding/WinAnsiEncoding/FontDescriptor 7 0 R/FirstChar 32/LastChar 93/Widths 130 0 R>>

endobj

7 0 obj

<</Type/FontDescriptor/FontName/Times#20New#20Roman/Flags 32/ItalicAngle 0/Ascent 891/Descent -216/CapHeight 693/AvgWidth 401/MaxWidth 2568/FontWeight 400/XHeight 250/Leading 42/StemV 40/FontBBox[ -568 -216 2000 693] >>

endobj

8 0 obj

<</Type/Font/Subtype/TrueType/Name/F2/BaseFont/Arial,Bold/Encoding/WinAnsiEncoding/FontDescriptor 9 0…

Continue reading Choudhuri v Whight

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Orders of the court

Background to the litigation

Evidence Before The Court

Reasons for decision

Legal Principle Established