Chhetri v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CHHETRI v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2019] FCCA 298
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Application for review of Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) decision – whether application infected by jurisdictional error as it is informed by a policy alleged to be ultra vires the Migration Act and Regulations – whether jurisdictional error present as applicant alleges that the relevant criteria were misapplied – no jurisdictional error revealed – application dismissed.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.48, 476
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), sch. 2 cl.820.211, sch.3 item 3001, 3002,
3003 and 3004

Cases cited:

Babicci v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2005] FCAFC 77; (2005) 141 FCR 285
MZYPZ v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCA 478; (2012) 127 ALD 510
Waensila v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 32; (2016) 241 FCR 121

Applicant: ANIL SINGH CHHETRI
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number: SYG 1245 of 2017
Judgment of: Judge Nicholls
Hearing date: 6 September 2018
Date of Last Submission: 6 September 2018
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 13 February 2019

REPRESENTATION

Solicitors for the Applicant: Christopher Levingston & Associates
Appearing for the Applicant: Mr C Levingston

Counsel for the Respondents:

Solicitors for the Respondents

Mr G Johnson

Mills Oakley Lawyers

ORDERS

  1. The application made on 24 April 2017 is dismissed.

  2. The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs set in the amount of $5400.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT SYDNEY

SYG 1245 of 2017

ANIL SINGH CHHETRI

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This is an application made on 24 April 2017 pursuant to s.476 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”), seeking review of the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) made on 31 March 2017, which affirmed the decision of the Minister’s delegate to refuse the grant of a partner visa to the applicant, Mr Anil Singh Chhetri (“the applicant”).

  2. The evidence before the Court is contained in a bundle of relevant documents (the Court Book) tendered by the Minister (“CB” – “RE1”).

Background

  1. The applicant first arrived in Australia in July 1999 as the holder of a student visa.  He applied for a protection visa on 18 October 2002.  This was the subject of an unsuccessful review by the then Refugee Review Tribunal on 22 April 2003.  The applicant’s last substantive visa had ceased on 9 October 2002. He remained in Australia without authority until he was issued a bridging visa at the time of applying for the partner visa.

  2. The subclass of visa for which the applicant applied was a subclass 820 visa. I note that, relevant for current purposes, the applicant was required to meet the requirements of cl.820.211(2)(d)(ii) of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (“the Regulations”) because he was not the holder of a substantive visa at the relevant time of making his application…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chhetri v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCCA 298
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia for review of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The applicant, Mr. Chhetri, sought to challenge a decision by the Minister for Immigration, which had been affirmed by the Tribunal. The core of the dispute revolved around the application of Schedule 3 criteria within the Migration Regulations, which the applicant alleged were applied in a manner that constituted jurisdictional error.

The applicant advanced two grounds for jurisdictional error. Firstly, it was contended that the policy underpinning the Schedule 3 requirements was *ultra vires* the *Migration Act 1958* and its Regulations, particularly in light of the facilitative provisions of section 48 of the Act. This, it was argued, improperly fettered the consideration of "compelling" circumstances. Secondly, the applicant alleged that the Minister had misapplied the Schedule 3 requirements by failing to give genuine and proper consideration to all of the applicant's relevant facts and circumstances, which he asserted constituted "compelling" reasons within the meaning of the Schedule 3 concession.

Judge Nicholls found no jurisdictional error. The Court examined the grounds of the application and the relevant provisions of Schedule 3 of the Migration Regulations. The Court determined that the applicant's arguments did not demonstrate that the policy was *ultra vires* or that the Schedule 3 criteria had been misapplied. The Court concluded that the applicant had not established that the Minister or the Tribunal had failed to consider the relevant facts or had fettered their discretion in a manner that constituted jurisdictional error. Consequently, the application was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Chhetri v Minister for Immigration pertains to an application for the review of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The applicant, Mr. Chhetri, challenges the AAT's decision on the basis that it is infected by jurisdictional error, as it allegedly rests on a policy that exceeds the powers granted by the Migration Act and Regulations. Specifically, Mr. Chhetri argues that the policy underpinning the schedule 3 requirement in the migration regulations is beyond the scope of the Act, and that this policy restricts the consideration of "compelling" circumstances in a manner that contradicts the facilitative provisions of section 48 of the Migration Act and criterion 820.211 of the migration regulations. Furthermore, Mr. Chhetri contends that the Minister for Immigration misapplied the schedule 3 requirement by not adequately considering the personal circumstances of himself and his sponsor, which he argues constitute "compelling" circumstances warranting a concession under criterion 820.211.

The factual background of the case reveals that Mr. Chhetri had been in Australia without a substantive visa for a period and was subject to visa cancellation. He applied for a visa under the schedule 3 criteria, which requires the Minister to be satisfied that there are compelling reasons for granting the visa, among other conditions. The AAT reviewed Mr. Chhetri's application and ultimately dismissed it, leading to his appeal to the court. The crux of Mr. Chhetri's appeal is the assertion that the AAT's decision was flawed due to the alleged ultra vires policy and the Minister's failure to genuinely consider his personal circumstances. He maintains that these factors combined to result in a decision that was not properly made under the Act.

At the hearing, Mr. Chhetri was represented by his solicitor, while the Minister was represented by counsel. The court was presented with the specific provisions of the schedule 3 criteria as they existed at the time of the decision, which outline the conditions that must be met for an application to be valid and the circumstances under which a visa may be granted. The case hinges on whether the AAT's application of these criteria was correct and whether the policy that informed the Minister's decision was within the legal bounds set by the Migration Act and Regulations. Mr. Chhetri's argument is that the AAT failed to recognise the compelling nature of his personal circumstances, thus leading to an improper application of the criteria.

This case involves an application for judicial review of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) in the matter of Chhetri v Minister for Immigration. The application was brought before the Federal Court of Australia to challenge the AAT's decision, with the applicant contending that the AAT's decision was infected by jurisdictional error due to the application of a policy alleged to be beyond the powers conferred by the Migration Act and Regulations. Additionally, the applicant argued that the AAT had misapplied the criteria in Schedule 3, specifically criterion 820.211, by not properly considering the applicant's compelling personal circumstances. The Federal Court was tasked with determining whether the application to review the AAT decision was indeed affected by jurisdictional error as claimed. The procedural journey of this case began with the applicant lodging an application for judicial review directly with the Federal Court, challenging the AAT's decision. The application was supported by grounds that essentially argued the AAT had erred in its application of the Migration Act and Regulations by not considering the applicant's compelling personal circumstances appropriately. The Federal Court assessed the application on its merits, scrutinising the AAT's decision-making process and the validity of the policy applied. Throughout the proceedings, the Court considered the arguments presented by both the applicant and the Minister for Immigration, represented by counsel, and deliberated on the specific provisions of the Migration Act and Regulations, including the interpretation and application of Schedule 3, criterion 820.211. The Court's role was to determine whether the AAT's decision contained any jurisdictional errors as alleged, without delving into the substantive merits of the case or the policy's correctness. The decision of the Federal Court in this matter focused on the procedural legitimacy of the AAT's decision-making process, without addressing the substantive aspects of the applicant's case or the correctness of the policy applied.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the policy underpinning the schedule 3 requirement incorporated in the regulation ultra vires the Migration Act 1958, particularly in relation to the facilitative provisions of section 48 and criterion 820.211 of the Migration Regulations?
2. Did the Second Respondent misapply the schedule 3 requirement embedded in criterion 820.211 by failing to give the applicant's relevant facts and circumstances a proper and genuine consideration on its merits?
3. Do the personal circumstances of the applicant and his sponsor constitute "compelling" circumstances within the "concession" embedded in schedule 3 at criterion 820.211 of the migration regulations?

Held
1. The policy underpinning the schedule 3 requirement incorporated in the regulation is not ultra vires the Migration Act 1958, particularly in relation to the facilitative provisions of section 48 and criterion 820.211 of the Migration Regulations. The application on this issue was dismissed.
2. The Second Respondent did not misapply the schedule 3 requirement embedded in criterion 820.211 by failing to give the applicant's relevant facts and circumstances a proper and genuine consideration on its merits. The application on this issue was dismissed.
3. The personal circumstances of the applicant and his sponsor do not constitute "compelling" circumstances within the "concession" embedded in schedule 3 at criterion 820.211 of the migration regulations. The application on this issue was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The grounds of the application to the Court are in the following terms:“1. The application is infected by jurisdictional error in that it is informed by a policy which is ultra vires the Migration Act and regulations.Particulars(a) The policy underpinning the schedule 3 requirement incorporated in the regulation is ultra vires the Migration Act 1958, in particular the facilitative provisions of section 48 amended in September of 2009 and so fetters the consideration of ‘compelling” circumstances so as to traverse the facilitative nature of both section 48 and criterion 820.211 of the migration regulations.2. The application is infected by jurisdictional error in that the Second Respondent has misapplied the schedule 3 requirement embedded in criterion 820.211 by failing to give all of the Applicants relevant facts and circumstances a proper and genuine consideration on its merits.Particulars(a) The genuine and proper consideration of the personal circumstances of the Applicant and of his Sponsor constitute “compelling” circumstances within the “concession’ embedded in schedule 3 at criterion 820.211 of the migration regulations.” At the hearing, the applicant was represented by his solicitor. The Minister was represented by counsel. For current purposes, the Schedule 3 criteria referred to at cl.820.211(2)(d) were in the following terms: “3001(1) The application is validly made within 28 days after the relevant day (within the meaning of subclause (2)).(2) For the purposes of subclause (1) and of clause 3002, the relevant day, in relation to an applicant, is:(a) if the applicant held an entry permit that was valid up to and including 31 August 1994 but has not subsequently been the holder of a substantive visa -- 1 September 1994; or(b) if the applicant became an illegal entrant before 1 September 1994 (whether or not clause 6002 in Schedule 6 of the Migration (1993) Regulations applied or section 195 of the Act applies) and has not, at any time on or after 1 September 1994, been the holder of a substantive visa - - the day when the applicant last became an illegal entrant; or(c) if the applicant:(i) ceased to hold a substantive or criminal justice visa on or after 1 September 1994; or(ii) entered Australia unlawfully on or after 1 September 1994; whichever is the later of:(iii) the last day when the applicant held a substantive or criminal justice visa; or(iv) the day when the applicant last entered Australia unlawfully; or(d) if the last substantive visa held by the applicant was cancelled, and the Tribunal has made a decision to set aside and substitute the cancellation decision or the Minister's decision not to revoke the cancellation - - the later of:(i) the day when that last substantive visa ceased to be in effect; and(ii) the day when the applicant is taken, under sections 368C, 368D and 379C of the Act, to have been notified of the Tribunal's decision.3002The application is validly made within 12 months after the relevant day (within the meaning of subclause 3001(2)).3003If:(a) the applicant has not, on or after 1 September 1994, been the holder of a substantive visa; and(b) on 31 August 1994, the applicant was either:(i) an illegal entrant; or(ii) the holder of an entry permit that was not valid beyond 31 August 1994; the Minister is satisfied that:(c) the applicant last became an illegal entrant, or, in the case of a person referred to in subparagraph (b)(ii), last became a person in Australia without a substantive visa, because of factors beyond the applicant's control; and(d) there are compelling reasons for granting the visa; and(e) the applicant has complied substantially with the conditions that apply or applied to:(i) the last of any entry permits held by the applicant (other than a condition of which the applicant was in breach solely because of the expiry of the entry permit); and(ii) any subsequent bridging visa; and(f) the applicant would have been entitled to be granted an entry permit equivalent to a visa of the class applied for if the applicant had applied for the entry permit immediately before last becoming an illegal entrant or, in the case of a person referred to in subparagraph (b)(ii), if the applicant had applied for the entry permit on 31 August 1994; and(g) the applicant intends to comply with any conditions subject to which the visa is granted; and(h) the last entry permit (if any) held by the applicant was not granted subject to a condition that the holder would not, after entering Australia, be entitled to be granted an entry permit, or a further entry permit, while the holder remained in Australia.3004If the applicant:(a) ceased to hold a substantive or criminal justice visa on or after 1 September 1994; or(b) entered Australia unlawfully on or after 1 September 1994 and has not subsequently been granted a substantive visa; the Minister is satisfied that:(c) the applicant is not the holder of a substantive visa because of factors beyond the applicant's control; and(d) there are compelling reasons for granting the visa; and(e) the applicant has complied substantially with:(i) the conditions that apply or applied to:(A) the last of any entry permits held by the applicant (other than a condition of which the applicant was in breach solely because of the expiry of the entry permit); and(B) any subsequent bridging visa; or(ii) the conditions that apply or applied to:(A) the last of any substantive visas held by the applicant (other than a condition of which the applicant was in breach solely because the visa ceased to be in effect); and(B) any subsequent bridging visa; and(f) either:(i) in the case of an applicant referred to in paragraph (a) - - the applicant would have been entitled to be granted a visa of the class applied for if the applicant had applied for the visa on the day when the applicant last held a substantive or criminal justice visa; or(ii) in the case of an applicant referred to in paragraph (b) - - the applicant would have satisfied the criteria (other than any Schedule 3 criteria) for the grant of a visa of the class applied for on the day when the applicant last entered Australia unlawfully; and(g) the applicant intends to comply with any conditions subject to which the visa is granted; and(h) if the last visa (if any) held by the applicant was a transitional (temporary) visa, that visa was not subject to a condition that the holder would not, after entering Australia, be entitled to be granted an entry permit, or a further entry permit, while the holder remained in Australia.”