Cheng Fung Pty Ltd v Heloui

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Cheng Fung Pty Ltd v Heloui [2005]  NSWCA 222

FILE NUMBER(S):
40482/04

HEARING DATE(S):               24 June 2005

JUDGMENT DATE: 15/07/2005

PARTIES:
Cheng Fung Pty Ltd - Appellant
Michel Youssef Heloui - Respondent

JUDGMENT OF:       Mason P Handley JA Giles JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          DC 11530/01

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     McLoughlin DCJ

COUNSEL:
C S Leahy SC & J H Gibson - Appellant
J Sharpe & J de Greenslaw - Respondent

SOLICITORS:
Hunt & Hunt - Appellant
Fallon Safetly Lawyers - Respondent

CATCHWORDS:
Negligence - employer's duty of care to provide safe system of work - avoiding exposure to unnecessary risk of injury - robbery of pizza delivery driver - order by mobile phone - new customer - caller rang again - call back by employer unanswered - whether employer should have called off delivery - evidence of recognised risk of robbery and circumstances of suspicion - including mobile phone orders from new customer when call back unanswered - finding of negligence open to judge. D

LEGISLATION CITED:

DECISION:
Appeal dismissed with costs.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA  40482/04
DC 11530/01

MASON P
HANDLEY JA
GILES JA

Friday 15 July 2005

CHENG FUNG PTY LTD v HELOUI

Judgment

  1. MASON P:          The judgment of Giles JA sets out the facts in detail. 

  2. His Honour’s patient archaeology has exposed the layers of reasoning of the primary judge and brought the critical findings to the surface.  Liability ultimately turned upon the conclusion that Mr Cheng ought in the circumstances to have aborted the delivery because he was unable to raise the person who ordered the pizza by calling him back on one of the mobile phone numbers recorded on the delivery docket.  Each number had originally been typed into the computer that produced the docket, one number being provided orally by the caller, the other being displayed on the phone system as that of the mobile phone used to make the incoming call.

  3. The evidence led at trial does not disclose whether the number provided by the caller was a genuine one.  I would infer that it was not.  The caller must have known this. 

  4. It is possible that the caller would have realised that telecommunications technology enabled the pizzeria to know the number of the mobile phone that was actually used.  Since however this issue was not explored in evidence or submissions I say no more about it.  It required proof to turn the possible into the probable and middle-aged judges are unlikely to be au fait with what may be commonplace for the younger generation. 

  5. The evidence is also silent as to the means whereby Mr Cheng satisfied himself that the second call, enquiring about the delayed delivery, came from the man who had made the first call.  No one suggested that technology assisted this linking.  It is more likely that Mr Cheng had a small bundle of outstanding orders and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cheng Fung Pty Ltd v Heloui and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWCA 222
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Cheng Fung Pty Ltd v Heloui*, the New South Wales Court of Appeal considered an appeal by the employer, Cheng Fung Pty Ltd, against a finding of negligence. The respondent, a pizza delivery driver employed by the appellant, suffered psychiatric injury after being robbed while on a delivery. The dispute centred on whether the employer had breached its duty of care to provide a safe system of work by failing to adequately protect the driver from the foreseeable risk of robbery.

The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the trial judge had erred in finding the employer negligent. This involved determining whether the employer ought to have foreseen the risk of robbery to its delivery drivers, particularly in circumstances involving mobile phone orders from new customers where a call back to the provided number was unanswered, and whether the employer had taken reasonable steps to mitigate such risks.

The Court of Appeal reasoned that the evidence supported a finding of negligence. It noted that the Bankstown area, where the delivery occurred, had a high crime rate, and the employer was aware of this and had previously been robbed at the pizzeria. The employer had instructed drivers to be careful and to hand over money and pizzas if threatened. While the employer provided some training on dealing with armed robbery, the specifics were unclear. Crucially, the employer recognised certain circumstances as suspicious, such as orders from public phones or requests for delivery to public parks, and had a practice of attempting to call back numbers to verify orders. The trial judge was entitled to find that the employer should have called off the delivery in this instance, given the combination of a mobile phone order from a new customer and an unanswered call back, which constituted a recognised risk of robbery.

The appeal was dismissed, and the appellant was ordered to pay the costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondent was understandably distressed. He went back into the building, and was assisted by one of the occupants. The police were called, and the respondent phoned Mr Cheng and told him what had happened. Mr Cheng came to the address. It is unnecessary to detail what then happened; it was found that the respondent suffered psychiatric injury from these events.Other evidence Apart from evidence from the respondent and Mr Cheng, the judge had evidence going to liability from Mr Mohab Maggar, the senior business development manager of the Pizza Haven franchisor, and from Mr Richard Jennings, a security consultant. Each witness was called by the plaintiff. According to Mr Jennings, Bankstown had a high crime rating, more than double the state average for a local government area, and as to robbery generally had “an extremely high record in the top half dozen crime rates for the state”. Mr Maggar said that the Bankstown area, amongst others, was known to Pizza Haven as “a rough area” at the beginning of 2001. He explained this as “trouble-make”, further explained as “trouble could be anything you know”. Prior to March 2001 Mr Cheng had been twice robbed at the pizzeria by persons armed with knives. He agreed that the area was a “rough area”, and said that after the robberies at the pizzeria he told the drivers that the area was rough, that they should be careful, and that if anyone asked for money just give them what they had and “don’t get yourself involved”. He agreed that he had safety concerns when the drivers were delivering pizzas, and said that he told the drivers that if they were held up when they were doing a delivery they were to hand over the money and the pizza and “get out [of] there”. In the appellant’s time as a Pizza Haven franchisee, however, there had not previously been an “assault” of a driver. Pizza Haven provided a training course to Mr Cheng and his wife, and an instruction book. The evidence was that the training included how to deal with armed robbery, but no further detail was given and the instruction book was not tendered. It is not clear whether the training and instruction were concerned only with robbery of a pizzeria or also with robbery of delivery drivers. There were, however, recognised circumstances of suspicion about an order. Mr Cheng said that if a phone call was from a public phone, which would come up on the display, he would not deliver the pizza, because “probably there is trouble”, meaning “like, you know they probably rob the pizza or something or whatever”. He said that if the caller asked for delivery to a public park he would “probably check” by ringing the phone number back. At one point he clearly enough said that he did not regard a difference between the (mobile) phone number on the display and the phone number given by the customer as exciting suspicion, saying that it was quite normal and the caller could be part of a group and give a friend’s address or contact number. Later he said, when asked if he customarily rang back before delivery, that he could not remember or “promise” and, “If happens like the phone’s different then the guy ring, probably – sometimes I ask like – later I check the number”. The answer earlier noted when Mr Cheng was being asked about his general procedure may have been referring to this.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.