Charatsis v Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CHARATSIS v BENDIGO & ADELAIDE BANK LIMITED [2016] FCCA 321
Catchwords:
BANKRUPTCY – Review from decision of registrar – costs arising from presentation of creditor’s petition – petition dismissed following appeal decision in the Supreme Court of South Australia which set aside judgement debt on which petition founded – registrar awarded costs in favour of creditor – respondent seeks review and opposes award of costs – matters to be considered.

Legislation:

Bankruptcy Act 1966, ss.32; 40(1)(g)

Bankruptcy Regulations 1996, r.4.02A
Federal Circuit Court of Australia Act 1999; ss:104(2)
Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001, r.79(2)

Cases cited:
Charatsis v Bendigo & Adelaide Bank Limited [2015] FCCA 548
Charatsis v Bendigo & Adelaide Bank Ltd [2015] SASC 131
Nicholl Holdings Pty Ltd v Minister for Health (No 2) [2014] FCCA 1272
Latoudis v Casey (1990) 170 CLR 534
Applicant: TERRY JOHN CHARATSIS
Respondent: BENDIGO & ADELAIDE BANK LIMITED
File Number: ADG 95 of 2015
Judgment of: Judge Brown
Hearing date: 26 November 2015
Date of Last Submission: 26 November 2015
Delivered at: Adelaide
Delivered on: 19 February 2016

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: In person
Solicitors for the Applicant: Not applicable
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr Thomas
Solicitors for the Respondent: Scott Lawyers

ORDERS

  1. Order 2 of the orders made by Registrar Parkyn on 7 September 2015 is discharged. 

  2. Each party bear their own costs in respect of the application for review filed on 24 September 2015 and the costs of the creditor’s petition presented on 17 March 2015.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT ADELAIDE

ADG 95 of 2015

TERRY JOHN CHARATSIS

Applicant

And

BENDIGO & ADELAIDE BANK LIMITED

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. These proceedings relate to an application to review an order of Registrar Parkyn made on 7 September 2015.  On that day, the Registrar made the following orders:

    “1.    The petition be dismissed.

    2.  The applicant creditor’s costs (including any reserve costs), be fixed in the sum of $9,473.00 and be paid by the respondent.”

  2. Mr Charatsis, “the applicant” seeks to review the second order, relating to the costs payable by him to the Bendigo & Adelaide Bank Limited “the creditor” or “the Bank”.  The applicant has no complaint that the bankruptcy petition, filed on behalf of the bank, naming him as a creditor, should be dismissed. 

  3. The factual circumstances of the case are somewhat convoluted, as they involve proceedings in this court, the Federal Court; the District Court of South Australia and the Supreme Court of South Australia.  Some of the relevant background is set out in a judgment published, by me, in respect of an earlier review decision relating to an extension of time to comply with a bankruptcy notice issued to Mr Charatsis.[1]  As I understand it, the following matters are not contentious. 

  4. The applicant is a legal practitioner, who has suffered from a depressive illness, for many years.  At some time, in 2008,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Charatsis v Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCCA 321
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Charatsis v Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Limited*, the County Court of Victoria considered a dispute between the applicant, Mr Charatsis, and the respondent, Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Limited. The applicant sought to set aside a default judgment entered against him by the respondent.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the applicant had established sufficient grounds to set aside the default judgment. This involved determining whether the applicant had a meritorious defence to the claim brought by the bank and whether he had provided a satisfactory explanation for his failure to file a defence within the prescribed time.

Judge Brown found that the applicant had failed to demonstrate a meritorious defence. While the applicant raised a general assertion of a dispute regarding the loan amount, he did not provide sufficient detail or evidence to substantiate this claim. Furthermore, the explanation offered for the delay in filing a defence, which primarily involved personal difficulties and a misunderstanding of court processes, was not considered by the court to be a sufficiently compelling reason to excuse the default. The court applied the principles that a party seeking to set aside a default judgment must show both a defence on the merits and a good reason for the delay.

Consequently, the court dismissed the application to set aside the default judgment.

Background

Background to the litigation

Terry John Charatsis, the applicant, borrowed approximately $35,000.00 from Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Limited, the respondent, through a personal loan in 2008. Defaulting on the loan instalments, the bank commenced proceedings against Mr Charatsis in the District Court of South Australia in March 2011. The case was compromised in October 2011, with Mr Charatsis agreeing to pay $330.00 per month until the debt was fully paid. The bank claimed that Mr Charatsis defaulted on this settlement agreement, leading to the bank renewing proceedings against him on 24 July 2013.

On 23 October 2013, the bank filed an application in the District Court seeking an early trial of its claim. Mr Charatsis filed defences, claiming the bank's failure to consider his depression when issuing default notices constituted unconscionable conduct. The bank denied these claims. On 17 March 2014, Mr Charatsis failed to appear at the trial, resulting in a default judgment against him. This judgment formed the basis of a bankruptcy notice issued by the bank on 12 May 2014.

On 17 July 2014, Mr Charatsis applied to set aside the default judgment, arguing that his appeal against the District Court's decision had merit. His appeal was ultimately allowed by Bampton J on 28 August 2015, who set aside the judgment debt and ordered a fresh trial in the District Court. Despite this, the bank presented a creditor's petition on 17 March 2015, based on the now-set-aside judgment debt. The petition was dismissed by Registrar Parkyn on 7 September 2015, who also ordered Mr Charatsis to pay the bank's costs in the sum of $9,473.00.

Mr Charatsis sought a review of this costs order, arguing that the petition should not have been presented given the ongoing appeal. The bank contended that it was reasonable to present the petition, as the bankruptcy notice would have expired if they had waited until the appeal was resolved. The case hinges on whether the bank is entitled to costs despite the dismissal of the petition and the setting aside of the underlying judgment debt.

The case of Charatsis v Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Limited originated as a creditor's petition filed by the Bank against Mr Charatsis in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The petition was grounded on a default judgement debt obtained by the Bank against Mr Charatsis in the District Court of South Australia, which was subsequently set aside by the Supreme Court of South Australia. The Federal Circuit Court Registrar dismissed the petition and awarded costs to the Bank, leading Mr Charatsis to seek a review of the costs order. The review hearing took place before Judge Brown, who had previously dismissed Mr Charatsis' application to set aside the bankruptcy notice. The convoluted procedural history includes applications and appeals in multiple courts, with key decisions involving the dismissal of the bankruptcy petition, the setting aside of a default judgement debt, and the allowance of an appeal against the decision to refuse to set aside the judgement debt. The case underscores the complexity of bankruptcy proceedings and the interplay between different courts in resolving disputes over debt and insolvency.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Federal Circuit Court has jurisdiction to review the costs order made by the Registrar.
2. Whether the Registrar correctly exercised his discretion in awarding costs to the creditor.
3. Whether the creditor's decision to present the bankruptcy petition was reasonable, given the appeal was on foot.
4. Whether the creditor is entitled to costs, despite the petition being dismissed and the underlying judgment debt being set aside.
5. Whether the principles of costs following the event apply in this case, given the unusual circumstances.

Held
1. Whether the Federal Circuit Court has jurisdiction to review the costs order made by the Registrar.
The court concluded that the Federal Circuit Court has jurisdiction to review the costs order made by the Registrar. The review was allowed to proceed.

2. Whether the Registrar correctly exercised his discretion in awarding costs to the creditor.
The court concluded that the Registrar did not correctly exercise his discretion in awarding costs to the creditor. The costs order was set aside.

3. Whether the creditor's decision to present the bankruptcy petition was reasonable, given the appeal was on foot.
The court concluded that the creditor's decision to present the bankruptcy petition was not unreasonable, given the circumstances, but the timing was questioned.

4. Whether the creditor is entitled to costs, despite the petition being dismissed and the underlying judgment debt being set aside.
The court concluded that the creditor is not entitled to costs, as the proceedings did not result in a clear outcome and the costs order was set aside.

5. Whether the principles of costs following the event apply in this case, given the unusual circumstances.
The court concluded that while costs generally follow the event, the unusual circumstances of this case warranted a different outcome. Each party was ordered to bear their own costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing whether it had jurisdiction to review the costs order made by the Registrar. The court cited sections 104(2) of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia Act 1999 and 32 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966, which provide that a party to proceedings, in which a Registrar has exercised delegated powers, is entitled to seek a review of that exercise of power to this court. The court found that it had jurisdiction to review the costs order.

Next, the court considered whether the Registrar correctly exercised his discretion in awarding costs to the creditor. The court noted that while the discretion is unfettered, it must be exercised judicially. The court found that the Registrar had exercised his discretion correctly by considering the principles of costs following the event and the unusual circumstances of the case.

The court then turned to whether the creditor's decision to present the bankruptcy petition was reasonable, given the appeal was on foot. The court noted that the creditor had argued that it was reasonable for it to have presented the petition, particularly as a consequence of regulation 4.02A of the Bankruptcy Regulations 1996, which requires a bankruptcy notice to be served within six months of its issue. The court found that the creditor had a valid and subsisting act of bankruptcy at the time of presentation of the petition and had no viable alternative other than to present its petition.

The court next considered whether the creditor is entitled to costs, despite the petition being dismissed and the underlying judgment debt being set aside. The court noted that the creditor's petition had been rendered nugatory and that there was no act of insolvency on which the creditor could rely to present any fresh petition. The court found that it was not just and reasonable that there be an award of costs, notwithstanding the abortive nature of the proceedings, which did not produce a clear result.

Finally, the court considered whether the principles of costs following the event apply in this case, given the unusual circumstances. The court noted that costs follow the cause and that an award of costs will generally flow with the result of litigation. The court found that while the creditor's petition had been rendered nugatory, it was reasonable for it to have commenced the bankruptcy proceedings against Mr Charatsis, because he was and remains indebted to the creditor. The court held that the appropriate outcome of the aborted sequestration proceedings against Mr Charatsis is that each party should bear their own costs, including the costs of the review proceedings.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that while the discretion to award costs is unfettered, it must be exercised judicially and with consideration of the principles of costs following the event and the unusual circumstances of the case. The court found that it was not just and reasonable to award costs to the creditor in this case, despite the creditor's argument that it was entitled to compensation for the costs it incurred in presenting the petition. The court held that each party should bear their own costs, including the costs of the review proceedings.