CHAKRAVARTY & COMMISSIONER for ACT REVENUE (Administrative Review)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

CHAKRAVARTY & COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE (Administrative Review) [2012] ACAT 68

AT 12/24 & 12/50

Catchwords:             ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – First Home Owner Grant – Home buyer concession duty reassessment – whether exemption from residency requirement applies - matters to consider for imposing penalty under the First Home Owner Grant Act 2000 and the Taxation Administration Act 1999 – whether there is reasonable basis for remission of interest

List of legislation:     ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008, s.68

First Home Owner Grant Act 2008, ss. 20, 23, 47, 48 & 49

Tax Administration Act 1999, ss. 25, 26, 29, 30, 31 & 37

List of Regulations:   Taxation Administration (Amounts Payable-Eligibility-Home
Buyer Concession Scheme) Determination 2008 (No 1),
s.5

List of cases:              Calcaro v Commissioner for State Revenue [2004] NSWADT
158

Chief Commissioner of State Revenue v Farrington (GD) [2004] NSWADTAP 41

Davey v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2008] ACTAAT 30

Tribunal:                  Mr G. Lunney SC – Senior Member

Date of Orders:  9 October 2012

Date of Reasons for Decision:       9 October 2012

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          

AT 12/24 & 12/50

BETWEEN:

SUBHANGI CHAKRAVARTY

Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:            Mr G. Lunney SC – Senior Member

DATE:  9 October 2012

ORDER

1.The decision of AT 12/24 under review is confirmed.

2.The decision of AT 12/50 under review is confirmed.

………………………………..

Mr G. Lunney SC

Senior Member

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. These are two applications for review of decision which were heard together on 21 August 2012. They concerned decisions relating to a grant paid to the applicant under the First Home Owner Grant Act 2000 (the FHOG Act), and an assessment of concessional duty under the Tax Administration Act 1999 (the Tax Act) and the Taxation Administration (Amounts Payable-Eligibility-Home Buyer Concession Scheme) Determination 2008 (No 1),(the Determination). The application under the FHOG Act was matter AT 12/50, and the application under the Tax Act and the Determination, was numbered AT 12/24.

  2. Much of the evidence given by the applicant related to both matters; however, consideration of the applications required the tribunal to apply principles prescribed by the two different Acts.

  3. The different applications will be dealt with separately as appropriate within these reasons.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

The Tax Act – AT 12/24

  1. On 16 October 2008, the applicant entered into a contract for the purchase of the property to which the Tax Act application related. The purchase was settled on 10 December 2008.

  2. On 19 November 2008, there was an initial assessment of duty payable for the purchase of $10,875.00. This was a non-concessional assessment.

  3. On 13 November 2008, the applicant signed an application for a home buyer concession (HBC) under the Determination. The application contained a declaration to the effect that the applicant would reside in the home as her principal place of residence for a continuous period of 6 months; that period to commence within one year of the transfer of the property to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CHAKRAVARTY & COMMISSIONER for ACT REVENUE (Administrative R... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] ACAT 68
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Chakravarty and Commissioner for ACT Revenue, an administrative review case, was before the court. The applicant sought a review of decisions made by the Commissioner for ACT Revenue concerning the grant of a First Home Owner Grant (FHOG) and a duty concession under the Duties Act 2001 (ACT). The Commissioner cancelled the grant and duty concession because the applicant failed to meet the residency requirement under the FHOG Act 2009 (ACT) and the Duties Act 2001 (ACT).

The court had to decide whether the applicant was a resident of the ACT as required by the relevant legislation at the time of applying for the FHOG and the duty concession. The applicant argued that she had moved to Melbourne under duress and was not aware of the residency requirement because her solicitor had failed to inform her of it. The Commissioner argued that the applicant's move was voluntary and that she had failed to meet the residency requirement, justifying the cancellation of the grant and duty concession.

The court found that the applicant had voluntarily moved to Melbourne to pursue a career in data warehousing, and her decision was not made under duress. The court also found that the applicant's solicitor had not made her aware of the residency requirement or the period during which she could have requested an exemption. However, the court held that the applicant's failure to meet the residency requirement was a valid reason for the cancellation of the FHOG and the duty concession. The court confirmed the decisions of the Commissioner for ACT Revenue to cancel the grant and duty concession.

The court confirmed the decisions of the Commissioner for ACT Revenue to cancel the First Home Owner Grant and the duty concession. The applicant's appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision of AT 12/24 under review is confirmed.

2. The decision of AT 12/50 under review is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 68 of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (the ACAT Act) sets out the powers of the Tribunal on review.68 Review of decisions(1)This section applies if the tribunal reviews a decision by an entity.(2)The tribunal may exercise any function given by an Act to the entity for making the decision.Note A reference to an Act includes a reference to the statutory instruments made or in force under the Act, including regulations (see Legislation Act, s 104).(3) The tribunal must, by order—(a) confirm the decision; or(b) vary the decision; or(c) set aside the decision and—(i) make a substitute decision; or(ii) remit the matter that is the subject of the decision for reconsideration by the decision-maker in accordance with any direction or recommendation of the tribunal. The first application made by the applicant was signed on 18 April 2012 and filed the same day. The grounds for the application were set out as an annexure. A great deal of supporting material was attached to the statement of grounds. It was apparent that the grounds and supporting material were intended to apply to both applications. The applicant relied on the contentions set out below. She entered into the contract for purchase of the property on 10 October 2008. She moved to Melbourne to take up a job in the Victorian Public Service that commenced on 27 October 2008. This was after she negotiated with the employer for increased salary on the basis of an appointment that she had obtained in the ACT. She said she had tried to return to Canberra, but was unable to find employment on acceptable terms. In a letter to the respondent of 5 January 2012, the applicant said of her move to Melbourne:Further, I accepted the job offer in Melbourne since I felt I was stagnating in my career and desperately needed to take action. Hence, it wasn’t done voluntarily but under duress. At the hearing, the applicant said that she wished to pursue a career in data warehousing. Opportunities were limited in the ACT. A possible opening in the ACT was not on terms that were acceptable to her. She was able to obtain a suitable job in Melbourne. The job in Melbourne had the same income as the job available in Canberra, however, she opted to move to Melbourne to pursue what she thought was a career with long term advantages. She said that she had unsuccessfully attempted to find employment in the ACT since that time. I am satisfied that the applicant made a considered decision to accept employment out of Canberra in order to advance her career. This not only involved moving outside the Commonwealth employment system in which she had obtained equivalent salary employment, but took her to another state and city; away from the residential property purchase which was partly funded by an ACT scheme. She has never returned. I cannot agree that her decision was made under duress. It was a voluntary decision made in the interests of her career. At about the time that she applied for the grant and for the duty concession, the applicant engaged a solicitor who she says did not make her aware of her responsibilities. She says that he did not tell her about the residency condition, or the period during which she could have requested exemption etc. She complained to the Law Society about the solicitor, but only after being notified of the investigation and its consequences. The solicitor, in his reply to her complaint, pointed out that by the time the FHOG application was made, the applicant was resident in Melbourne. There is no information available to me about whether the Law Society took any further action in relation to the complaint and if so, what the outcome of the action was.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established