CGU Insurance Ltd v One.Tel Ltd (In Liq)

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
HEYDON, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ

CGU INSURANCE LIMITED  APPELLANT

AND

ONE.TEL LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) & ORS  RESPONDENTS

CGU Insurance Limited v One.Tel Limited (In Liquidation)
[2010] HCA 26
4 August 2010
S78/2010

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed in relation to order 2 of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales made on 18 December 2009.

2.The answers to the questions reserved for separate determination be recorded as:

Question 1:  Can the plaintiff named in the amended summons maintain these proceedings to seek recovery from the first defendant of the alleged property identified in paragraph v of Schedule A to the deed ('the Property')?

Answer:  Yes.

Question 2:  Upon the termination of the Deed, did any alleged interests or rights of Greaves in respect of the alleged Property cease to be held by the plaintiff as trustee or otherwise identifying the same?

Answer:  No.

Question 3A:  In what capacity does the plaintiff hold any alleged interests or rights of Greaves in respect of the alleged Property?

Answer:  Not necessary to answer.

Question 3B:  In what capacity would the plaintiff hold any proceeds of the realisation of any interests or rights of Greaves in respect of the alleged Property?

Answer:  Not necessary to answer.

Question 4:  Which of the parties (including Greaves), if any, hold any alleged interests or rights of Greaves in respect of the alleged Property, and in what capacity?

Answer:  Not necessary to answer.

Question 5A:  Upon termination of the Deed, was Greaves released and discharged from all liability at law and/or in equity in respect of the orders made on 6 September 2004?

Answer:  No.

Question 5B:  Upon termination of the Deed, did Greaves obtain the accrued benefit of a covenant not to enforce in respect of the compensation and costs order made on 6 September 2004 in the ASIC proceedings?

Answer:  No.

Question 6:  Does CGU have accrued or binding rights under the Deed such that the plaintiff and/or Greaves have no further rights to seek recovery of the alleged Property?

Answer:  No.

Question 7:  Are any or all of the plaintiff and the second to fourth defendants precluded from bringing any claim, including the present proceedings, against CGU in respect of the alleged Property in relation to the orders made on 6 September 2004 by reason of any or all of the following matters:

(a) There being no relevant 'Loss' (at the time of entry into the Deed or upon termination of the Deed) within the meaning of the Policy;

(b) Greaves having no existing Loss within the meaning of the Policy for which he may be legally indemnified arising out of any Claim by reason of any Wrongful Act for the purpose of Insuring Agreement A of the Policy in relation to the compensation and costs

order made on 6 September 2004 in the ASIC proceedings;

(c) There being no subject matter for indemnity as provided in the opening words of the Policy?

Answer:  No.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CGU Insurance Ltd v One.Tel Ltd (In Liq) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] HCA 26
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered an appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales concerning the rights of a trustee under a Deed of Arrangement and the effect of the termination of that deed. The dispute arose from proceedings commenced by the trustee, David Patrick Watson (and later his executrix, Christine Watson), against CGU Insurance Limited, the insurer of a directors and officers liability policy held by John Huyshe Greaves. Mr Greaves, a former director of One.Tel Limited (In Liquidation), had been ordered to pay substantial compensation to One.Tel and ASIC. The Deed of Arrangement, entered into by Mr Greaves, included a covenant to assign his rights under the CGU policy to the trustee.

The central legal issues before the High Court were whether the trustee could maintain proceedings to recover alleged property under the policy after the termination of the Deed of Arrangement, whether Mr Greaves's interests or rights ceased to be held by the trustee upon termination, and whether CGU had accrued rights under the Deed that precluded further recovery. The Court also had to determine the effectiveness of the covenant to assign and whether any transfer of property was void after the Deed's termination.

The High Court reasoned that the Deed of Arrangement operated as an equitable assignment of Mr Greaves's rights under the policy to the trustee. Crucially, the Court held that the termination of the Deed did not extinguish the trustee's rights or the equitable assignment. The termination did not render the assignment void, nor did it release Mr Greaves from his liabilities in a way that would prevent the trustee from pursuing the claim. The Court applied principles relating to equitable assignments and the effect of termination of deeds of arrangement, concluding that the trustee retained the capacity to pursue recovery of the alleged property.

The High Court allowed the appeal in part, overturning the Court of Appeal's decision on certain reserved questions. The Court affirmed that the trustee could maintain the proceedings and that the termination of the Deed did not cause the cessation of the trustee's interests or rights. The Court also determined that CGU did not possess accrued or binding rights under the Deed that would prevent further recovery, and that the covenant to assign was effective. Consequently, the Court answered specific questions in favour of the trustee, allowing the appeal in relation to those orders and dismissing it otherwise, with CGU ordered to pay the first respondent's costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed in relation to order 2 of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales made on 18 December 2009.

2. The answers to the questions reserved for separate determination be recorded as:

Question 1: Can the plaintiff named in the amended summons maintain these proceedings to seek recovery from the first defendant of the alleged property identified in paragraph v of Schedule A to the deed ('the Property')?

Answer: Yes.

Question 2: Upon the termination of the Deed, did any alleged interests or rights of Greaves in respect of the alleged Property cease to be held by the plaintiff as trustee or otherwise identifying the same?

Answer: No.

Question 3A: In what capacity does the plaintiff hold any alleged interests or rights of Greaves in respect of the alleged Property?

Answer: Not necessary to answer.

Question 3B: In what capacity would the plaintiff hold any proceeds of the realisation of any interests or rights of Greaves in respect of the alleged Property?

Answer: Not necessary to answer.

Question 4: Which of the parties (including Greaves), if any, hold any alleged interests or rights of Greaves in respect of the alleged Property, and in what capacity?

Answer: Not necessary to answer.

Question 5A: Upon termination of the Deed, was Greaves released and discharged from all liability at law and/or in equity in respect of the orders made on 6 September 2004?

Answer: No.

Question 5B: Upon termination of the Deed, did Greaves obtain the accrued benefit of a covenant not to enforce in respect of the compensation and costs order made on 6 September 2004 in the ASIC proceedings?

Answer: No.

Question 6: Does CGU have accrued or binding rights under the Deed such that the plaintiff and/or Greaves have no further rights to seek recovery of the alleged Property?

Answer: No.

Question 7: Are any or all of the plaintiff and the second to fourth defendants precluded from bringing any claim, including the present proceedings, against CGU in respect of the alleged Property in relation to the orders made on 6 September 2004 by reason of any or all of the following matters:

(a) There being no relevant 'Loss' (at the time of entry into the Deed or upon termination of the Deed) within the meaning of the Policy;

(b) Greaves having no existing Loss within the meaning of the Policy for which he may be legally indemnified arising out of any Claim by reason of any Wrongful Act for the purpose of Insuring Agreement A of the Policy in relation to the compensation and costs

order made on 6 September 2004 in the ASIC proceedings;

(c) There being no subject matter for indemnity as provided in the opening words of the Policy?

Answer: No.

Question 8: Is the covenant in the deed to assign to the plaintiff effective in the events that have occurred?

Answer: Yes.

Question 9: Is any transfer and assignment to the plaintiff of the Property void and of no effect within cl 1(e) of the Deed after termination of the Deed by reason of cl 1(e) of the Deed and/or s 213 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth)?

Answer: No.

3. Appeal otherwise dismissed.

4. The appellant is to pay the first respondent's costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

FRENCH These proceedings were heard on agreed facts. It is desirable to outline the material parts of those facts at the outset.The agreed facts The proceedings have their origins in the conduct of the third respondent, John Huyshe Greaves ("Mr Greaves"). From 28 February 1995 to 31 December 1995, and from 25 July 1997 to 31 March 2001, Mr Greaves served as a director of the first respondent, One.Tel Limited (In Liquidation) ("One.Tel"). He was insured under a directors and officers liability policy of insurance ("the Policy"). The insurer was the appellant, CGU Insurance Limited ("CGU"). On 12 December 2001 the fourth respondent in this appeal, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission ("ASIC"), sued Mr Greaves in the Supreme Court of New South Wales ("the ASIC proceedings"). On 21 May 2002 CGU purported to avoid the Policy. On 6 September 2004, by consent, the Supreme Court made orders and declarations against Mr Greaves in the ASIC proceedings. That relief included an order that Mr Greaves pay compensation to One.Tel in the sum of $20 million ("the $20 million compensation order"). It also included an order that he pay $350,000 to ASIC. On 30 November 2004 Mr Greaves entered into a Deed of Arrangement ("the Deed") pursuant to Pt X of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) ("the Act")[1]. The other party was David Patrick Watson, who died on 18 July 2009. His executrix, the second respondent, is Christine Watson. It is convenient to refer to Mr and Mrs Watson as "the Trustee".[1]The relevant provisions are in Pt X as it stood before the commencement on 1 December 2004 of the Bankruptcy Legislation Amendment Act 2004 (Cth), which made very substantial amendments to Pt X. Clause 2 of the Deed provided:"[Mr Greaves] covenants to convey, transfer or assign or cause to be conveyed, transferred or assigned to the Trustee all the property more particularly described in Schedule A hereto on trust to be dealt with by the Trustee in accordance with this Deed of Arrangement."Paragraph (v) of Sched A included Mr Greaves's rights under the Policy. Clause 3 provided:"The Trustee accepts appointment as Trustee of this Deed and the conveyance and assignment of the said property upon the trusts hereinafter set out." Clause 4 provided:"The Trustee shall get in and realise the assets set out in the said paragraph 2 hereto as soon as reasonably practicable provided that he shall have the power to postpone the sale of any part thereof as he in his discretion considers expedient." Clause 5 provided that the Trustee should apply any amount received by him under the Policy in payment of any liability that Mr Greaves might have to ASIC and One.Tel. Clause 6 provided:"Subject to clauses 5 and 18, the Trustee shall apply any moneys received by him pursuant to this Deed in making payments in the order described by Section 108 to 114 inclusive of the Act as modified by Section 237(2) thereof." Clause 7 provided:"Immediately after [Mr Greaves] has in all respects complied with his obligations under this Deed and the Act the Trustee shall certify that [Mr Greaves] has complied with the Deed. Notice that such certificate has been executed shall be given by the Trustee to [Mr Greaves] and the Creditors."A certificate pursuant to cl 7 was executed on 2 March 2006.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, HEYDON, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, HEYDON, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ

Full text does not contain this section.